Do you have a dumb question that you're kind of embarrassed to ask in the main thread? Is there something you're just not sure about?
This is your opportunity to ask questions. No question too simple or too silly.
Culture war topics are accepted, and proposals for a better intro post are appreciated.
Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Notes -
Do you think the Muslim world’s proximity to Africa and use of Slavic slaves gave them a big advantage in warring against Europeans? They had a constant supply of slaves in their economy. I wonder how they would have done in war if they had no slaves supplying them constant boosts in productivity.
Slaves are not a productivity boost(they usually perform worse than free labor), not really, and labor generally isn’t the limiting factor on premodern economics anyways.
It’s possible that the use of military slaves gave Muslim armies a greater degree of flexibility in comparison to European armies where, pre-line infantry, soldiers performed tasks in battle dictated by their civilian social standing rather than the needs of the army. But I don’t think ready supply of Eastern European slave girls did much for the Ottoman Empire.
Not sure how this passes the intuition test. If I force you to labor in a mine and beat you if you don’t, the mines will be productive, and I don’t have to pay you much. Or, if I have to pay a cook $30 an hour to come to my house, it is more productive if I pay you in $4 beans and beat you if I don’t comply. All of the extra “resources” saved could be taxed to raise armies.
Slaves have poor motivation to improve their condition. They have little aspiration to improve their position, and practically speaking you can't beat a cook into making you a great dinner. You can beat them into cooking you A dinner by beating them if they don't cook; but if you're going to beat them unless the dinner is perfect they're probably getting beaten regardless. At which point there's no motivation to make a better dinner. Where a free chef who comes to my house is motivated to enhance his status, make a great dinner, get more business, etc.
Free labor typically provides for itself in the long run on a lower wage than it costs the slaver to feed and maintain his slaves. Chattel Slavery only works with continual infusions of fresh slaves from foreign parts, otherwise it doesn't tend to perpetuate itself well.
Of course slavery takes many historical forms, and we can debate details.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link