site banner

Small-Scale Question Sunday for November 15, 2026

Do you have a dumb question that you're kind of embarrassed to ask in the main thread? Is there something you're just not sure about?

This is your opportunity to ask questions. No question too simple or too silly.

Culture war topics are accepted, and proposals for a better intro post are appreciated.

1
Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Does anybody else hate Mehdi Hassan? This guy might be the worst faith debater I have ever seen. He has no interest in the truth and instead just interrupts whoever he is talking too and just calls them names like racist or Islamophobe. What’s funny too is he he has himself made extremely hateful remarks in the past that show “Islamophobia” is a perfectly warranted response to Islam. He is also literally a sophist and wrote a book showing people how to win every debate by engaging in sophistry.

At least Dawkins humiliated him in their debate, but that was just because he showed how ridiculous Islam and forced him to admit he believed Mohammed flew to heaven on a winged horse.

He’s pretty loathsome. I actually do not think the winged horse thing is the best place to attack Islam; it seems silly, but if you accept miracles it not particularly interesting. I think the biggest dilemma for Islam is the following:

  1. Muhammad is a moral exemplar that all Muslims should follow. This ranges in mainstream interpretation from he never commits major sins to he literally never sins.
  2. The Hadiths and Quran are reliable in describing his actions. These actions include slavery, marrying Aisha at 6 years old then having sex with/raping her at 9, and violent conquest and murder.

You have to either soften 1 or 2 to have a religion palatable to westerners. Probably most cultures object to sexually abusing 9 year olds.

I think Dawkins attacked that because if you go into what you talked about, Muslims get super defensive and start throwing out claims of racism. With the winged horse and splitting the moon, it’s just so ridiculous that it makes it look like a joke. The problem with attacking Islam though is that it is also an attack implicitly on Christianity because it also is obviously not true and the Old Testament is arguably worse than anything Mohammed did. Because the right is more sympathetic to religion and Christianity, you have to be careful here because they are your allies opposing Islam.

While you may consider them cope, both Christianity and Judaism have large and dominant interpretations that explain why Leviticus should not be implemented in full. While there are liberal Islamic subcultures, the big bulk of Muslims don’t come from them. If Jews were 90% Charedim you would likely consider them pretty terrible neighbors. Similarly if 90% of Catholics were integralist tradcaths who think error deserves no rights*. I think this is a sociological issue rather than a pure religious issue.

  • I know Vatican II officially supports freedom of conscience. This is just for illustration.

I think there is a lot of cope there, but the fact that they try makes it better than modern day Islam. But Christianity also was very violent in the past i.e. burning Joan of Arc. Christian theology to me is just nonsense and cope though. You go back far enough and it’s people arguing over what is the correct day for Easter. I have an appreciation for Christianity and I like a lot of things about it, but like Islam its biggest problem is that it’s just not true. Islam though is a particularly awful religion and needs to be eradicated as a belief system. Christianity, while not true, isn’t an imminent threat to our societies and safety like Islam is.

You go back far enough and it’s people arguing over what is the correct day for Easter.

Oh no! Well, how wonderful for us that we don't quibble over petty time-keeping details anymore!

Seriously, bruv, that line there is exactly a Chesterton essay

The message of Christ was perfectly "simple": that the cure of everything is Love; but since He was killed (I do not quite know why) for making this remark, great temples have been put up to Him and horrid people called priests have given the world nothing but "stones, amulets, formulas, shibboleths." They also "quarrel eternally among themselves as to the placing of a button or the bending of a knee." All this gives no comfort to the unhappy Christian, who apparently wishes to be comforted only by being told that he has a duty to his neighbour. "How many men in the time of their passing get comfort out of the thought of the Thirty-Nine Articles, Predestination, Transubstantiation, the doctrine of eternal punishment, and the belief that Christ will return on the Seventh Day?" The items make a curious catalogue; and the last item I find especially mysterious. But I can only say that, if Christ was the giver of the original and really comforting message of love, I should have thought it did make a difference whether He returned on the Seventh Day.

Joan of Arc was given a highly political show trial at the behest of the English, and their allies in Paris, not the Church, and was initially sentenced to imprisonment after abjuring her 'heresy' (a heretic who abjured could not legally be burned - at least, not at the time). Compare that to secular treason trials of the time, since, after all, from an English perspective she was in rebellion against the true King of France. There is an inherent conflict between the brutality of secular power and the commandments of faith in Christianity that is less pronounced in Islamic history. Having said that, from a secular-right perspective, one could also say that Islam wouldn't be a serious problem if we didn't have that Christian merciful-universalist strain in our modern morality.

I just don’t think you can say it was a moderating force when the Wars of Religion caused up to 40% of Germany to die. Like you said it’s hard to say where religion ends and politics begins, but it definitely played a massive role. Charlemagne also genocided German pagans as another example. Even the Vikings didn’t do that. Part of the Crusades was also an extermination of the pagan religion in Northern Europe. Christianity was extremely violent and had no problems with genocide and spreading itself by the sword.

Part of the Crusades was also an extermination of the pagan religion in Northern Europe

You are referring to the Northern Crusades, which indeed were about establishing Christianity but like many things also co-opted by rulers wanting to extend power, influence, and territory.

Charlemagne also genocided German pagans as another example

With the downstream effects of that being the creation of a sadly awful metal song by Christopher Lee, although his bit in there about "shedding the blood of the Saxon men" is almost awesome enough to redeem the rest of it.

Almost.

Charlemagne also genocided German pagans

I have actually sperged out about this one before

I feel like that’s cope. It’s similar to it’s not real communism cope or Islam is religion of peace and the 9/11 hijackers weren’t real Muslims cope. They burned her at the stake for religious reasons and political reasons. I’ve also seen some historians push back on the fact that it was just a show trial. Even if it was a show trial, she was brought up on trumped up charges enabled by the Catholic faith and its belief system. There’s plenty of other examples of the Catholic Church doing similar things. The people who found her guilty were all Catholics. These are the religious waters Medieval Europeans were swimming in. There’s countless examples I could give even if you reject Joan of Arc as an example.

Christians broadly built stuff. Sure the Church has defanged, but atleast you can point towards accomplishments that have come from it. Muslims in modernity at their absolute finest are petrostate lottery winners and otherwise incapable of really achieving even mid-tier nation-states. The issue of modernity is that a Islamic world would likely just produce a ton of go-nowhere ennui as civilization went to shit as opposed to actually providing a real competitive force for anything.

The historical practice of apostolic Christianity produced universities as a side effect and created the economic conditions necessary to make moveable type printing worth it.

Now I don't mean that in the sense of 'Christian marriage laws changed society such that Europeans invented capitalism and prioritized learning'. Chinamen are clearly capable of the same thing by a different route, because they did it. I mean that universities grew out of Cathedral schools which were created specifically to train boys for participation in Christian religious rituals which require fluency in Latin and a good understanding of music theory and movable type printing was only invented because the Church's religious practice required large numbers of copies of identical texts- the orientals had had printing for hundreds of years but hadn't developed movable type which would allow a publishing industry, because there was no anchor tenant which would make it worth it.

More comments

Does the Islamic golden age count to you? Scholars often say the Andalusian paradise was a myth back when Spain was under Muslim control.

More comments

Even if it was a show trial, she was brought up on trumped up charges enabled by the Catholic faith and its belief system.

Yes, the Catholic English wanted the execution of a Catholic French war hero who had put a crimp into their claims on disputed French territory, and they went for heresy as a face-saving PR move as well as "no in fact she didn't beat our asses like a gong because God was on their side not ours". If they had all been atheists, the motivations would have been the same but the ostensible philosophical defence would have been different (don't make me drag Stalin into this).

You think everyone involved got the memo and thought they were making it up? You think none of the Catholics involved actually thought she was a heretic? You can’t be that naive. There were also plenty of French people involved as well it wasn’t only the English.

More comments

For Joan of Arc it's pretty accurate (even the "it wasn't a show trial" revisionist school is trying to rehabilitate the English and their clerics), you'd want to look at something like the Albigensians or Jan Hus, burned by a Church Council after being given safe conduct by the Emperor. Joan was charged with religious offences because she was a religious symbol, which seems fairly straightforward to me.

More generally, burnings and other such things were fairly rare in the Medieval era unless they were directly connected to political upheaval, like the Albigensians - and my understanding is that such things were also relatively rare in Medieval Islam, much of their fanaticism is a reaction to modernity. The Reformation changes that a lot in Europe, but even then it's a drop in the bucket compared to the general brutality of the time. There was no real separation between politics and religion and, as such, it's basically up to you if you want to charge religion or politics with things like the Thirty Years War. But up until the Reformation, if you read any sources from the time it's clear that Christianity was a moderating force on violence rather than an accelerant.