self_made_human
amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi
I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.
At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!
Friends:
A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.
User ID: 454
I'll rest when I'm dead, but thank you, the exam went as well as could be hoped.
Thank you <3
I have never been this angry at an upcoming exam in my life, mostly because the "best" study material is out of date or dangerously misleading. But I'm less stressed than I was before, which might be mostly due to fatalism, but I'll take it.
Im definitely drinking something more alcohol-enriched than root beer tomorrow, I can tell you that.
I have answers that cannot fit in the margin of this comment box, mostly because I have a career gating exam tomorrow. Ask me later?
I have had two exes who managed to out-horny me, to the point where I was the one who had to stay in the dog-house when I turned them down. The spirit was willing, but the flesh couldn't take it anymore. No comments on the bruising. And I'm a red-blooded young man (or at least I could pass as young when this happened). It's one thing to know the theory, it's another to engage in praxis.
(Yes, steak too lobstery, butter too juicy, yada yada).
I suppose I'd take that over dating women with a low libido, which is no fun either.
I mean, I expect that selection pressure will eventually result in a return to normal or historical TFRs, if only because the high fecundity populations replace the ones who act like pandas in captivity.
I also think the late-reproducing people have a ton of negative externalities on the rest. of us and as they fail to replace themselves those externalities will fade and all of the well-adapted people will be happier and wealthier.
I am somewhat perplexed by how you, after telling me that I haven't done a basic cost-benefit analysis, happen to casually gloss over the rather catastrophic near to medium term economic and societal damage of societies with far more old people than children, or drastic population decline as projected.... in pretty much every developed country. And many developing ones.
I don't lose sleep over this, because I expect technological interventions like AGI+robotics, artificial wombs etc to reduce or eliminate the current coupling between population growth/composition and the stability of national economies. I genuinely don't think we're going to need humans for their physical or cognitive labor in a decade or change, possible less. It's the same reason I don't worry particularly hard about the worst case projections for global warming, if it gets that bad, someone is going to burn a billion dollars of sulphur or inject it into the stratosphere. Inertia only goes so far.
You do not seem as optimistic, nor even as open to technological solutions, and I do not see how you can reasonably claim that your distaste for nudging or assisting the sub-fertile into having more children (by any means) can compensate for decaying infrastructure or potential collapse in a generation or two. If it's business as usual with no major technological breakthroughs and serious social engineering (or even just the widespread adoption of the suggestions I've endorsed), I don't see how you account for the disaster that represents.
I have a very realistic looking houseplant. The fact that I haven't watered it since I moved in a year ago suggests that it's probably plastic. (Or that I've stumbled onto a hardy new species of Scottish cactus.)
Back home? A Labrador and a Golden. The former has two brain cells, both currently on lunch break. The latter is too smart for his own good. I adore them both, and I look forward to being settled enough to justify getting a dog here. I grew up with more dogs than I can count, which is unsurprising given that we also had more parrots than I could count, or that my grandfather once owned a tiger. (Yes, a tiger. A different time, a different country, very different ideas about what constitutes a reasonable household animal.) I think my kids should enjoy that same privilege, even if I've concluded that a single animal is perfectly adequate. This is probably the consequence of a serial injection of pragmatic genes into the family. The men in my ancestry tend toward pleasant eccentricity, the women toward laudable sanity. I'm not sure where I land.
My personal benchmark for canine intelligence is the ability to open doors. The Golden could do it from the moment he was tall enough to reach the handle on his hind legs. My Lab can't, and just stares at them mournfully until someone takes pity. An earlier German Shepherd managed it too, though less consistently than his mother. She was a rescue (so is the Golden), and she came into our house with a profound distrust of menfolk. It took over a year for her to accept that I wasn't going to hurt her, and then assent to scritches behind the ears. She'd graduated to begrudgingly accepting belly rubs a year or so before she passed. Her son, and every dog since, seems to gravitate toward me. Maybe it's because I'm unusually considerate of their needs, while my younger brother has been known to wield a chancla when they misbehave. My father is the living archetype of the "we are absolutely not getting more dogs" to "I cannot live without them" pipeline. My mother is usually the one who talks us into the original transgression.
Honestly, I'm glad that most of my dogs passed away suddenly, and painlessly. I support euthanasia in principle, but taking an animal I love to the vet with full knowledge that they aren't coming back with me would break parts of me I'd prefer to keep intact. Dogs live unfortunately short lives. Parrots live far too long.
Some say we don't deserve dogs. I find that farcical. They're one of humanity's greatest achievements: without anything resembling a modern understanding of genetics, we managed to turn a ravenous pack predator into a creature that will, more often than not, lay down its life for you. We made dogs. We deserve them. (If anything, the dogs got the better end of the bargain, though I doubt they'd phrase it that way.)
Cats? I don't mind them. I'm slightly fond of them. Some can be cute, and they seem to like me in particular because I don't go out of my way to fuss over them. I've irritated quite a few of my female cat-loving friends by being the lap of choice. While renting elsewhere, I once had a stake in a kitten who would always climb up into my bedsheets and snooze on my feet. I'd wake up every morning, and before I could panic-dress and run off to catch the bus, I had to make sure she was safely disentangled. I could have stepped on her without noticing, which is probably also why she enjoyed sleeping inside my shoes. I felt awful the one time I forgot to let her out of the bedroom, coming back from work to see her practically leap ten times her body length over my shoulder to escape. Oh well, at least she kept coming back. I wonder how she's doing these days. She was on the smaller side, and lived a semi-outdoor lifestyle in an area where cats go missing with distressing frequency. I hope she's fine, and that she has kittens who've found smaller shoes to fill.
My own case for it, without reference to fiction and with reference to real science, would lead me to write a book about dynastic aristocracies with supermen who control technology instead of letting technology control them.
I wish to note that I put serious weight on an oligarchic future where a few elites control AGI, and thus the rest of us. I am far more skeptical of genetic engineering being the primary driver behind the creation of a permanent underclass, for the same reason that cars went from being something that were the playthings of the rich to available to most. Everything I've described has gotten cheaper over time, often drastically so.
We spend way too much on healthcare and it really doesn't improve human happiness much. These medicines have pros and cons. You seem to fixate on the pros without acknowledging any cons. Why is that?
This is more reflective of your unfamiliarity with me. I mean that without insult. I've written on exactly that topic at length, multiple times, over years. I have very long effort-posts on the importance of using metrics like QALY/DALY and cost-benefit/cost-utility when it comes to dictating policy on medical care. If that weren't true, that would be a fair critique, but this is one of the rare occasions where I genuinely can't afford to be as thorough as I'd desire. I am not writing a policy white paper, I am crunched for time because of exams, and in all honesty, I shouldn't even be here in the first place. I have not pretended to have done a comprehensive cost-benefit analysis here, but I have linked to the work of people who have.
But considering my own output:
https://www.themotte.org/post/2899/culture-war-roundup-for-the-week/359026?context=8#context
I'll run the numbers on grandma, even if I already know the answer. A $300,000 treatment (roughly £240,000) for a 60% chance at two months (0.16 years) of very low-quality life (let's generously say 0.2 QALYs) results in a cost per QALY that is astronomically high. The answer from the system is a clear, predictable no. Conversely, a treatment with the same price tag for a teenager that offers a high chance of fifty more years of healthy life would be approved without a second thought. The system is explicitly utilitarian. It prioritizes maximizing the total amount of healthy life across the population. It can and will spend millions on a child, but it will counsel a family against a futile and painful intervention for a demented octogenarian. This isn't some big secret either. I have had such discussions with dozens of families, and not a single one has had a problem with it, or withdrawn their relative to go elsewhere, as they are at full liberty to do.
For those who find this calculus unsettling (I do not know why the standard approach to handling scarce resources unsettles anyone) the system provides an escape hatch. The existence of the NHS does not preclude private medicine. The wealthy, or anyone with good private insurance, can opt out of the public queue and pay for the treatment the state has denied. You can, in effect, disagree with the state’s valuation of a life year and substitute your own. The state provides a robust, free baseline for ninety-nine percent of situations, while allowing a private market for those who want more. A similar model exists in India, a country with far fewer resources than the United States (citation available on request) which manages to provide basic care for free while supporting a thriving private sector.
In other words, I am the last person who you should accuse of not considering the diminishing returns to further healthcare expenditure. Also, note that diminishing returns are not the same thing as no returns, let alone negative returns. If you have a billion dollars and want to spend all of it on care that has a negligible chance of healing you, be my guest. I'm more concerned with public policy and public funds.
I am also a transhumanist, so I want medical technology to get even cheaper (which it mostly has), alongside society getting wealthier. The expected result is that we end up with cheaper, better treatments, and can provide them to more people. Be it privately or through public funding.
Anyway, IVF is extremely expensive and basically works to perpetuate people who barely want to reproduce. That attitude correlates positively with other negative behaviors that punish those around them as well. The babies it makes are sicker on average. Why should we have more sick people who hate family life at such a high cost? Who does that benefit? I'm not seeing it pass the pros and cons audit.
There is very, very good reason that I advocated for embryo selection above and beyond subsidized IVF. Consider that that cuts down the majority of your arguments at the knee. The "sicker IVF babies" finding is largely driven by maternal age, multiple-embryo transfers (now declining as standard practice), and underlying parental subfertility rather than the IVF procedure itself. You can't accuse me of not acknowledging that, when I have already offered a solution.
I also do not particularly care about whether people "barely want to reproduce", as long as the answer is more yes than it is no. I'm not a gynaecologist, but in general, if someone tells me that they want children, I support them. Even if it would be easy to scold them for being irrational or indecisive and making things harder for themselves. In psychiatry, it's all too common for depressed people to not want to be helped, because depression strongly correlates with reduced self-esteem and a sense of being unworthy of care. Many people show up in front of me who just care enough to get out of bed and see a psychiatrist. I treat them nonetheless, and I am happy doing so.
The IVF population is overwhelmingly composed of couples who want children intensely (often more than the median fertile couple) and whose biology has betrayed them, and that conflating them with "people who barely want to reproduce" is incorrect.
Humans are fallible, non-omniscient and imperfectly rational actors, and society should make some concession to those unfortunate facts.
If you disagree with this on moral grounds, be my guest. I am on Scott's side, in the sense that Society is fixed, Biology is mutable.
Have you read Dune? It makes a compelling case that's the opposite of true.
The Logical Fallacy of Generalization from Fictional Evidence
You know what, maybe we shouldn't have invented treatments for malaria, chemotherapy for aggressive cancers, ozempic for the obesity epidemic. Maybe reducing infant-and-child mortality rates from the ~50% they hovered around for most of human history to the rounding error they are today was deeply misguided. Maybe doctors should all retire en masse and society should return to the state of nature, however we're defining that this Sunday.
If you disagree, then I think the arguments for trying to fix demographic collapse write themselves. If you don't, then we're not going to get anywhere.
Guys, have you ever spoken to any women about how many kids they want to have, if they want to have kids, and why don't they want ten kids like their grandmothers' generation?
Why yes, I've had this conversation with my serious partners. The answer ranged between 0 and 3, with the modal value being 2.
Would you undergo circumcision for any money if it was a repeated operation?
Any money? Like, how much money we talking about here? I'd do it for $250k, maybe even $100k. Hell, if they were pretty reasonable and made sure I was well anesthesized, I'd do for it much less. Presuming the foreskin grew back, and this isn't just the equivalent of removing my dick with a cheese grater. I would charge at least a few hundred million dollars for that.
Sadly this must remain a hypothetical, since I was circumcised for medical reasons, and I didn't even get paid for it.
The biggest problem with the rest of your arguments is that they're emotive/rhetorical, not numerate or quantitative.
Men will leave because "you pay more attention to the kids than me".
How many men? How often? Ballpark figures, even? Because lurid anecdotes are not a good argument.
At the end of the day, I'm a weak policy pro-natalist. I do not make it a general point of going around ordering women to have kids. I think the government should encourage people to have more kids, for a form of encouragement that is closer to an anti-smoking campaign than it is to a breeding camp. Personally? I simply wouldn't marry a lady who didn't want to have kids, and I am perfectly willing to make the sacrifices necessary to support them. No hypocrisy here.
British psychiatry trainees like me almost universally rely on a paid resource and question bank called SPMM for our written exams. It's very expensive for the entry level package, doubly so if you want their paid mocks, triply if you want a statistics crash course.
Why? Because the nominal syllabus is... everything. Or at least so large that it's completely impractical for even the best trainee to read the official reading list/syllabus and then understand whats relevant to the test. We have to rely on SPMM (or lesser known alternatives) to make things manageable.
You would think that the dedicated teaching we get during our training itself, or the Royal College's free online material would help right? Oh no, that's unwarranted optimism. Like it or not, you need SPMM.
Who is writing these questions and who is grading the responses?
SPMM claims to have unusual, perhaps questionably legal levels of insight into the actual questions that come on the exam (they probably ask the people who just gave it to jot down as much as they can from memory). That's alongside their doctors hand-crafting what they imagine are representative questions to pad things out. What kind of doctors? From what I can tell, ones just a few years senior to me. Which is not necessarily a bad thing, since they would have given the same exams recently.
I presume the same people choose the correct answer for the questions they wrote, and then the answer stem too. But once that's set in stone, the grading is automated. I can't even flag things to the attention of a human within the company. They don't care.
Assuming your situation is similar, it wouldn't surprise me if the mocks are being graded by non-practicing doctors who may not be doing the best job, especially, if like me, you went with a less expensive option than the industry standard.
Are they non-practicing? I hope not. They're probably just cash-strapped and asked to shit out a ton of output for not very much money. QC seems inadequate. Even their teaching material is riddled with errors. And this is the best money can buy!
I passed my earlier exam with a different version of the paid material, and I can tell you that the overall quality of things was grossly superior. This time, they're borderline scamming me. By the time I realized, it's too late to simply give up and read the primary sources, or even to switch to a competitor. Literally every other resident I know is in the same boat, and it's rapidly sinking.
The good news is that the actual exam, or at least the last one I gave, was mostly sane. Mostly. There was a question about the mechanism of action of a new antidepressant, where the real answer was "nobody knows", but I had to choose something else anyway. Praying that's the case here, but bad study material and bad mocks are driving me nuts.
I've had the displeasure of seeing that Reddit thread. The takes in it are so bad that they're known to the state of California to cause cancer.
Fortunate, the people chimping out in public are not the same people who make mods. I don't know about the VIC 3 modding community, but the CE discord is chill. My mod didn't get much backlash while published, and there are plenty of mostly AI made mods that do way more in terms of mechanics of depth, all without popular outcry. The people on the subreddit can cry away, they have no real power over things.
From a psychiatric perspective, I must discourage self-harm and adjacent practices.
I wish to note that my proposal is not mutually exclusive with anything you've said.
What differentiates $10k for egg-harvesting from a direct reward for natality?
- It particularly helps the middle class and UMC, who are the most likely to postpone fertility till it falls off a cliff.
- You get the eggs in hand, and the demographic that is most likely to experience severe hindsight regret gets optionality later.
- An actual child is much more inconvenient to produce. My recollection is there's strong empirical evidence that comparable cash awards for actual child birth have barely done anything at all, though I don't have the time to go digging right now. Exams.
So the real target for my proposal are people who want kids, but have a tendency to postpone things till it's way too late. At that point, having eggs preserved (preferably from way earlier) would be an absolute godsend. To contrast, if they wanted to get the $10k for the child then, it's far more likely that it's too late. That's true regardless of how badly they want the kids.
The benefit of the wider embryo-selection policy is that avoids or minimizes dysgenic effects. Even if $10k means a lot more to the poor, you can still screen and select for the higher quality potential children. Conveniently, the same markers that promise general good health also correlate positively with IQ. Follow the LW link for a better exploration of that point. You don't even need to do the politically difficult thing of actively selecting for IQ, you can just say you want healthier kids (by pretty standard definitions of health) and get IQ points as a happy little accident.
And even if there's no embryo selection? Well, at least we have good eggs for the IVF. That should make a difference. There's plenty of other things you could reasonably try, but I'm not writing a policy whitepaper here.
How many times has one particular poster here been accused of using AI, denying it, and then sheepishly admitting that he "polished" it with AI?
On the off-chance that you're referring to me, I'd appreciate evidence that I've ever denied using AI when asked (when I've actually used it, which isn't most of the time). Au contraire, I make it a point to admit that I have, if asked, including being painfully specific with proof-of-work when I have it.
Here is a specific example:
https://www.themotte.org/post/3690/culture-war-roundup-for-the-week/434542?context=8#context
I can't think of who else you might be referring to, barring perhaps our dear friend @BurdensomeCount, and even he had the grace to admit to it when specifically challenged. By me. With my mod hat on. I suppose we have had our share of bad-actors who try to get away with AI spam, but that's the kind of thing that gets caught by the moderation filter or explicitly warned/banned.
If you mean someone else entirely, then please disregard, though preferably not before you clarify things.
Suppose you made IVF 100% subsidized and free, you still have to convince young women to undergo an invasive surgical procedure.
Young women, the demographic known to be particularly fond of cosmetic surgery? Hmm..
The easiest answer is to bribe pay them. I expect plenty of takers if it's a $10k one-off, with heavy government encouragement.
As far as I can tell, my proposal involves less demanding all-encompassing public propaganda or government intervention than any alternative I can name. Is it a perfect solution? Of course not, but praying away cratering TFRs might be cheap and also wouldn't work.
"Patient displays dimished insight into condition"
(That's a joke)
I would bet good money on you having Aspergers (or high functioning ASD, as we'd call it these days). This is mostly a gestalt clinical impression on the basis of significant familiarity/fond perplexity. It's not a formal diagnosis. I haven't had the pleasure of meeting you (I am sadly not invited to the party), which is the bare minimum for a formal diagnosis. Or actually, below the bare minimum, because the GMC would disbar me if that was my standard practice.
Man... Where would I even begin to answer that question? That's a serious statement.
A written house warming invite is perfectly fine. The specific format and terminology you've used is... unusual. Please note that I'm not assigning any negative connotations here at all. Never have. It's friendly riffing on the internet with a kernel of truth in it. It is abundantly clear that you are high-functioning and a productive member of society, even after retirement. You should probably get that depression properly checked out, if you haven't already. You clearly know where to find a PHQ-9 form.
Come on, you're exaggerating here.
To be clear, I don't think any degree of autism, by itself, can get a human being ITAR restricted. Nor do I actually believe you can manage to build a space elevator, at least not with a reasonable budget. Megastructural engineering is probably not your area of expertise as a civil engineer, but then again, you probably know the specs of elevator-planning, and what is a space elevator but a very, very tall elevator?
Okay. I'm burnt out on exam prep right now, so I will take a half-hearted crack at identifying supportive elements from the textual evidence provided:
The autism is that your housewarming invitation opens like a government form, proceeds by FAQ, and invokes 2024 International Fire Code 1004.5 to explain why invitees may bring one pet but no household members. You cite the occupant load factor for "assembly without fixed seats, unconcentrated (tables and chairs)," derives a 14-person cap, concedes the IFC isn't actually applicable to private residences, and then independently re-derives the same number from your floor plan geometry. Three justifications, in order, for the guest cap on a sixteen-person gathering.
A five-level wellness rubric with columns for Willpower, 24/7 headache, Enjoyment of life, and Rough time period, with your current 2-to-3-out-of-5 rating disclosed in a public appendix circulating to your former colleagues and your brother. I am genuinely glad you are not still at 1/5. Late 2025 sounds rough. Your coworkers from the retirement job, though, probably did not show up looking for a quarterly state-of-the-soul report. I mean, I can't rule that out either, maybe all civil engineers are like this?
Capitalized WILL in "Entry WILL be refused to anything beyond that," where "anything" rather than "anyone" is appropriate because pets are grammatically inanimate. The same all-caps treatment on "My plan for the future is to RELAX." Consistent signature style throughout. Your mother parenthetically identified as "the renter of a bedroom in the house" rather than as your mother, because... I genuinely don't know. I am the wrong flavor of neurodiverse for that.
I must reiterate: no negative connotation. I'm saying this with sincere affection and anthropological awe. You are clearly high-functioning, productive, technically competent, conscientious, and capable of producing documents that make normal people look like chimps poking at drywall with a stick. When you ask "what exactly about this is autistic?", you so while standing inside a two-page exhibit titled Invitation to Housewarming Party with appendices A through D.
People like you are probably responsible for 90% of human civilization, especially the boring but important bits. That's also my approximate level of confidence in the autism diagnosis.
I'm not going to get into the whole cultural debate around declining TFR or putative causes. I am painfully pragmatic, and what I intend to demonstrate is that there is a technological solution to the problem (the best kind of solution, mwah):
A country as wealthy as Sweden can circumvent the dysgenic concerns raised by @sleepyegg through embryo selection. The primary costs are the IVF itself, which should be in the realm of affordability for the middle class and above (who suffer disproportionately from reduced TFR). If not, I think any sane government should be willing to spend enormous sums of money to prevent population collapse.
You can screen for a lot of things, including strong proxies for health/mutational load. The screening itself is a trivial fraction of the cost compared to the egg extraction, freezing and IVF, and as mentioned it's the IVF that's the costly part.
Further, implantation success rates are remarkably stable even for older women. It's the age of the ova itself that matters, someone using eggs they harvested at 25 when they're in their late 30s is way more likely to succeed (for a given number of cycles) than that person using recently harvested eggs.
In other words, the uterus can handle things just fine for a very long time. The eggs continue to degrade the longer they stay in the ovary. You're already born with all the eggs you'll ever have if you're a woman, or as man, though that depends on when you last went to the supermarket. The success rate for implantation or the dysgenic effects of mutational load on the viability or overall health of the eggs/children increase precipitously once you're in your 30s. It's no coincidence that the risk of Down syndrome shoots up with increasing maternal age around that time.
The problem is, of course, that few governments have crossed the minimum sanity threshold to do these things. The fruit couldn't hang much lower without already being in the dirt.
Recommended reading:
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/dxffBxGqt2eidxwRR/the-optimal-age-to-freeze-eggs-is-19
As a matter of fact, I would strongly recommend everything GeneSmith has ever written on the topic. I'd trust him to smith my genes, or those of my children.
https://open.substack.com/pub/rawandferal/p/norman-polycule?r=a71by
Funniest thing I've seen all year. That's my honest assessment, I was there from the start, before it was officially disclosed as satire (that was obvious to me, but apparently not to millions of people).
Such a shame. I wish I had an invite, but if you thought trying to attend Inkhaven was hard, imagine me trying to explain to the American embassy staff that I want to attend the house warming party of an online acquaintance with weapons-grade autism.
I dare say that your autism is so strong it would be ITAR-restricted. Imagine if you resettled in China: they'd have a working space elevator in two weeks, built to code handed down retrocausally by the Singleton at the end of time.
I don't even know man. I think that there's only like a 5% chance that this is satire only matched by that fake Bay Area polycule invite from a month back. The rest of my probability mass is mostly on you playing this straight, with perhaps some degree of self-awareness/attempted humor (which works).
Please share the final form when you're done. I might do a case study on it, or at least a funny essay. And good luck with the actual housewarming, even if it involves inviting your uncool brother.
since they need to be great at them to get anywhere inside India, and if I were in their position I'd 100% do the same thing
This is incorrect, I'm afraid. You can't use that kind of identity politics to get ahead the way you can in the States. When do you get the tangible benefits in the form of reservations and quotas for being lower caste? When you have a certificate from the government that says your ancestors were lower caste.
Can you get a fake one? Technically yes, but you'd be spending a lot of money on bribes, and you'd be rather screwed if you were caught. I don't know anyone who did this, though I'm sure it does happen (as I always say, India is a big country, with many Indians).
No, the sad reality of it is that the kind of person you spoke to learned to play that game in the States, or were intelligent and unprincipled enough to be well prepared before they got there.
- In psychiatry most problems are fixed by an SSRI or an antipsychotic - who cares if they have schizophrenia, schizoaffective, or bipolar disorder if the solution is the same.
You're giving me exam PTSD, and I haven't even given the exam. SSRIs are not just what you'd rely on for BPAD, there's a ton of context for when they're actively harmful, or when you need antipsychotics and mood stabilizers. Good to know that the exam prep prepares me for discussions on this underwater basket weaving forum.
Thank you for advice, I do appreciate it. But I will say that my Motte use is a hobby and, in a very real sense, a coping mechanism.
Let's say I've had a really, really bad time before my exams. I've been taking more stimulants than I can tolerate. They're wearing off, and my focus is gone. Or I'm waiting for the next dose to kick back in. This is dead time. I can't study. Instead, I could be using Twitter or Discord. I'd rather be here. I get to talk about interesting things with interesting people. I write about what's going on, which is in part a letter to ny future self. I hope that pain and suffering converts to some degree of amusement for my readers, someone ought to be laughing after all.
And guess what? Half of what I write about is psychiatry. I love psychiatry. I just don't like the way it's taught or trained in the UK. This gives me a small fig leaf. I can pretend that I'm being semi-productive. Maybe some if it is genuinely productive
But without truly draconian steps, being on the Motte is good for me. It's where the people cheering me on live.
A slight tangent. About a year back, I made a Rimworld mod. Minuscule in scope: a handful of infantry-grade railguns, designed to work exclusively with Combat Extended, a popular and (depending on who you ask) deeply contentious mod.
CE is something I refuse to play without. It transforms vanilla Rimworld's ranged combat from "two blind, drunk, concussed gangbangers shooting airsoft pistols at each other" into something resembling tactical depth and realism. Every self-respecting gun nut has it installed.
(Sorry Zorba. Rimworld combat is dogshit. I've been on CE since at least Alpha 14.)
The trouble with adding weapons is that they require art. Sprites, at the bare minimum. I am not an artist. For years, going back to early Stable Diffusion, I had been trying to coax AI image generators into producing decent guns in the Rimworld style, with results ranging from "comically bad" to "merely embarrassing". I gave up several times. That changed with GPT Image 1 and Nano Banana, which, after a fair bit of prompting and selection, finally produced passable output.
I should specify that the vanilla artwork for Rimworld is also awful. Nobody plays it for the graphics. The guns are particularly egregious; they look like plastic goop, especially if you use mods that let you zoom the camera in. Most self-respecting modders make their art to substantially higher standards, even if the game itself doesn't reward photorealism.
(Sorry again Zorba, but it's true.)
What I ended up with was decent. Probably well above the average amateur human artist-modder, though not as good as the best.
I also tried to get the AI of the day to write the code for me. This did not go well. Rimworld code is niche, Combat Extended code is niche-squared, and the available models simply weren't up to the task. It also might have been a skill issue on my end.
In the end, I wrote the code myself, asking for guidance on the Discord and lifting scaffolding from open-source and permissively licensed mods. The result wasn't perfect, but it worked.
Then came the part I was actually dreading. I posted the finished product, AI-generated art included, for feedback. I expected a shitstorm and I got one, though smaller than feared, and largely confined to one reasonably famous modder. He is best known (or most notorious) for using what can be charitably described as fetish art for the thumbnails of his mods, regardless of their actual content. To my pleasant surprise, the majority of the other modders were either neutral or supportive (one of them, I believe, lurks here, hi). I told him to get bent and stick to the fetish art. I explained that I was making free content, in my spare time, and that his gatekeeping was somewhere between unwarranted and retarded. I even said that I fully expect my own profession, the one that pays the bills, to get automated eventually. I can't stop that. I'm just enjoying the newfound ability to work around my utter lack of talent at the visual arts. The reception of this position was, again, better than I had any right to expect. Most Rimworld modders work for free, and they understand that even a small mod represents real opportunity cost.
The mod went up. It was unabashedly niche, but over a hundred people downloaded it and a dozen favorited it.
That was almost a year ago. Recently, bored, I considered making a better version with the new tools at my disposal. In hindsight, I should have used my Claude Max plan for the code, but I now know enough to bumble through. I made new art assets and posted them for feedback. Enough time had passed that most people had forgotten the original controversy and were appreciative. Then, on cue, that same jerk-off showed up, and we had our usual sparring match. I was expecting it. What I wasn't expecting was that, even after the AI-generated nature of the new assets was disclosed, the majority continued being supportive.
That included some seriously talented modders, ones known for producing high quality art. It warms the cockles of my heart to see people being reasonable, or at least on my side. Their verdict was that the art was now better than average, up to the standards of the best human work being done in Rimworld. The guns even made sense from a design/realism standpoint, GPT-Image 2 in particular is remarkably intelligent, and it knows what distinguishes a near future but plausible railgun from a standard firearm in Hollywood furniture. Prompting it is a piece of cake.
I'll probably get to a proper version after my exam. The interesting thing is the trajectory: making the art itself went from impossible, to a PITA, to nearly trivial. Maybe I'll tackle something more ambitious. I have thoughts about Rimworld's medical system and its approach to mental health and psychology. I've helped on a mod that fixes some of the issues, though my role there is best described as "local doctor you can ping for advice on trauma medicine". I've done freelance consulting on much larger projects, including some tactical shooters. A few systems in Gray Zone Warfare (a Tarkov competitor) made it in on my recommendation. Good times.
The best part of the anti-AI controversy is how easy it is to ignore the detractors, particularly when you aren't trying to make money off any of this. All I want is the opportunity to make cool things, for my own enjoyment and that of others. If someone isn't cool with that, that is their problem.

Shameless hijacking of the SSQ for a Wellness/Fun topic, because I just can't wait till the middle of the week. Forgiveness requested in advance.
Ahhhh. The exam is over. Is it over for good? I don't know. The Royal College usually takes about 5 weeks to release results, uncannily close to how long you spend waiting on a new antidepressant before you can tell anyone whether it's working.
By this point in my career, I've made peace with the fact that my anxiety and post-exam nihilism do not correlate particularly strongly with exam performance. I've done well (or at least passed) every test to date, even when the emotions actively present while I'm staring at the screen are some mixture of incredulity, frank confusion, and mild despair.
I dare say I felt less actively homicidal during this year's Paper B than its predecessor. The majority of questions seemed reasonable. There might be one or two utter stinkers in there, but unlike last time, my frank confusion is just as likely to be the product of my ignorance as it is incomplete information or bad phrasing. Progress, of a sort.
Working myself to near-meltdown did pay off, even if the last week and change was spent un-teaching myself what SPMM taught me.
When I first saw them reference NICE/SIGN guidelines from 2019/2020 many months ago, I assumed they did this because the guidance hadn't meaningfully changed since then. This was wrong. Badly wrong. About 20% of the material is out of date. The core management of psychiatry has not undergone any fundamental upheaval (haha, no), but NICE does its usual cost-benefit/utility analysis and pushes out minor updates whose effects ripple through the decision trees. I spent my last week of revision correcting these dangerous errors instead of actually being able to study. I pay these fuckers to do that for me. They haven't updated jack-shit since at least 2022.
Can you give methylphenidate to a child with ADHD and comorbid tic disorders? SPMM (quoting older NICE) says no. New papers by 2025 say: uh, actually, probably fine. No need to condemn the poor bastards to guanfacine, which doesn't help with inattentiveness. This precise question came up in my exam, and I chose methylphenidate, praying that if the College demands its trainees stay up to date, it has the courtesy to do the same.
I said I was tired. I still am. Nervous energy and the upper limits of Ritalin intake only go so far. I came out of the exam hall craving a drink. Craving two, maybe, or three and four if time allowed. Six seven? What, do I look Italian?
This means I have not bothered to sit down and do a proper post-mortem to see whether my answers were correct. I couldn't be arsed. Still can't be. Maybe tomorrow, if I haven't forgotten everything by then.
The most exciting event during the exam was the fire alarm going off, prompting a rapid evacuation of the test center. Nobody seemed to be in a position to answer reasonable questions like "is the building actually on fire?" or "can we pause our fucking tests while you figure this out?" or "what if I'm willing to fight the fire with water (coolers and actual extinguishers) if that's the price of a pass?" We spent half an hour in the rain, grumbling and despairing in equal measure.
It turned out to be a false alarm. We were allowed back to our seats, and after an interminable wait, the invigilators managed to get hold of the RCP and wrangle extra time on the test for us. I consider this an absolute personal win. I stretched my legs, drank some water, and took an ibuprofen for the mounting headache. If the exam had actually been cancelled or postponed, I was angry enough to sue, and so were most other trainees. Some intend to lodge a formal complaint anyway.
I used the extra time to revise my revision, changing a grand total of 2 questions to another, equally plausible answer. Idk, the vibes were better. I was exhausted, it had been 4 hours in there, and ibuprofen and nicotine gum only go so far.
I left with time to kill and went to the seedier, smaller parts of Glasgow. Always a good way to get a feel for the place. At a tiny pub the size of my living room, I had a pleasant time with the bartender and his geriatric buddies. I fielded multiple questions about the accent (I have a mental script handy) and explained that their guess on its provenance was as good as mine. They suggested Canadian, which is... maybe? Some of them had actually visited Toronto, so they might be onto something. I'll continue calling it a mongrel for now.
Then a haircut. Not strictly necessary, but I needed to treat myself. I treated myself to a hefty bill: £38 for a cut and shave at a Turkish barber, where my actual barber was a pleasant enough Scottish man with ADHD and depression (we had a productive discussion that changed nothing; it was idle conversation). At least it's a great haircut, done super quick. Maybe ADHD can be a superpower, if that superpower is running a trimmer at speed? Whatever. I got a nice hot towel waterboarding experience (probably billed) and coffee and nicotine gum (entirely free, thank god).
Then a sinfully delicious meal at a pub. Goan venison with rice and a whole-ass femur cracked open to let the marrow out. I could have had seconds. Instead, I settled for a helping of Vietnamese later from somewhere cheap and cheerful.
Then a train back, where I had the opportunity to debrief my parents before it got too late in India. To my pleasant surprise and bemusement, I'd received another arranged marriage proposal. Daughter of dad's medical colleague, a fully qualified dentist. I would like to claim I used to have a slight crush on her when we were kids meeting every year or so, but I could be imagining things entirely. Apparently she'd been stalking my Instagram and liked what she saw? Good for her, girl, but I live in a different country and like my teeth the way they are. If I didn't, I'd go talk to those Turkish gents. They'd hook me up.
I was also bombarded with an unusually high number of likes on dating apps, those technically-still-on-my-phone shrines desperate to remind me of their existence. I suppose my sunny disposition suits Glasgow, which lacks any solar insolation for most of the year. Certainly for as long as I was in it. Someone claimed I had a contagious smile, which is probably the better kind of very local endemic condition.
Not a bad day. Managed to take the train home uneventfully, managed to crawl into bed, and also managed to dread going back to work tomorrow. My sleep cycle is in dire need of new tyres. I'm tired. Adios.
More options
Context Copy link