This weekly roundup thread is intended for all culture war posts. 'Culture war' is vaguely defined, but it basically means controversial issues that fall along set tribal lines. Arguments over culture war issues generate a lot of heat and little light, and few deeply entrenched people ever change their minds. This thread is for voicing opinions and analyzing the state of the discussion while trying to optimize for light over heat.
Optimistically, we think that engaging with people you disagree with is worth your time, and so is being nice! Pessimistically, there are many dynamics that can lead discussions on Culture War topics to become unproductive. There's a human tendency to divide along tribal lines, praising your ingroup and vilifying your outgroup - and if you think you find it easy to criticize your ingroup, then it may be that your outgroup is not who you think it is. Extremists with opposing positions can feed off each other, highlighting each other's worst points to justify their own angry rhetoric, which becomes in turn a new example of bad behavior for the other side to highlight.
We would like to avoid these negative dynamics. Accordingly, we ask that you do not use this thread for waging the Culture War. Examples of waging the Culture War:
-
Shaming.
-
Attempting to 'build consensus' or enforce ideological conformity.
-
Making sweeping generalizations to vilify a group you dislike.
-
Recruiting for a cause.
-
Posting links that could be summarized as 'Boo outgroup!' Basically, if your content is 'Can you believe what Those People did this week?' then you should either refrain from posting, or do some very patient work to contextualize and/or steel-man the relevant viewpoint.
In general, you should argue to understand, not to win. This thread is not territory to be claimed by one group or another; indeed, the aim is to have many different viewpoints represented here. Thus, we also ask that you follow some guidelines:
-
Speak plainly. Avoid sarcasm and mockery. When disagreeing with someone, state your objections explicitly.
-
Be as precise and charitable as you can. Don't paraphrase unflatteringly.
-
Don't imply that someone said something they did not say, even if you think it follows from what they said.
-
Write like everyone is reading and you want them to be included in the discussion.
On an ad hoc basis, the mods will try to compile a list of the best posts/comments from the previous week, posted in Quality Contribution threads and archived at /r/TheThread. You may nominate a comment for this list by clicking on 'report' at the bottom of the post and typing 'Actually a quality contribution' as the report reason.

Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Notes -
The Jensen Huang saga rumbles on. Now it looks like he's trying to pull a Sam Altman:
Two questions I have here. One, do people think this will succeed or will the board hold firm? Two, what exactly is meant by "outside the frontier labs"? Does that mean that the cutting-edge AI crowd don't like Jensen? Is there a hint that they are trying to do him down? If so, why?
The problem remains that if Alice Huang was one where she was a spy, that means it wasn't just an affair, it was getting the company entangled in matters above their paygrade. If she wasn't, then we have two (maybe three) instances in which he can't keep it in his trousers. Sleeping around (allegedly) with two Nvidia subordinates raises questions as to his judgement and how workplace romances interfere with the smooth running of the business, as people will be jealous, people will gossip, there will be perceptions of unfairly favourable treatment, there has to be an investigation into was there unfairly favourable treatment, and if the ladies decide to try and salvage their careers, sexual harassment cases. As far as Nvidia is concerned, a few tens of millions per case is probably pocket change, but it's bad publicity that the company does not need.
The argument for restoring Huang, so far as I can make out, is that he has led Nvidia to be hugely profitable with the pivot to AI and that without his visionary guidance all that momentum will be lost. The argument for booting him out, so far as I can make out, is that his judgement has been revealed to be suspect, he can be led around by his dick and his vanity (if those are not one and the same), and that hugely profitable pivot might in fact rest on poor financial decisions that possibly could come back to bite them, despite the rosy aspect put forth for the upcoming earnings call.
Not caring about the personal ethics of elites is degenerate behavior and the tech right makes itself look repulsive when it loudly does so in Jensen’s defense.
In voter polls in the midterms, one of the biggest actually reported reasons for the swing wasn’t inflation or ICE or the Iran War, it was “corruption” ie venality. In fact, in most polls it was the second or third most important issue for voters. It’s also why Orban lost, because voters could see every day how absurd it was that his childhood best friends were all billionaires, that his little ancestral village was the richest place in Hungary etc.
Private immoral behavior is unsavory in rulers but ultimately acceptable. But public degeneracy (whether it is paraded loudly or revealed by the press) is an anchor on support, if not immediately then eventually. Even Trump, history’s great survivor, has been weighed down by it now. That grotesque case of that Biden administration official arrested for stealing women’s clothes at an airport (multiple times, I think), and the wider trans issue which provokes a certain reaction in many people, no doubt contributed seriously to the 2024 result.
I really have no problem with people who cheat on their spouse losing their job. Doesn’t the US military have the same policy?
Caring about the personal ethics of people you see on TV is parasocial behavior. Jensen Huang cheats on wife, user 2rafa hardest hit?
Why do you think you get a vote? Tech companies have to cater to your sense of ethics? One of the great virtues of capitalism has been the opposite, actually -- that the productive and artistic and great are given power beyond the ability of prudes to veto them. Or else, why stop with Jensen Huang? Peter Thiel and Sam Altman are degenerate gays, Elon Musk is fathering children out of wedlock, Jeff Bezos and Bill Gates are philanderers, do we need to take their jobs?
Well, the important thing about Jensen Huang cheating on his wife is that we found a way where it's somehow Republican's fault. Did Republicans lose the midterms because of their weak stance on no-fault divorce?
I think this is a silly point to make. Jensen Huang is a part of our larger social fabric. His actions affect us, and though the effect is more diffuse, our actions can affect him.
I'm reminded of Plutarch's anecdote about Aristides the Just. The Athenians would hold a vote each year deciding which politician to ostracize, exiling them for 10 years, and one year an illiterate farmer unknowingly asked Aristides to carve "Aristides" onto a pottery shard so he could cast his vote to ostracize him. Aristides asked the farmer if he had ever been wronged by Aristides, and the farmer replied that he had never even met the guy, but he was tired of hearing him called "Aristides the Just" everywhere. Without revealing his identity or arguing, Aristides just carved his own name into the shard and handed it back to the farmer.
While the anecdote is mostly about Aristides living up to his epithet, I think it also shows a way in which parasocial behavior can cross over into action that affects real people. Even before TV or the internet, people's lives were affected by politicians and businessmen who they might never meet, and people felt the need to intervene through the ordinary political and social process to the extent that they could.
I mean, people voted with their dollars. The stock market gave people the ability to say how they felt about the situation and its effect on the company and its shareholders.
More options
Context Copy link
By that reasoning we shouldn't care about murder either. I mean, yeah, I think murder is unethical, but we're not supposed to stop people from doing unethical things, right? Why should I get a vote on whether you can murder?
(And if you say 'murder affects unwilling people', so does betraying your country for profit.)
Have you been jacking off to porn? Said the r-slur? Had a girl say you raped her? This is highly unethical, as everybody knows, and society cannot allow you to continue working if you engage in unethical behavior.
Oh, you want me to make an exception for you? I can’t do that without logically condoning murder. So we have to condemn Jensen Huang, he had an affair.
The answer to your point is easy to make within the virtue ethics tradition.
A person's actions are downstream of their character. If a person has spent a lifetime building habits of personal moral excellence and turned themselves into a paragon of virtue, they won't succumb to temptation when presented with opportunities to cheat or engage in dirty dealing for personal gain.
In the Renaissance tradition that built on Aristotle's politics, there is an idea that the character of rulers and public figures is more important than the character of ordinary people, because the ruling class sets the tone for the rest of society. If the ruling class behaves as aristocrats in the original sense of the term, embodying the best traits of humanity, then the masses will benefit from it in countless ways. If the ruling class behaves as self-serving oligarchs only concerned with their own benefit, then the rest of society will suffer as a result.
On this view, it does matter if Jiro does any of the bad things you mentioned, but it matters far more what the moral character of Jensen Huang is like, and the three affairs gave us our answer.
I agree with this up to a point, but it’s also clear that anyone can be tempted at any time. Who’s to say you wouldn’t cheat on your wife? You haven’t had the opportunities that Jensen has.
We don’t pick tech CEOs for their moral virtue. “We” don’t even pick tech CEOs at all. They generally pick themselves because it is extremely hard to do what Jensen Huang did and build a successful company. You and I are just watching this on TV. But the option is always there for you to try and join the ruling class yourself.
The answer is that the object level is actually important.
We should not have have a principle "we don't get a vote on other people's actions"; neither should we have a principle "we always get a vote on other people's actions". We have to determine it case by case without appealing to general principles like that.
If you ask me "what if you jacked off to porn, should someone get a vote on that" the answer is "no, becase jacking off to porn is not very serious". The answer is not "no, because people never get a vote on the actions of others". Sometimes they do and sometimes they don't--it doesn't generalize.
More options
Context Copy link
Honestly, I'd rather be a Cleanthes or a Diogenes than an Alexander or a Plato.
Though I fall far short of both Cleanthes and Diogenes. I usually settle for being myself but a little bit better than the day before if I can manage it.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Most people aren’t saying that doesn’t make him an asshole. By what standards do CEO’s have an obligation to be a moral paragon to the public? One might say to be a CEO means you’re obliged to do highly unethical shit at some point down the road. That’s distinct from fucking your business partners (I get it.), but it’s not some kind of failing on the same level with embezzling money or engaging in wage theft, unless the more serious charges against him stand up to scrutiny.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
No but they did lose the midterms in part because voters were fed up of the countless examples of personal enrichment and corruption by senior administration figures, their family and friends, as per polling, which falls under the same standards for personal ethics.
In general, it is a bad idea to trust adulterers. If someone cheats on the person they purport to love most, the parent of their children, the person they swear to remain remain faithful to, why are they going to honor the petty handshakes and promises of ordinary commercial or political life?
Perhaps I am. Or at least expropriate more of their property than we do entrepreneurs whose personal morals I agree with. I already advocated for taxing the unmarried and childless more, taxing users of prostitutes and surrogates (both deeply immoral) like most of those you cite more is something I completely agree with.
Capitalism, more than anything, was the one social tech that let us tame the Big Men of history, so that rather than gathering continent-spanning empires by conquest, gathering slave harems and casting leprous corpses across city ramparts, they mostly work to produce widgets that entertain us in return for a small predictable payment. The only concession is that we had to grant them in return was a modicum of tolerance for their eccentricities. Forgetting for a moment that AI doom is imminent anyway, do you really want to cancel the deal?
More prosaically, as old man Moldbug observed, power is always a two-way street. As long as your moral principles have no way of affecting Jensen Huang or Elon Musk, they in turn have no motivation to affect your moral principles. If you start saying Jensen Huang can't have affairs because you find affairs immoral and coordinate with enough people that your view matters, you will find that he will develop an interest in changing your view and smashing your ability to spread it and coordinate with other people who have it. Alarmed at drag queen story hour? How much CEO harem story hour do you think several billions of $ can buy?
Power in our system is a two way street. It isn’t so for other systems. It’s both a blessing and a curse.
On one hand you get some say in what people do with power, on the other hand most people are ill suited to running a company let alone a society. And also getting a say means that you open the door to the government running your life. If we had a system where no voice existed for us plebs, I don’t think they’d be interested in using power against us. Propaganda in dictatorships is easily ignored and doesn’t affect much of the cultural life of the people. In democracy, every organ must be turned to the propaganda of the elite.
The 20th century totalitarian states argue rather strongly against this.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Jensen Huang could have maintained a harem if he wanted to look at Elon Musk, or Leonardo Decaprio or Charlie Sheen。 He's in trouble for fucking enemy agents circumventing export laws and fucking subordinates. That last one being a rule at a company he founded and controlled the rules of.
Also your history is just straight ideology, CEOs are not what stopped wars what stopped wars was the cost of modern warfare nukes and aggression becoming less culturally acceptable. We had continent spanning empires well into the time of capitalism, and Europeans even managed to corporatize it with organizations like the East India company.
Pre-capitalism things were a lot more stagnant yes there were great men who carved out empires but in general things like this were done after the collapse of a dynasty. There's far more stagnation and less meritocracy in many places almost unheard of for commoners to rise to the upper classes and in places where they did this was usually though combat which is an entirely different skillset than entrepreneurship.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Jensen Huang isn’t elite because he passed the 2rafa morality test. There was no election. He didn’t ascend the cursus honorum. Nobody in the general public had even heard of this guy until Nvidia’s stock surge in 2023 made it valuable. That is, he didn’t rise because of a formal process that you can veto. He rose in fact through a system that does not ask for your approval and in fact could not exist if it did.
What would happen if we applied this standard backwards in history? I think it’s fair to ask:
Alan Turing was a homosexual who committed sexual acts with young boys. Is it good that he was prosecuted, stripped of his security clearance, and ultimately driven out?
Weather Von Braun was the chief architect of Saturn V. Should he have been? Do you agree with giving Nazis power and influence?
Oppenheimer hung out with Communists and carried on affairs: would you have put him in charge of the Manhattan Project?
Jeff Bezos and Bill Gates have committed very public affairs, at what point would you have taken their companies from them?
I've been over this before on the motte and thought he had an adult man fetish, not children. Severe misremembering on my part?
A quick googling re-confirms his youngest partner was 19. That matches my memories of people saying he fucked teens, sneakily implying he raped children rather than almost 20 year olds.
He sponsored a Jewish refugee, Bob Augenfeld, and later propositioned him at 16. Bob rebuffed him, though.
There's also a young Norweigan man, Kjell Carlson, who he had a "very light kiss beneath a foreign flag under the influence of drink". No idea as to the age of this "young man", though: as Turing was 40 at the time he could easily have been in his twenties.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
You're cherrypicking examples. I can think of people to whom applying this standard would have made us better off.
Besides, this is an example of concentrated cost versus diffuse benefit, and in this case the benefit being diffuse makes it harder to see. I would expect that consistently applying this test would
As for Bezos and Gates, I don't think that infidelity by itself is evil enough that we should punish people for it using the law. If Bezos and Gates had affairs with spies, though, their companies should be punished by enough that it would undo the damage a spy is likely to cause, taking into account that you will not discover all the damage that a spy actually causes.
And we'd gain from getting rid of Gates even if he didn't have any affairs. I could even argue that Gates' predatory anti-consumer practices and his affairs stem from the same lack of empathy towards the people he harms, and are therefore related.
Also, yes I am, but isn’t that the point of examples? If you can name some leaders society would have been better throwing out over moral reasons I would be interested to hear the counter-case. That is, business leaders or tech CEOs or something equivalent, not merely political leaders who had scandals.
More options
Context Copy link
The spy thing is a deeper wrinkle that requires some more nuance here — although again I would point out that now the news is saying we’re not really sure if she was a spy or not. But I’m not trying to make this about the spy as such: I want to reject the argument that we get some kind of moral busybody veto on who gets to be a tech CEO.
I mean, well, we already do have such a veto, it’s the law, and we elect representatives to decide it. I would be fine with Jensen Huang being punished if he killed a kid because that’s illegal, everybody knew that going in. If people think he should be punished for having an affair, we have mechanisms for that, someone can campaign on putting people in jail for cheating on a spouse. Nobody seems to be saying that though.
You could campaign on penalizing companies for having the CEO date a spy. If he gets lucky and doesn't cheat with any spies, then nothing happens, but if he cheats he does assume the risk that one of the people he cheats on is a spy.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Yeah but definitions of 'evil' vary wildly between generations and plenty of people with 'good' intentions create massive second-order effects.
Also it's consensual extramarital affairs, most likely with atleast implicit acceptance from Jensen's wife. Who cares.
I might agree to that if 1) the woman wasn't a spy and 2) otherwise accepted conflict of interest/nepotism rules were followed for both women.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Do you happen to have a source for this? I'm curious because the AI vehemently denied it. (I assume that by "young boys" you mean boys who were under 18.)
That being said, I agree that this is an area where the perfect can be the enemy of the good.
Maybe I’m being imprecise. Arnold Murray was apparently 19 when they met — Turing would have been about 39. I would have guessed he’d had relations with someone 16-17 but perhaps I’m confusing him with someone else — it’s fairly common in gayworld.
Maybe this makes a better argument anyways: you can’t impose a Neo-Puritan moral sex code on the tech CEOs when we made it up five minutes ago. Look at Alan Turing, his life was ruined over what today would be totally unobjectionable.
Except we didn't make it up 5 minutes ago -- @porkpiehat has it right. You can do anything you want sexually as long as it isn't heterosexual sex engaged in as a man -- THAT has to be done according to strict standards.
Which, if you don't like that code, is certainly reason to oppose it. But it's not novel.
I don't think porkpiehat or you have this right.
When one of my aunts cheated on her husband, it was treated about the same as when one of my uncles cheated on his wife. Both were condemned for their actions by the rest of the family.
If fewer women CEOs get ousted over affairs, I would chalk it up to a combination of there being fewer women CEOs, and women cheating less and cheating in different ways than men. But it seems silly to me to pretend that nobody cares about female sexual conduct in our society. Like, wasn't one major part of Gamergate a scandal around a female indie dev who slept around?
Honestly, this whole thing comes across as a bit of a bravery debate.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Yeah, although the joke of it is that we are drifting into a situation where an adult man getting with a 19 year old woman is becoming more and more objectionable. I wonder what would happen if it came out that Huang had had a 19 year old mistress who was just a barista at the local coffee shop and not associated with any foreign interests.
I mean, probably the same nothing that happened to Leonardo DiCaprio. Sure people make fun of him for not dating above a certain age, but I think a lot of it is grounded in envy more than real disgust. And either way, the moral condemnation and posturing doesn't actually stop DiCaprio from snatching up a new pretty young thing when the old one gets past her sell-by date.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
One of the interesting things about my own security clearance is that we were, in fact, required to report any sort of sexual misconduct, affairs, etc., etc. I think within 3 days of it happening. Not because the government cared about the morality of it, hell no. But because it's a vulnerability, that could result in pressure to reveal secrets. They'd actually be much more concerned about it remaining hidden than if we had it out in the open.
Of course, we also had reporting requirements for contact with foreign nationals, especially emotional or physical relationships with foreign nationals, and the usual HR "clients/subcontractors/subordinates" clauses as well. But we were a bit more secure and USA-limited secrets than just chips for AI.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
If they hadn’t governed poorly, the economy was rocking, they and didn’t do tariffs or Iran, I don’t think people would have cared about the corruption that much.
Probably true, judging by Trump I, but not particularly reassuring.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Republicans lost the midterms because their braindead conspiracy theories backfired on them while they were campaigning on incredibly controversial and toxic culture wars stances while gas and beef prices were high at the same time.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link