Do you have a dumb question that you're kind of embarrassed to ask in the main thread? Is there something you're just not sure about?
This is your opportunity to ask questions. No question too simple or too silly.
Culture war topics are accepted, and proposals for a better intro post are appreciated.

Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Notes -
Why do women (specifically wives and girlfriends) hate video games and when men play video games? The typical Reddit answer is that the man must be ignoring the relationship or his duties as a boyfriend or husband or father or worker, but I know plenty of guys who play a few hours a week total, are good and attentive partners, and their ladies still complain about it. Is it an outdated “video games are for nerds” thing? I can’t figure it out.
Man, rarely have I seen the forum be so wrong.
@Rov_Scam and @hydroacetylene: Goofy ass take in 2026. Maybe made sense when we were kids, but at this point it's an absurd boomer nostalgia belief, that reflects failing to accept that we are in fact old men now. A 25 year old woman today had a dad who was a young man in the SNES/N64/PS1/Sega days, even if she had an older dad he was around for the Atari or the Capcom arcade days in the 80s. Hell, I have weirdly old parents, and I'm 35, and my mother LOVES Ms Pac-Man. Young women today grew up with gaming as a common activity her father engaged in. It's not inherently a kids activity any more than golf or baseball are kids activities.
@Tretiak: you're basically accurate, but video gaming is more disliked than other hobbies that take up time that could be spent on her, so why?
Gaming is clearly more disliked than other hobbies that are comparably pointless, time consuming, or childish. So why is gaming most disliked?
My answer:
To quote Lindyman:
When I leave the house and go rock climbing or go to BJJ, I'm going out and interacting with a wider group of people. I come home with stories, maybe a weird and incomprehensible story about the relative morality of wrist locks, but a story. I'm in a social space where I can tell her a story about what happened, with real people. When I play WoW, I'm home, it's clear nothing has happened.
Women like hobbies that demand respect from other men. It's frequently pointed out that women report liking slimmer men in comparison tests, but muscular guys never have problems getting laid. This is because Weightlifting demands respect from other men, which is sexier than being pretty. Video games do not demand respect. Even other gamers don't really respect each other for their skill and talent. Nobody is intimidated to talk to a wow raid leader or a guy with a great K:D in CoD. Women will respect video games as a hobby when men respect it as an achievement. This is, of course, circular: men would respect having the Pokemon Fire Red speedrun record if it got you laid with hot girls, and it would get you laid with hot girls if men respected it.
There is no actual achievement in a video game. A solo game is no achievement at all, no one knows or cares. A linked, online game is constantly at the mercy of the crowd, the plug can be pulled at any time. There's no lasting result. Nothing built, no part of yourself improved. There's not even any way to pretend that it does. It's a pure entertainment waste.
BONUS: Mrs FiveHour adds that it's super annoying when a man says "oh hang on let me finish this level;" where a book will be put down a phone will be put down a video game requires constant attention. Sort of the same thing that makes them worthwhile.
Anybody who demands I stop whatever I'm doing at the time on the spot to pay attention to them immediately for something that isn't an emergency is annoying and deserves to be single. I promise you flipping the mattress will wait until the end of this chapter. "Hey, come upstairs!" with absolutely no elaboration only for it to be a not time-sensitive question about what we may or may not be doing in six weeks' time? Annoying. Don't fucking do that.
From the perspective of many a woman, any time she has a want or a need constitutes ipso facto an emergency for her boyfriend/husband.
More options
Context Copy link
I hope you've found your perfect woman. If not, good luck brother.
all women will try it, most women, even the very imperfect ones, will behave better if you set boundaries for them and they respect you
if they don't, well, you're going to be getting home from a long day and just as your butt touches the chair you'll be nagged to come immediately address something silly which could wait
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I usually just drop whatever I'm playing and pay attention to real life when real life shows up. It's usually my wife who then tells me "stop talking to me, you're about to get killed!", at which point it's usually too late, which gives me an opportunity to shrug it off in a display of healthy priorities. It's a compromise solution. It also helps that I'l usually only play games if I know that the rest of the family is taken care of; i.e., kid's in bed and wife has her own dopamine faucet to drink from. It also helps that she was the one who originally got me started on Hunt: Showdown, mind you, so she's weirdly happy to see me stick to it.
The problem is when real life hasn't shown up but your wife (or a child) wants some jaw exercise and expects you to be visibly paying attention because not paying attention is disrespectful. I have told my autistic son that the cat is deeply interested in his imaginary world (false) and will listen to him talk about it for hours (true), but it didn't work. When an appropriate opportunity arises, I have occasionally told my wife the same thing.
More options
Context Copy link
I think the perception here stems from my wife trying to talk to me while I'm gaming on my laptop next to her and not paying attention, versus my wife trying to talk to me while I'm reading and I'm not really making any progress in the book but I am paying attention to her.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Your argument is well-taken, but keep in mind it also applies to Disney Adults. I also doubt that your mother is playing several hours of Ms. Pacman a week.
Sadly, it does. Even moreso, it applies to people being surprised that Jay-Z is doing the Super Bowl halftime show. Jay Z is oldies! Jay Z's biggest hits started coming out 30 years ago. American Graffiti more or less invented the genre of oldies radio in 1973 with a film set in 1962. Teenagers who snuck Jay Z albums past their parents are now parents of teenagers. We're getting old. And at times I see this tendency to call things "young" or "juvenile" either positively or pejoratively, and it's just not true anymore.
You know, my cleaning lady's account at the time was that my mother would regularly sneak up into the attic to play Ms. Pac Man on our Super Nintendo for hours at a time in the afternoon while we were at school. But this is decades ago, and at any rate I never felt my mom didn't do enough around the house or otherwise, and my mom is 70 so definitely pre-video game as a person, it's just a funny anecdote. My father, who is 81, has to my knowledge never successfully played any video game, but bought a pinball machine at an estate auction when I was in college and would play it for hours at a time. Sometimes I'd have a buddy over to lift weights or drink, and my dad would dragoon us into playing pinball with him for dozens of games.
More options
Context Copy link
She could be playing several hours of Words with Friends.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I can't remember my dad playing video games growing up, unless it was with me on a game I was already playing. He spent his decompression time watching football. My friends, ditto, would play video games on their own or with their dads, but their dads didn't just 'play video games'.
When I entered the work force(and the stereotype of HVAC may not always be positive, but it is Adult and Male), coworkers basically never talked about video games- although they talked about TV, fishing, sports, and cars. Things might be different in tech, I don't know- but the median woman does not work in tech. The men she works around talk about TV, sports, maybe politics. My hunting club(mostly landmen and accountants) talks about politics, hunting and fishing, sports, their jobs, comedians/TV, and wildlife. Selected, sure, but if you hang around varying groups of adult men you won't hear much videogame talk. Lots and lots of sports. Lots of TV. Some current events.
You know who talks about videogames a lot? Children and early adolescent boys. Yes, there's lots of adult men playing video games- statistically most of the market- but this is not visible to most women.
Working in a nuclear lab, with a lot of engineers and tech writers? Yeah, there was a ton of video-game talk, including someone who's now nearing retirement that loved BFME2
My first RTS right there. I have such nostalgic memories of playing BFME2 with my friends and with my father.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
And how old are you? I'm under the impression that you're a typical mid-30s Mottizen, so our parents would be born some time in the 1960s on average (mine happen to be older). While our parents might have run into an early video game or two in their youth, they were well into adulthood before real modern videogames came online.
For a 25yo girl today, her father would have been a young adult for the PS1 and the N64, in his early 20s for Halo and World of Warcraft. It would be something her dad did, if not in front of her at least in concept.
Yes, because it's an unattractive hobby, so no one talks about it.
Why are physical sports like football, basketball, and baseball popular to talk about among men but generally not video games except in nerdy or techy circles? Is it a tribal identity affiliation thing, where you demonstrate tribal connection by showing sports knowledge?
Me, my brother, and my dad are all slightly autistic so it seems to be something we just don't get very well. We are all on the nerdy/techy side, but sometimes we will watch the world series or the super bowl. We don't dislike sports, but we won't go out of our way to learn about or watch them either. I personally know a bit about mainstream American sports, but only because of sports video games that my older cousins really liked and played with me when I was younger.
Sports is one of the great unifiers across class/race/etc. I can talk football with my mechanic, my pediatrician, my priest, random street bums, etc. It's like if the weather were really interesting, or the news were mostly uncontroversial.
More options
Context Copy link
Watching sports is the default male hobby in the universal culture that arose out of victorian Britain. Before that, the default male hobby in most societies was either drinking heavily or gambling on sports. Playing sports also has immediately obvious benefits(making IRL friends, physical exercise, etc) while videogames are Just Fun.
More options
Context Copy link
In a reversal of most posters here, I'd suggest that it's because women, the gatekeepers of sexual relationships and therefore the arbiters of men's value, don't like them. It's not high status among men because it doesn't attract women.
More options
Context Copy link
Also where do you want to draw the line in the sand between saying, “This person just has an unconventional hobby,” and it not really being a hobby? Because technically “anything” can be a hobby if you want to be that pedantic just like everything can be a dildo if you’re brave enough. But I think people who do that are playing with words more than anything else.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
“Shopping” isn’t a hobby, just FYI. Whenever I’ve taken the chance to observe women in their natural habitat, it’s very clear to me that most of them have absolutely nothing going on in their lives, or pretty darn close to that. I’m not saying that’s a bad thing necessarily; I’d love to get a day where I had jack shit to do. I very rarely play games anymore but hope to one day pick it up again for a day, just as an immersive decompression activity, after I’ve put in my usual hard day’s work in a fight with the rest of the world.
Back when StarCraft e-Sports was beginning to absorb a good slice of western audiences on TeamLiquid and AfreecaTV, and places like YaoYuan.com were also popular for downloading replays, FPVOD’s became extremely popular. Usual VOD’s of the Korean circuit you could get off torrent sites and the demand for them was enormous, but first person VOD’s, where you could see the screen moving back and forth with the player clicking across the map were highly prized because they were heavily guarded and extremely difficult to find or hope for a leaker. We all wanted to experience the beauty of the game. Now you want to know what an “FPVOD” was for some of the females who liked to play StarCraft? Playing the game with a camera sitting right in front of them so their audience could see her. They seemingly had no ability to take a purely objective interest in anything. The hobby was never about the hobby itself. It was about them. Of course not all women are like this naturally and maybe it only applies to the vain ones, but it’s definitely something you can pick up on if you’re paying close enough attention in the aggregate. It’s the same reason if you ever attend a real Basketball or Football game, the women seem more into scrolling on their phone, taking pics of themselves on Instagram at the game, or doing other shit. They had very little appreciation for the game itself.
Assuming that we're considering video games a hobby for this conversation, what definition would you use by which "shopping" is not a hobby but "video games" are?
The problem is you’re not talking about leisure in isolation. You’re talking about it in a context. If you and I were having fun playing a Chess game I’d say there’s a mutual enjoyment and satisfaction going on by which we’re both benefitting. If I was burning through money on your credit card, that’s a transaction going on at someone else’s expense.
Ok I think I missed a step here chief, I have no idea what you're talking about at this point.
That’s the context. You asked (paraphrasing): “Why are video games a hobby yet shopping is not?” Because what I described is usually what happens when you’re in a relationship. That is why “shopping” is not a hobby. I’m answering his question.
I asked:
Your replies have not contained a definition of a hobby, let alone one that includes "Video Games" but excludes "Shopping."
"Doesn't cost money" can't be the definition of a hobby, because lots of definitional hobbies cost a lot of money. Golf, sailing, classic cars. "Doesn't cost somebody else's money" is incoherent, sailing is a hobby if it's my credit card I'm destroying but not if it's my wife's credit card?
So like, I don't see how any of this is responsive beyond you working through some kind of issue.
A “hobby” is a leisure activity that you do to be engaged (e.g. playing video games). Shopping is an activity you do to get things. The former is mostly about what you do with your time, the latter is about what you do with your money.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Not sure if I agree with the third point, which is equally true of basically every entertainment medium, few of which seem to inspire the same contempt.
It's more true of video games than it is of any other hobby for a variety of reasons.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
That point applies in spades to reading fiction or watching movies/shows, but women diss those a lot less, not to mention often engaging in those themselves.
Listen Mrs. FiveHour tells me that playing video games is unattractive, Mrs. FiveHour has watched Gilmore Girls from beginning to end three or four times since we got married. Do I find that attractive? No, it's vaguely disgusting. But she has a great rack so I don't really sit around thinking about whether her hobbies are optimal, she's attractive anyway.
Think of classic stories like Cinderella. A beautiful young girl marries the prince. Now imagine the reverse. A handsome begger man marries an aging queen. The second tale is not going to become a classic except if the humor is very well done.
Men are partly attractive because of their status. Women generally aren't. Do you know any male who finds Hillary Clinton/Ursula Gertrud von der Leyen attractive enough to lust after? Men are quite happy to choose a pretty girl with little or no status. Women want a man with confidence and who has status, and they are willing to give up some things they'd otherwise want to get it.
One of the jokes in Gilbert and Sullivan's Trial by Jury is a Horatio Alger-style ascent from poverty (in this case an expensively-educated child from a lower-middle-class background, not an actual poor) story which centres around the future Judge falling in love with a rich attorney's elderly, ugly daughter. So the idea was already a joke by the mid-19th century.
More options
Context Copy link
Actually it'll be one of the most popular books of all time, literally memorized by millions of people, because he'll go on to conquer a significant part of the known world and found a major world religion
More options
Context Copy link
Sounds like the sort of story Benjamin Franklin would like.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
This isn’t true. Reading makes you smarter and helps you know more about the world. Even shitty books like Atlas Shrugged helped me articulate how I felt about the world and learn about myself.
If you're inclined to become smarter and know more about the world, a single player game's storyline can help you just as well, and if you're not, no amount of consuming trendy books will do that.
Certainly true.
And now I have to disagree, in two contradictory directions at once:
On the one hand, a single player game's storyline can be a work of art, not "just as well" as a book, but much better, in ways no non-interactive art form can match. The suspense of wondering what an author's internally-conflicted character will choose just can't measure up to the internal conflict of being forced to decide what you would choose in their place.
On the other hand, it probably won't. Making a story interactive in ways that are meaningful (e.g. doing side quest A before B or vice-versa doesn't count) requires the plot to branch, and every bit of writing that has to handle N branches makes writers do N times as much work as the audience gets to see, and the RoI for doing that plummets fast. Naively, n choices in a game gives you at least N=2ⁿ branches, so writers either have to make n small (my favorite huge choice is in Deus Ex, but there's just the one and it's right at the end), make the branches "decouple" (e.g. there's a half dozen other major choices in Deus Ex, but IIRC no writing that has to handle the cases for more than one of them at a time), make the branches "merge" (e.g. in Life is Strange episode 2 there's a bunch of choices with a single binary outcome based on "did the good choices outweigh the bad ones"), etc. Telltale Games was probably the best at making this kind of thing tractable, and they still get shit on for the compromises (Google "telltale games choices matter" - I get 2 neutral/nuanced and 5 negative opinions in the top results). The alternative is what you see more often: games where the writers don't risk disappointing you by even trying to make your choices significant. At best they give you sets of quests which each have a couple outcomes that only matter in short-term or materialistic senses, and at worst they railroad you, and either way you get a story that you could have read in 5 hours, diluted by 20 or 30 hours of gameplay.
More options
Context Copy link
I'm not sure if you're being serious here. You seem to be implying the point is about reading "trendy books" (?) as opposed to reading books, period. Or maybe you're suggesting that the point is personal curiosity and desire for knowledge?
You know, I think it's true and fake at the same time. I can produce a more interesting motte-post book review of the way the differences between World of Warcraft (2004) and WoW Forever (2026) illustrate cultural changes* than an NPC could write about War and Peace. But the critical muscles I built to interpret WoW as a document were built on thousands of pages of reading, and I don't think you could build them playing video games.
*The religious revival in western culture and the end of /r/atheism is encapsulated in giving Gnomes the ability to roll priest
Good Good, now do undead paladins!
Ties into the same thing, but also there's some inside baseball with the Forsaken. A lot of this is from reading Staat's WoW Diary while my wife was in labor for 36 hours at the hospital.
2004 WoW was built around a certain set of cultural values inherent in computer gamers in California. Engineering is massively, absurdly OP compared to every other profession. Leatherworking lets you make an ok-ish pair of leather pants, Engineering at the same level lets you make grenades. The Gnomes are the engineering race. Their city, which they ruined, was a techno utpopia. Their racial attribute was a 5% higher intellect than all the other races. But they had no religious classes. No priests, no shamans, no druids. When you go into Gnomeragen, there's no cathedral, no temple, no religious district. The gnomes are clearly atheists, or at least (given that religion is pretty materially true when the village priest can raise you from the dead at level 12) agnostic and uninterested in religion. The implication is obvious: religion is primitive, and science will supersede it. The California 2004 worldview.
In the same way, Undead were originally this big fancy lore plotline: they were the Forsaken, betrayed by everyone, hated and feared, but also pretty evil. And the lore team had one vision, but the game designers mostly just saw them as evil zombies, and these two visions conflicted in the portrayal in game. Forsaken were punk rock, their /dance was head banging, their aesthetic was goth, and they wanted to kill everyone and everything. Early Forsaken quests explicitly revolve around creating a new zombie plague from bat blood or whatever, while the opening voiceover explicitly tells you that they harbor "no real loyalty" to the Horde and are merely allies of convenience. There's this tension between the misunderstood oppressed, and the evil dark sorcerers.
Giving the Undead paladins is Blizzard taking a firm stand on that tension: they're misunderstood do-gooders on the inside. Which reflects the softening of all the alt lifestyles that the Forsaken stood in for in game. It's the degeneration of Goth into Diner-Goth. The kid who wore black to school every day, who listened to punk rock and death metal, used to be thought to be a little dangerous. Emo turned it into an aesthetic for the misunderstood, the losers who wanted to get laid and be winners, harmless. Ordinary proletarians are into punk and emo and metal now, ordinary reliable good family people. And the Forsaken are following that, they're so misunderstood that it's hard to believe they were ever misunderstood to begin with. Because nobody is going to take the original aesthetic of the Forsaken seriously in 2026, it's fully understood that the skulls and evil aesthetic is just a bit.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I'm suggesting that the point is personal curiosity and desire for knowledge. I specified "trendy books" to highlight that I don't just mean some wordslop like isekai/romantasy novels aren't the key to self-improvement, but also that the classics aren't either.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
How does playing the Witcher 3 help me in any way? There a few well thought out games like Bioshock but even then you could play the game without engaging with the philosophy at all (or even being literate): It’s also extremely inefficient in terms of how you intake information. Even just reading Agatha Christie is better than playing a video game. At least then you’d know England didn’t used to have lots of black people and Muslims and was a much different Country not that long ago.
Witcher 3 might get you to reflect on how a guy with good intentions could end up being a bad father. A book might get you to do the same and faster, but playing Witcher 3 could get you to feel it viscerally through storytelling. The combined visual-audio medium of video games can bring forth strong emotions that makes you reflect more deeply than a book could.
More options
Context Copy link
Sure, if you compare a video game set in a fictional world and a novel set in our world on the scale of "telling you historical facts about our world" then the video game is going to rank unfavorably.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link