TheDag
Per Aspera ad Astra
No bio...
User ID: 616
Interesting take. I'm sympathetic to both sides tbh. It's definitely a fraught situation!
Is the whole point of Effective Altruism to be a place for nerds to meet women?
Based on many of the frothing defendants of polyamory on the EA forum - seems like that is a major driver. Check out this comment where a relatively connected EA directly says:
As a poly EA, I'm more likely to bother to show up for things if I think I might get laid. It increases engagement and community cohesion. A group that is a good place to meet interesting opposite gender people is going to have an intrinsic advantage in pulling in casually interested people over one where that is strictly banned.
This dude got a grant for tens of thousands of dollars to write a fantasy book for EA. Go figure.
I have been involved in EA for a while outside of the Bay Area / UK sections, and damn I had no idea the rot went this deep. It's wild to see these poly folks mask off.
Amen brother. Amen.
Good lord this blunt honestly is a breath of fresh air. Comments like yours are why I love this damn place.
Update to @Quantumfreakonomics 's post about EA Drama downthread.
For context:
You may remember a few weeks ago the article Effective Altruism Promises to Do Good Better. These Women Say It Has a Toxic Culture Of Sexual Harassment and Abuse was published in TIME (Motte discussion here).
Basically, a major EA figure was outed as having sexually harassed at least five women, some he had plausible professional power over. The community health team in EA knew about it and essentially did nothing until the TIME article outed it.
Even now, he's getting the kid glove treatment - temporarily resigning and not taking on new mentorships, but continuing all his other duties. Realistically he'll probably still function as an informal board member.
In addition there have been two other major updates, and I cannot overstate the importance here. Both of the heads of the two biggest EA organizations, Holden Karnofsky at Open Philanthropy and Max Dalton at the Centre for Effective Altruism are stepping down. In Holden's case, temporarily to work on AI risk.
If you haven't been following Effective Altruism this may just seem like another set of scandals - it's not. The past 6 months or so have been a constant barrage of issues, starting with SBF's massive fraud and the collapse of FTX, the issues with Nick Bostrom being outed as a racist/HBD enthusiast, the TIME article mentioned above, and finally both of these central figures resigning. There have been many more petty dramas playing out as well.
This is the crucible, the defining moment for Effective Altruism. Whether the movement lives or dies will likely be determined in the next year.
Whoever takes over the reigns of the movement, it's clear that shifts are happening and power is up for grabs. With AGI likely around the corner, this realignment of power in the EA sphere has the potential to determine the singleton who controls the future.
Expect a bloodbath either way.
Wow, great writeup. I'm in the middle of deciding this very question with my partner - this helped move me more towards committing. I've been waffling/worrying if it's the right choice, but this framing helped me realize it's always going to be a risk. (Almost) Nobody is 100% sure going into marriage it seems.
The Golden Oecumene is an interesting sci fi trilogy that explores this.
Reading Tales of the Ketty Jay and loving it so far. It’s an unapologetic romp of some dastardly freebooters in a steampunk world with airships. Quite fun.
This is quoted from the link, I haven’t checked the study’s methodology though.
Thanks for the vote! I thought my entry was rather banal honestly, I’d like to expand on the thought down the road with more research and a stronger tie in.
Wow excellent link there. I had no idea other folks had so clearly outlined some of my own half baked thoughts on intuition.
the darkness that comes befofee
Ahh a fellow Bakker fan eh?
And again fascinating points here. I’m not sure I grasp the theory about densely connected episodic memory, but it sure does sound smart.
In terms of your image, I’d say that science started off more in tune with object level reality/mathematics, and has been bastardized after we destroyed the elite class. It’s like a religion that has thrown open the gates to its priesthood.
Reading Masters and Mages by Christian Cameron. Amazing standard fantasy so far. He writes battles better than anyone I've ever seen.
I'm interested in the topic, but unwilling to doxx myself hah.
Try breakfast in bed!
Thanks for sharing. Personally all of the “your personality is fixed by 25” stuff seems completely bunk to me. I know people who have barely changed from 15 to 25, and people who undergo full transformations from 25 to 28. It really depends on where you’re at and what your thinking is like.
I will say I believe there is some inertia to thinking. Thoughts tend to wear grooves in your mind, for lack of a better word. The trick is to learn to observe your mind, and try to shift your thoughts towards something more positive or beneficial.
This can be a Herculean task on your own. All the standard advice about friends, therapy, exercise and health activities applies here and helps.
If you’re really at a loss, I’d recommend trying some type of substance. Do some research, but a very small dose of marijuana or a psychedelic can let you glimpse entirely different ways of thinking and being in the world. Once you realize it’s possible, it becomes much easier to work towards.
I’d never heard of intuition in mathematics - that’s a fascinating perspective.
As I said to @felipec elsewhere, I wonder if rationality or conscious thought can be seen as a sort of overarching myth which we use to coordinate. Every human mind has its own tangled threads, and rationality is a sort of weave we use to impose order on them, similar to religion or social customs, just more defined.
I know the left often decries capitalism as a religion - but what if mathematics, physics, and economics really are a new iteration of these classic religious myths?
They bind people together, coordinate action at a large scale, loosely get people to share some moral valence (albeit worse morals than religion did imo). The main difference to my mind is that there is an inherent logical structure behind them.
Perhaps this logical structure prevents the sort of fervent, faith based belief that older religions engendered. Then again, maybe we simply need to wait until we can find the synthesis between the vehicles of religion and rational structures.
I found it difficult, but mainly because I’m at a very busy point in my career and didn’t have as much time to research as I’d like. It’s definitely a topic I plan to come back to.
Strange, I thought I was giving intuition a fair shake.
conscious thinking is just an illusion
See, I have practiced Buddhism for a while and I agree with this statement. That being said, conscious thought or rationality or whatever you want to call it is clearly real, and has effects on the world. Something can be an illusion and still change the way people act/behave.
The way I see rationality is essentially a shared fiction or mythos that groups of humans indulge in because it helps us coordinate very precisely on meanings, measurements, etc. If rationality didn’t matter at all and you fully bought into the idea of it being a pointless illusion, why even have this conversation?
I actually appreciate it the Stoics are my favorite. I'd start with Seneca over Aurelius though, he's much more accessible. Epictetus is good too.
Just started Masters and Mages by Miles Cameron. Excellent so far, seems a pretty standard high fantasy trilogy.
His other series, The Traitor Son Cycle, is a breathtaking masterpiece of high fantasy that even manages to be relatively historically accurate. If anyone is looking for a new fantasy series I’d highly recommend it.
Funny, I’m the exact opposite. I invited my partner out for coffee and she didn’t even know it was a date until I kissed her. Luckily it worked out.
1/12 for me with my current partner being the 1. I’m lucky(?) in the sense that I’ve dated quite a bit but I have another regret about not marrying my previous partners. I do regret some of the ways I acted, but not that we didn’t end up together.
The one partner that may have qualified left me because I didn’t break a stated boundary, which I found stupid enough to disqualify her. Basically she told me the whole “I don’t want to do X my parents would never approve,” so I didn’t. Turns out that’s what she wanted the whole time.
Overall most people I’ve dated have been highly depressed and/or anxious, like myself. Even my current partner. I hate the modern medical distinctions and think they’re full of holes, but I do think it takes a neurodivergent person to truly bond with another one.
Thanks for the rec, I’m going to order some myself.

I’ll be honest, it just gives me a sort of deep disgust reaction. I run a meetup myself and thinking of a dude showing up trying to get laid pisses me off.
I also think that EA is at risk of being destroyed by cultural tides of wokeism, and behavior like this is why. It’s 70% male, and many high status males are constantly looking to sleep with any woman in the community. Creates awful social dynamics.
More options
Context Copy link