Why are some Christians so intent on rejecting evolution? I've come across a series of blog posts that have really raised my hackles by arguing against evolution using the most disprovable of hypotheses. For example, in the first article, Yoshi claims that we don't have any direct evidence of evolution, but we literally do, and even if we didn't have any direct link between the appearance of a phenotype and the appearance of a genetic cause for that phenotype (a transposable element), personal incredulity of molecular genetics is not a valid argument. Abiogenesis (the topic of the second article) is a more tricky subject, but again Yoshi completely fails to engage with the relevant literature that would easily refute his most wild claims (that bacterial genes can't evolve rapidly: the lenski experiments showed that E. coli could evolve an entirely new metabolic pathway to metabolize citrate in less than 20 years). This isn't just isolated to internet crazies. My godfather, who is a very smart, educated man, sent me the second article because he thought it was convincing, and multiple of the Dominicans at the parish I used to attend also told me that they thought evolution was unlikely to be true because it was incompatible with scripture (one of the reasons I ended up leaving that particular Parish, and the church in general).
The Catholic Church as a whole is actually agnostic about evolution, so it doesn't make sense for it to be something that people believe because the church said so. I also had no problem believing in evolution and christ when I did go to church. In a conversation with my old roommate last night, he suggested that the real issue could be related to undermining the role of Jesus in history. After Adam and Eve sin in the Garden, God introduces death, which Jesus' sacrifice supposedly saves us from. Even if you take death to be a psychological idea related to consciousness (after the fall we understood that we died, which made death real), rather than assuming humans were immortal before Eve ate the apple, evolution undermines this whole narrative. Another possibility related to this one is that evolution makes the distinction between human and animal souls much more artificial, undermining the anthropocentrism that is so important to Christianity (and many other faiths too).
I'm curious if any actual creationists on this form can chime in on why evolution is problematic from a theological perspective. I personally cannot really endorse a belief system that is incompatible with both free inquiry into these types of questions, and unwilling to examine the evidence from the real world (God's more true bible), which a big part of why I've completely stopped going to church.
Ehhh the world is still very dependent on diesel (including China). I'm much more bullish than you for that reason. Gas consumption sure, but diesel seems to be a sticker. Diesel is still close to 7/gallon where I live, whereas oil has returned to normal.
I want a blog post on Norwegian Wood! I love this book too and would love to hear more of your thoughts.
I was an AI doubter for a long time. After using it for work for the past three months, no longer so much. It's a better biologist than me (it just can't do benchwork). Add on a few more layers of recursive self-improvement, and it'll be a better biologist than my PI. We don't even need super intelligence for this thing to completely flip the entire job market on its head.
Why would I ever hire a tax accountant or financial planner when AI can do these things far better for far less money? The entire white-collar finance wing of the economy, which most of my "successful" peers seem to be a part of is going to fall apart in the next few years, even without super intelligence. Same goes for software, administration, and many other cushy PMC positions. The world is going to change rapidly, even without super intelligence.
Nah I'll do a November update/December goals post on the first WW in December.
Haven't been doing an amazing job with my goals, probably because I have too many (although I am not single anymore which is huge), and I think the weekly update is a little distracting because it's too granular. Next year I want to have few and very concrete goals, which will probably benefit from checking in more frequently.
Yup!
I think I'm going to switch to monthly updates, as I can provide a more meaningful and reflective update that way.
Huh cool, I didn't know about this serial endosymbiosis!
I will say that even in that case the mitochondrial origin event is still a little different, as it was the fusion of two very different clades of life (Asgard archae and alpha-proteobacter).
In Lane's book (The vital question) there was also some evidence for a proto eukaryote found via deep sea trawling. So you may be right.
Yea but all of those symbioses happened after the initial mitochondrial endosymbiosis, which drove adaptions that made those subsequent acquisitions much easier. I think there’s something special about that first endosymbiosis that makes it especially difficult.
I think eukaryotic life is probably pretty rare in the universe. Happened a single time in evolutionary history and there are no intermediates. Will provide more detail later.
Seconding that rec. Worked very well for me. Still struggle with sleep sometimes, but there's never any anxiety about it any more.
It's frustrating that apple continues to make phones bigger. I don't want to switch to an android phone because the iPhone is just such a good product, but at the same time I don't want to be spending 2-3 hours a day on this thing after spending 8 hours at work on my computer.
Iphone 17e. The screen is much larger and more pleasant to look at, which means I look it at it more.
- Work: frustrating week at work because equipment keeps breaking.
- Fitness. Knee is still bothering me but I've started running again. Not sure if this is the greatest idea, so checking in with my PT and coach to see if it's safe to do so.
- Intellectual stuff. Wrote two blog posts last month, and have been continuing my study of history, although not making as much progress as I would like.
- Finances. Ended up spending around $3400 last month, which is pretty typical, giving me a savings rate of 13% after taxes. I apparently have been overcounting taxes significantly, so I'm really saving a lot more than this, but I'm going to keep it like it is this year to make sure I pay capital gains tax appropriately.
- Dating. Hung out with my girlfriend once on Thursday night and another time on halloween!
- Tarot. No session this week.
- Social: friend's halloween party.
- Screen time: 2.5 hours phone. Big new phone is really addicting and now I have to bring it to work so my screen time is really on the rise.
- Meditation: Have moved up to 15 minutes a day, sometimes twice a day. Looks like I've collectively meditated 7 times (15 minutes each) since the last update, which is huge!
I don’t know man. People trot out Aquinas and Augustine like it’s some slam dunk (at least in the catholic circles I used to frequent a few years ago). Then you read the guys and they’re riddled with logical fallacies.
Reading that article I see that we are capped at 10k of those bonds per year. Is that right?
-
Work: got roped into this AI project at work which is getting me excited but also nervous about how I'm going to manage my time.
-
Fitness. Knee is bothering me so I'm pushing off the start of formal training for another week.
-
Intellectual stuff: Feeling overwhelmed with work so haven't made much progress on anything.
-
Finances: Haven't spent much more this month, on track to be under $3100. Trying to square away some delisted securities and a 403b account I didn't know I had before the end of the year.
-
Dating. Saw the girlfriend once last week and we are going to a halloween party as penguins together.
-
Tarot. No session this week.
-
I was in Shedendoah all weekend with XC friends from when I was on the team earlier in my PhD. Super fun time, but drank way too much.
-
Screen time: 2.2 hours phone. Big new phone is really addicting and I'm playing way too much Pokemon Champions.
-
Meditation: Have moved up to 15 minutes a day once a day so far this week.
Where can one get semaglutide in the US without prescription. My roommate is struggling with having to eat a huge amount of food (way more than his metabolism needs) and I think Ozempic could help him out a lot.
You gotta read the book now. More of my thoughts about it here, but I didn’t really like how the movie sanitized the books inherent pessimism.
https://deusexvita.substack.com/p/review-8-of-2024-cloud-atlas?r=u4cqu
- Work: continue to make slow and steady progress on the last part of my PhD.
- Fitness. Started training a bit for Boston. I'll be following a plan by John "Hadd" Walsh which I can't start until I get to about 50 miles/week, which should be some time in mid November. Added in a 10 minute stretching routine before bed, which should hopefully help with some injury/flexibility issues.
- Intellectual stuff: Finished War and Peace and War (hoping to do an effort post on this book soon, it was great), and have started listening to another audiobook of Turchin's which I am also really enjoying. Spanish has fallen a bit by the wayside, but that's okay because I'm reading a lot. I've fallen a bit behind on blog posts, but that's also okay as I've published quite a bit this year.
- Finances: Spending has been pretty bad this month because of three big purchases (Chicago marathon for next year, Shenandoah trip, and two rounds of metabolic testing for $400). Money from parents should help with being in the green for the month (money market dividends should be very large from the extra $200k I have in the account), but I still need to practice better fiscal discipline. Spending so far: $2775.
- Dating. Hung out with the girlfriend all of last weekend and she met some more of my friends.
- Tarot. No session this week.
- Socializing: Spanish happy hour, saw my friend Emory at the Baltimore marathon, hung out with my girlfriend's sister and husband.
- Screen time: 2.5 hours phone. Big new phone is really addicting.
- Meditation: Butyeko meditation sessions 3 x a week before bed.
- Work: nothing new to report.
- Fitness. Chicago went great until 24 miles then I had to walk run to prevent cramping. I was on pace for 2:40 or under, but lost a good 4 minutes in the last 2 miles to finish a 2:44. I wrote up more about my race and the prep on my blog. Now it's time for two weeks off and then training for Boston!
- Intellectual stuff: Bopping around a lot of books right now, trying to finish some up. Highlights include War and Peace, War and Peace and War, and the Vital Question. The first is with my girlfriend, the second is for philosophy book club, and the third is so I can write a blog post on the origins of life to push back against some creationist substackers who are arguing that abiogenesis is impossible.
- Finances: My parents transferred another third of the money to my account yesterday, meaning I can start talking to realtors about buying a house in the spring. Spending so far this month: $1800.
- Dating. Didn't see my girlfriend all week, but called/FaceTimed her which was good!
- Tarot. No session this week.
- Socializing: Saw a bunch of friends at the Chicago Marathon, spent some time with my parents, and went to the beach with my friend Jeff.
- Screen time: 1.6 hours phone
- Meditation: started Buteyko breathing, which has been helpful for giving me more motivation for meditation. 3 sessions last week.
How do you find time to read so much?
Damn what a good summary of Harry Potter and some of the things I love about it and it's message.
What Romantasy would you recommend checking out? Might be a good way to get some of my foreign language hours up?
Mutual warm feelings!
- Prev
- Next

Just read that comment chain. Interestingly enough it was Teilhard that got me started on this whole thing, because I really liked his attempts to square the circle re: evolution and some of the other problems I had with Christianity (why are we the only beings in the universe to receive the salvation of Christ in this very small slice of history/time). I really really liked the idea of cosmic christ, but when I brought it up to the priests at the Parish they shut me down because a). Teilhard was censored and b). Saint Paul said christ only died once so cosmic christ can't be true. I found it really off-putting that my attempts to make Christianity more palatable to myself were shut down so hard basically because of close-mindedness, and I stopped going to church shortly thereafter.
More options
Context Copy link