This is a refreshed megathread for any posts on the conflict between (so far, and so far as I know) Hamas and the Israeli government, as well as related geopolitics. Culture War thread rules apply.
Max Blumenthal’s TheGrayZone has an interesting article compiling accounts of Israel shelling / shooting its own citizens during the October 7 attack. Lots of citations to mainstream newspapers; of course, that shouldn’t preclude being skeptical of his overall point. Some excerpts:
Tuval Escapa, a member of the security team for Kibbutz Be’eri, set up a hotline to coordinate between kibbutz residents and the Israeli army. He told the Israeli newspaper Haaretz that as desperation began to set in, “the commanders in the field made difficult decisions – including shelling houses on their occupants in order to eliminate the terrorists along with the hostages.”
An Israeli woman named Yasmin Porat confirmed in an interview with Israel Radio that the military “undoubtedly” killed numerous Israeli noncombatants during gun battles with Hamas militants on October 7. “They eliminated everyone, including the hostages,” she stated, referring to Israeli special forces.
According to Haaretz, the army was only able to restore control over Be’eri after admittedly “shelling” the homes of Israelis who had been taken captive. “The price was terrible: at least 112 Be’eri residents were killed,” the paper chronicled. “Others were kidnapped. Yesterday, 11 days after the massacre, the bodies of a mother and her son were discovered in one of the destroyed houses. It is believed that more bodies are still lying in the rubble.”
Hitting low-probability potential targets in order to prevent hostages leaving Israel — regardless of whether it kills the hostages — would be in line with Israel’s Hannibal Directive. Examples of this in the past include —
The Hannibal Directive was invoked in October 2000 after the Hezbollah capture of three Israeli soldiers in the Israeli-occupied Shebaa Farms area. An Israeli border patrol was attacked by a Hezbollah squad with rockets and automatic fire. St.-Sgt. Adi Avitan, St.-Sgt. Benyamin Avraham and St.-Sgt. Omar Sawaid were captured and brought over the ceasefire line into Lebanon by their captors. When the abduction was discovered, the Northern Command ordered a "Hannibal situation". Israeli attack helicopters fired at 26 moving vehicles in the area since they assumed that the abducted soldiers were transported in one of them.
During the 2014 Gaza War, the third major offensive launched by Israel in Gaza since 2008, IDF Givati Brigade Lieutenant Hadar Goldin was captured by Hamas soldiers after a brief skirmish on August 1, despite the announcement of a 72-hour ceasefire agreement earlier that day. Israel then reportedly initiated the Hannibal Directive, ultimately resulting in carnage dubbed "Black Friday. The IDF carried out air and ground attacks on residential areas of Rafah during the Hannibal Directive attempt to prevent capture of Lt. Goldin. A2015 joint report by Amnesty International and Forensic Architecture found that Israel's indiscriminate violence against all human life amounted to war crimes. […] The massive Israeli bombardment killed between 135 and 200 Palestinian civilians, including 75 children, in the three hours following the suspected capture of the one Israeli soldier.
I wonder how many of the civilians and particularly the children were actually killed as part of the Hannibal Directive. I guess it’s unlikely we will ever know. How would it change the moral calculus if some quantity of the Israeli children killed were actually shelled by the IDF in an attempt to prevent them becoming hostages and kill the hostage-takers?
American journalist Max Blumenthal was in Gaza during the 2014 war. Blumenthal wrote that doctors were burnt out after weeks of amputations and shrapnel extractions, with some "on the brink of insanity". One of the hospital directors screamed "Can’t the world see that we’re human?".[31] Blumenthal reported that many refugees had setup tents beside the hospital during the war.[32]
To be honest i haven't dug into it, but seems like he was added and cited as an anti-"Hamas uses this hospital as a base" voice? Even the citation itself seems biased, and doesn't even include the full book?!
This website is a place for people who want to move past shady thinking and test their ideas in a
court of people who don't all share the same biases. Our goal is to
optimize for light, not heat; this is a group effort, and all commentators are asked to do their part.
The weekly Culture War threads host the most
controversial topics and are the most visible aspect of The Motte. However, many other topics are
appropriate here. We encourage people to post anything related to science, politics, or philosophy;
if in doubt, post!
Check out The Vault for an archive of old quality posts.
You are encouraged to crosspost these elsewhere.
Why are you called The Motte?
A motte is a stone keep on a raised earthwork common in early medieval fortifications. More pertinently,
it's an element in a rhetorical move called a "Motte-and-Bailey",
originally identified by
philosopher Nicholas Shackel. It describes the tendency in discourse for people to move from a controversial
but high value claim to a defensible but less exciting one upon any resistance to the former. He likens
this to the medieval fortification, where a desirable land (the bailey) is abandoned when in danger for
the more easily defended motte. In Shackel's words, "The Motte represents the defensible but undesired
propositions to which one retreats when hard pressed."
On The Motte, always attempt to remain inside your defensible territory, even if you are not being pressed.
New post guidelines
If you're posting something that isn't related to the culture war, we encourage you to post a thread for it.
A submission statement is highly appreciated, but isn't necessary for text posts or links to largely-text posts
such as blogs or news articles; if we're unsure of the value of your post, we might remove it until you add a
submission statement. A submission statement is required for non-text sources (videos, podcasts, images).
Culture war posts go in the culture war thread; all links must either include a submission statement or
significant commentary. Bare links without those will be removed.
Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Notes -
Max Blumenthal’s TheGrayZone has an interesting article compiling accounts of Israel shelling / shooting its own citizens during the October 7 attack. Lots of citations to mainstream newspapers; of course, that shouldn’t preclude being skeptical of his overall point. Some excerpts:
Hitting low-probability potential targets in order to prevent hostages leaving Israel — regardless of whether it kills the hostages — would be in line with Israel’s Hannibal Directive. Examples of this in the past include —
I wonder how many of the civilians and particularly the children were actually killed as part of the Hannibal Directive. I guess it’s unlikely we will ever know. How would it change the moral calculus if some quantity of the Israeli children killed were actually shelled by the IDF in an attempt to prevent them becoming hostages and kill the hostage-takers?
how reliable is max blumenthal? seems like hes always writing about “51 days in gaza” but wasnt actually there, etc.
do the citations substantiate his piece? sorry, have read his stuff before and am less trusting
He’s not permitted as a Wikipedia source, for whatever that means.
He's a direct cited source in the Al-Shifa Hospital wiki page, specifically described in the 2014 war section and is the 31 and 32nd citations (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Shifa_Hospital#cite_ref-31):
To be honest i haven't dug into it, but seems like he was added and cited as an anti-"Hamas uses this hospital as a base" voice? Even the citation itself seems biased, and doesn't even include the full book?!
Sorry, to be clear "not permitted" means Max and The Gray Zone have been deprecated as a source.
Some discussion here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Reliable_sources/Noticeboard/Archive_287#RfC:_Grayzone
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link