site banner
naraburns  nihil supernum  1yr ago (text post)   29874 thread views

Israel-Gaza Megathread #1

This is a megathread for any posts on the conflict between (so far, and so far as I know) Hamas and the Israeli government, as well as related geopolitics. Culture War thread rules apply.

20
Top Bottom Old Controversial Comments
Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

What's a good anti-tunnel strategy for the Israelis? A few things immediately come to mind:

  1. Blowing them up / collapsing them
  2. Flooding with water
  3. Sealing / flooding with concrete & rubble
  4. Attacking clean air with smoke / toxins
  5. Occupation / patrol / drones / auto turrets

I think the tunnels are the main infrastructure advantage for Hamas, and Israel will need to confront them directly somehow.

Also important to mention that very probably a large number of the hostages brought to Gaza are in those tunnels.

They send robots down the tunnel. When the tunnel is cleared, they map it and blow it all up. There are a few specialized units in the IDF for that.

Rats with GOF-d rabies. I liked the Brad Pitt World War Z more than the book, Yonkers gave me an aneurysm, my brains are eminently vulnerable to hydrostatic shock even if zombies aren't.

It would fit the cycle of escalation seen in the 20s, and serve as a nice palate cleanser alongside getting the aliens watching to suspend disbelief when the Isreal-Palestine conflict ends.

Well, if teaching microorganisms to only attack Islamists fails, I think nerve gas might work, I'm sure there's some variant that rapidly degrades and isn't too lethal unless you're stuck breathing it. Maybe just pump carbon monoxide, and have sensors that detect the leaks where Hamas opens the air holes every now and again.

Or starve them out. Bunker busters. And as someone suggested, flood them.

https://zombie.fandom.com/wiki/Battle_of_Yonkers

It's about the dumbest military conflict I've had the misfortune of reading.

There's no way a bullet to the head would kill those things if their insides being liquified under artillery bombardment wouldn't. Worst case, you drive over them with tanks they can't hurt, and if you keep moving, you're not getting bogged down either.

I just re-learned about rabies, in the last 10 days:

  • if you're symptomatic, you're a dead man walking
  • symptoms take weeks to months to present
  • symptoms include hydrophobia, which is an intense thirst combined with your musculoskeletal system refusing to accept water (via the nervous system)
  • IV fluids for some reason do not ameliorate
  • "foaming at the mouth" is related to increased saliva production combined with an inability to swallow said fluids
  • zombie-like symptoms including an instinct to bite others
  • transmitted primarily via saliva
  • zoonotic reservoirs are mostly bats and rodents, with dogs as the bridge to humans
  • very few canine or human cases in countries like USA
  • a really shit way to go
  • less prevalent but more scary than I thought

There's a reason that even us lazy interns in a government hospital in India didn't fuck around with jabbing our patients who got so much as scratched by a stray cat with their shots. And we chased people who suffered road traffic accidents out onto the streets, as soon as we were reasonably confident they wouldn't die as soon as they left.

If you watch archival footage of the rare cases caught on video, it's a horrible way to go, the only way to ease their passing is to sedate them into oblivion.

I'm glad I've never seen a real case, even India isn't so backward that a normal doctor, even in a rural area, can expect to see one.

Probably the worst thing bats have done for us, COVID notwithstanding.

Do you know why IV fluids fail to hydrate? I am only going off wikipedia here, and maybe errantly...

The short version is that it gives you a very bad brain infection and then you die (encephalomyelitis, if you like). What actually results in death is as usual more complicated than expected but that's the short version.

If you scroll to the "pathophysiology" section of the below article (accessible for me without a login) it should be pretty understandable even without specific training. It also mentions the whole hydrophobia thing.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK448076/

Rhabdoviridae

Interesting, is this related to the rhabdo that Crossfitters get? Rhabdomyalysis? Something to do with kidneys and hydration?

The article is ungated for me, FYI

Rhabdomyolysis is essentially a process where you work out too much and one of the good parts of that (muscles breaking down, which leads to better muscles in the long run) becomes excessive and overwhelms your kidneys. This generally occurs with very excessive workouts like a marathon or people going all in on CrossFit, but in the case of poor kidney function or fitness it can happen with milder activity (and hydration is a component as you mention). Importantly doesn't need to be "exercise" - psych patients who are restrained and on PCP can get it from fighting the restraints, if someone has their arm run over by a truck they might get it. The word is from Greek - "Rhabdo" "Myo" (Muscle) "Lysis" (Breakdown). Rhabdo more generally means "rod" but in this case species "striated muscle" which is the type of muscle we except to be causing Rhabdo by breaking down.

In the case of the rabies it's a rhabdovirus because it's sort of rod shaped, which is a boring but common way of naming shit in medicine. Many bacteria are called "bacilliform" because they are rod shaped (with that being Latin for rod).

It's not something I've thought about, but after looking it up, it seems what kills them isn't a lack of fluid, per se, but pretty much every organ in the body shutting down.

My first thought would be flood 'em but given this is a desert the best solution is probably to ignore them. Forget fighting in Gaza, forget even bothering to bomb Gaza. Instead shut off the water, shut off the electricity, mine the port, and wait.

The siege ends when all hostages have been safely returned and whoever masterminded the attack delivered before the Knesset in chains.

Those have all been cut. Projections are that Gaza runs out of fuel by Wednesday.

The problem is that ends with a humanitarian crisis, Israel as a pariah state, the US (under the next administration, probably) cutting them off, and then the Arabs starting another full scale war against them (also with Iran's backing) with them surviving or not on their own. And maybe some areas of glass desert.

No one, including the democrats, actually cares about Arab lives. For that matter the Arabs don’t care about Arab lives. Israel could get away with killing well north of a million civilians without repercussion beyond the level of a strongly worded note.

No one, including the democrats, actually cares about Arab lives.

To paraphrase Stonetoss, "Arab lives?"

This is all about punishing Israelis, and Arabs are a convenient cudgel. We've seen it hundreds of times before: Israel bombs a mortar site, which was oddly located in an elementary school cafeteria 30 minutes after dropping pamphlets saying in 10 languages, "LEAVE THE SCHOOL WE ARE GOING TO DROP A BOMB." And then they "mysteriously" don't leave (don't mind the gunman at the door), and now a mortar and 20 kids are bombed, yet CNN's cameras can, again "mysteriously" only capture the dead bodies of the kids.

Ben Shapiro also makes the point that they drop "knock bombs" before the real bombs, the only purpose of those bombs is to shake the building to tell civillians to evacuate.

No, they don't care about Arab lives. But they do care about not being seen not caring about Arab lives. So when the anger dies down, they blame Israel for doing what it did, and also for all the sad images and videos they see in their social media feed.

It could end with the Hostages released, and the crisis largely averted.

The Palestinians say they want "self-determination"? I say present them with the opportunity.

Don't merely flood the tunnels, flood the area. Then you don't need to locate the tunnels. You also create a tactical asymmetry for fighters unable to equip themselves with the proper footwear.

High capacity seawater pumps exist: https://www.tobeepump.com/sea-water-pumps/tsh-large-seawater-pump.html

At 14,400 cubic meters per hour, you could flood a football pitch a meter deep in about half an hour.

Downthread /u/bro posted a video from a tunnel expert which would make 1 and 4 infeasible. 2 is probably infeasible because of steel doors. 3 would require finding all the tunnels and 5 would require a risky amount of personnel within drone distance.

https://www.themotte.org/post/705/israelgaza-megathread-1/147199?context=8#context

Related, I think nothing less than total destruction of all known tunnels should be a, if not the, primary strategic objective for Israel. Or at least how they frame it. They can't count on UN support for killing Hamas, but they could probably muster international support for eliminating the tunnels.

In the process, Hamas gets wiped along the way.

Surely the greatest challenge is finding them

Agreed, but once you're in, you should be inside the network. No doubt there are segments and isolated clusters, but all it takes is one entrance per segment.

There are quite a lot of IEDs and booby traps in those tunnels.

Airborne ground penetrating radar.

Not as easy as it sounds, unfortunately. Effective range is rather limited; the last GPR I worked on was humvee-mounted. Finding a steel can 6 inches under the ground might be easier than a rough tunnel.

There are air-mounted magnetic imaging devices that penetrate deep underground and are used in geological surveys. They're helicopter-mounted and able to pick up the depth at which the material of the rock underneath changes composition, so would presumably be able to pick up on the metal used in the tunnels somewhat easily, though I can't guarantee that.

I tried to look into this, but I only found a couple scuffed wiki [pages](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_survey_(archaeology). I’d be really interested if you have any more details.

My experience with it is from working with a mining company that surveyed a rather large area, including our property, looking for mineral deposits. It was a large array, probably around 10'x10', carried by a helicopter, and the results were impressive. Can't remember if they let me keep any copies of the study, but I'll dig and see if I can pull it up as it may have more details. It was definitely considered pretty cutting edge at the time, but it was like 10 years ago. Might have been more of a proprietary secret than I realized at the time.

I thought LIDAR was good at finding underground structures, even in dense urban build-up. Am I imagining this?

Yes, I imagined that. I am big dumb.

I don't see how lasers could penetrate the ground.

You're not using enough power.

...right. I should really think before I post.

I know LIDAR is pretty good at finding recently disturbed soil: cut and cover trenches, landmine holes, fresh backyard graves, etc.
You'd need a pretty good laser to make it work 6' underground though.

It’s not just the tunnels, as tough as those are, it’s also the mountain of cheap drones they’ve no doubt stockpiled.

Time to import championship skeet shooters?

Thermobarics?

What is this place?

This website is a place for people who want to move past shady thinking and test their ideas in a court of people who don't all share the same biases. Our goal is to optimize for light, not heat; this is a group effort, and all commentators are asked to do their part.

The weekly Culture War threads host the most controversial topics and are the most visible aspect of The Motte. However, many other topics are appropriate here. We encourage people to post anything related to science, politics, or philosophy; if in doubt, post!

Check out The Vault for an archive of old quality posts. You are encouraged to crosspost these elsewhere.


Why are you called The Motte?

A motte is a stone keep on a raised earthwork common in early medieval fortifications. More pertinently, it's an element in a rhetorical move called a "Motte-and-Bailey", originally identified by philosopher Nicholas Shackel. It describes the tendency in discourse for people to move from a controversial but high value claim to a defensible but less exciting one upon any resistance to the former. He likens this to the medieval fortification, where a desirable land (the bailey) is abandoned when in danger for the more easily defended motte. In Shackel's words, "The Motte represents the defensible but undesired propositions to which one retreats when hard pressed."

On The Motte, always attempt to remain inside your defensible territory, even if you are not being pressed.


New post guidelines

If you're posting something that isn't related to the culture war, we encourage you to post a thread for it. A submission statement is highly appreciated, but isn't necessary for text posts or links to largely-text posts such as blogs or news articles; if we're unsure of the value of your post, we might remove it until you add a submission statement. A submission statement is required for non-text sources (videos, podcasts, images).

Culture war posts go in the culture war thread; all links must either include a submission statement or significant commentary. Bare links without those will be removed.

If in doubt, please post it!


Rules


Recommended Posts And Communities

Recommended Realtime Chats