Transnational Thursday is a thread for people to discuss international news, foreign policy or international relations history. Feel free as well to drop in with coverage of countries you’re interested in, talk about ongoing dynamics like the wars in Israel or Ukraine, or even just whatever you’re reading.
Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Notes -
Grafton Street, a bustling pedestrianised street in Dublin's city centre, is one of the biggest shopping streets in the country. It's often one of the first places tourists go to when they arrive in Ireland, and accordingly on weekends will be thronged with buskers looking to make a few bob from Americans who can afford to splash out.
On South Anne Street, just off Grafton Street, there's an establishment called Club 22. I've been in there once, and the clientele was overwhelmingly made up of black men and white women (many of the latter, to my eyes, looked underage). Last February, the club was hosting a gig when an argument erupted outside in which a 34-year-old Nigerian asylum seeker, Quaham Babatunde, was stabbed to death. One of the perpetrators fled to Belfast where he was picked up by the PSNI (Police Service of Northern Ireland) and returned by them to Dublin. All four perpetrators were eventually charged and convicted:
Tache and Carr received three years each. Reports from earlier in the year claim that Oloo Omee and Forde were due to be sentenced in April, but I can't find any articles about their sentencing.
(Without wishing to speak ill of the dead, the victim was no angel, having been scheduled for deportation from Italy owing to a rape allegation.)
Last weekend, history repeated itself as tragedy. The Bewley's café on Grafton St was hosting a hip-hop gig when a fight erupted outside. A 21-year-old club promoter, Qayyam Balogun, was chased to nearby Clarendon St (less than 300 metres from Club 22) and stabbed to death. Police have arrested a suspect (whose name they have yet to release), who apparently fled to Northern Ireland and then Scotland immediately after the stabbing. In the immediate aftermath of the stabbing, he apparently bragged about it online, and is well-known to the police, being out on bail for a different stabbing at the time. Police have also arrested his girlfriend.
The whole thing is just a bit eerie. Two Nigerian men stabbed to death in a very affluent part of Dublin, separated in time and space by less than eighteen months and 300 metres, by killers with mile-long rap sheets who subsequently fled to Northern Ireland.
I know progressives tend to be big believers in "rehabilitative justice", but I have to ask the obvious question. Does anyone actually believe that any of these five men will ever go on to be productive, law-abiding members of society? How much of a hardened criminal do you have to be to rack up thirty-four previous convictions by the age of 22? This most recent perpetrator stabbed someone, got arrested and charged, was mercifully granted bail, almost immediately stabbed someone else, then went on social media and bragged about it. This is a lack of forethought and impulse control I'd expect from a prepubescent. It's extremely difficult for me to avoid the conclusion that this man will be in and out of prison for his entire life, every few years getting out only to stab someone else and be back inside within a year. His life will end in one of two ways: either someone will finally stab him before he manages to stab them, or he'll realise he's getting too old for this shit and live out the rest of his miserable life on some combination of social welfare and disability payments for a fictitious medical condition. His entire life will be lived at the taxpayer's largesse.
What the hell does one do with a person like this?
Idealism is a cancer.
Imo - hanging, drawing, quartering, in public.
More options
Context Copy link
If I wanted to channel some Dread Jim, I would say public humiliation and then public execution. Make it very clear that they are not a role model and make them look as pathetic as possible, so every would-be gangster can see exactly badass they're going to look as they're publicly shamed before being hanged. The general deterrent value is debatable, but the specific deterrent value is quite high (hard to re-offend after being executed).
More options
Context Copy link
Rehabilitative justice mostly doesn't work, it just allows repeat convicts more time and resources to spread their violent genes in your population. Better to do capital punishment after the n+1 conviction and if your society has the stomach for it, take out their useful organs to help law-abiding productive people live longer. Asset seizures of convicts are of course a given if we're already taking their organs.
Does capital punishment sometimes get the wrong person? Surely it does, but the general population is probably satisfied if police forces can blame and catch the right criminal most of the time (90%? 95%?), perfection is unrealistic. Is organ harvesting a crime against humanity? Maybe it is, but it's only used to mitigate the tax burden of dealing with criminals, so it's not necessary. Harvesting organs of repeat criminal offenders is just a way to force convicts to repay their victims, which includes taxpayers, in the event they have no other resources to give.
I further propose that a convicted Nigerian's organs be given to a law-abiding Nigerian as a priority on the organ recipient wait list. Non-nigerians would only have second priority on the convict organ transplant list. In this way we sustain Nigerians with better genes, and avoid the apperance of Nigerians being harvested purely for the benefit of other ethnicities.
Great now all George Soros needs to do is frame a healthy white guy, or jew depending on the current Schrodinger's minority status, in order to get his heart transplant. Way to invent the rich harvesting the organs of the poor.
The rich already harvest the organs of the poor because the rich already game the system to be prioritized.
https://www.cuimc.columbia.edu/news/study-finds-link-between-income-and-organ-transplant-access
If it's going to happen anyway society at large may as well get some benefit from it while eliminating criminality.
I suspect Soros has no problem getting any transplant he needs, no need to frame anyone when he is going to be the top of the waiting list anyway.
More options
Context Copy link
What do you mean, "invent"? Canada has had MAiD for years.
But Canada's MAiD agents are too busy targeting soldiers with bodies ruined by war, not exactly prime blood boy donor targets. Maybe they are building Frankensteinian super soldiers from the bodies?
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link