This weekly roundup thread is intended for all culture war posts. 'Culture war' is vaguely defined, but it basically means controversial issues that fall along set tribal lines. Arguments over culture war issues generate a lot of heat and little light, and few deeply entrenched people ever change their minds. This thread is for voicing opinions and analyzing the state of the discussion while trying to optimize for light over heat.
Optimistically, we think that engaging with people you disagree with is worth your time, and so is being nice! Pessimistically, there are many dynamics that can lead discussions on Culture War topics to become unproductive. There's a human tendency to divide along tribal lines, praising your ingroup and vilifying your outgroup - and if you think you find it easy to criticize your ingroup, then it may be that your outgroup is not who you think it is. Extremists with opposing positions can feed off each other, highlighting each other's worst points to justify their own angry rhetoric, which becomes in turn a new example of bad behavior for the other side to highlight.
We would like to avoid these negative dynamics. Accordingly, we ask that you do not use this thread for waging the Culture War. Examples of waging the Culture War:
-
Shaming.
-
Attempting to 'build consensus' or enforce ideological conformity.
-
Making sweeping generalizations to vilify a group you dislike.
-
Recruiting for a cause.
-
Posting links that could be summarized as 'Boo outgroup!' Basically, if your content is 'Can you believe what Those People did this week?' then you should either refrain from posting, or do some very patient work to contextualize and/or steel-man the relevant viewpoint.
In general, you should argue to understand, not to win. This thread is not territory to be claimed by one group or another; indeed, the aim is to have many different viewpoints represented here. Thus, we also ask that you follow some guidelines:
-
Speak plainly. Avoid sarcasm and mockery. When disagreeing with someone, state your objections explicitly.
-
Be as precise and charitable as you can. Don't paraphrase unflatteringly.
-
Don't imply that someone said something they did not say, even if you think it follows from what they said.
-
Write like everyone is reading and you want them to be included in the discussion.
On an ad hoc basis, the mods will try to compile a list of the best posts/comments from the previous week, posted in Quality Contribution threads and archived at /r/TheThread. You may nominate a comment for this list by clicking on 'report' at the bottom of the post and typing 'Actually a quality contribution' as the report reason.

Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Notes -
A modest proposal to solve the trans sports issue (and maybe also all other gender issues in human society)
(Warning: controversial and lizard brain pilled. I’m not sure how much I actually believe this, I just want to have some fun speculating)
Recently, despite the massive blue wave in the midterm election, there was one conservative victory: the state of Washington (a very blue state!) passed a ballot measure that banned trans girls from competing on girls’ sports teams. This has triggered a quick lawsuit, and I have to think it’ll get struck down, but we’ll see. At any rate, it shows what a controversial issue this still is.
My proposal: stop segregating girls and boys sports teams all together. “Separate but equal is inherently unequal.” We already make them take classes together, and in fact mix genders in almost every activity now, even the Boy Scouts! Separate male and female bathrooms are also quickly becoming a thing of the past. And women are now proudly welcomed into every branch of the military, even front-line infantry. Also, kids are fully expected to play together during elementary school sports, as well as most adult rec leagues. So why are middle and high school sports this one, weird exception where everyone wants segregation?
I think that if we’re being honest, there’s one clear reason: it’s because the boys are too much better than the girls. We make the separate girls league so that the girls can win and feel good about themselves. It’s to give them self-confidence.
But isn’t that anathema to sports? Or at least, to competitive sports where there’s tryouts and tournaments and stuff? It feels wrong that the same league which says “you must do everything to be the very best and win” also says “but we’ll make a special, easier division to give out more trophies to the weaker players.”
At a stroke, this instantly solves the transgender issue. Everyone plays on the same team. No need for “vagina inspection day” or however the hell Washington was planning to do it. (And if you ban trans girls from the girls team, then where are they supposed to play? I guess they just don’t get to play sports at all?)
You might ask, but wouldn’t this stop girls from playing sports? No, I don’t think so. They’ll still be on the team, they’ll still practice and compete. It just might stop them from being starters, because they’re probably not good enough for that. But that’s the same problem that most boys have, too. It’s not some fundamental human right to have a starting spot on the varsity basketball team.
But what about the girls’ self-confidence? Wasn’t that the whole point? Well… here’s where things get extra spicy. (Translation: deranged, half-baked, hot takes.)
I believe that a lot of problems in our current society are caused because women have too much self-confidence, and men have too little. The girl who was the star of her girls’ field hockey team gets a full-ride scholarship to Harvard, then gets recruited into a hedge fund, where she is quickly promoted to make diversity quotas. So she becomes an extremely confident, ego-tripping, “girl-boss,” with immense power to make bad decisions that damage the world, or at least her company. She makes life hell for her subordinates, and loses all attraction to any normal men. She advocates strongly for feminist programs that benefit women like herself: more money for girls sports, no trans girls allowed in girls’ sports, and more female executives.
Meanwhile, her male equivalent? Well, he diligently played sports throughout his teen years, and was objectively better than her, but not good enough to make the Varsity team. Certainly not good enough for any college to offer him a scholarship, or even really care. So he goes to his local state university where tuition was cheap. He struggles to date anyone there because he looks bad compared to the football players and celebrities. He graduates, gets a perfectly normal job, but struggles to get promoted because “they have too many men in management already.” He tries and fails on all the dating apps. He stops giving his opinion on politics, because he’s scared of getting cancelled or shouted at by angry feminists.
Mixing up the girls with the boys would change all of this dynamic. The boys would get a big shot of confidence as they realize just how big and strong they are. The girls would stop getting fake confidence at winning a separate league, and really appreciate the boys for what they are. The colleges would open up far more spots to boys, so the gender ratio there would balance out. The boys would get laid a lot more, boosting the birth rate. And then they’d go on to get better jobs and be more active in politics, thus restoring reason and logic in our society.
Am I right? Tell me how any of this could possibly be wrong.
edit: see my response to people saying that the male league is technically "open" here: https://www.themotte.org/post/4074/culture-war-roundup-for-the-week/497696?context=8#context
I'm not a huge fan of how they're portrayed as "just as good" as men's/open sports, but to defend women-only sports, all sports are arbitrary to begin with. Women's sports are just as much of a carveout for people who couldn't hack it at the top level as "normal" sports are compared to a hypothetical league or sports organisation that explicitely allowed PED, mechanical aids, etc... By the time you've finished stripping away all the arbitrariness of it, your 100 m dash champion is gonna be the lightest person you can strap to a rocket.
The reason we have this arbitrariness is because what we respect in sports is the struggle, the grit, the human stories, the competitive spirit. This inspires some people. It's thinking "this guy grew up in a poor village in Kenya/a favela in Brazil and through hard work and discipline (and some genetic lottery for certain) now millions are cheering for them, so maybe I should put a bit more of hard work in discipline in my life". It's not just seeing a human shaped body go fast or kick a ball hard. So in that spirit, adding one more layer of arbitrariness to allow women's leagues to exist is worthwhile, so that those inspiring stories have more reach and impact on the half of humanity that's concerned.
As for letting women's leagues exist as "open but worse leagues", the main issue I see is that they would be quickly dominated by men who start from scratch but launch past that skill level. For instance, right now I'm out of shape and I don't have any sports ability. But I am a man with a man's hormones and my body has a man's potential. Right now, I would probably get my ass kicked by most women except the very beginners in most women's leagues in most sports. So sorting me by ability into one of those leagues with a lot of women would be appropriate! But I expect that even if I gave it only half the effort that the women in those leagues give it, as my skills start to approach theirs, as I get in better shape my body will quickly (as in within months) give me an insurmontable advantage against almost all of them. It would be extremely frustrating for those women who work hard and train hard to see themselves overtaken over and over again by lazy bums half-assing it on their way to the bottom rung of the ladder of "teams with mostly men".
Well in my view, the "just as good" issue is the key point. Of course there is wheelchair basketball; road races for people over 60; and so on. But none of them demand (and are granted) unearned respect and money as do women's sports. I mean, what is wrong with our society that a news reporter can seriously propose that Serena Williams is the greatest tennis player ever and not get laughed out of the room?
There's men's college football and basketball. Why should these get the respect and money they do when at least 60% of the athletes involved couldn't crack a CFL or NBA Europe roster? Why do I occasionally hear equally ridiculous things like the idea that the college championship team could beat the Browns or whatever the consensus-worst NFL team is?
Because there is a lot of organic grass roots interest. People will genuinely invest significant time and money to watch these sports. To put it another way, these sports EARNED respect and money.
One can contrast that with (most) women's sports, where respect and money comes from pressuring lawmakers and other elites into putting a big thumb on the scale.
What would be (almost) equally as absurd is if a commentator seriously proposed that a particular college team was the best football team ever, including NFL teams. If a commentator proposed that Serena Williams could beat the lowest ranked male players on the Tour, that commentator would probably be wrong but it wouldn't be absurd, not absurd like suggesting that Serena Williams was the best tennis player ever including men.
More options
Context Copy link
Do you think that was ever true? I can't help but feel like Florida could have given the Lions a run for their money in 2008.
Other than that I'm not sure.
No, it was never true. Even top prospects have trouble adjusting to the speed of the NFL, and a lot of little things are exponentially tougher; for instance, the open windows for receivers are a lot smaller and shorter. But let's take a closer look at the players:
QB Tim Tebow: The defense kept every game close, and he was able to pull off late-gem heroics. But he wasn't an NFL caliber player, and was out of the league in a few years. Jon Kitna at least had a solid career as a backup and occasional starter. WR Riley Cooper: Spent a few years at the bottom of the depth chart on the Eagles WR Percy Harvin: Made the Pro Bowl and was Offensive Rookie of the Year, but he was no Calvin Johnson. Admittedly, his career may have gone differently if he weren't a locker room cancer. C Maurkice Pouncey: Solid career at an important position. RG Mike Pouncey: His bullying aside, he was very good TE Aaron Hernandez: His murdering aside, he was very good RB Jeff Demps: Was a freshman in '08 and barely had an NFL career. RB Chris Rainey: Fun Fact—a friend of mine was once on lockdown at his house after he caused a DV incident that led to a SWAT team shutting down the whole street. Before that, he couldn't beat out such luminaries as Jonathan Dwyer and Isaac Redman. The following year he got cut from the Colts for an unspecified violation of team rules after 2 games and no touches. DE Jermaine Cunningham: The Pats moved him to LB and then benched him after a disappointing rookie season. Also had a PED suspension somewhere in there. DE Carlos Dunlap: Had a decent career, but couldn't crack the starting lineup of a mediocre Bengals team for several years LB Brandon Spikes: Another guy with an okay but unmemorable NFL career CB Joe Haden: I always liked Joe Haden. Good career. CB Jackrabbit Jenkins: Decent career despite the legal issues. FS Ahmad Black: Practice squad/special teams guy SS Will Hill: Slightly better career than Ahmad Black
The only true NFL caliber players on this list are Harvin, the Pouncey brothers, Hernandez, Spikes, Haden, and Jenkins. Dunlap did too, but his history suggests that he wasn't anywhere close to that level while in college. That's 7 of 22 guys who can hang, and another 7 who were fringe NFL players with short careers. The remaining 8 didn't play in the NFL at all. Most notably, all but two of their O-line, including both tackles, half their D-line, and 2 of 3 linebackers were not good enough to play for a team as bad as the '08 Lions. As awful as that team was, they were still mostly starting journeymen who were able to hang around the league for a while.
Is your core belief that the individual capability of each player on the roster overwhelms coaching, coordination, and all the other intangibles?
I'm not looking to argue here - just to learn.
In this situation, yes. It's my opinion that while intangibles may have an effect at the margins, they can't compensate for lack of talent. You see this a lot in the college game where teams without talent will often develop an unusual scheme to make the best of what they have. Look at a team like Navy. They compete in the top division but can't recruit like the rest of the college cesspool can. For years they ran the triple option under coaches Paul Johnson and Ken Niumatalolo, long after the triple option went out of style. If you're not familiar, the triple-option is a descendant of the wishbone, which was developed in the 1960s and reached its zenith in the 1970s and early 1980s. It's a 3-back attack where the quarterback reads what the defense is doing post-snap and either keeps it, hands it off to RB 1, or pitches it to RB2, depending on where the hole is going to be. Teams like Texas and Oklahoma won national championships using this approach, but it had since been superseded by any number of other schemes. When Johnson took over in 2002, most of the good college programs were running pro-style offenses, which required skilled players of sufficient size and speed. The advantage of the triple option is that it didn't require any of that, just players who were good athletes capable of executing a simple system. And the fact that few teams ran the system meant that their opponents had to make special preparation when they played against them, which was tougher than normal since it was so different from what teams were typically running.
The result was that Navy had much more success than service academies typically have. Between 2002 and 2015, Navy only had two losing seasons, one of which came in Johnson's first year running the scheme. By contrast, rival Army only had a single winning season across the same period, and most of those seasons they only managed 2 or 3 wins. I use these dates because Army hired Jeff Monken in 2014 and started running the triple option. Though the team struggled his first two years, they've only had a single losing season since. The thing is, neither team is going to compete for a national championship (though Army came close a couple years ago). Both teams play in the AAC, a conference that isn't the most competitive. Navy plays Notre Dame every year, and hasn't won since 1963. And the teams Notre Dame was fielding during the Charlie Weis era weren't exactly gangbusters. Scheme was able to turn below-average mid-major teams into above-average ones, but it wasn't able to turn them into mediocre major teams.
In a broader sense, though, it's funny that you mention coaching, because this experience played out in real life. In 2021, Urban Meyer, who coached the Florida Gators in 2008 in the middle of an illustrious career that included stints at Utah and Ohio State, was named head coach of the Jacksonville Jaguars. This was a bad team, but it nonetheless had players who were 100% NFL talent, and Trevor Lawrence, the hottest QB prospect. The results speak for themselves. Meyer's tenure in Jacksonville was an unmitigated disaster, and he was let go before the season even ended. He thought the team had potential, but he seems not to have realized the level of talent in the NFL; I recall reading a quote from him where he said in an exasperated tone that it was "like playing Alabama every week". Now put this in the context of the offense Meyer actually ran in 20088: The Spread. Like the triple option, spread offenses were developed as a way to take advantage of lesser talent. The first time I recall seeing it was when Pitt played South Florida in 2001. USF was a mid-major that had just started a football program a few years prior and couldn't land top recruits, even compared with mediocre programs like Pitt. Instead they got fast receivers and a mobile quarterback, and used a 4 wideout set with no tight end and only one running back. They passed constantly and kept the tempo up, and a pro-style team like Pitt had trouble keeping up. USF ended up winning the game by 9 points, even they had no business doing so.
Florida actually ran a run-first variation of the spread called a spread option which incorporated aspects of—you guessed it—the triple option. Elements of spread offenses have worked their way into the NFL over the years, particularly following 2010 rule changes prohibiting hits on defenseless players, but the implementation is much different than in college. If there's been a trend in NFL draft busts over the past decade, it's taking guys similar to Tebow who are great atheletes but who come from offenses similar to what Florida ran in 2008. The weakness is that these offenses rely on the QB making one read and then running, and that doesn't work in the NFL. We've seen the careers of Colin Kaepernick, Justin Fields, Malik Willis, and, well, Tim Tebow all struggle due to an inability to hang in the pocket long enough to find the open man. In the NFL, the open windows are tight, and they aren't open for long. Meyer's passing approach relied on Tebow looking to see if one guy was open (by NCAA standards) and taking off with the ball if he wasn't. It also relied on Tebow looking at what the defensive end was doing and making the decision whether to hand the ball off or keep it. NFL quarterbacks do a little of this, but generally speaking, NFL defensive linemen are fast enough that a college running back isn't going to get a jump on them based on what they do immediately after the snap. And with no NFL-caliber tackles, Tebow is likely on his ass before he can even figure out what the defensive end is doing. Anyway, I could get more into this but I think that's enough for now.
This is illuminating. Thanks.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Sure but no one would claim that the best college football team is the best football team in the world. Serena probably wouldn’t win a game against Novak if Serena was in her prime and Novak is Novak today.
That's not really the point, since few people are claiming women are objectively as good as men at sports. The point is that quality of competition doesn't necessarily equate to how much money and respect the public is willing to give you. College football isn't more popular than the NFL, but it is more popular than any of the various B-leagues that have come and gone over the past few decades, despite a lower quality of play. Serena Williams would probably lose handily to a guy like David Ferrer, but she's made a lot more money, and Ferrer only made as much as he did because guys like Federer, Nadal, and Novak were able to draw interest. Novak may be pushing 40, but he's still better known than anyone ranked above him.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Because they're fun to watch? That's a subjective opinion but you can tell it's shared by a lot of people by viewership.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link