Do you have a dumb question that you're kind of embarrassed to ask in the main thread? Is there something you're just not sure about?
This is your opportunity to ask questions. No question too simple or too silly.
Culture war topics are accepted, and proposals for a better intro post are appreciated.

Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Notes -
Not really a "small-scale" question, but feels more appropriate for this thread than it does the CW one because of its somewhat stream-of-consciousness, freewheeling, not very rigorous quality. Possibly better for Wellness Wednesday, but that thread's not up yet. Anyway: How do you find meaning in Universal Culture?
Scott, in How The West Was Won, refers to a great shoggoth devouring the world: "I am pretty sure there was, at one point, such a thing as western civilization. I think it included things like dancing around maypoles and copying Latin manuscripts. At some point Thor might have been involved. That civilization is dead. It summoned an alien entity from beyond the void which devoured its summoner and is proceeding to eat the rest of the world." Scott calls this alien entity "Universal Culture", a term which I think fails to capture the consumption-forward, disposable, hollowed-out nature of much of it. I have seen it referred to by another, more apt term on the SSC subreddit: "Global Vegas". It's a maximum point on the memetic fitness landscape, the set of cultural characteristics towards which all countries converge in a certain technological and communication environment, the process of endless optimisation not in any sort of real human-flourishing sense but to serve the ceaseless goal of efficiency and convenience and spreading faster and farther. Universal Culture is, crucially, a mix of things that are actually good and productive (e.g. modern medicine), "optimised" Molochian solutions that are adaptive for the community but seem to make everyone more unhappy when adopted (mass urbanism turning everything into anonymised concrete tower-blocks), and straight-up harmful parasitic superstimuli/habits that absolutely shred the fitness of the host and simply spread due to cognitive evolutionary mismatch (the most indisputable ur-example of this being fast food).
Don't get me wrong, it's good that we no longer die from preventable disease and no longer suffer from persistent food insecurity. It’s a better time than any other in history by any objective metric, and yet it appears that a lot of people feel something is missing, though it's hard to articulate what. To put it succinctly, it feels as if the flanderisation of culture is impossible to escape now regardless of where you go in the modern world, and so much of our current cultural output feels like disposable trinkets that's been optimised for quantifiable metrics of reach and retention, distanced from any kind of meaningful tradition. Much of the built environment reflects an incessant search for efficiency and mechanisation, and many of the "third spaces" that still exist in public are oriented around consumption in a way where it seems like the world has become a massive shopping mall. Increasingly The Future seems to be nothing more than identical glass-and-steel skyscrapers stretching to the horizon, entertainment industries optimised for the production of "media" as opposed to anything on the ground, old rituals long swapped out for the New Shiny Thing which will be obsolete in 5 months. An endless desert of disposable architecture and disposable entertainment and disposable culture, optimised for maximum convenience and maximum short-term pleasure, stripped of community, stripped of meaning, stripped of heritage. Eternal September for the real world.
The kinds of popular content that survive in this environment are all legible without context, pleasurable without effort, and cheap to reproduce. While context and effort are the defining feature of deep and meaningful traditions, partially because they exist as a signifier of community belonging (look at how strange and high context Peking opera or Indian classical music or the Western tradition before a certain point is), a lot of what exists today is the entertainment equivalent of wireheading meant to optimise for reach and common ease of access across a wide networked range of communities. It's the difference between traditional forms that served a community-building purpose and "content" made solely for individualised consumption, with serious emphasis on the "individualised" part of things; in this paradigm it's a massive boon if they can be consumed in your room, on your own, without having to interact with anyone else. Personally because of these trends I'm finding it harder and harder to find meaning in the world or much of contemporary output, which also drives me to make the problem worse by just failing to "touch grass" and interact with a culture I consider to be impressively hollow. It feels like so much meaningful culture has just been hyper-optimised out of existence, and much of the little that remains has itself been transformed into a product. Not that consumption didn't exist beforehand, it did, but it seems to have absolutely taken over much of modern life in lieu of other sources of meaning.
I have found myself becoming a compulsive purveyor of Old Things as of late. Old architecture, old artworks, old customs. In contrast, it just seems as if so much in the Current Year has become increasingly soulless in the pursuit of optimisation and efficiency and commodification, and making sure everyone experiences the lowest possible amount of friction.
We have slack, and its where all great things start.
How did we get culture in the first place? I think its because we had very big brains that didn't need to be used 100% of the time for survival and so they drifted onto mentally pleasing but not fitness maximizing things.
Once culture became a human universal and competition was primarily against other humans rather than the environment the culture got suborned into being a part of the fitness maximizing algorithm. A religion that didn't tell your people how to live better than all your competition to produce babies and armies, useless, and soon to be dead when your neighbors develop a religion that does it better. An item produced for beauty? Only if that beauty can also be quickly converted to purposes of war. Metallurgy is not for shiny pretty metals, it is for swords and armor. Moments of slack could still temporarilly arise. The Greeks had a lucky enough win against the Persians that gave them enough time for culture. But even they suffered the problem within, the Spartans ultimately won the war, a culture that was as devoted as possible to winning an arms race rather than producing anything beautiful.
Now we are once again in a time of slack. Technology has temporarily (or maybe permanently) rendered culture obsolete as a fitness enhancer (I say temporary, because birth rates might be important in the future, but maybe permanently because that might have technological solutions as well via pod births or longevity).
Culture is instead on a runaway optimization process that serves only itself. As you pointed out, it is becoming the most virulent easily digestible form of itself. Its digestible to a mostly uneducated tweenager with a room temperature IQ. Which is where the slack comes in. You can almost certainly digest the necessary parts of the Global Culture more quickly than the tweenager. Then you'll have plenty of time leftover to digest any kind of culture that you'd like to consume. The main limitation on the second thing is just finding other people being willing to engage in that culture with you, since many forms of culture require multiple people to participate. That is my reason for optimism. I don't need to devote every non-working moment in my life to things that make my culture/nation more dominant. I can spend that free time doing what I want, which is some level of consumption of global culture, but I think far less than the average for my age.
More options
Context Copy link
The 'universal culture' emerged out of western culture- specifically Victorian Britain. Spectator sports(most pre-Victorian cultures did not watch sports), Christmas, university education, later marriage, full emancipation at legal adulthood, prose literature, it's all very western.
How are you defining 'watching sports'? There's definitely a lot of sports-adjacent religious festivals throughout human history and I'm pretty sure Roman horse racing and gladiatorial exhibitions would have been fairly familiar to modern audiences.
Mass sports entertainment before the later half of the nineteenth century did not revolve around watching- it revolved around gambling. That's why racing sports were overwhelmingly more popular up until surprisingly recently, and also why sports attendance often had a bit of a rough reputation, or was off limits to women and children.
Now, there's plenty of team sports in history- but 'going to a knattleikr game' was to play knattleikr. The Victorian innovation was to standardize the rules of these 'village team sports' that had been around forever, cull out the best players of a particular area, and have those face each other with everyone else watching due to their new, highly urbanized and deracinated society. Thus, we get association football(which Americans call soccer) and then rugby football- an example of the much less deracinated upper classes following suit.
In America you saw a similar process with baseball.
Yeah but we're arguably back to gambling-centric appreciation being the epicenter of sports and I think you're underrating how much gambling has gone on historically on even ostensibly 'social' sports. Also a bunch of folk rituals that verymuch resemble sports where it's an ego thing between two different villages and the women/children/elderly would be there to spectate even if the able-bodied men were ostensibly there to participate.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I was wondering the other day if there were space in the modern culture for a Western equivalent of Mishima. Although I don't know how impactful a novel could be in this day in age, or exactly what notion of "lost Western culture" it would be a requiem for.
In most western countries, you can just go join a group practicing much older norms while still using modern technology.
Who did you have in mind? The Bruderhof, Mennonites and Hasidic Jews?
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I think it is interesting to think about what our culture has that is still alive.
This is not to be taken for granted. Capitalism, liberal democracy, humanism, and the scientific method are all under threat. But I would consider these aspects of western culture that still exist.
What blessed place do you live in that this is the norm? You don't have to answer. I'm just surprised.
The US does it ‘more’ than other countries. There’s nowhere near as much authenticity to it as we fetishize, and it’s a maxim we pay lip service to and engage in performance art over. How many times have you been in a situation where you’re the ethnic minority (if not sole individual) in a community of other people and everyone there will side against you for no other reason than the fact they’re the same race as the other person. Even when it’s negatively impacting their own group, they’ll stick together no matter what.
My own experience does not bear out this thesis, though yours might.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Whenever I read this, I feel like something is being missed. It might just be that none of us is fully capable of truly appreciating our own culture, because we are too close to the situation. Or a slightly different problem--maybe it is that there is no and has never been any truly great culture, but only the appearance of culture through rose-colored retrospection.
Or maybe--and this is the explanation I find myself increasingly favoring--Western Civilization is so amazing that basically all rational people want to participate in it, but the vast majority of living humans do not have values that are actually compatible with that participation (at least--not fully). Western Civilization hasn't gone anywhere, it's still landing rocketships and producing art and what-have-you. But it is sometimes hard to see, because we have attached a multitude of converter arrays, siphons and interfaces and other cultural technologies intended to "share" the beauty and bounty of Western Civilization with the billions of people who are only capable of appreciating those parts that happen to be "legible without context, pleasurable without effort, and cheap to reproduce." Such people always existed, of course! Most Romans were neither poets nor sculptors nor philosophers, after all. But never in history have so many people directly and indirectly benefited from the cultural superiority and magnanimity of so few.
And because one of the great insights of Western Civilization is a broad-based humanism, it generously, even gregariously invites these interfaces to take everything, forever, without payment, without gratitude, without apology.
It speaks to the greatness of Western Civilization, really, that it manages to survive the process at all. A pessimistic viewer might call this a "bloodletting" and suspect that, despite its strength and superiority, Western Civilization is doomed to eventually collapse from exhaustion and perish altogether, perhaps taking the entirety of humanity with it. But pessimism is not the only option! Optimistically, the more the rest of humanity takes from Western Civilization, the more it comes to resemble Western Civilization. A group with partly or wholly incompatible values today need not have incompatible values later. And what's more--one of the values of Western Civilization is improvement through competition! As other cultures arise and develop in the wake of the magnanimity of the West, they can serve to reinvigorate Western Civilization. Yes, we lose the unipolar pax Americana, but what we gain instead is an opportunity to enter into renewed competition and conflict.
I sympathize with much of what you say--certainly contemporary architecture needs to die a horrible, screaming death--but I actually love so many new things, Western or otherwise. Video games especially, but also novels, anime, even Hollywood continues to produce the occasionally fantastic movie. AI technology is awe-inspiring, even if it might also be our doom. Medical technology is increasingly just straight-up miraculous. Most of this is either directly or indirectly attributable to the operation or influence of Western Civilization. Which is why I increasingly suspect that people are only losing sight of this because so much energy is getting poured into somehow finding ways to share the bounty with people who neither understand nor appreciate it, but seek to benefit from it only because the benefits are too great and obvious to be ignored.
I'm curious as to why you're vaunting this current state of affairs as Western Civilisation, since I regard a large portion of Universal Culture as hopelessly self-defeating in the long run and believe we have just successfully shielded ourselves from the worst of the costs thus far. The supposed magnanimity and humanism you and other commenters are referring to is not a noble trait; it’s the suicidality of a decadent society, and this current iteration of
Universal CultureWestern Civilisation being spread everywhere is exactly the strand of progressive thought we complain about endlessly on the CW threads, and which many of the old great western philosophers of yore would have thought of as an aberration. So many of the norms that exist at the moment are the product of a society that became too big to fail off the shoulders of their forebears, and which I don’t want to see exported anywhere. This set of norms and ideologies creates drag on societies, it destroys state capacity, it shreds fertility, it fucks up streets and cities, it ruins the social world in service of retarded gibmes and a tyranny of the minority, and it is only in spite of this utter absurdity that "Western Civilisation" continues to function. It’s strange to me that so many conservatives here want to lay claim to it, since it’s not clear to me why they should when it is actively hostile to them. If Culture ending up like this is a path-dependent property of Western Civilisation, I can’t help but regard it as utterly delegitimising. It may once have been awesome, but increasingly I’m getting less of a sense of “awesome” and more of a sense that the entity is being cannibalised from the inside and worn as a skinsuit. What’s there may be high-entropy, but just because a meme spreads fast doesn’t mean it’s good, and if it is Western Civilisation, it’s Western Civilisation in the throes of a bloated late-Qing-like failstate.I exaggerate, but only a little bit. There is still a nonzero amount of good things about the West, but every day there seems to be yet another erosion of norms and as time goes on more and more people appear to be hitting the defect button. The amount of leeway that the West has to fix shit is only shrinking as the years go on and the institutional paralysis and social derangement deepens. The west has just been so rich for so long they’ve never been required to confront the costs of their policies, as if the bill will never come due. At the moment, western countries still on balance offer a superior quality of life, but the non-Japan parts of Asia are busy catching up and we’ll see what happens if current trends continue the way they do. The western position in the world is less assured than triumphalists seem to think it is, and its biggest competitor is China; possibly the least western modernised country on earth. A country, I might add, that the West has tariffed and embargoed countless times, in opposition to the “acceptance of competition” and free trade that I am told the Western Civilisation stands for.
As for magnanimity, I’m not certain geopolitical events align very well with that self-perception. Is "magnanimity" and "wanting to expose the rest of the world to the nourishing fruits of Western Civilisation" the reason why America staged a coup to replace a democratically elected PM in Iran with an American-aligned monarch? Is this why they repeatedly did so in Latin America? Is this why the U.S. in the span of half a century interfered with 81 elections around the world, so that the unwashed masses could have a taste of scintillating Western freedom and values? Or is it because they didn’t want competition they couldn’t control? Even the whole letting endless refugees in thing is not entirely a magnanimous and self-effacing position taken for the benefit of the poor foreigners; it's a defect button in a coordination problem. Keeping a massive low-skill population that is fully dependent on the largesse of the party that let them in is extremely politically profitable, and in order to justify that people ignore the fact it excoriates the social fabric in their own country and drains the labour force from undeveloped countries, choosing instead to create post-hoc rationalisations which portray it as compassion and basic human decency. "The West" is as self-interested and amoral as any other people are, and this isn’t necessarily a condemnation as much as it is just an observation of the kinds of incentives that drive behaviour. Every country is self-serving, Western nations certainly wouldn’t be the first ones to be so, but the glazing does not correlate with what's going on in the real world.
I’m not "anti-Western Civilisation" per se. But I am a cynical doomer par excellence who believes that ideology is often just a smokescreen for uglier, baser human tendencies, and I can't get myself to share this outlook.
I mean, first, I think I was pretty clear about that--both in terms of technology and art, things are going very well--but second, you seem to be attributing to me a great deal of confidence that I don't actually feel. Rather, I identified a few possibilities, only one of which I "find myself increasingly favoring"--a far cry from "vaunting," I think! I understand your pessimism, but you should still at least be realistic in noticing the good stuff, such as it is.
Yeah, what I'm suggesting is that this is the result of the "interfacing," rather than the result of Western Civilization per se. One possible response would be that we should cut back (or entirely) on the interfacing. If there were no other civilizations with which to "interface," that might lead to a stagnation problem instead, but all I'm suggesting is that it's not Western Civilization to blame, it's the step to "Universal Culture"--which turns out to be a misnomer and maybe ought to be abandoned. Only certain kinds of people can do Western Culture (and that extends to most Western people, who benefit from Western Culture but do not contribute to it, but thanks to value compatibility at least do not create the same kind of drag as the "interfacing" does).
You seem to regard me as among the "triumphalists" here but I was pretty explicit about the rise of other cultures potentially being a good thing for Western Civilization--not only through competition, as I mentioned, but also just through the reduction of demand for interfacing. Imagine the pressure it would take off the U.S. if suddenly the Islamist world was obsessed with doing terrorism in China instead of the U.S., or if China became the preferred target for illegal immigration from around the world.
And yet it is only the West that has liberated the world, ever. So far! None of this should be taken to suggest that the West is somehow unusually moral or never responsible for skullduggery or whatever. I have said "there is a lot of great stuff in Western Civilization even today" and your response seems to be something like "the West is not perfect and is often quite bad" and to that all I can say is "I never claimed anything to the contrary." You're talking past me. If you think that, on balance, Western Civilization really is dead, or bad, or whatever, like, I don't have a lot to say about that. That's a slightly different topic than whether it still exists at all, or whether it still makes valuable contributions to its constituents or others.
I mean, you do seem to be very clearly anti-Western Civilization, though.
To the contrary, you seem to be holding out quite a lot of hope and optimism with regard to e.g. China, which you expressed pretty clearly above. I could pretty easily write a laundry list of sins perpetrated by the CCP, but I doubt any of it would be news to you. I don't think you've said anything, in either of your posts, that strikes me as clearly false or wrong. You just don't seem interested in applying your cynicism evenly across all ideologies. In my experience, this is almost always how "critics of Western Civilization" end up: expert at criticizing one (what is often their own) civilization, often in totally legitimate ways, while nevertheless weirdly fawning over (typically, foreign) alternatives that are either not obviously better, or are in fact obviously worse.
Won't respond to everything now (broadly I agree with your framing more here, and I wasn't actually intending to suggest you were a triumphalist, I was thinking about other people). But I don't think you have me correctly characterised with this:
That is simply because I do think China is more resilient, less dysfunctional, and more of a serious competitor than many give it credit for, and it actually has state capacity, which is legit very important (also there are some doomer things reported that are just straight-up astroturfed). That does not mean I don't think they have their own sets of serious issues or massive failure modes that are specific to the Chinese system - there is a lot to criticise about, say, their insane handling of COVID or more generally just aggressive overreach in multiple domains and noticeable struggles with checks and balances, and it's not the case that I would necessarily like to live there. It is simply that, as you note, I doubt any of it would be news to anyone here. People here, as is true in most of the English-speaking world, generally don't like (read: often really fucking hate) China, and I'm a habitual contrarian so I don't feel the need to already reaffirm whatever people already believe. My actual opinions on China are complex and ambivalent, and I don't think it's "obviously" better; but people here are mostly in favour of the West so I play devil's advocate and advance the counterargument a lot. Definitely became something I was more interested in doing upon the outbreak of the Iran War, which I very much did not like, and seeing just how many people decided to do the whole America Triumphalism thing really showed me the extent of who/whom that was operating (it also soured me aggressively on unbridled West-bullishness, because that's where you end up if you take it too far. I will probably not be able to read anything even adjacent to that without cringing for a while).
Paradoxically, another part of the reason why I don't rant about China's foibles is because I'm less invested in the success of the Chinese system than I am the Western one. It's the difference between being interested in something vs being actually morally invested in it. With China, I simply do not hate them in the way other people appear to, I am fascinated by the culture and system in a more academic and somewhat anthropological fashion where I am interested to see how it turns out (and also do like travelling there, good value proposition and nice people). If it wasn't already clear, I like difference and novelty for its own sake. But the Chinese system is far away and I do not have much of a stake in whether they end up succeeding or failing, nor do I think the likelihood of them making the world into the Chinese Empire where everyone has a social credit score or something is particularly high, so I find it hard to get very invested. On the other hand, there are pretty large swaths of Western values that I actually do have personal investment in because I grew up believing in them, and I am therefore way more personally upset and become increasingly disillusioned when the nations that are supposed to be its proponents fail to live up to what I view as its core tenets. There is an actual reason why "tyranny of small differences" is a thing.
I generally don't trust morality-based geopolitical claims made by nations, regardless of whether China or America is doing it. Chinese century-of-humiliation based land claims (e.g. Taiwan) are clearly vacuous legitimising babble and I'm not sure I've said anything different. Their rationales for their geopolitical actions are about as sincere as America claiming that its geopolitical role is the enforcement of a global rules-based order or the promotion of Western liberal democracy. It's all realpolitik, all the way down.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Civilization of virtually any kind will be loved to all the people who are actively benefitting from it. Every successive generation has a way of looking back to their own past experiences with nostalgia, that in a lot of ways wasn’t the “fantasy” the younger generations chalk it up to. There’s a lot of “hollowing out” of western culture that’s happened over a century, and a lot of what made it good and enjoyable has been displaced without substitution. I wouldn’t want to go back to 20th century healthcare; but I also wouldn’t mind going back to a world without social media or the level of political polarization. But, civilization is one of those compromises and trade off’s where you have to take the good with the bad, and there’s no mechanism as such that’s been demonstrated to have the best of both world’s. If I had to completely accept one vision of western society, I’m glad to be living in 2026 with all its faults.
More options
Context Copy link
All that you say may be true, but then I'm merely left realizing that for all its material benefits, for how it beats all alternatives in its weight class, it was never "Western Civilization" that my heart belonged to.
More options
Context Copy link
Let's call the following the "Tory interpretation of history":
This is in contrast to what Scott says, which both "Whigs" and "reactionaries" agree on (just with different moral slant) - that there is a radical discontinuity between the "traditional West" and the present day. Now, I'm sure many people here would debate which interpretation is correct, and I'll admit that I may be romanticizing the past somewhat, but the "Tory" perspective seems underrepresented so I wanted to call it out and name it.
The discontinuity thesis arises (explicitly, in Scott's case) from taking the non-western experience of having modernity foisted upon your people from outside, and projecting that back onto western civilization itself. But the more I read about history the more I come to believe that the western tradition is continuous with modernity. If I feel "alienated" it's not because of modernity, but because of people from other cultures coming in and imposing their idea of "tradition", which is alien to my own cultural assumptions. Scott (the other one) may describe himself as "shtetl-optimized", but I certainly don't.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link