A weekly thread to discuss financial matters - from personal all the way up to global.
Ground Rules
- Remember that we're all just Internet randos. Don't bet your life savings on a hot tip from this thread.
- Keep culture war in the culture war thread. Yes, global events may impact our personal finances, but that does not mean we have to incessantly harp on culture war aspects here. If you are going to discuss it, please stick to the practical impacts of it on an individual level.
- Be kind. Remember that everyone here comes from different circumstances. We all have different resources available and different risk tolerances.
- Don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good. Better is better. Celebrate people when they take a step up and work to move their finances in the right direction. Don't flame out because they haven't followed what you consider the optimal path. Everybody has to start somewhere.

Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Notes -
Google was down bigly today so I loaded the boat. I think their quarter was actually pretty good, with cloud revenue up 100% year over year!! The headline earnings miss was mostly because of a reduction in the value of their SpaceX holdings.
Their AI offering is supposedly at the frontier now as well, but no one cares because it's buried beyond Google's clumsy interface.
I guess I like this investment because there are a few outs.
If there is a snapback rally, I'll just book my win.
If Sundar gets fired (and he should) stock will shoot up a lot. 5-10% odds in next 12 months.
They somehow fix their AI messaging
As cloud revenue grows to be a larger percentage of overall revenue, Google's revenue growth will reaccelerate
Google is so ripe for layoffs it's ridiculous
Happy to hold this for a few months.
Why do you say that?
Incoherent AI strategy. They have this supposedly great AI product and no one can figure out how to use it. There is zero excitement about their recent frontier release.
Their name should be mentioned in the same breath as OpenAI and Anthropic and the CEO should be maniacally focused on that.
Sundar is imperfect, but there's much more to Google's AI strategy than "Gemini Gemini Gemini!" Cloud is up not because GCS is suddenly surging in popularity, but because ANT and increasingly OAI are giving GCP ungodly piles of money; ripping TPUs away from Core to Cloud was one of Thomas Kurian's masterstrokes. (TK will be Sundar's successor, whenever that happens.)
Who will end up making money from AI is an open question: frontier model developers? The hardware owners? Platforms and enterprise integrations? Google is currently straddling all three, giving it incoherence but also optionality. This means less compute and privileging of GDM, but at least in some worlds that's fine (though I think Google has realized it was under investing for the frontier model dominance scenario).
Three other notes:
I interpret the market response as less to the earnings miss itself and more to lackluster Search. We're finally starting to see the cannibalization of search revenue by AI.
As for layoffs: I've heard through the grapevine a big one is coming in Q1.
The market this week has been really stupid, and within a month or three Google will have a substantial recovery. (I console myself over a solidly six figure loss in a single day.)
Yes, and Anthopic's S1 revealed they have like $120 billion in cash with presumably another $100 billion or so raised during the IPO. So there is a clear path forward for more Google Cloud growth.
I take your point about Google maintaining optionality. And clearly their TPU initiative has been a roaring success. But I also think they are dropping the ball on their frontier product big time. Given all their advantages, Google should have been where Anthropic and OpenAI are now.
Incredibly, search revenue was actually up 12% year over year with queries up 17% even as more sophisticated users barely use it anymore.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Futes are fake.
I was tempted to throw some money into Kalshi on Paxton in Texas, Rogers in Michigan, and (as a Hail Mary) Vivek in Ohio. These markets are wacked out and make no sense.
Then I read about the IRS rules for this stuff. It's brutal. The prediction markets do NOT give you tax documents. Instead they say "you figure it out".
So, if you want, you can claim winnings as capital gains and you might get audited. To be safe, you can claim them as gambling winnings, which means fully taxable winnings and (importantly) you can only deduct 90% of losses, and they can ONLY offset winnings.
This makes betting in prediction markets a suckers bet. And that's why they are extremely thinly traded and not efficient.
I would guess the vast majority of people do not earn enough , given thin liquidity, losses, and tiny trade size, to ever be at risk of an audit.
Yeah, but it’s also not worth it for me to deal with the headache to win $1000 or whatever on a Paxton mispricing. Even getting a letter from the IRS or filing an extra form kills any alpha to me. I’d do it for 100k but these markets are so thinly traded that’s not possible.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Success story/total brag/I'm an asshole:
I got a somewhat panicked call from my broker about 3 weeks ago. He periodically (like every 3 years or so) goes through the accounts of the people he serves with a fine-toothed comb to see if there are diversification issues and noticed boy did I have a shitload of money tied up in Nvidia. This was total serendipity, luck, and completely careless financial negligence on my part.
In mid-2017 my beloved aunt died and left me 200k that I was not expecting. She had two kids, one with kids of her own who aren't exactly doing well, so I figured maybe she'd give me a token amount for old time's sake not big money. Apparently, though, my mom and her sisters are/were extraordinarily frugal investors; my other aunt died this year and she left behind 4 million to my mom and two cousins on a college admin's salary. Mentally, I treated it as monopoly money so I figured I'd build a gaming PC and put the rest in my kids' college fund. In the process of researching parts I thought the graphics cards were imo too pricy and the buzz on reddit was that cryptomining was fucking up the market. So I took a risk betting on crypto and told my broker to put 100k in Nvidia ("...are you sure wsgy?" "yeah I got a feeling") and took what was left and bought bitcoin in 4 instalments in the last 4 months of 2017. I printed out my wallet number and stashed it in our safety deposit box at the bank. I largely, but not completely, forgot about both of these investments because I am an idiot, but again, my mindset was "monopoly money".
So yeah the two of those put together as of last week was like 5.5 million dollarydoos and I sold the bitcoins, almost all of the Nvidia, bought 1.3 mil in T-bills (anticipating that would be my cap gains taxes this year) and put the rest in an S&P 500 index fund, and then took my wife out for champagne and oysters to tell her after everything was stitched up.
I'm on the threshold of being a 1%er now. I'm done putting money in the kids' education funds. If the 4 of them go to 4 years of private high school, 4 years of private university, and 4 years of private medical school (though that last one isn't likely to happen), we'll still have money left over for each of them to take a gap year to find themselves in Thailand. All the better since the oldest kid is 10. My in-laws (who are loaded) have said they will keep sending us 15k checks per kid for their college accounts and hell I don't think that's necessary anymore. We're at a point where there's too much money.
I feel guilty about this. We're financially secure enough that I can just drop 200k on some insanely risky investments and not think about it, meanwhile tons of people are living paycheck to paycheck. I guess I could have lost all of it fairly easily but man it does seem like the universe is extraordinarily unfair.
It's amazing how those huge investment successes still doesn't put you in the top 1%. It's like there is a lot of hidden wealth in the US.
""When I think of a really rich man," says a Boston blue-collar, "I think of one of those estates where you can't see the house from the road." Hence the name of the top class, which could just as well be called "the class in hiding." Their houses are never seen from the street or road. They like to hide away deep in the hills or way off on Greek or Caribbean islands (which they tend to own), safe, for the moment, from envy and its ultimate attendants, confiscatory taxation and finally expropriation. It was the Great Depression, Vance Packard speculates, that badly frightened the very rich, teaching them to be "discreet, almost reticent, in exhibiting their wealth." From the 1930s dates the flight of money from such exhibitionistic venues as the mansions of upper Fifth Avenue to hideways in Virginia, upper New York State, Connecticut, Long Island, and New Jersey. The situation now is very different from the one in the 1890s satirized by Thorstein Veblen in The Theory of the Leisure Class. In his day the rich delighted to exhibit themselves conspicuously, with costly retainers and attendants much in evidence. Now they hide, not merely from envy and revenge but from expose journalism, much advanced in cunning and ferocity since Veblen's time, and from an even worse threat, virtually unknown to Veblen, foundation mendicancy, with its hordes of beggars in threepiece suits constantly badgering the well-to-do. Showing off used to be the main satisfaction of being very rich in America. Now the rich must skulk and hide."
Paul Fussell, "Class: A Guide through the American Status System", 1983
I wonder how much of this is ignoring the effect of changing crime rates. The NYC homicide rate nearly doubled during the Great Depression, and although it came down again, any families scared out of their Fifth Avenue mansions could have felt pretty smug when homicide nearly quintupled in the 60s.
Other crimes you might have wanted to hide from, if you could afford it:
"Efforts to address the increase in prostitution, especially by juveniles, were derailed by the arrival of crack cocaine to Times Square in 1986. As a result, crime rates spiked and continued to increase through 1989. The addictiveness of crack made it an especially insidious drug, as users focused their energy and resources on scoring the next ‘hit’. Crack dealers, junkies, and the cardboard encampments of the homeless took over the streets."
(from the Times Square Official Website - imagine how an anti-NYC-biased description looks!)
I also wonder how much of Fussell's analysis has now been obsoleted by further changing crime rates. NYC homicide rates plummeted rapidly, back to "at least no worse than the Great Depression" levels, in the 90s, and then dropped back to the previous baseline in the 2010s. I've never been acquainted with more than a couple high-paid New Yorkers, but I get the impression that having a second home out in the countryside is now just a way to better enjoy days off with the kids, not a desperate attempt to hide wealth out of sight.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
You got lucky. Enjoy it. Nothing to feel guilty about. You owe "tons of people" nothing, take care of your family and let everybody else take care of their own business. Give to some charity if you are so inclined (but you don't owe that too, it's just what some people feel good about doing).
More options
Context Copy link
You took the risk, you should get to enjoy the rewards.
Don't feel guilty. $5.5 million is not really all that much in the scheme of things. I regret to inform you that you're not all that close to the 1%, which is $16.5 million as of 2025. America is a ridiculously wealthy country.
Also, five is a nightmare. https://youtube.com/watch?v=m0sRrsara9c
"To be in the top 1% of American households by net worth, a household needs a minimum net worth of approximately $16,463,320. "
this is the most insane statistic ever. It's like , no this is more crazy than quantum mechanics.
I’ve been noticing a lot more people just don’t work in the upper class and it’s stretchy now. It’s like all our tech companies need Indian CEO’s because all the white guys retired at 25 whose dads would have been captains of industry.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Unless you for some reason live in an insanely expensive area or have to maintain extremely luxurious lifestyle, $5M+ is "never have to work again unless you want to" kind of money even in the US now. Of course, it's not "never can't spend it all" money - if you live too large, it's pretty easy to get through it, but if you lead a modest middle class lifetime, it should be enough.
divorce and kids can easily whittle that to a 1-2 million
Yeah sure, that's like the joke goes: "Can a woman make a man a millionaire? - Sure, if he's a billionaire!".
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
5.5m though is definitely post-economic unless you decide to live in San Fran or NYC. The main reason to live in those cities is to make money. Once you have money there are plenty of ways to live that avoid the high lifestyle expenses of those cities.
If you want to live even in Palm Beach maybe not in proper Palm you can find options. A friend just showed me a condo for 700k with 1500 sq ft that has a buyout offer at 1.75m from a developer for redevelopment. So far the HOA has said no (need 95% yes). Point is once your out of those cities you can find options in close enough to high IQ places where your home isn’t 5m.
Oh yeah, 5 million is a lot. It's rich. You're in the top 0.1% worldwide and 0.01% of people who have ever lived.
But...
We are in the richest country that has ever existed. If you start comparing yourself to the Jones's then $5 million feels very small of a sudden. In the U.S. alone, there are about 5 million households with a net worth above $5 million. And they are everywhere. Some guy in Kansas sells his insurance brokerage in 1996 for $3 million, puts it in stocks, and now he's worth $52 million. That sort of thing.
Rich people have weddings that cost 5 million dollars.
In terms of "median net worth by individual," it's not so bad. Outliers inflate the mean.
Median Net Worth by Age Group
• Under 35: $33,000
• 35 to 44: $135,000
• 45 to 54: $247,000
• 55 to 64: $365,000
• 65 to 74: $410,000
• 75 and older: $504,000
I get that this is kind of hiding a couple of things, but this is kind of just "why TFR is rock-bottom" in microcosm.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Prospering you is not to blame for my living paycheck to paycheck. No need for guilt.
More options
Context Copy link
Congratulations! That's great.
I myself have a comfortable net worth, but I'm older than most users here and all of my children are adults (albeit still settling into stable adulthood). Most of my assets are my home and my retirement accounts--though I don't have any particular reason to ever retire (teaching college is easy money, just not very much of it). I've missed a lot of investment gains by being a nervous and conservative investor, but I've also missed a lot of losses. On average I've beaten the S&P 500 by a modest margin basically every year for the last several decades.
I've never had a success story as good as yours, but like you I often wonder about the "fairness" of such things. I'm not a 1%er but I'm a comfortable 15%er in the USA, human life honestly just doesn't get much better than that (at current tech levels). What amazes me is how precarious it often feels anyway. Over the course of my life I've seen a bad health diagnosis, a freak accident, or a series of bad or even just unlucky decisions completely wipe out the accumulated wealth of many people far better off than I am.
Ultimately, fair or not, the only person who can live your life is you. So, enjoy it while it lasts--and best wishes on having it last a long, long time.
More options
Context Copy link
Cheers, mate! Sometimes those hunches pay off!
More options
Context Copy link
Congrats! Consider whole life for you and the Mrs. and VUL for the kiddos, and you'll probably have generational wealth locked up as well.
You're gonna have a pretty crazy tax bill as well with selling the crypto and Nvidia
Congrats!
More options
Context Copy link
I'm going to go ahead and doubt this, but you could always give 100k to a charity you find deserving. Anyway, congrats and I'll do my best to not plot murder while I'm at my shitty public defender job tomorrow.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Apparently, the average cost of a health insurance plan for a family of four in the United States is now $28k. When I was shopping last year, unsubsidized Obamacare was in that price range. Gallingly, the plans still come with large deductibles that must be met before insurance pays for anything.
So we simply canceled our health plan. Now we're raw-dogging it and have saved probably $20k this year. Might join again for 2027 for anticipated maternity bills.
It feels good not to be subsidizing the bad life choices of others.
Remember how Obamacare originally fined people for not buying insurance because obviously people wouldn't pay outrageous rates to subsidize other people unless they were forced to? Well, there is no mandate anymore. Why are people still buying insurance?
Hospital stays are hugely expensive. Some drugs are ruinously expensive (to the tune of tens of thousands of dollars per month, at least at the official price). If you got a condition where you need one of those to survive, you have no choice. If you're healthy and foresee staying healthy for a year, and don't do any risky activities - like skiing, hiking, running, driving, etc. - sure, play that game. As your odometer picks up miles, this becomes more and more risky game.
Yes, the whole system is horrendously broken and becomes more broken each year. Nobody is capable of fixing it, and every half-assed attempt to do it makes it much worse. A lot of people make money on the chaos in the meantime though. So it's going to continue this way.
That's one risky activity, one normal activity, and two activities that indicate a much lower health risk than normal.
At $28,000/year, unsubsidized Obamacare is such a crappy deal that it's like having a serious health event every year. Who is even paying that? I feel like everyone here just has employer insurance and doesn't feel the pain.
I get the tail risk argument, but at some point the premiums are so high there is no point. What's the limiting principle. Would you pay $50k for health insurance? $100k? At what price would you argue that someone shouldn't buy it?
That is indeed the preferred mode. Obamacare plans were bolted on existing system for people that can not afford paying insurance, so "unsubsidized Obamacare plan" is a red-headed child of the system, nobody really is trying to make it workable because most people go either employer or subsidized.
There's certainly a point, which depends on your private risk assessment and risk tolerance. I have employer's insurance, and it's the best deal available for me, it'd be stupid not to use it. But if I couldn't use it I would have quite shitty options indeed before me.
It's one of the big reasons why I'm not seriously looking into consulting, even if I reach a point where I'd be mostly able to retire early.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Good move, imho. Hospitals offer tons of discounts if you pay upfront and you can negotiate to lower the bill.
I'm not sure you'd be in a mood for negotiation arriving at emergency room at 3am with an acute condition. You'll probably go to the closest hospital and sign everything they ask you to. And then the bills will come. If you are judgment proof, you're in luck. If you have a comfortable middle-class life, which means having assets that can be targeted, there's a whole industry aimed at of separating you from those assets. Very big risk, IMHO.
You don't negotiate during the emergency. You negotiate afterwards when they send you the bill. Don't mention your assets, downplay your income as much as possible, threaten to go to bankruptcy, and see what they will let you get away with.
Admittedly, I'm working class rather than middle class, but it worked out pretty well for me. I got hit with a $40,000 bill for a hospital stay and I was like "lol, lmao even". It took months of negotiations and applying for financial aid, but I got it down to $600.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I really don't recommend this. If you are rich then you are likely advancing in age and therefore inevitable comorbidity. If you have kids they can have complications. Also, if you are rich they will make you pay if something expensive happens.
Maybe you get cancer. Maybe you get T-boned at an intersection by someone running a red light and then you end up in an ICU for 4 weeks followed by another 6 weeks of various step down care and end up with a 450k medical bill. Which they will make you pay if you can pay.
If a half a mill in medical debt doesn't make you blink then you can afford to just pay for the health insurance.
It's just not a good bet. Sure, you will probably be fine, but the level of catastrophe that can happen is immense, and just assuming it will never happen to you is not wise.
You can negotiate this much lower, and lots of discounts if you pay with cash. Even with insurance, people report being denied or incomplete coverage. Refusal to pay medical bills is not as bad as it sounds and it's not like they can take your property (homestead laws apply).
You can but they don't have to do that, and if you have a lot to lose and can actually afford to pay that can become a problem.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Paying 30k for 10k worth of insurance is not something I’m interested in doing.
If I get T-boned I’ll happily pay the 450k but I’ll also make sure I don’t pay more than I would owe in a just system. I’ll pay my fair share but I won’t pay their phony rack rates. Since I’ll be paying cash I’d expect a lower rate than an insured patient.
Mostly I don’t want to participate in a corrupt system.
If you have 450k and dropping 450k is financially survivable for you, then fine, roll the dice. Note though they have literally hundreds if not thousands of people that make a living on getting maximum amount of money from people like you, and they have decades of experience and they paid for all the laws and procedures to be arranged to maximize their gain. They probably won't be able to take your home if you own it, and 100% of your income, but they have a lot of experience of making the lives of people like you unpleasant. Unless you have a lot of experience waging war on the other side, it may not go well for you. There are people who are good at handling such things, and milk the system for years while getting away with outrageous behavior - the question is whether you think you can be one of those people.
There's no other system. Unless you forgo the medical care completely, your only choice is how, not whether you will participate.
Sure there is. The other day I paid $125 in cash to have a couple of moles removed. At no point was a third party involved between me and the care provider.
Ok, yes, for small-time stuff there is. For something like surgery or long-term treatment or complicated condition there's only one system. Sure, you can pay out of pocket for everything and deal with all the billing systems by yourself, but the doctors and the hospitals and the pharmacies will still be part of the same system.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
This is true to some extent, but it's mostly about an ability to pay. If you can afford to pay you will pay.
With respect to injustice and a corrupt system, you'll be using insurance (ex: Medicare) when you are older, not self-insuring. That's what you are supposed to be subsidizing now. That would make you the corruption you are complaining about.
Do hospitals actually have the investigative power to go find your accounts and know if you have money? This sounds highly doubtful since the majority of uninsured probably don’t have money.
The hospital doesn't do it. they would likely outsource it to a debt collection agency, assuming it ever got that far. Because it's a service, like student loan debt, it cannot be repossessed . This means trying to garnish wages, and courts can block this. Medical debt is like delinquent student loans: a long drawn out legal process that works to the debtor's favor, and lots of wiggle room. The best bet is to negotiate as much as possible and pay as little as you can, but do not ignore the bill.
They can't collect. It won't go on your credit. And you have the legal right to tell them to stop harassing you.
For the record, I don't recommend doing this since it's morally wrong. I would pay the hospital a fair price far before it ever got to this.
If it goes to collections and is substantial (over $500), it will. There are grace periods but eventually, if you don't pay, it will end up in collections, and on your credit report - unless you convince the owner to drop it (which they have no incentive to do unless you pay at least part of it). Once it's there, it stays there for 7 years (or until you pay).
More options
Context Copy link
If they can’t collect and you don’t take a credit hit there’s zero incentive to pay. I 100% recommend doing this, contra your point about ethics. I’m selfish. I’ll own it.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
My knowledge of this is less intimate than I'd like because most of my career involves decreasing autonomy and the hospital does shit in the background with little involvement from me, but it's usually pretty obvious that someone can't pay. You can ask for a payment plan or pretend to be homeless or whatever but you have to convince them if they are going to adjust.
As others note the amount they charge the insurance company isn't going to be the same amount they charge you (or the insurance company pays) but that's only mostly. Private equity run physician groups will be aggressive about seeking professional charges even if you are homeless or other similar things can pop up. The hospital can refuse to negotiate and does do that.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Is that really true? My impression is more like "the bill will eventually be sold to collectors for pennies on the dollar and then you can bargain with them to pay a few more pennies than they paid and it all goes away." Why is that wrong?
Even that's too optimistic. Apparently, you can pay them zero and they have to stop harassing you.
More options
Context Copy link
They can reduce the bill but they don't have to, and even if it goes to a debt collecting agency thats going to show up on your credit etc. which if you are a person of wealth can be a problem.
It seems like it's only a problem if you aren't a person of wealth. I have good credit, but unless I'm planning on buying a house I can't see it mattering in the near future.
More options
Context Copy link
It's not allowed to go on your credit and as a rich person I have zero need of credit anyway.
Again, it's wrong to not pay and I would never recommend doing that, but the hospital has zero leverage.
I believe it does affect your credit once it goes to collections.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
This strategy for dealing with healthcare was has been on Twitter for a while. If people here are talking about dropping health insurance then a spiral on Obamacare seems well underway. The only people that should have insurance are already sick and if the risks pool is 4 sick people for every healthy person than obviously the healthy person is paying way more than the benefit they get.
Yes, and I view it as a personal service to help accelerate the collapse of Obamacare. It's pretty much the only thing I'm an accelerationist about.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Just get term life insurance and tell them to pull the plug
Better yet, kick the plug out of the wall and claim it was an accident.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
There's also tail-end risk. A cancer diagnosis, serious injury, major chronic illness, pregnancy, etc can easily hit five or ten times the cost of that annual premium, and over a longer time frame the chances of something popping up gets bad enough to think about. The math's a lot harder to figure out now that most medical debt can't go to your credit score, but it's not a trivial thing, either.
yeah, but you can negotiate much lower if you pay cash or default on medical debts. so this changes the math materially .
More options
Context Copy link
You can sign up for a plan during the enrollment period any time you want. You can also sign up after qualifying life events such as the birth of a new baby. (Would be interesting to see how much of the maternity bills you could foist on the insurer if you signed up the second the baby popped out).
Clearly, if you are healthy, the cost of unsubsidized insurance is much greater than the anticipated benefit. How much greater is it? 2x? 5x? When you take all the money you saved for several years, the chance of a health event exceeding that amount starts to get really small.
For me, I'm fortunately rich so I can easily cover any bill that will occur. Since I don't have any need of an insurance product, it just comes down to a simple cost-benefit calculation.
But for people who aren't rich there are other options like negotiating down your bill or simply (as you hinted) not paying. I heard of one case where a person with a 150k medical bill ended up paying 3k.
This all feels wrong and scary, and I get why people are too scared to do this. But at some point, are you really going to spend 20% of your post-tax income on a medical plan that is DESIGNED to be inferior and force you to subsidize other people? It's preposterous.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Target date funds get a lot of attention in retirement planning, but many financial planners suggest that the recent underperformance of bonds relative to equities make their glide paths too conservative.
What is your opinion on that kind of one stop shop for retirement?
Ignoring the fact that many corporate plans only offer a TDF, they seem like they're great for the average saver who might otherwise choose to do nothing. I've split the difference and contribute to one in my 401(k), but selected a date farther into the future than the one that most closely matches my retirement date.
Like most financial products aimed at retail my quick thought would be they suck and you can do something better easily if you know what you’re doing. They are designed to be sold at scale but with higher fees. It’s for middle class people completely confused with financial markets. Almost everyone here can learn enough about finance to create a better product for themselves. Someone here said they wish they had these with fewer bonds. Honestly I kind of like bonds here, but a better solution that’s not active management for people here is to just do the spy, vti, and Tlt game at lower fees and customize your own ratios.
A financial advisor managing a 45 year old nurse with 300k liquid doesn’t have the time to do everything bespoke and just needs a good-enough product which is far superior than a bank savings account and worse than do it yourself.
That's what I've wound up doing, even though I've been fortunate enough at my past two companies that the ERs for the TDFs were pretty dang low. Not quite as good where I am now, but at my previous company I think the TDF ERs were 0.035% (but at that company the S&P 500 index was 0.006% and their bond index was 0.01%, so... although at that level it's pretty close to just splitting hairs)
Yes. I somewhat hate the good/bad financial product distinction. There’s some stuff that probably is dogshit like Grant Cardonas product, but if some broker needs to hand-hold someone to invent in spy and basic stuff he deserves to get paid. And that client is still better off.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I'm a fan. I personally wish the furthest out had a lower bond allocation than what I've seen (8-10% seems to be the base; I'd appreciate the option of 5 or less), but they're a great default option, the asset mix means they'll never be the worst performer in a list of options which is great for psychological reasons, and for the vast majority of people with 401ks, "don't letter 'better' be the enemy of 'good enough'" really needs to be the philosophy.
If anything, though, recent papers on retirement allocations have me thinking their main problem is at the end of a career, not early (where the limited bond allocation doesn't have too much of an effect). From what I've read (mandatory disclaimer: God Almighty am I not an expert), it's looking like a "bond tent" may be the way to go: that is, after it reaches the conservative retirement allocation, instead of staying flat, the glide path reverses, and starts shifting back to more equities once the worst "sequence of return risk" years are past.
More options
Context Copy link
With the caveat that they are indeed better than nothing, aww Hell no pretty much sums up my opinion on the target date retirement funds. Maybe somewhere there's an organization that has a decent set of them but every time I've looked at them they've been chronic underperformers. I'm skeptical of the entire bond market in general, have been ever since cities going bankrupt became a Thing over a decade ago, so I stick with index funds and I've thrown in a RE fund for funsies.
By definition, they'll always underperform one way or another, won't they (like any asset mix will)? When stocks are on a tear, the bond allocation will hold them back. And if bonds recover (which they might, now that interest rates are higher) and stocks have a crash, they'll underperform a heavier bond allocation. The hope is that they'll have a smoother climb while still having good enough growth for most people.
Indeed they will, and I wouldn't disagree with anything that you're saying in a general sense. Bonds are still, generally speaking, viewed as "safer" than stocks, and in many cases, I expect that they are, and are still a good choice for the more risk averse. For me personally, it always made more sense to go with straight stock indexes simply because they had the best long-term returns, and the only time period in which that was even close to coming into question in my own life was the doldrums of the Great Recession. That's something that I'd probably think long and hard about if I were a younger investor, and there's a good chance that I'll reallocate down the road if/when financial turmoil gets significantly worse. In these Interesting times of inflation and interest rates once again starting to reflect reality, I may well see things differently a few years down the road, but for now, my concerns lie elsewhere.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link