Pasha
Defend Kebab
No bio...
User ID: 481
The problem is that without military control over Golan/West Bank, Israel is an incredibly indefensible country. Israel's leaders understandably don't trust the "World opinion" from protecting them from real armies. This is a good primer: https://youtube.com/watch?v=ulHDsnhh_Cc
Also important to mention that very probably a large number of the hostages brought to Gaza are in those tunnels.
There are quite a lot of IEDs and booby traps in those tunnels.
The "proposal" is so autistic that I hope it is trolling, but to be fair each side does like 10 things per day that constitutes an act of war.
On an unrelated note, how the hell can I get through these YouTube "you must watch ads" pop-ups?? I am on safari with adguard
As a side/meta note: something really changed around 2016
I think many people have long felt this. Thanks to Elon Musk open sourcing Twitter's internal correspondence with American government agencies it became clear that it wasn't just "Eternal September" type nostalgia but a very real and coordinated change.
attacked Israel as soon as she was born
Such a miraculous thing, states being "born". With totally no other context behind the event. Land of virgin births indeed.
This is exactly what I am talking about. It devolves into a silly and extremely dishonest game of definitions. See, it is not an open prison, it is just a double whammy tight "land border" with a "blockade" on the sea side. Just like what Canada and the US have! And then of course there is always the attempt to justify why Gazans deserve to be imprisoned in this totally-not-open-air-prison because they elected bad people.
So Israel forced those people (who aren't usually actually from Gaza, but typically from areas south of what is now Israel, and have families all over Israel and West Bank) to emigrate to refugee camps in Gaza. And then made their exit illegal and dependent on rarely obtained "permits" that they can get for sustained good behavior. And also convinced Egypt through a combination of US bribery and regime self-interest arguments, to do the same. And also destroyed their only airport and closed down the sea access as well because it is totally not a prison, see, they are just not allowed to leave.
The fact that there were extra steps and justifications to Gaza becoming an open air prison, doesn't change the fact that it is now an open air prison.
Not really. There are very few American Jews and they aren't an important voting block. Majority of them are Americans first and foremost and become more assimilated every passing generation. The power of the Zionist lobby has nothing to do with their voting power, but their power to influence elite discourse and institutions.
Alan Dershowitz thinks US should give weapons industry 5 trillion dollars for propping Israeli interests and losing a war.
A rather unsurprising turn of events
I have been to similar raves in that area. It is a popular place for such events because lots of open space and the desert at night is beautiful. It is not like this was the event of the year in Israel or something. (I feel like the natural demographics of the Motte might not be super interested in such things but there are a lot of music festivals everywhere all the time if you are into that sort of thing and Israel has a massive techno scene)
There is good reason to believe that even the American high command doesn't think it can actually win a war of invasion against Iran in any realistic scenario.
but nothing in Israel's inventory that would be reasonably be used as that effect
Well they do have nuclear weapons if we are talking about sci-fi scenarios
Isn’t the Syrian conflict plenty high-profile?
Yes it was incredibly high-profile (especially for such a sluggish long running conflict). The OP seems to have made this up because it fits the arguments he wants to make.
It is right, and there is a reason Obama tried so hard to reorient US Middle Eastern policy towards a reconciliation with Iran. If US foreign policy was devised by an insular diplomatic corps who only had US interests in mind, this would have happened decades ago. Alas, there are certain groups who are very good at wielding the US foreign policy apparatus for the benefit of their ethnic group.
Yes exactly. I have asked a couple of Israeli friends their opinion about the upcoming military campaign and they all seemed stuck with this dilemma (that IDF has to level the place and otherwise might very well lose or at least "win" with incredible casualties). The emotions are running high with all of them (and Israelis are a very direct people) so the literal sentiment was "send the civs to Sina/EU and make a parking garage of the rest".
There are actually reports coming out that only a small part of the military leadership planned this attack and was aware of it and not even the political leaders of Hamas were aware. And other militant groups were only informed moments before the action and joined in an impromptu manner. Obviously impossible to know for sure but this would make much sense since otherwise it would be impossible to keep this secret.
this passage from their holy book
That is a Hadith. Not a passage from their holy book. If we will go down to such a base level of argumentation at least let's get the facts right. Ironically, one side of this conflict actually does have a holy book where their God instructs them to genocide the inhabitants of the land and settle it themselves which they do according to the said book.
people who call Gaza an “open air prison”
I would agree with this statement and I am curious how someone can disagree with it using honest direct arguments.
Egyptian government has never amounted to much more than a small group of generals using the country as a milking cow. For close to half a century these generals have been propped up by American money and weapons and diplomatic support. America does this with the express intention of getting the generals to stop fighting Israel and cooperate on issues such as Gaza.
It is quite a simple explanation really.
Perhaps because they were alive before last Saturday? It is not for nothing that people who actually spend serious attention on this conflict (and don't have certain affinity for one side) usually end up lament the evil done by both sides and shake their heads in despair.
This was the sentiment among basically every Arab I have talked with in the West Bank. PA is pretty unpopular among people and it is propped up by mostly financial streams that Israel either directly (border levies between West Bank/Jordan) or indirectly (foreign aid that Israel can cut easily if it wants) controls. If there were elections tomorrow they would almost certainly lose against a much more radical faction.
It is incredible how so many world shattering events seem to keep happening in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict over so many decades and ultimately this equation at its heart just never changes.
Yes this was either a parody or this place is becoming a parody of itself.
Germans were thrown out of lots of territories post-WWII
Mostly as a revenge for Germans themselves attempting to conquer and settle into their neighbors' territories. Am I the only one who sees Germans as more analogous to the other side in this conflict?

This is quite a pointless line of questioning in this matter when
We are not talking about a landlocked country that has bad relations with its neighbors.
More options
Context Copy link