site banner

Culture War Roundup for the week of July 17, 2023

This weekly roundup thread is intended for all culture war posts. 'Culture war' is vaguely defined, but it basically means controversial issues that fall along set tribal lines. Arguments over culture war issues generate a lot of heat and little light, and few deeply entrenched people ever change their minds. This thread is for voicing opinions and analyzing the state of the discussion while trying to optimize for light over heat.

Optimistically, we think that engaging with people you disagree with is worth your time, and so is being nice! Pessimistically, there are many dynamics that can lead discussions on Culture War topics to become unproductive. There's a human tendency to divide along tribal lines, praising your ingroup and vilifying your outgroup - and if you think you find it easy to criticize your ingroup, then it may be that your outgroup is not who you think it is. Extremists with opposing positions can feed off each other, highlighting each other's worst points to justify their own angry rhetoric, which becomes in turn a new example of bad behavior for the other side to highlight.

We would like to avoid these negative dynamics. Accordingly, we ask that you do not use this thread for waging the Culture War. Examples of waging the Culture War:

  • Shaming.

  • Attempting to 'build consensus' or enforce ideological conformity.

  • Making sweeping generalizations to vilify a group you dislike.

  • Recruiting for a cause.

  • Posting links that could be summarized as 'Boo outgroup!' Basically, if your content is 'Can you believe what Those People did this week?' then you should either refrain from posting, or do some very patient work to contextualize and/or steel-man the relevant viewpoint.

In general, you should argue to understand, not to win. This thread is not territory to be claimed by one group or another; indeed, the aim is to have many different viewpoints represented here. Thus, we also ask that you follow some guidelines:

  • Speak plainly. Avoid sarcasm and mockery. When disagreeing with someone, state your objections explicitly.

  • Be as precise and charitable as you can. Don't paraphrase unflatteringly.

  • Don't imply that someone said something they did not say, even if you think it follows from what they said.

  • Write like everyone is reading and you want them to be included in the discussion.

On an ad hoc basis, the mods will try to compile a list of the best posts/comments from the previous week, posted in Quality Contribution threads and archived at /r/TheThread. You may nominate a comment for this list by clicking on 'report' at the bottom of the post and typing 'Actually a quality contribution' as the report reason.

11
Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Ok so I am at a Notre Dame wedding where I went. I’ve fallen away from the news of the place the last few years. A few people did the student to administrator route so I got some news on how the place is doing. The school no longer has priest in the dorms. From what I can guess it’s because people aren’t entering religious life so they lack the numbers. Notre Dame isn’t the church but I do think it had a special place in American Catholicism.

I feel like this has a culture war point. The right is no longer reproducing itself. The right perhaps is a larp from people who remember the old days but aren’t living that life. Which would explain how someone like Trump could be the chosen leader.

When I went there we would all do our things during the week and live together then our rector a Priest would give mass. And if you wanted to you could go to daily mass and walk down the hall.

I feel like this is anecdotal but there is something here when an institution is failing to reproduce itself.

There's an argument to be made for a celibate-caste dedicated solely to cultural advancement. But having priests, the best and brightest and most devoted, as celibate was just suicidal. If priests instead had a calling to have among the largest families with the prospect of inherited priestly function, and a congregation helping provide support in return for spiritual leadership- that would be how you develop a self-sustaining religion. A religion that demands celibacy from the best and brightest deserves to go extinct.

If priests instead had a calling to have among the largest families with the prospect of inherited priestly function, and a congregation helping provide support in return for spiritual leadership- that would be how you develop a self-sustaining religion.

Let me introduce you to a little thing called "Protestantism" and their adoption of married clergy. As for "largest families", there's a novel in the series of novels called The Chronicles of Barsetshire about "The novels concern the dealings of the clergy and the gentry, and the political, amatory, and social manoeuvrings among them".

This novel has a subplot about a character called Mrs. Quiverful who, as the name implies, is the mother of a large family, and the wife of a clergyman. Instead of being encouraged and supported by the congregation in return for having large family with the prospect of inherited priestly function, her troubles are that of being poor and needing, eventually, to be helped out by the schemes of the bishop's wife. Anglicanism did indeed have "the prospect of inherited priestly function", one of the plot points is about the son of the former bishop not succeeding him as expected:

The much loved bishop having died, all expectations are that his son, Archdeacon Grantly, will succeed him. Owing to the passage of the power of patronage to a new Prime Minister, a newcomer, the far more Evangelical Bishop Proudie, gains the see. His wife, Mrs Proudie, exercises an undue influence over the new bishop, making herself as well as the bishop unpopular with most of the clergy of the diocese. Her interference, leading the Bishop to veto the reappointment of the universally popular Mr Septimus Harding (protagonist of Trollope's earlier novel, The Warden) as warden of Hiram's Hospital, is not well received, even though she seeks to have the position given to a needy clergyman, Mr Quiverful, who has a wife and 14 children to support.

There certainly was a social aspect to the novels which included the disapproval of having such large families (see the joke at the end of the Monty Python sketch about Every Sperm Is Sacred, where the Protestant couple discuss how Catholics have to have children every time they have sex, and the husband maintains that if he wanted to, he could buy and use contraceptives because they're Protestant - except he doesn't want to), clerical politics, and absentee clergymen (given how livings or benefices in the Church of England were distributed, a cleric could get a good living that paid well, then pay a subsitute at a reduced rate to administer it and carry out the duties for him while he was free to live as he wished off the majority of the money):

The Bishop, or rather Mr Slope under the direction of Mrs Proudie, also orders the return of the prebendary Dr Vesey Stanhope from Italy. Stanhope has been in Italy recovering from a sore throat for 12 years and has spent his time catching butterflies.

Martin Luther was very strong on marriage, and indeed Protestantism in general that women should not go into religion but should all get married and be wives and mothers. Strangely enough, since then over the centuries, Protestanism has become the home of denominations that have women clergy, LGBT clergy, divorce and contraception and abortion (even if some denominations still hold out against abortion). The "largest families with inherited priestly function supported by the congregation in return for spiritual leadership" notion has not protected them against "our lesbian bishop and her partner opening the fundraiser for the fight for abortion rights" and cratering membership numbers, SecureSignals.

A religion that demands celibacy from the best and brightest deserves to go extinct.

Sorry to be brusque here, but that's a stupid atheist talking point which they took over from a stupid Protestant talking point. The clergy were not always celibate, even when the discipine was introduced, and you just have to read the mediaeval tales and poems including the bastard children of the priests being proud of their social standing and the monks and friars all cuckolding married laymen. They weren't all the best and brightest either, as see the mediaeval jokes about the mass-priests who were barely literate, badly educated, and often had no idea what the Latin they recited meant.

Very often, up to modern times, going into the priesthood or religious life was a 'second-best' for younger children who had no hope of inheriting anything, getting married, or getting other work. Given the historic cases of abuse (not just sexual) that have come out in recent years, you can see that there were far from 'the best and brightest' going into religion. And pre-Reformation (as well as after it), wealthy and noble families treated the Church as one more of the professions: the eldest son inherits, the second son goes into the church (hopefully to gain high office) and the third son goes into the Army or another profession.

Having one of your sons be the abbot of the local wealthy monastery, or becoming a bishop or even cardinal, was another way of concentrating wealth and influence for the noble families.

See St Thomas Aquinas, who when he said he wanted to be a religious, his (small local) noble family "Well okay, we can certainly swing it that you go into the Benedictine abbey which we fund and where your uncle is abbot and you'll take over from him in due time", but he wanted genuinely to be a member of a religious movement - the Dominicans, lately founded and an order of mendicant friars, not at all the thing for a sprig of the nobility. This led to fun times as his family tried everything to dissuade him, up to and including kidnapping him and locking him up at home. But you can read his biography online for the rest of it:

Landulf's brother Sinibald was abbot of Monte Cassino, the oldest Benedictine monastery. While the rest of the family's sons pursued military careers, the family intended for Thomas to follow his uncle into the abbacy; this would have been a normal career path for a younger son of southern Italian nobility.

...At the age of nineteen, Thomas resolved to join this Dominican Order. Thomas's change of heart, however, did not please his family. In an attempt to prevent Theodora's interference in Thomas's choice, the Dominicans arranged to move Thomas to Rome, and from Rome, to Paris. However, while on his journey to Rome, per Theodora's instructions, his brothers seized him as he was drinking from a spring and took him back to his parents at the castle of Monte San Giovanni Campano.

Thomas was held prisoner for almost one year in the family castles at Monte San Giovanni and Roccasecca in an attempt to prevent him from assuming the Dominican habit and to push him into renouncing his new aspiration. Political concerns prevented the Pope from ordering Thomas's release, which had the effect of extending Thomas's detention. Thomas passed this time of trial tutoring his sisters and communicating with members of the Dominican Order.

Family members became desperate to dissuade Thomas, who remained determined to join the Dominicans. At one point, two of his brothers resorted to the measure of hiring a prostitute to seduce him. As included in the official records for his canonization, Thomas drove her away wielding a burning log—with which he inscribed a cross onto the wall—and fell into a mystical ecstasy; two angels appeared to him as he slept and said, "Behold, we gird thee by the command of God with the girdle of chastity, which henceforth will never be imperiled. What human strength can not obtain, is now bestowed upon thee as a celestial gift."

By 1244, seeing that all her attempts to dissuade Thomas had failed, Theodora sought to save the family's dignity, arranging for Thomas to escape at night through his window. In her mind, a secret escape from detention was less damaging than an open surrender to the Dominicans. Thomas was sent first to Naples and then to Rome to meet Johannes von Wildeshausen, the Master General of the Dominican Order.

Random story time! This is one of the first times I've encountered SSPX since my brother-in-law's wedding. His cousin joined CMRI a few years ago and came down for a wedding. He attended an SSPX for the Latin mass and was shocked to see half the congregation openly carrying firearms. Our families are both very evangelical Protestant, and as a recent convert, he is fervent about informing us that we're all destined for hell. Personally, that's never bothered me much. I mean, why should I care if another religion thinks I'm going to hell? I certainly don't believe I'm heading there, at least not for the reasons they believe.

Of course, this caused some tension within the family. What stood out, even more, was when he admitted that if he had his way, the US would be a theocracy, and all other religions or denominations would be banned from public practice. I pointed out that after enjoying the freedom to practice and grow his religion under the Protestant commitment to religious freedom, he would then take that very right away from Protestants. It seemed like an odd thing for a lawyer not to have considered before.

His cousin joined CMRI a few years ago

The sedevacantist group with ties to the mafia?

He attended an SSPX for the Latin mass and was shocked to see half the congregation openly carrying firearms

That would be very SSPX-like, yes, but it’s surprising that 1) a sedevacantist, particularly from out-there hardliners like the CMRI, would go there and 2) any regular Latin mass goer would find lots of open carry shocking.

The sedevacantist group with ties to the mafia?

It's all Greek... er I mean Latin to me.

Yes, sedevacantist. He did go in to that, but not mafia, gonna have to look in to that one.

  1. a sedevacantist, particularly from out-there hardliners like the CMRI, would go there and 2) any regular Latin mass goer would find lots of open carry shocking.

And based on my culture waring these surprised me as well. I figured he'd hate a group like SPXX with almost more passion than the Holy See. Also I ribbed him about being surprised at open carry because his church is in an area of the country nationally famous for open carry. He said only like three guys in his congregation open carry. He's fresh moved there and is a Cali boy so I'm thinking he's still learning the ropes.

Usually the SSPX and sedevacantists get along worse than the SSPX and the Vatican, or sedevacantists and each other, but it might just be an individual thing.

He did go in to that, but not mafia, gonna have to look in to that one

The founder’s investigation for sex abuse got derailed when he was arrested for arms trafficking. His replacement was ordained by a bishop who was literally a mob boss in Galveston. At least that’s the TLDR I remember. The details could be different, I think there might be a schism in there somewhere.

Okay, so I don't run into the character limit in replies:

Not just for noble families, going into the Church was a path of power for the poorer but ambitious as well, see Cardinal Wolsey (and again, he didn't stick too rigidly to celibacy, having illegimate children). Excerpted from "Thomas Cromwell" by Tracy Borman:

Like Cromwell, Wolsey was the son of a tavern-keeper. He was some fifteen years Cromwell’s senior, having been born in Ipswich in 1470 or 1471. His father became a butcher soon afterwards, and it was this profession that inspired the jibes that the younger Wolsey would suffer in later years. No matter how high he might rise at court, he would always be derided as the ‘butcher’s son’ by his noble adversaries.

Diarmaid MacCulloch isn't any too impressed about Wolsey's son who does not seem to have shared his father's talents or intellect (regression to the mean, perhaps?). From his biograpy of Cromwell:

Rullo was personally acquainted with Cromwell before he knew Pole, and in the early 1530s was very happy to do him a favour by being agreeable to that polished young nonentity Thomas Winter, Cardinal Wolsey’s son, then visiting Venice.

[Cromwell] probably did a better job as [Salisbury]Town Clerk than did Wolsey’s talentless illegitimate son Thomas Winter as diocesan Chancellor.

Thomas Wolsey, a man whose appetite for enjoyment equalled his appetite for hard work, fathered at least two and maybe three illegitimate children, rather exceptionally for an English bishop in this self-consciously well-regulated region of the Western Church. A daughter was born in 1511, and quietly placed in the great West Country nunnery at Shaftesbury before Cromwell entered the Cardinal’s service. Nevertheless another old servant of Wolsey belatedly brought her to Cromwell’s attention when in 1535 she was caught up in his own bureaucracy as royal Vice-Gerent; she was still just young enough to fall under his new ban on people under twenty-four taking full monastic vows. She clearly had no desire to leave Shaftesbury at that time, and it is interesting that this same autumn of 1535 a personal decision of Cromwell lowered the threshold for dismissal to twenty. After that, unnamed for posterity, she disappears from the record. A hitherto unnoticed but likely third child of Thomas Wolsey is a young man called Thomas Minterne, who in 1529 entered Winchester College (Wolsey having just become Bishop of Winchester) as from the town of Sherborne, aged thirteen, so born around 1516.

…A further begging letter to the King after Cromwell’s fall significantly indicates that financial support had now dried up for his travels abroad, but he carried on some sort of clerical career as a canon of Salisbury Cathedral as late as the 1560s, not otherwise troubling the course of history. …Born around 1510, and so the oldest of this trio, Thomas Winter gained an even more lavish education than Thomas Minterne: carefully chaperoned studies at Louvain, Padua and Paris, studies which left him with beautiful italic handwriting, an ability to turn a graceful phrase in humanist Latin and a breathtaking sense of entitlement. The best that one can say about Winter is that looking after him gave gainful employment in pleasant overseas surroundings to various of Wolsey’s protégés and Cromwell’s friends and acquaintances, notably that talented future Cromwellian propagandist Richard Morison, yet another evangelical finding his way on to the strength of Cardinal College Oxford in the 1520s.

…While the Cardinal was alive and in the fullness of his power, Winter’s promotion in high Church office passed parody. Particularly offensive East Anglian deployments of the lad in the diocese of Norwich aroused the wrath of the venerable and conscientious Bishop, Richard Nix; Nix was one of that generation of elderly bishops like Audley of Salisbury who thoroughly disapproved of Wolsey’s general high-handedness, to say nothing of his progeny. Winter was high on Nix’s list of grievances: appointed aged sixteen as Rector of the major benefice of St Matthew’s Ipswich in succession to one of Suffolk’s most respected secular clergy, in order to secure the shrine of Our Lady for Wolsey’s plans for Cardinal College, and, worse still, in the same year becoming Archdeacon of Suffolk. Early in 1529, Winter added the Archdeaconry of Norfolk to his preferments, and this seems to have been the final straw for Nix.

And getting any sort of job in the Cardinal's household was a plum position with the prospect of advancement and wealth, at least up until Wolsey made a couple of misjudgements, most severely in the case of handling the King's divorce; Henry was ungrateful when he didn't get what he wanted the moment he wanted it, and Anne was vindictive and made Wolsey a personal target, so his enemies took advantage of all this to engineer his downfall:

Yet Wolsey’s handicap as Church reformer, apart from personal self-indulgence far outstripping any other late medieval English cleric, was the vast scope of his duties not simply as papal legate, but also as omnicompetent royal minister and dispenser of justice in Star Chamber. It was just all too much.

Wolsey used his talents to rise in the Church and in the court, and garnered the rewards that came with such power; part of it was showing off the pomp and glory for the publicity value that the English were just as sophisticated, tasteful and wealthy as the Continentals, and part of it was self-aggrandisement as a reflection of his master the King, a display of wealth and power that further aggravated his enemies. From Derek Wilson's "A Brief History of Henry VIII":

What made Wolsey different was his omnicompetence. He was the executive officer par excellence. His mind was a well-filled and finely-organized filing cabinet. He was compulsively industrious and few details escaped his attention. He had the mental facility to evaluate arguments and the intuition to weigh up people. This did not mean that he was a funless bureaucrat, far from it. Even those who disliked Wolsey acknowledged his eloquence and wit. If, as his power grew, he could threaten frighteningly, he could also charm disarmingly. Few men of his time, and perhaps no Englishmen, were more cultured. He was a lavish and discerning patron, a generous host and bon viveur. The wealth he acquired from his ever-growing portfolio of offices and sinecures was expended on display – houses, clothes, jewels, music for chapel and hall, tapestries, carpets and table plate.

Very often, up to modern times, going into the priesthood or religious life was a 'second-best' for younger children who had no hope of inheriting anything, getting married, or getting other work.

IIRC the Roman Catholic Church’s internal data shows most of the people taking religious vows are fifth children or younger to this day. Thats a bit different from the secular clergy most people mean when referring to catholic priests, but probably pretty close.