I mean I think the article is accidentally a great example - they didn't actually need to know and numbers, it got covered, no?
They did end up running around sweating because the insurance company decided to be an asshole, which is what they do. Physicians complain about prior auth abuse all the time, and United is one of the worst. Basically they just try and refuse enough and slow things down enough that at times patients and doctors will give up and go with sub optimal management.
Quality price transparency doesn't help in those sort of situations and will likely help insurance company's beat on health systems.
It's also extremely expensive, you'd have to hire a lot more staff, and since people always expect physicians to know these things you'd probably have to cut clinical supply.
You could certainly change the system via regulation but that has its own costs and there are easier targets to reduce patient angst like prior auth reform.
For a more paternalistic and therefore likely less popular take - the system is incredibly complicated and even people who are subject matter experts in it get shit wrong quite a bit. Injecting patients into the mix would just add to the confusion, expense, and angst.
So uhhh that's me. Intent here is to provide context not inflame drama so mods tell me if you think I should just delete that portion or just the whole comment.
Background - got in a loooooong argument with this guy which to my recollection involved neither of us covering ourselves in glory and involved me feeling my interlocutor was being deliberately obtuse and getting highly annoyed so I doubt the essential thrust of my point comes across well. Also not sure if it's appropriate for me to participate in this discussion since I blocked the guy for what I perceived to be him following me around complaining after the discussion stopped becoming productive.
That said, here's a summary of the argument: "the number is fake anyway, so you don't need to see it," (as you say!).
But yeah healthcare demand is typically excruciatingly inelastic which is a large part of it. Supply is also often inelastic in the short term. Add in all the usual complexities of the U.S. healthcare system and shit is a mess. It doesn't need to be, but it is.
The problem is that the cost to provide the healthcare, the price the hospital wants to charge the insurance company (and therefore you), the price the hospital actually charges the insurance company, the price the insurance company actually pays, and how much you are on the hook for are all totally different, often completely unrelated to each other, and involve information that other parties don't have. Your health system can usually functionally guess how much your insurance will want you to pay for something but it's a guess and insurance companies deviate frequently and quite substantially. If the insurance company knows exactly how much something costs they'll low ball the hospital and the hospital will go out of business (we have a huge issue with hospitals going out of business right now).
Even if the hospital knew with perfect information how much the average procedure "costs" the hospital, and could predict how much the procedure will "cost" you (they can't) it still has no relationship to how much the patient actually pays because their insurance company decides that and they do whatever the hell they want.
You can choose to socialize things and make everyone pay an average for a given thing but Americans typically don't like that so it usually only happens with "safe" stuff.
Smuggled into here is the expectation that the doctor specifically and the healthcare system in general provide information about what another actor (the insurance company) will do. Hospitals already spend a ton of time and salary costs on trying not to lose a war with insurance. Adding more expectations to this will not help anyone and have a low degree of accuracy because fundamentally insurance companies will do the shit they usually do like randomly change which inhaler they'll cover with no warning.
Physicians themselves having awareness of some of the specific numbers is possible in an environment like one guy only doing total knees with a few major insurance companies but that doesn't usually happen. Asking us to know quickly balloons into a time consuming, pointless, inaccurate mess. We'll usually try and keep track of some things that can be leveraged into value for a patient (like which beta blocker is cheapest for your insurance) but this has the risk of becoming rapidly inaccurate and is questionable when you are considering giving someone something less effective to save them money. Is the patient equipped to truly understand the tradeoff? Do you have time to consent and document this in a way that doesn't create risk of later lawsuit?
Messy.
As a practical matter I assume most people want this so they can say spend less money on their colonoscopy, but again their is a lot of inaccuracy and false sense of security that can be driven by this.
Let's say you try three GIs and you get a quote of 5k, 10k, 15k being charged to your insurance or you. The 15k guy says he knows your insurance and they are in network and will for sure only charge you a 20 dollar copay.
What are some possible outcomes?
Maybe you take up 15k guy, go in for your procedure and he has to do a stat case and he offers his partner. You are exhausted from the bowel prep and don't want to spend another day shitting yourself so you say sure. Wait this guy isn't in network! Full bill. If you are lucky they'll notice this in advance and tell you but you might not notice because at this point you are sick, but realistically some random intraop nurse saying "hey do you want this done today or nah" isn't going to catch that problem.
Maybe you want to self-insure and pay the 5k guy. It's a colonscopy the pricing std is going to be pretty favorable. Okay but you have a cardiac event during the procedure and are now on the hook for millions of dollars (wouldn't quite work this way but I'm trying to keep the examples constrained). Maybe your insurance covers 5k guy and you go with that but it doesn't cover the replacement anesthesia because they aren't in network or the cost of your adverse event.
Ultimately the problem is that it's hard to give numbers in general, it's harder to make them accurate, nothing the hospital can do can guarantee the numbers are accurate, they are therefore not very useful in the vast majority of situations and also have a very real cost to deliver to a patient (in the form of literal costs in staffing to generate the numbers and in negotiating costs with other actors).
I know this isn't popular but I quite disagree, I think Floyd was exactly as bad a martyr as everyone else, he just stuck a lot better because of the circumstances and that makes it harder for people to have awareness of that.
I mean it seems to be clearly multifactorial and a perfect storm situation - lock everyone up with a lot of fear and guilt, have this roiling social justice/woke thing that's been fermenting increasingly unquietly for years, and have a lot of money and power and propaganda trying to aim itself at Trump and anything that seems Trump related. Boom.
A number of non-conspiracy conspiracy theories over the years have commented on this like foreign funding trying to divide America and Democrat aligned sources trying to create division to make Trump bad.
Thank you for sharing.
The subset of these types of people who end up requiring medical attention is of course not representative of the true population but I've Noticed Some Things that are of course not captured in the literature even when they are hinted at so it is useful to collect more N.
I can only speak to the first season as I mentioned, but it's one of the best seasons of television of the last ten years. Full stop.
Now admittedly it's not to everyone's taste, it's a slow and deliberate Cold War spy thriller living in the most Star Wars feeling Star Wars since the original trilogy.
If you are the kind of person who liked Better Call Saul as much or more than Breaking Bad you are 100% going to love it, but I don't fault people for needing a faster pace etc.
Put another way it reminds me of Winter Soldier which duct taped an excellent non Marvel script to Marvel IP and kept the advantages of both.
It does have some woke elements but they are chiefly background casting stuff that isn't too annoying when it's drowned in quality. It is also explicitly anti-fascist and anti-authoritarian but not in the childish modern politics way so it shouldn't chafe too much.
It's much less Wolfenstein haha kill the nazis and much more Das Leben der Anderen this is the reality of these systems. Sure the woke end up liking it but that's by accident.
I still haven't seen the last one, and should be surprised if I ever do.
I feel so seen haha. I also refused to watch the last one. Can't even remember its name if I'm being honest. Total fundamental drop off of interest.
You know I also thought Rogue One scratched the itch - interesting. Lots of the more traditional non-woke critics hated it.
Andor was actively incredible though (although I have yet to see the second season, just timing issues).
Why have I never seen this word before this week, and yet like eighteen references in the last few days, each of which is presented in such a way as to help normalize it? Is this a psyop?
It's popping up because it is slang and then it got picked up in the tech-sphere (which is highly adjacent to here) as the term of choice for the behavior of LLMs being overly supportive in chats.
It's all over the place right now because of people complaining about LLMs and then a bunch people picking up and using a youth term because "neat new" and "how do you do fellow kids."
The thing to remember here is that the show was conceptualized much closer to the Floyd/BLM time period.
Yeah I've always heard the writing was done quite proximal to Floyd events so it has zero moderation or sense.
I saw on Twitter someone comment that the idea that the company that owns Marvel, Star Wars, and Indiana Jones would need to look for a new IP to help draw in young male audiences in their teens & 20s is pretty hilarious and absurd.
You know it's fascinating. If the movies were actively actually bad (like worst Transformers movie bad) and you ran that for 20 years it would still be easier to recover from than what we got.
It's worse than bad.
Truly one of the most epic bag fumbles of all time.
Anecdotally - I was a kid who grew up a Star Wars nerd and it was a big part of my identity, establishing my interests, and so on. I spent a ton of money on it when I didn't have a lot of money to spend.
Now I'll never spend another cent not just because its bad right now (it is), not just because it hates me for demographic reasons (it does), but because it's associated in my mind with all the extremities and terrors of shitty social justice and all that did. I've seen too much fucked up stuff, lost friends, etc and Disney dropped their flag on that behavior.
Lots of people are never coming back and they didn't really connect anyone new.
It's really hard to tell what you are asking for specifically - are you asking for no romance at all? That's hard! Stories of any kind usually jam in a romance element because it is a "cheap" way to add additional appeal. Stories written for women or by women are more likely to do this because women are generally more interested in people, it's usually only hyper-masculine coded stories and themes that avoid any romance at all and even most war/military properties will find a way to slide in a romance element, even something close to explicitly homoerotic like Top Gun.
I've been on an anime binge recently so:
Full Metal Alchemist - written by a woman, most people can't tell.
Dan Da Dan - written by a man, many would guess the writer is a woman. Has lots to appeal to women and to men. Has a cute teenage romance that even some of my gym bros enjoy.
The Apothecary Diaries - written by a woman, clearly teenage girl fantasy elements but still enjoyable for many who hate that. Female lead has "super powers" but is helpless at the appropriate times and weird with significant character flaws. So yeah "basest" urges of women, maybe? But also illustrates that if you do a good job who cares. Same thing with hypermasculine product that everyone loves if it is good enough.
Now all three of those are Eastern so yes a possible theme here is The Message tanking artistic product, so to take it in another direction - how about Shrinking* and Ted Lasso? Two modern comedies with low levels of romance elements, strong female characters who aren't perfect (even the literal girl bosses), strong female coding in the form of lots of feelings discussion, therapy culture, and so on.
Non-slop and um, quality slop? still exist.
*only seen season 1 of Shrinking.
My wife's disabled, non-binary friend
Out of curiosity in which way is she (assuming natively she, correct me if otherwise) disabled?
This comes up on Reddit a lot so you can always search over there (Steins;Gate generally shows up on lists but I was never a fan of that anime in general).
Anything recent and high budget (ex: Dan Da Dan, Apothecary Diaries) is always likely to be good.
Someone else here mentioned Cowboy Bebop which I think is a good pick but that is in part because the English voice fits the mood and vibe better, I don't think the dub is truly stellar by modern standards.
My personal vote is FMA: B, the dub is pretty great and has some big names you'll recognize if you know their voices, but the outtakes are absolutely incredible and work better if you spent the show listening to those interpretations of the characters.
While I'm sure you had some exceptions I doubt you had the current situation where many states had problems with a flood of zero English effort population and the government was both forced to and decided it was fine to essentially instantiate a second official language.
And for instance the Pennsylvania Dutch are small, isolated, insular, and German - and still are. Very different from getting on public transit in NYC and getting surrounded by Spanish speakers.
If something has changed in the modern era, I would argue that it stems from the welfare state.
I am amenable to data that shows otherwise, but it seems to be that in ye olde days you came to America assimilated and depending on who and where you were you might be prevented from doing so by disgruntled locals.
Today the (hispanic at least) immigrants make no effort and seem to have no interest in assimilation. Even outside of Texas and California you see signs in Spanish everywhere, official governmental communication in Spanish and so on.
This is a huge difference in character of immigration with respect to previous waves of it.
My guess is that under the hood this was a political grenade and everyone deemed this the easiest way to defuse it without causing other problems. The reality of the law was likely subordinate to getting out as clean as possible.
So we get this - and move on.
I've seen a number of stories on the internet where someone states they found mountain lions outside the accepted range and the response from the government is "nope but actually yes it's just rare and I don't want to deal with the paperwork."
I can't say for sure if this is a meme or refection of reality.
Exactly! Is that enabling sclerotic politics? Is that perfect for enabling minority representation?
Shit I don't know but it is complicated and not a new political ethics problem caused by modern political division.
AuDHD
Made up shit likely because of poor understanding of the underlying substrate and map/territory issues.
Something like about 75% of patients with autism meet the criteria for at least one other mental illness and of the pot of mental illnesses something like about 75% meet the criteria for ADHD.
So it's not everyone but pretty close enough.
That said, I state "meet the criteria for" instead of "has the disease" which usually isn't very important but is instructive in this case since it is very possible that the underlying cause of the symptoms is not the "problem with the brain's hardware and software that causes the majority of ADHD symptoms in individuals with no other mental illness" and is instead a sequence of behavioral deficits better explained as caused by the same underlying issues as the autism which does a lot for explaining the prognosis* and high degree of comorbidity and at the same time just means that the person is going to get the same treatment as everyone else.
Psychiatric formulation is mostly a kludge used to jam something that resembles the medical model in place for purposes of billing and ease of communication.
Needless to say from my rant you aren't likely to catch much clinical conversation using AuDHD unless its more word bad less word good type situations.
However most of the wild type implementations of AuDHD are likely to pattern match to people identifying with their mental illness and trash tier social media engagement about health.
Sorry recently triggered by a soccer mom.
*I'd have to do a lit review to be sure but I'd hazard that spontaneous remission rates in pure ADHD patients are higher than in the ADHD with comorbid AUD population however this would be likely be hard to research.
If you date enough absolutely gorgeous women you will find out two things:
-
A shocking number of them are obnoxiously perfect (by which I mean they are smart, kind, and functional). It's quite unfair! ...And it puts pressure on the relationship because they know they can have anyone.
-
For the ones that aren't, well it gets tiring and it happens oddly fast (especially because most of them aren't good in bed). A girlfriend + porn rapidly starts to seem better than the 10/10 girlfriend who is annoying. If you happen to know a bunch of beautiful women closely you'll be shocked at how much some of the complain about not getting laid especially the ones in a serious relationship. The quote "no matter how hot she is, someone out there is sick of dealing with her shit" is prescient.
I imagine this guy is having some number two action.
Yeah it's a problem as old as the republic and has a buncha good to go with the bad - making a minority district so the minority actually gets a representative instead of just getting diluted is a good thing. Or a bad thing?
...It's deeply complicated.
The one I always think of -
I mean I worry that I get to say this because I have a high degree of financial security and that we shouldn't asking others to make the same mental commitment.
But it should be talked about.
Instead we see a lot of people with no skin in the game cheering and negatively impacted people struggling to admit to themselves that it wasn't what they wanted or not worth it.
Many major metro areas have big and tall stores, depending on yours they may have something that fits your needs or know how to help you look.
Depending on your social network you can sometimes find athletes who have the hookup or a decent plan that doesn't involve tailoring everything. Trickier to do but you'd be surprised how much of a market exists for "finding a home an NBA player can actually shower in" and how that trickles down.
I just gave up and wear scrubs but that probably doesn't help you.

I would advise people to be extremely careful about this because the rules are frequently revised, confusing, or impenetrable to patients.
Yeah you do see issues with straight up fraudulent charges at times (usually you see this in Medicare when someone gets caught and obliterated by a federal prosecutor) but usually it's completely by the book or mild but justified up-coding. Hospitals have entire departments whose job it is to comb through notes and make sure they extract every dollar from insurance.
Does talking to the patient about their relationship count as brief therapy? What if the psychiatrist uses CBT language you aren't familiar with? Does an ear lavage count as a procedure? Does time based billing refer to purely face to face time or does coordination of care, medication ordering, and documentation count? Can you use MDM as part of your E/M instead of or in addition to time based billing? When was the last time the answers to any of these questions changed?
Doctors often go to workshops that teach them how to bill correctly, yes to up-code but also to make sure they don't accidentally commit fraud by putting something in wrong. It's hard.
If you complain you may get some stuff knocked off but it's very possible you are making an accidental fraudulent complaint and they just don't want to fight about it.
Especially if your insurance is paying, help the health system out dawg.
The doctor is unlikely to find out you did complain but if it's an iterated relationship and you keep doing this you will end up with worse service because they'll get told to clean up their documentation and be careful and it will knock them out of their flow state and likely result in petty inconveniences (ex: more likely to rely to mychart with 'schedule an appointment'").
For OP specifically - I'm obviously a homer for the medical care side of things but you should consider that insurance companies are famous for incorrectly denying things that were provided and even things were provided and billed correctly.
More options
Context Copy link