This weekly roundup thread is intended for all culture war posts. 'Culture war' is vaguely defined, but it basically means controversial issues that fall along set tribal lines. Arguments over culture war issues generate a lot of heat and little light, and few deeply entrenched people ever change their minds. This thread is for voicing opinions and analyzing the state of the discussion while trying to optimize for light over heat.
Optimistically, we think that engaging with people you disagree with is worth your time, and so is being nice! Pessimistically, there are many dynamics that can lead discussions on Culture War topics to become unproductive. There's a human tendency to divide along tribal lines, praising your ingroup and vilifying your outgroup - and if you think you find it easy to criticize your ingroup, then it may be that your outgroup is not who you think it is. Extremists with opposing positions can feed off each other, highlighting each other's worst points to justify their own angry rhetoric, which becomes in turn a new example of bad behavior for the other side to highlight.
We would like to avoid these negative dynamics. Accordingly, we ask that you do not use this thread for waging the Culture War. Examples of waging the Culture War:
-
Shaming.
-
Attempting to 'build consensus' or enforce ideological conformity.
-
Making sweeping generalizations to vilify a group you dislike.
-
Recruiting for a cause.
-
Posting links that could be summarized as 'Boo outgroup!' Basically, if your content is 'Can you believe what Those People did this week?' then you should either refrain from posting, or do some very patient work to contextualize and/or steel-man the relevant viewpoint.
In general, you should argue to understand, not to win. This thread is not territory to be claimed by one group or another; indeed, the aim is to have many different viewpoints represented here. Thus, we also ask that you follow some guidelines:
-
Speak plainly. Avoid sarcasm and mockery. When disagreeing with someone, state your objections explicitly.
-
Be as precise and charitable as you can. Don't paraphrase unflatteringly.
-
Don't imply that someone said something they did not say, even if you think it follows from what they said.
-
Write like everyone is reading and you want them to be included in the discussion.
On an ad hoc basis, the mods will try to compile a list of the best posts/comments from the previous week, posted in Quality Contribution threads and archived at /r/TheThread. You may nominate a comment for this list by clicking on 'report' at the bottom of the post and typing 'Actually a quality contribution' as the report reason.

Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Notes -
Texas's new required school reading list includes stories from the Bible
Texas is the first state to establish such a list, as others generally give wide latitude to school districts and boards to select their own texts.
There are fourteen stories, listed in order of grade level: Jonah and the Whale (Jonah 1:1-5, 10-17, 2:10), David and Goliath (excerpt from The Children's Book of Heroes), Daniel and the Lion's Den (Children's Adapted Version), The Necessity of Humility (Luke 14:7-11), Moses (Exodus 3, 14), Do Not Be Anxious (Matthew 6:25-34), The Shepherd's Psalm (Psalms 23), Beatitudes (Matthew 5:1-12), To Everything There is a Season (Ecclesiastes 3), Lamentations 3, The Prodigal Son (Luke 15:11-32), Job (Job 1-7, 11, 14, 19, 28, 38-42), Adam and Eve (Genesis 2-3), The Definition of Love (1 Corinthians 13).
They also select a variety of translations: the New International Reader's Version, which is for a third-grade reading level, the English Standard Version, the King James Version, and the Jewish Publication Society. The ESV/KJV have their own history as evangelical texts; this is why there are so many parochial Catholic schools, though it's doubtful whether modern Catholics (who make up ~22% of Texas's population) care as much.
Teaching Biblical stories as cultural or historical texts does not violate the 1st amendment. Certainly the Bible is the most influential book in Western thought and has relevance to any serious study of literature and history. That being said, certain passages err on the side of theology and perhaps should be avoided outside of a comparative religion course. And some atheists will be disappointed that the more controversial passages have been excluded.
I've long thought that an AP-Theology course would be a great idea at the high school level. An easy dunk of a 5 for well educated religious kids who know their bible, helps non-religious kids learn about the world, helps sell Conservatives on public education. Just an easy all around win.
Wait, you guys don't do theology in highschool?
Not in the slightest.
I remember telling otherwise intelligent kids at a selective private college that Jesus was Jewish, and they were confused.
Incredible
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Religion is such an important part of history and many modern cultures; we're absolutely doing kids a disservice by not teaching it.
Of course, the problem is, how much does one trust teachers to teach this properly, from one angle or another?
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
In my high school in a blue district of a blue state we read Genesis chapter one. The King James Bible was a major influence on the written English language and is suitable for study in an English class. Which I understand is different than mandating teaching exclusively Christian theology.
Since you mention teaching Christian theology...
My high school American history teacher, when we were talking about the Puritans settling Massachusetts, spent most of one class period spelling out Puritan theology and how these historical Puritans applied it in their lives. He got it absolutely accurate, in such detail that I left that class convinced he was a Christian himself! But, some time later (after I was no longer taking his class), I found out that he's an atheist! That increased my respect for him in one way: he understood very well how important Christian doctrine was to American history.
One of the strongest signs of intelligence is the ability to present views you reject in a way that resonates with actual adherents of the view.
A person's background and prior experiences tend to colour their entire outlook, and for a large contingent of reddit atheists, it's pure trauma and resentment. Most will struggle (and make no conscious effort) to separate their emotions from their reading of religious tradition.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
That's kind of my problem with this plan in a nutshell. The bible is a tough read. You've got this very old-fashioned text, which probably began as some sort of oral history, only later written down by various different people at different times. Then that gets translated from paleo-Hebrew to Aramaic to Greek to Latin and then finally to English. On top of which, a lot of it is just plain confusing, with complex metaphors and moral lessons that only made sense from the point of view of a bronze age tribe living a harsh life. From my point of view as an atheist, some of it is fascinating and great reading, but some other parts are a horrible mess or just plain boring. I don't think it should be used to teach kids reading, because they're inevitably going to misunderstand it. I don't even trust most high school teachers to properly understand it- there's a good reason that theology and bible study is its own unique discipline.
That's the point. Are you going to teach the Bible as ancient book written by ancient Near Easterners for ancient Near Easterners, or as infallible guide for all men of all times and places? Even if you mandate one, how you are going to monitor the teachers to do not thwart it into the other?
I mean, I would hope that they're just teaching it as a text like any other, and letting students make up their own mind about what it means. But I'd be worried that Texas is trying to mandate it into the latter.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
We had the littlest bit of Bible reading in my high school long ago and I recall my teacher having quite the shallow understanding.
More options
Context Copy link
Very few 90 IQ students are learning French, Modern Standard Arabic, and classical Arabic. "An Arabic dialect" is their native language. MSA is a formal version they learn in grammar class and use nowhere else, and classical Arabic they only get from the Quran and most don't understand it any better than the average English speaker can follow King James Bible English. A version of French is learned by Arabs in North Africa but usually just enough to kind of get by.
You have an extremely exaggerated idea of how easy it is to become multilingual. And teaching elementary students a useless dead language to satisfy some classicism fetish would be a complete waste of time. They can learn Ancient Greek in college if they have an interest in it (but then you'd probably mock them for studying useless humanities).
More like one or two thousand for each language.
You probably have one or two thousand hours of reading just this forum.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Then why is it that so many students who spend hundreds of hours studying a foreign language in school come out the other end not knowing how to speak them?
Most kids have the capacity to learn a language really easily, because humans are designed to learn to talk. They don't have the capacity to learn two. At best, the second language overwrites the first language and they forget their native tongue (as happens to very young immigrants) or they completely forget the second language once they are no longer required to study it (as happens to millions of American students who take French or Spanish in high school). At worst, they end up speaking a shitty creole of both languages (e.g. Spanglish).
From "The Myth of 'They Weren't Ever Taught…'" by Education Realist:
From "Language is Culture" by Spandrell:
And from "The Numbers Speak: Foreign Language Requirements Are a Waste of Time and Money" by Bryan Caplan:
Oh, ouch. True, or does this writer have it in for the Japanese?
As one of our resident weeaboos and a big fan of Japan generally I'd say this is mostly true rather than the writer having an axe to grind. You see this all the time in anime and older games (especially in stuff from before western studios dedicated to localizing stuff into English became more commonplace, those have their own major issues related to wokeness and similar things that I won't dive into right now). There's just all kinds of gibberish and Engrish found all over inside of these works, and it's due to most Japanese people just not learning English very well (if at all).
Some fun examples off the top of my head:
Animes and mangas being given nonsensical English titles by their Japanese authors. My favorite example of this is the manga All You Need Is Kill. You probably know it better from its film adaptation (starring Tom Cruise and Emily Blunt): Edge of Tomorrow.
Opening and closing credit songs for animes being in horrible Engrish. For example the first line to the closing credits song for the first season of Frieren is broken English, with the singer saying "And you alright" instead of "Are you alright?" or "And you're alright" (not sure which was intended). Or the opening credits song to the 4th season of Legend of the Galactic Heroes clearly being sung by someone who doesn't speak a lick of English.
My favorite random example from the Studio Ghibli film The Cat Returns. In the background in one of the early scenes in the movie, there are banners in the background of some town square that read "Crossroad". Near the end of the film there is another scene in the same location and the banners now read "Crossload". I might have the order mixed up here, it's been a few years since I watched it. Studio Ghibli is basically the premiere animation studio in Japan, often called the "Japanese Disney", so that even they make mistakes like this is telling when it comes to the typical level of English fluency in Japan.
English is just a hard language, especially when coming from a language like Japanese. This has at least had the beneficial effect of somewhat insulating Japan from the world of woke retardation, so I can't really complain. And honestly the Engrish and other mistakes and issues are endearing.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Because in monolingual countries with a large population, neither the student not the teacher cares enough to have the student come out with a strong grasp of the foreign language on the other end. In countries where getting good at English or another lingua franca is a practical necessity, you better believe a lot of students are coming out with functional language skills despite many of these students having a fraction of the investment rich Anglo countries do.
This doesn't make any sense. While obviously there are physical limits in the extreme, there is no evidence that language acquisition is bottlenecked by storage space of all things - if you have a GeForce 256 and a 100TB SSD obviously storage is not going to be the bottleneck in your system.
As Pigeon says bilingualism is very common globally - the fact that many children don't learn multiple languages comes from a lack of incentives rather than a lack of ability. Many people across South America, continental Europe, Africa, and ex-CJK Asia will at least be conversant in a global lingua franca and a native language out of necessity: e.g the Nordic countries and the Dutch are almost all perfectly bilingual English speakers.
These are indictments against the requirement to learn languages in school, which I agree is useless for unmotivated students, but really this is a general argument against teaching anything in school above basic numeracy and literacy. I broadly agree with Caplan's Case Against Education thesis, but these posts do not support your bailey that secondary language acquisition is not possible or detrimental.
The motte here is that the opportunity costs of language learning are high, which I think is probably correct for English speakers even as a hobbyist polyglot myself, but in the long run everyone is dead anyways. There are much worse and unproductive things that most people do with their lives.
More options
Context Copy link
I don’t think this is accurate. Most Swiss people use more than one language in daily life, something like 25% of India speaks 2+ languages, you have varying degrees of bilingualism for English and Tagalog in the Philippines, standard Thai and the various regional Thai languages (sometimes + a functional grasp on English), and so on. Even East Asian hubs like Tokyo and Seoul and Taipei will have a reasonable amount of people who are bilingual. And of course we have many examples of people here who are bilingual largely or at least in part due to education.
Surely the issue is that most American children don’t naturally find themselves in situations where they would need to speak a second language, and language perhaps rusts more quickly than other skills do.
(I am unsure about the value of formally educating children in a second language, but I want to nitpick a specific claim here.)
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
The ease with which children learn languages is exaggerated, but yes, it's easier to learn languages when you are young. It is not "easy." The "passive language-absorbing sponge" theory is not true.
I think you would be dismayed to learn what kids in Muslim countries do spend much of their school hours learning. And while I can guess what you think of Martin Luther King, Jr., I would be dismayed (am dismayed) at American students not being taught about the American Revolution or the reproductive cycle of flowering plants.
Understanding history and being able to relate it to the world we live in is definitely a cognitive skill.
Kids should actually know something about the history of their country and the world. A population ignorant of history and science but which can speak a couple of languages is not a recipe for success.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Our modern school system cannot handle teaching kids Spanish. They take years of Spanish class and no point can any of them speak Spanish. I don't think they have what it takes to teach ancient Greek.
I was made to take years of French, never got any further than slowly being able to struggle through a newspaper, and have since forgotten all of it. My English, however, is decent.
The difference is that I actually use my English. I grew up watching American movies. Higher education is in English and office jobs require English. Bilingualism comes naturally if you are in a situation where you need to speak two languages.
Nobody is going to retain any Spanish unless they need it, except some language nerds. And anyone can (will, indeed) learn any language if they must, but not otherwise.
More options
Context Copy link
It's the kids and the system. The teachers have no authority to personally punish or transfer disruptive students, so when you get a little shit stain they disrupt the whole class, god forbid there are multiple of them, and due to a conflux of bad incentives a good bit of the teachers are women, as a class entirely unprepared to assert a subconscious fear of physical reprisal or an air of authority and respect.
More options
Context Copy link
There is no time when everyone learned classical languages in school- because most people didn't go to school.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
So I don't think state legislature calling for the school board to make a list of required books is a great idea, though I'm also not sure that I'm right on that, either. Both the school board and the local individual teachers can be corrupt so easily, that I'm not sure which one should have that sort of power, or how to regulate the corruption properly.
If we take for granted that the school board must compile such a list for public schools to follow, it occurs to me that having Bible stories in it actually strengthens the separation between church and state instead of the other way around, because it's treating Bible stories as equivalent to any other literature, rather than placing the Bible on a special pedestal as having status that's different from any other significant piece of writing. But I don't think anyone could have the confidence that individual teachers - perhaps especially in Texas - wouldn't teach these works of literature strictly as works of literature. In the private secular high school I went to, I was made to read Genesis in English class, and our teacher was very clear about this, but teachers and students in such environments are filtered so heavily that I'm skeptical that we can count on the same phenomenon repeating all across the public schools in any given state.
I'm not sure how to adjudicate this other than just letting someone sue and having the Supreme Court eventually make the call. It could ultimately rest on an empirical question of how real schoolteachers actually teach real students.
It's been pointed out, of course, that we already allow religious proselytization in schools by schoolteachers and administrators directed towards students in the form of social justice ideology, and so this is a "good for the goose, good for the gander" situation even if this led to the Bible being pushed as anything more than literature in schools. But I think the solution to that would be to find a way to declare such ideologies as religious in nature, which I'm not sure how would be done in a legal perspective, even if they clearly are in a logical and fact perspective.
More options
Context Copy link
Is it? In 1900, sure.
But in 2026?
Do our politicians read the Bible and actually implement biblical doctrine, socially or economically? Is Christianity a major social movement in the West today? The recent pro-life moves in the US only gave individual states the ability to ban or legalize abortion, that doesn't seem Christian so much as federalist.
Sodomy is very fashionable, there are literal Pride parades. Bigamy has made a comeback with polyamory. The less said about usury, lust, greed, sloth and envy the better.
In media, any major new works of Christian art? Film? TV? Video games?
What about the Pope? Any Crusades recently? His powers to excommunicate, have they been relevant in world affairs much? Or does nobody really care if they're excommunicated, what does that say about the Pope's abilities?
The Church of England? Well the Supreme Governor of the Church of England, the King 'protects the space for Faith within the multi-faith nation' per the Palace description of the role of the Head of State. He still holds the role of being 'Defender of the Faith' but it seems fairly clear his heart is not really in it. De facto the King issues milquetoast proclamations that nobody pays much attention to:
No reference to Christ can be found in the whole 150 page document. Only in Russia, in Africa, in Latin America is Christianity taken more seriously. Defacing churches in Russia and LGBT behaviour is treated very seriously indeed.
Christianity's influence is mostly historical, like how mammals in the time of the dinosaurs were mostly tiny mouse creatures. They had tremendous influence in a certain sense. We are descended from tiny mouse creatures. There are still tiny mouse creatures around. But the tiny mouse creatures around today are not really influential and we are not really tiny mice. Even if most of our DNA is mouse there are important distinctions.
Marx is more relevant than the Bible to Western thought today, there are powerful cadres of communists, true believers (still!) Or the Limits to Growth - degrowthers and climatists have significant influence on the left and especially in Europe. They see datacentres, power plants, industry and development but unlike Christians they don't just murmur or complain about things they're against, they reach out and crush them to death. That's not to say that it would be good to teach people Marx or other bad ideologies but they're certainly more relevant.
Marxism's root is in Christianity, Wokeness is Christianity that has evolved to the point of opposing itself. The current ideological justification for tolerance of "sodomy and bigamy" is built off of Christian ethics. Christianity lies at the root of all Western, and therefore world, culture.
((FWIW I also think that high level studies at any ideological bent should include Kapital, if you can't understand why the majority of intelligent Europeans between 1860 and 1960 were admirers of Marx then it's a problem with you or your education))
How about Islam? Islam is monotheist and spiritual, it explicitly endorses Jesus as a prophet and endorses the general spiritualist ethos that Marxism denies.
Are Muslims then Christian? No. Even though Islam is rooted in Christianity to a certain extent, that doesn't substantially matter, they belong in separate categories not least because of a long history of hatred and warfare between the two. Islam is far more rooted in Christianity than Marxism is.
Wokeness also rejects Christianity and co-opts Christianity to be more like itself. Wokeness has roots in Christianity but it's like I was saying upthread. Humans have genetic roots in mice (about 85-90% of DNA being shared) but aren't really mice in a significant sense. Wokeness --- Marxism ------------------- Christianity --- Islam.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
The Bible’s influence is everywhere in our culture. The year’s biggest game so far is Resident Evil Requiem. The most anticipated launch next month is Halo, about the savior “John 117” and a covenant, flood, and ark. The most popular movie this year is Project Hail Mary. Not to mention that the Bible is essential for understanding Western music and literature before 1900. If we were thinking objectively about what readings to include in public education for the purpose of cultural literacy, easily half the readings would just be the Bible. Probably more like 80% of the readings.
It's Super Mario Galaxy: https://www.boxofficemojo.com/year/world/
Project Hail Mary doesn't have anything to do with Christianity thematically, it's a sci fi alien story.
Resident Evil Requiem doesn't seem to have anything to do with Christianity in the game. The word itself doesn't carry much weight.
The most anticipated game of 2026 is GTA 6, which is a pretty unchristian game thematically given it's all about shooting police, robbing people and girls in bikinis. GTA is a 5x bigger franchise than Halo too. The Combat Evolved remake isn't even a new game or a new remake (they already remade it in MCC)
The one part I agree with is that the Bible is needed to understand pre-1900 culture.
The cultural power of an iron age desert cult does not extend to a post-industrialized hyperurban internet economy. We are not shepherds, we don't give servants talents of gold to invest. We pick and choose various interpretations of biblical verses to suit our arguments at any given time, you of all people must be sick of the good samaritan being waved around as a leftist sigil. In that case, it's Christian arguments being made for fundamentally secular reasons, objectification of Christianity as a bludgeon, not actual sincere belief which would probably be smeared as fundamentalism. And it is kinda crazy to try to live by these rules in a thoroughly different society.
Ah yes, the story of Ryland Grace, the man whose existence throughout the story constitutes an undeserved favor to others and who ultimately has to decide freely whether or not he must sacrifice himself utterly in order to deliver the entire human race from disaster after they put him to death. The man whose sidekick is a "rock". Yeah nothing Christian to see here, pure coincidence. I guess the characters literally talking about God didn't lay it on thick enough.
You just think it doesn't because you are as a fish asked about water. What water?
"Forget about the industrial-scale killing of unborn children, parades devoted to sodomy and sexual deviance, pornography, breakdown of marriage rituals - the third biggest movie of the year's main character's name has Grace in it and he has to consider whether to sacrifice himself or not!'
Huh?
I confess I haven't read the book or watched the film, just skimmed the plot on wikipedia. But it's not exactly the Sistine Chapel! Looking at the themes, I see scientific materialism ranking ahead of Christian values.
The water I'm swimming in sure looks like it's about 98% iron oxide.
Go watch Mikhail Romm's Nine Days in One Year or Klushantsev's Road to the Stars and come back and tell me Project Hail Mary is a story of scientific materialism over Christian values.
Personal drama about redemption, survival and self sacrifice don't suddenly become something else because they drape themselves in soft-scifi technobabble.
Nor, frankly, does cultural influence work in the sort of all or nothing way you seem to imply. Post-Christian cultures are still determined by Christianity in the same way that post-Roman cultures are still determined by Roman influence. Cultural power reaches far further than naive notions of theocratic imposition, that it is a loose binding makes it no less scary a binding: rejection of the frame is still in the frame.
The Japanese routinely make stories that contain no Christian influence, but they're only able because it's not a core part of their civilization. Westerners don't have this luxury. The secular world you might want to see as separate does not contain a lot of mythic alternatives for artists to draw from. Either because the Catholic Church removed them in the high middle ages or because like Marxism they're themselves successors of Christian mythologies.
So Piss Christ is Christian art then? As far as I'm concerned, it's an insult dressed up as art. Defacing a Koran isn't Islamic art, no muslim would think that, they'd get really angry about it. Marxism may descend from Christianity in some respects but Marxists hate Christianity and work around the clock to undermine and suppress it as shown from when they get any scrap of power and usually start killing nuns and closing churches. It's not really Christian. Is /r/atheism Christian? Many users were Christian at one point. But it isn't a Christian website.
Cultural power is a kind of power, it has an effect on the world. Where is Christianity's cultural power? Are we getting new words from Christianity? Or just a sea of old words, old words that people can barely define anymore? Prelate, deacon, abbott, cardinal - even educated people might not know what they mean. When's the last time anyone went to a conventicle?
Power is about making things happen. What has Christianity made happen recently? You're saying that everything in Western civilization is drawn from Christianity in some respect and alluding to extremely broad ideas like redemption, survival and self-sacrifice (notably shared by other cultures that never heard of Christ). But what specifically has happened recently as a result of this power, tangibly? Gay marriage, pride parades, a tonne of porn everywhere, women wandering around with buttocks visible through some skimpy hot pants, a fountain of materialist greed in everyone's social media, gluttony, envy, sloth, revenge and more aborted kids in the last 60 years than died in every war in human history?
Where is the cultural power going exactly, what is it doing?
There are no live controversies about saying the lord's name in vain, only saying 'nigger'. What does that say about cultural power?
Christianity doesn't even measure up to long-dead religions in this respect. Drawing from pagans today: Age of Mythology, Titan Quest, God of War, Hades, Assassin's Creed Valhalla, Jotun, Northgard, and The Banner Saga. Valheim. The Pharoah Series. The Witcher.
Drawing from Christianity today: Darksiders, Diablo and Dante's Inferno + maybe the Binding of Isaac which is anti-Abrahamist.
Both pale in comparison to thematically modern stories about man and technology which gives us huge rich veins of sci-fi, robots, ray guns, flying machines, totalitarian states.
What else could it possibly be? Iconoclasm is still, ultimately, a form of respect for the power of the idol. True contempt is indifference.
Since 2024 even Richard Dawkins calls himself a Cultural Christian. All the parts of New Atheism that aren't ex-muslim apostates are so pretty much. And Old Atheism was so self evidently.
No, it's also about making things not happen. Which is mostly what cultural victory is about. Long settled arguments about things you don't even think about like whether children owe anything to their parents, whether individuality has any value, whether you should obey the law or your own internal morality first or whether humans can be property.
People say Tradition has no power, and then go on to not do all the things Tradition managed to eradicate.
Where is the power of Christianity? In that a lot of the things you list as contrary to its doctrine are still viewed as either outright sins or objects of moral debate. A civilization without this influence simply does not ask such questions.
It is waning though, you are right about that. Time makes everything diminish. And Western civilization is old now and far into its second barbarism. But just because power wanes doesn't mean it ceases to exist as a factor. The Romans still have eminent effects on us down to how we record time itself, never mind half of the world's laws.
Almost none of these are actual pagan stories full of pagan virtue though. They're Christian subversions. God of War was almost so explicitly.
The stories that actually extol pagan values are few and far between, and almost all of them are products of Nietzscheans like Milius or Coppola who are still haunted by the corpse of God despite their best efforts to transcend him.
To be the most valiant opponent of something is to be its strongest proponent. Someone who isn't irremediably a son of Abraham would simply not think about him at all. Not make endless art about his mythology.
Gaze into the Abyss and it gazes back into you. Black Sabbath is Christian Rock.
Which are all still derived from a cultural substrate. A setting is nothing but set dressing for themes. Which are in turn simply expressions of a worldview. All art is propaganda for something as Orwell famously said.
The Soviets had scifi stories that weren't about Christian themes, or at least not so directly since those values were still filtered through Marxism and irrigated by non-western cultural input like Cosmism. Even China today exports award winning scifi that works from its own cultural lens.
But the West can't run away from its own shadow. It is futile to try.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
All those examples look like shallow references where a thing was named after a biblical or Catholic thing to sound slightly cooler. Are any of those media Christian beyond that?
What's called a 'Hail Mary pass' in the USA is called a Garryowen over here, or at least that's the nearest thing to it. Upon first encountering the term, I had to look it up as to why it was called that. Do so, and you find out Notre Dame, and then you find out it's a Catholic prayer:
Even on Tumblr, I've seen people making direct connections between the ship name and the name of the main character: Hail Mary, full of Grace.
Learning the origins of common terms is not a bad thing. "Why is this called that?" decreases ignorance, you don't end up going "Dunno" and sounding like you are dumber than a box of rocks.
More options
Context Copy link
Although the Project Hail Mary title is a play on words, the movie itself takes the time for a pretty on the nose and fairly-needless-to-the-plot discussion about belief in God, which I would say is far from a shallow reference.
Mainstream Hollywood films with a fairly overtly Christian message aren't actually all that rare (see Unbroken, Silence, Hacksaw Ridge, etc.) and for every one of those there are two that take Christian ideas seriously, even if it's in more subtle ways. I was recently watching the Fallout show and one of the characters reaches for the Golden Rule, not as part of a come-to-Jesus sideplot, but because it's an important moral principle - obviously not one unique to Christianity, of course.
More options
Context Copy link
The first 5 Halo games are arguably far more "Christian" in both message and tone than many churches these days. Ditto Project Hail Mary though I don't have a effort post I can link for that one.
Specifically the themes of hope in the face of hopelessness, and the idea that the righteous and honest will always find themselves in conflict with the worldly.
More options
Context Copy link
In Halo 3, the Master and Savior of humanity sacrifices himself in the “gravemind”, says “it is finished”, and is then
entombedcryogenically frozen and later “resurrected”, all of which is very Biblical. But this is shallow because most things in our culture are shallow. To Kill a Mockingbird? Lord of the Flies? Not just shallow but actively detrimental to cultivating wisdom. Just worthless slop.What is the complaint against To Kill a Mockingbird? (And no fair bringing up Go Set a Watchman.)
Presumably because it shits on secular morality in the same w as y that the story of Jonah does.
Do you means shits on "non-secular" morality? Jonah can be easily read as a critique of religious righteousness. Personally, I think the critique is fairly trenchant.
No, it "shits" on secular morality by explicitly rejecting identity in favor of conduct.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
The heuristics it teaches about life and history are inaccurate.
[Contains mild spoilers for Lord of the Flies]
Can you expand on this criticism of To Kill a Mockingbird? I consider the novel as offering very powerful lessons about (e.g.) conformity and the nature of the legal system.
Also, what's the criticism of Lord of the Flies? I've always been partial to interpreting it as an anti-war novel - by having the boys rescued by a warship, Golding's emphasizing the parallels between modern and primeval expressions of savagery.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
That's because these things are perceived as against the state not because they are against Christianity. Homosexuality is mildly suppressed in Russia but so is Evangelical Christianity. Because both are perceived as foreign Western ideologies. And homosexuality is at most mildly repressed not "treated very seriously" There are open Gay bars and clubs in Moscow and St. Petersburg, gay men from all over the former Soviet Union move to Russia for it's tolerance of homosexuality. The whole reason Russia passed those gay propaganda laws is because they have enough organic western liberals they needed to suppress them.
And all of this flows from the state. When Russia was more open in the 90s they were more open to both Protestant missionaries and gay activists and now that the state is stronger both have been curtailed as foreign ideologies. Defacing churches is illegal but so is defacing any state approved religious house of worship Mosques included.
More options
Context Copy link
This one paragraph seems to completely override any point made earlier on in this post. The bible and stories therein aren't the tiny mouse creatures that are still around; the evangelical Christians and Catholics and such of today are the ones that are still around. The parts of our DNA that are mouse DNA (which in this hypothetical is most of our DNA) is the bible. Which means that it has tremendous influence.
More options
Context Copy link
In terms of "books to read to understand modern culture" Marx is less relevant than Harry Potter.
The Bible is still far and away the most important single book you can read to understand modern culture (including Marxism/socialism, which is a post-Christian ideology).
How does reading the Bible help you understand modern culture, exactly? It can teach you about the values some people profess to believe, it doesn't teach you about what actually happens, about real behaviour in the West. Harry Potter is more relevant.
In the England of King James II people really cared about the Bible, interpreting from the Bible about what the church was supposed to be, they were ready to stake their lives for particular interpretations of that book and the meaning of various rituals. That is not happening today! Nobody is waging war for Christianity in a Western country. They are fighting for oil, for national pride, for security interests, for human rights...
The values most people act on, including woke people, Marxists, and a/antitheists, are downstream of Christianity and the Bible. If you came back to the West after being gone for a few millennia, the questions you would ask (besides "what's a cell phone?" and "does anyone have a Latin-English translator?") would be things like "wait, why can't I buy a sex slave at Wal-mart?"
And the answer to that has nothing to do with cell phones.
It's 2026, the weapons of war are a laptop and a Westlaw subscription.
Well if the weapons of war are a laptop the US could save a lot of money by scrapping all those jets and bombs.
Furthermore, there's nothing in the bible about not having sex slaves, not buying sex slaves! Slavery was commonplace in biblical judea, there are parables about sending out slaves to do work for you. That's just in the New Testament. In the Old Testament the appropriate treatment and trading of sex slaves is laid out in black and white. So reading the Bible is quite misleading for this point you're making.
Again, you'd be better off reading Harry Potter which makes more of a critique of slavery than the Bible!
The New Testament is a pretty important part of the Bible, yes.
No, there's nothing in the New Testament... about not having sex slaves. There's plenty in the Old Testament about having sex slaves!
The New Testament condemns sexual activity outside of marriage, mistreating slaves, and deviant sexual practices. It doesn't say something like "sex slaves are banned" because the things it explicitly enjoins rules out sex slavery. (True, I suppose a first century Christian could buy a sex slave and...treat them in a chaste and kind manner, but at that point I'd say they were a former sex slave.)
It's as if I said "I think using force to harm other people outside of the due process of law is wrong" and you said "you'll notice that Shrike never condemns murder."
The fact that we're having to go over the basic sexual ethics of the largest religion on earth instead of arguing about anything Marx said is frankly a better refutation of your argument than anything I've said here. (Although I will say that it's making me want to suggest the Didache should be on a school reading list rather than anything that's technically from Scripture.)
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Yeah. How many 'marxists' have any real comprehension of the book itself beyond a vague understanding of 'Marx says we should all share everything equally and stop being mean'?
Which of course is far from unique to Marx!
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
People are still using terms like "Good Samaritan" in "Good Samaritan laws", so there's an amount of cultural knowledge still remaining. "Golden Rule", "love your enemies" and the likes. While I might be dubious about required reading of Bible stories, it's no harm to show where such terms came from, since there's a lot of modern ignorance (same with ideas from Greek myths and the likes, the level of assumed cultural knowledge that past generations had has decreased hugely in modern times).
More options
Context Copy link
Yeah but so many random books are part of the canon now. How many books on slavery or Jim crow will be mandated in most states for random bludgeoning with.
More options
Context Copy link
I must note about Russia, from my perspective here it does not look like its trad values such as slightly lower (relatively when compared to both USA and Afghanistan) acceptance of LGBT is in any way connected to greater influence of Christianity.
The penetration of the Orthodox gilding on top of the Russian state into Russian society is dismal. From what I see, being either an adherent Christian or a cultural Christian is a lot more common and "mainstream" among Americans than Russians. Hell, Americans actually prioritize Christmas above New Year's Eve.
I have elaborated on that elsewhere. For now, as per your metaphor the only legacy of mice Russia seems to keep over USA is that we eat more real cheese rather than the synthetic orange stuff.
More options
Context Copy link
I can never understand the trad Christian love for the Russian state as some enabler of Christian virtue - it's really really not the case.
Russia is a larp, pretending to be bits of the Soviet bear and the Imperial eagle whenever it suits, and as such they have made the Russian Orthodox Patriarchy an arm of that project by stuffing their mouths with gold. This is done for state aims, and many Eastern Europeans (including in Ukraine) attend churches regularly - more than Russians incidentally (which is kind of obviously true due to Ukraine's far lower muslim population for a start). The orthodoxy is another state pillar, and part of the legitimizing claims Russia projects, but I don't see much beyond that.
Russia comes down hard on those who damage churches as its popular among a fairly conservative core population that likes tradition and the larp (which I actually understand and respect), and because its a disrespect to a state arm like attacking a police station. It also lets Russia project an image of being against globalhomo too, which is popular for some and where the gay bashing comes in.
But what does being a supposedly trad Christian state actually do for morality and behaviour of the Russian system in general? They have mass muslim migration, onto a population that was already fairly muslim - 10-15% of the population (~ double to triple the poor UK), and a string of terrorist attacks to match. Homosexual rape and general degeneracy is embedded deeply into the Russian military, and the whole anti LGBT thing seems to miss out a lot - Russia is just repressed, not some trad paradise. I'm not sure Jesus would love old King Charles and his mealy mouthed words, Russia however is a few steps away from Sodom by comparison.
To be clear, this is aimed at the Russian state and high leadership of the church - I actually think a good chunk of normal Russians have solid christian convictions that are to their credit. However, that's inherited through time, was failed to be stamped out via the Soviets, and they seem to happily wage war on their very Christian Ukrainian neighbors. The Russian government itself is just very cynically using them, and burning through what it inherited - this isn't going to last long-term. Drug abuse, HIV/AIDS, divorce and spousal abuse are through the roof, that's your Christian paradise?
I'm not a fan of globalhomo, and Ukraine is going to have to navigate a minefield post war to chart its way through the various failure modes of the West, but Russia is just sad. Punching gays as strength and golden watches while the structure rots and now burns, if that's the best of the Christian project then it needs to find Christ too.
It makes sense once you recognize that it's mostly Edge-lords and Astroturf. As a general rule, sincere trad Christians aren't hanging out on "this part of twitter" and the ones who do are weird.
More options
Context Copy link
“Christianity done for political aims” is the traditional form of Christianity. The State has been invested in Christianity and using it for her own influence since Constantine. Remember that America got Pope John Paul II elected as an anti-Soviet measure.
You mean the central Asian migrants that will not receive citizenship? Who cares? The problem has always been political enfranchisement and replacement. Moscow is 90% White while NYC is like 30% White.
Because the North Caucasus was always Muslim, and they took it over. It’s not because of migration. Russia’s cultural capitals are way more Russian than ours are White American.
This is like NAFO propaganda. No, they are not all secretly gay or doing secret mass rape in the military; no, the new ayatollah is not gay either. They do not have 1% of the gay culture that America has, neither do they have gay mafias in their arts scenes or in tech like America. I would prefer that we “bash the gays” than allow them the kind of power they have in the West. I know two straight men in the classical arts who have been prevented from advancing in the industry because they aren’t gay. This is common where homosexuals get into power and I am personally envious of Russia’s ability to throw them back into the closet. I actually want straight men in all influential positions, but perhaps this is a matter of cultural taste, ie I like their cultural products and their conservatism and do not like to see homosexuality celebrated in our major cities.
The Muslim immigrants ruining Europe are mostly white. Mohammad Atta and Dzhokhar Tsarnaev were white. And a lot of the white ethnics (both immigrants and indigenous ethnic minorities) in Russia are Muslims in the Dzhokhar Tsarnaev mold. Assimilability has more to do with cultural Christianity than it does with skin colour.
More options
Context Copy link
John Paul II was elected because he was conservative and seen as a diplomat; the Soviets actually assessed him as being relatively weak on communism at the time of the conclave, and the cardinals wanted a conservative who would just stop tinkering given the disaster of Paul VI.
More options
Context Copy link
I am not certain I will be able to change your mind on much to do with chronic Russian hazing and rape, both by their own and by Kadyrov's boys, here. As I recall you thought that the Bucha massacre wasn't Russian discipline immediately collapsing once in an environment where they hold power, as is common, but instead somehow Azov who decided to kill everyone post liberation and then go back in time and doctor satellite footage of the massacre.
However, I guess it's worth a go:
Christ being misused and twisted by politics certainly is very old, and is a factor that can bring down such states in the past. This is a failure mode, not something to aspire to for a Christian and the states they wish to live in surely?
Your Youtube link doesn't work, but as I understand John Paul II was elected for several reasons, none of which support any relevant thesis that Russia is a model for a Christian state.
Moscow has an official Muslim population in the 1-2 million range, comparable with Paris, and many more unofficial migrants as you point out that will certainly push it much higher. Relations are not great, which boils into open war in the past, and terrorist attacks here and there. You might say the same about the west, but this is the same story, not a solution by the Russians.
Rape is endemic in the Russian military, including as hazing "Dedovshchina" where it is extremely common. All forces struggle with some incidents worldwide, but the Russian structure is famously bad for it since forever. For example: Russian recruits sold for sex, 1500 army sexual assaults reported in 2019 which must be a floor, and that only came to light after a guy snapped and shot those who were raping him.
We also have many incidents in the war, both by and inflicted onto Russians, but possibly the one you'll most be interested in was the Russian soldier raped by Kadyrov's troops who are used as barrier troops and left to run rampant over their Christian charges, who then hung himself. Not sure if you read Russian, but a rough translation is: "Goodbye. love, in the time that I am here I have seen hell. There were not so many deaths in Chechnya or even Afganistan. seas of human meat. but that is not why i depart. We here, Russian people, are nobody, and Chechens rule. They drink, are lawless and rape, they despise everyone and no ones doing anything about it. Kitty, they took all the money you sent and they did a thing to me. This is to let you know that I resisted. Remember that you and me owe nothing to anyone. This is the only way out. See you after death"
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
My experience as a European member of a conservative church is that this is mostly an online and political phenomenon and doesn't represent people who actually go to Church. It might be different in the USA, I don't have any info on the ground from over there, but over here in the Netherlands right wing populist politicians will exhibit sometimes the trad love for Russia and they will make some vague remarks about our country being Christian or whatever, but none of those politicians actually go to Church and if you push them all of them will admit they are cultural Christians and don't actually believe any traditional Christian dogmas. Just like you can get more liberal politicians to sometimes dress up progressive politics with vaguely Christian language about love or whatever, the right wing populists will dress up their anti Muslim sentiment with some vague rhetoric about us being a traditionally Christian nation or whatever. In both cases it is just superficial rhetoric trying to appeal to some cultural memes and doesn't really mean anything. In practice, people who vote for those parties mostly don't actually attend Church regularly and people who do attend Church regularly almost never vote for those parties. Maybe in other countries actual trads are more tempted to vote for the right wing populist parties as the lesser evil, but in the Netherlands having no electoral threshold and proportional representation in our parliament, we are spoiled with not just one, but two actual traditional Christian political parties and almost everybody who regularly attends a theologically conservative Church votes for them and both of these parties are not pro Russia.
In America russophiles are a bit more fringey than they are in Europe, because our right traditionally defines itself with strong russophobia, but also the right wing populists get the church attending vote.
More options
Context Copy link
I have always been fascinated by Christian political parties. The idea seems repulsive to me both as an American (due to separation of church and state) and as a Christian (I'm from a tradition that sees even voting as borderline sinful).
Do you think Christians should completely abstain from politics? In the end somebody has to run the country and I cannot imagine a version of Christianity that doesn't at least espouse some values that will inform how Christians think a country ought to be run. If you think Christians should completely abstain from politics, what do you think Constantine or Clovis should have done after converting to Christianity? How should a country be governed when almost all of its citizens profess Christianity, like most Western countries up until quite recently?
Jesus clearly teaches political quietism in the New Testament, and historically most radical Christian "back-to-the-fundamentals" movements are politically quietist (like the Amish). The first modern capital-F Fundamentalists were obviously not politically quietist (the extent of mass government-backed secular education in America c. 1900 made already it a lot harder to be politically quietist if you didn't withdraw completely from the wider society like the Amish do), but there is no discussion of secular politics in The Fundamentals.
Politically active Christianity is, obviously, almost as lindy as politically quietist Christianity. I think this is because Jesus doesn't say why he is preaching political quietism, so it isn't obvious how "don't be a Zealot and render unto Caesar" translates to contexts other than living as a religious minority in a pagan Empire.
The most common view between the time of Constantine and the present was "Christians should not seek political power unless it is explicitly thrust upon them by Divine authority" - the exception is broad enough to cover the political power of the Church, Divine Right kingship and appointed authority under it, religious visionary leadership like Joan of Arc, and even Cromwell and his major-generals.
"Democracy good" is an idea that largely skips from pagan Athens (and, to a lesser extent, the Roman Republic) to the explicitly anti-clerical French Revolution without touching the intervening Christian millennia. The first country to see itself as both Christian and democratic is Jacksonian America. I don't know enough about the political thought of the medieval and early modern Christian republics (like Venice or the United Provinces) to comment, although I note that American republicanism was established by men whose Christianity was somewhat heterodox (especially Jefferson) and looked more to the Roman Republic than any of the usual Christian examples.
Ho ho, let's roll up our sleeves and get stuck into that one! "Democracy good" perhaps, but in pagan Athens it's not democracy as we know it, Jim. Participation confined to free, male, Athenian citizens, and the definition of who was an Athenian became more rigid over time (you had to be born of an Athenian father and an Athenian mother, otherwise out of luck). You could lose your civic rights, and this might even become a heritable disqualification:
"Also excluded from voting were citizens whose rights were under suspension (typically for failure to pay a debt to the city: see atimia); for some Athenians, this amounted to permanent (and in fact inheritable) disqualification."
Some (such as Plato) thought democracy itself was suspect, others considered it could be good and bad forms, "true" democracy was distinguished from "rule by the mob" (which, of course, is always the danger and probably the form of this distinction today is "populism is the bad form of democracy").
Democracy as we think of it, the will of the people, one man one vote, everyone who is a citizen has a voice and there are no racial or gender disqualifications to citizenship, may not have "touch[ed] the intervening Christian millennia" but (a) democracy as we think of it likely would not have been recognisable to the Athenians and (b) some kind of limits, councils, advisors, parliaments, etc. did occur in the Christian era. Take our friend Henry VIII, he had parliaments which had to at least notionally agree with and consent to his desired policies, and he didn't always get his way, even though those would not have been "democracy as we know it".
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Groups like the Amish do not have this tension, and I think the ideal Christian behavior is far closer to the Amish than it is to the modal American/European Christian.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
All that is kind of true but how can a country with state sanctioned, state-promoted pride parades even be anything but anti-Christian? Both the medium and the message are pretty explicitly anti-Christian? How can a country with legal gay marriage be considered Christian, never mind divorce rates?
Even if Russia's goal is just vaguely seeming to be against globohomo, that's still way closer to Christianity than the Western countries who are promoting, spreading, directing globohomo.
I don't believe in the 'based trad Russia' meme. But in terms of social vice, it's hardly worse than America or the West generally. Abortions: 13.1 per 1000 vs 14.4 in America, 20 in UK. Russia is number 7 in drug deaths per capita but America is far ahead at number 1 worldwide, 4x Russia.
https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/abortion-rates-by-country
https://www.worldlifeexpectancy.com/cause-of-death/drug-use/by-country
Trying but mostly failing to be anti-LGBT in the military seems a lot more Christian than promoting LGBT and diversity in the military. However cynically Putin may use Christian rhetoric he's 10x more Christian than the average Western leader who's mentally redefined Christianity to mean 'more leftism but with cross aesthetics'.
Vladimir Putin who swore he was an Atheist to join the KGB for decades and is on record (via hot mike) of hoping tech not Jesus will make him immortal? That Vladimir Putin? He's against western Liberalism and LBGTQ+ sure but that doesn't make someone a Christian. By that standard Joseph Stalin was a Christian.
I will take 50 Stalins before the rule of Big Red and Greta Thunberg or whichever stand in with the politics of Merkel/Jean-Claude Juncker
More options
Context Copy link
He's a Hirsi Ali Christian: i.e. Christian because it's the only thing they see that can push back against liberalism (and, in Hirsi Ali's case, Islam and the alliance it's made with the left) and provide an alternate civilizational narrative.
This is obviously very different from communists, who think they already have said narrative.
He makes the same cultural noises every European leader does. But he's no more Christian then the liberal Western Europeans. Nor are Russians anymore religious then Western Europeans. Putin suppresses quite a bit of Christianity as well, Evangelical missionaries are not welcome in Russia。 America is a far more religious society then Russia.
Making the noises and then doing globohomo stuff seems worse than making the noises and keeping globohomo out/maintaining some semblance of Christian values.
But YMMV I'm not a Christian so maybe I don't value enough the value it places on the spirit rather than the form.
But, if you were a (Orthodox) Christian seeing your faith fade who would you rather support you? A leader like Putin or someone like Talarico that'll come up with some doctrine about how Genesis 1 means transing kids? Or a Stalin who just outright wants you gone?
Better an emperor driven purely by pragmatism than an outright heretic Buffalo Bill-ing your religion or someone hostile to the concept entirely, surely?
If your a non Orthodox Christian you have much more freedom to practice your faith under the Western Liberals. Look at the Amish and Hasidic in the US. America lets weird hyper conservative religions exist the Netherlands and France both have small but thriving communities of conservative Christians.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Do you consider restricting marriage to be between a man and a woman such a core part of Christianity that it beats all the rest of Christian practices and virtues, or lack thereof? It's hardly even exclusive to Christianity. Any run of the mill jungle tribe faith practices heterogamy.
Yes, marriage is a very important ritual in Christianity and public life generally. Who can marry whom is one of the most fundamental pillars of society! You used to need an act of parliament to divorce. Henry VIII had no end of religious problems with marriage.
The state has basically reduced marriage to a tax strategy and a party.
Furthermore, it's not like everyone is abiding by all the rest of Christian dogma on usury, fasting, work on the sabbath, lust, abortion, licentiousness and only gay marriage slipped through the net.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Just on a quick look through the list there's quite a lot of odd choices. Like why does seventh grade have so few items, most of which are short poems - and then they double up on Robert Frost and Langston Hughes? Why?
What was the goal here? It doesn't seem like breadth of cultural understanding. It seems more like a list put together by a committee with a few busybodies each pushing their own favorites and no clear criteria for what to include. Why is Pride and Prejudice, essentially Victorian era chick lit, required reading? Answer: who knows?
Like many such efforts, I can get behind the concept but find the implementation unimpressive at best.
Probably just a bias for short works cuz it takes less time to teach, easier to get kids to read the whole thing, etc.
More options
Context Copy link
I will not suffer such Austen slander!
First, Austen was Regency era. A generation before the Victorians, and there are some pretty significant differences (like the freedom with which Austen's heroines go unaccompanied to parties or go on walks with men without escorts and such, something Victorian ladies basically were not allowed to do).
Second, today Austen's novels are mostly considered "chick lit" and generally filmed as romances, but in her time, they were widely read by both sexes and considered comedies of manners with insightful descriptions of human fallibility, not female wish-fulfillment ("chick lit") despite the fact they generally ended in a good-hearted but poor woman marrying up.
Also, critically, before railways. The minor gentry (the class the Bennets belong to) was much less geographically mobile than they would be in a Victorian setting.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
It was set by the Texas state board of education, which is elected in partisan elections with a voter turnout that rounds down to zero.
More options
Context Copy link
Ask my Irish school curriculum circa 1978 (and then 1980 for Persuasion*) about that one, friend. It wasn't chick-lit in those days, the term was yet to be invented. Instead it was considered a classic novel in English. If Manly Men could be Janeites, I don't see why the non-gender-binary-normative young human animals (as distinct from non-human animals, don't be speciesist!) of our day can't be introduced to her writing! Granted, the highly intelligent youth of our time probably would struggle to read English that is not contemporary but let's be hopeful and make the experiment, yes?
*One of the girls in the class had the surname Durand and it was always deemed hilarious when we had to read (yes, we read it aloud in class, everyone taking their turn as the teacher went through it):
This is Texas. The teachers may not be particularly based, but the elected officials setting curriculum standards do not believe in 'non-binary', and might think this is some kind of new computer technology, and if I had to guess a majority of the state board of ed would vote in favor of sodomy laws if they thought they could get away with it.
Let us be correct and pure in our thinking and expression, even if the Texans are woefully recalcitrant.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Jane Austen's novels primarily concern themselves with moral education. Is it possible to ruin good breeding with poor moral education? This was actually a somewhat scandalous take back then.
The primary application of Pride and Prejudice today is to present young women with caution about their selection of mates. Which is a very worthy task, even if half the class is male and might not see the point (though the truly wise will understand what make's Austin's heroes the hero and not the villain, and maybe learn from that.)
It's arguably a pretty scandalous take here and now.
I think we struggle right now with the opposite question: are there some people whose poor breeding cannot be improved with a good moral education?
It's not "the opposite question" it is the same question.
That question is which has the greater effect, education or breeding?
It's perfectly possible that bad education can ruin good breeding, but bad breeding can't be improved by good education. In short, the relationship may be asymmetrical.
Anyone can make a tall man short by cutting off his legs, but good luck making a short man tall.
Bullshit, either education has a sufficiently large effect size to overcome breeding or it does not.
Why should the world be so convenient? Give Albert Einstein enough alcohol and you can make him a slurring, slumped vagrant. But there is nothing you can drink that will turn you into Albert Einstein.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
The boys can learn from Darcy and Bingley and Mr. Bennett and Mr. Collins and Wickham. Darcy nearly ruins his chances by appearing proud (really he's mostly socially awkward and bad at expressing himself) because he unthinkingly sticks to the rigid social hierarchy of the time. He does have a strong moral foundation, though, and is capable of thinking for himself without needing to destroy all the rules (that last is important, I think; you can change and grow but that doesn't mean you have to be radical rebel punk burn it all down).
Bingley is just a sweetheart who deserves to be happy and he gets to be happy.
Mr. Bennett is a neglectful parent. He may be unhappy in his marriage (which was for love, or at least lustful attraction between him and his wife, so it was not well-established from the start) but retreating into his library, indulging his favourite daughter, and neglecting his other daughters and responsibilities to them is not the way to do it. The estate is entailed so when he dies, his daughters will be turned out and have nothing to live on. That's why Mrs. Bennett is so anxious to get them all married off and settled as fast as she can. His neglect bears fruit in Lydia's caprice and what happens to her, and too late he decides to be more strict with Kitty so she won't turn out the same way.
Wickham is the superficially charming 'cool' guy who presents himself as a victim but who has not taken useful advantage of the help he received, instead he permitted envy and entitlement to shape his actions, and now he's basically a con man living off his wife and her in-laws, being bribed to shut up and go away quietly.
Making a good marriage is also an important message for the boys as demonstrated in this novel; Mr and Mrs Bennett's marriage was imprudent, Wickham's father was drowned in debt by his wife's extravagance, Mr. Collins is trying to marry based not on his own choice and judgement but 'what will please my patroness?', and Darcy almost runs off the rails by how he treats Elizabeth ("your family is terrible, I am lowering myself by being associated with them, but in spite of all the bad things this union will bring, I condescend to propose to you" is not a good way to propose marriage!) and Wickham runs himself into a shotgun marriage where his tricks of trying to compromise a rich girl in order to force such a marriage get turned on him (he runs off with Lydia but never intended to marry her). He's been fortune-hunting, the male equivalent of a gold-digger (there's another heiress he tries to nab but is foiled) and ends up caught in his own trap.
Bingley probably has the smoothest, most trouble-free, romance and marriage of them all, and that's because both he and Jane are good people. He's not foolishly proud, he's not marrying simply because of lust, she's not wealthy herself but she's a good match due to her character and upbringing, and they genuinely fell in love. Walk the middle path between greed (marriage based only on personal advantage and pecuniary gain) and lust (marriage based only on romantic and sexual attraction), be sensible, and you have the best chance of being happy.
Excellent post!
As an aside we need more adaptations with a hot MILF Mrs. Bennett, she's only in her 40s and supposedly a complete smoke-show. Her character becomes so much more layered if you imagine her as coming into the room with "hot chick at the club" type energy only to get brushed off.
That would be funny, adaptations tend to make the Bennetts older side of middle age. They both probably assumed they'd have a son to inherit the estate, I wonder if the five daughters were the results of efforts to get that son.
Once the New Relationship Energy wore off, they found they had nothing in common. Mr. Bennett couldn't share his intellectual interests with her and she couldn't get him to be interested in her social ambitions and (later) worries about marrying the girls off.
Still hot MILF Mrs. Bennett would be a great role in any new adaptation!
More options
Context Copy link
Isn’t that part of the point? Mr. Bennett is a weak man who married the uncouth but gorgeous party girl. He made a bad choice but never had the spine to guide her to a better path.
I think it's not that he didn't have the spine, as that he couldn't be bothered to make the effort. That's his weakness, as contrasted to Darcy who does change his mind and put in the work to win Elizabeth and meet her halfway. Mr. Bennett instead retreated to his library, let his wife handle running the house, and made a pet of Elizabeth because she was smart and he influenced her in how she viewed the world (part of Elizabeth's character growth is growing beyond her father's simplistic scorn for society around him and their neighbours).
More options
Context Copy link
In the the Book? Yes. I think a lot of the film adaptations end up missing out by casting Mrs. Bennett as a silver-haired matron and Mr. Bennett as a dottering old man, rather than as they were originally described.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Pride and Prejudice really is the classic popular novel. Most of what people read today are novels written for the masses, and before ~Austen's time no one was really doing that. (I'm not saying she was the groundbreaker, but she's certainly the one that had staying power.)
[SPOILERS BELOW I GUESS]
Also Mr. Darcy is quite an admirable character; he's on my personal list of exemplars of male virtue. The novel really does a great job of taking you with the viewpoint character in really hating him for half the book. I remember reading it and feeling mad at the thought that he was going to turn out to be the love interest, namely how dumb it would be that she "changes" him for the better. But it turns out he was actually a stand-up guy the whole time, and it was Elizabeth who had fallen into trapped priors! She's the one who changes, and Darcy is ultimately rewarded for his steadfast honesty and integrity.
It's both of them. The title says it all. Both of them are proud, both of them are prejudiced, and both of them have to learn to change their minds about snap judgements, about compromise, and seeing below the surface.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
My understanding (see for example this old article) is that Texas has a public comment process that allows random unhinged people to have a disproportionate input into curriculum design.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Side notice: Goldilocks and the Three Bears and the Grashopper and the Ants seem both a bit heavy-handed for kindergarden.
Also, the Texans (or Americans) really seem to love their founding fathers and presidents. Though I will also notice that Texas had the good taste not to make a hagiography of The Greatest President of All Times required reading. And I do not even want to speculate what kind of dirt Bennett (whose Children's Book of Virtues provides texts no less than seven times) has on the state board of education.
I think that religious background knowledge is often important context and the school should probably try to teach kids the basics. Quite a few of the great writers did have an education heavy on both Judeo-Christian and Greco-Roman mythology. If Melville's narrator introduces himself as Ishmael, he is implicitly assuming that the reader knows of the biblical namesake.
On the other hand, there is a thin line between education and indoctrination. Jonah (author credit: Jonah in the HC article, which is amazing, like crediting Odysseus with writing the Illiad) is basically a story about God railroading some unwilling guy (whom he gave free will for some reason) into delivering some ultimatum to some city, then chickening out when it came to follow up on his threats (remind you of anyone? Sadly, God does not always chicken out.), leaving Jonah pissed for a lack of fire and brimstone. Kindergardeners might not understand that the character of God is every bit as fictional as the character of the Grandmother Spider from How Grandmother Spider Brought Fire, because adults around them take one more serious than the other.
On the third hand, there is also merit to letting kids discover for themselves that the adults are full of shit. I got a bible in fifth grade (German schools have opt-in religious education), which is the book I credit with turning me atheist around ninth grade or so.
Also, it seems likely that blue states will retaliate by finding out what stories are most effective at turning kids away from Christianity and making them required reading. They can even co-opt Texas guise of providing Judeo-Christian context, the story of Lot should be enough to give most teens the Ick.
That would be the actual bibliography of the bible. Kids could get a real education on the jewish state, how they got their ass handed to them and how the bible was rewritten by no less than 16 different authors spaced in time so much that you could track who retconned what just by the way language mutated over time. Also there's like a whole book/scroll that was removed at one point. Lets not even mention the original polytheistic origins and the cast of various Elohim.
More options
Context Copy link
With an interpretation like that, sounds like the inclusion of Bible stories is a good idea! and maybe you could attend the same class? 😁
For those of you what never heard the Mass readings, God sends Jonah as prophet with a warning message to Nineveh and they convert and He spares them. I don't know what is "chickening-out" there, Jonah is explicit that God is merciful and will spare the truly penitent:
In Markdown, you have to add two space characters at the end of a line in order to create a line break.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Goldilocks and the Three Bears? Isn't that the kind of bedtime story parents will already be reading or telling to their kids? Depends on what version is in the curriculum, I suppose, but kindergarten is 4-5 years old, isn't it? Plenty old enough for a simple form of the story.
Aren't we already there? If the books aren't explicitly all LGBT+++ friendly, the new interpretations of them are, e.g. this 1970s series of Frog and Toad which I only knew of from seeing the characters presented as gay on Tumblr posts, and the author's daughter saying "yes, my gay dad meant them to be a gay couple".
Of course, Ernie and Bert are gay. What, you thought those two were straight? Pfft!
In Texas, kindergarten is five to six. Pre-k is four to five and officially optional(technically, so is kindergarten- but there isn't quite as strong a norm of going to Pre-k as there is kindergarten). After that grades count 1-12 in ascending order.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Goldilocks was extremely popular with small boys of my generation as soon as they were old enough to read - you didn't need to set it as a course book for illustrated copies to fly off the library shelves. I don't think this was motivated by misogyny because Tailypo was equally popular with boys who came across it.
More options
Context Copy link
Jonah is essentially about the mercy of God. Your claim that God 'chickens out' is embarrassingly backwards - the people of Ninevah clearly respond as required to Jonah's warning, which is why they are spared. What's interesting is that Jonah doesn't want them to be spared. That's why he initially tried to avoid God's call, not because he was lazy but because he hated the Ninevites and hoped they would be struck down. The ending of the story is the whole point - that God can destroy or give mercy to whomever he wants, and it's not for humans to complain because we have a limited perspective. Jonah tried to avoid God's call because he disagreed with God's plan, and it's only when he repents of that in the depths of metaphorical hell that he's saved. It's quite an interesting and layered story.
I get the vibe that you're some kind of angry atheist type? It's possible that if you'd been properly taught Jonah and other Bible stories as a kid you would have more respect and understanding for them, and maybe less hostility towards God.
To someone who grew up with western secular morality, properly explaining the lesson "God grants and denies mercy capriciously and we should not question his decisions" makes God less sympathetic, not more. The kiddie moral of "Johan was punished for his disobedience but forgiven in the end" is much more palatable to even Victorian sensibilities, let alone today's.
God doesn't need to be sympathetic. The purpose of the Bible isn't to make you think God is a chill dude, it's to describe his actual nature.
Also, the mercy in this story isn't capricious, in fact it's the opposite. God gives Ninevah the opportunity to repent, and they take it.
Anyway, the point of this story isn't God's treatment of Ninevah, it's Jonah's response to it. The person reading should see themselves in the person of Jonah, who seeks to avoid God's will for his life. Even a child can understand this basic theme. Jonah gets in trouble because he tries to flee from God's will, and is saved when he returns to that will. This concept is deepened by the context of Jonah's reasons for fleeing (his hatred for the Ninevites). There's no contradiction, this theme of Jonah's anger is an expansion of the simpler concept.
More options
Context Copy link
Except it's not "capricious" in the slightest. The people of Nineveh repent their wickedness and are spared. Jonah rebels and is punished. And all the while God tries to reason with Jonah and bring him on side rather than just leaving him to suffer.
It's a story about free-will and the difference between punishing sins and punishing sinners.
Jonah (like many people who subscribe to a "secular morality" these days) has become high on his own sense of righteousness and as such has become more concerned with sticking it to his outgroup than addressing real problems. This prompts God to test him and ultimately call him out on his bullshit. If God calling someone out on their self-righteous bullshit violates your precious sensibilities perhaps you are the one who needs the message most.
More options
Context Copy link
But it's not just about Jonah's punishment, it's about Nineveh being spared not capriciously, but after repenting. Caprice would be God telling Jonah after he arrived and proclaimed the message, but the people of Nineveh didn't believe and didn't change, "You know what? Changed my mind, you can go home".
The lesson for us is "don't be vindictive and punitive for the sake of it, don't try and tell God what to do based on our own desires and hatreds". If the wicked truly repent, they can be forgiven. The whores and tax-collectors enter the Kingdom of God before you, the self-righteous who look down on others.
More options
Context Copy link
It's not exactly capricious, the Ninevites explicitly go overboard in their repentance. Even the cows repent of their wickedness!
There are lots of layered takes to get out of the story, that's why it's so good! Jonah was punished for his disobedience but forgiven in the end. Also, God didn't just kill Jonah but brought him back - He could have just picked a new prophet but Jonah was given a second chance. Nineveh better at repenting than Israel/Judah. Israel has prophet after prophet spitting reams of flowery poetry sent to convert it and no one changes. Nineveh gets a half-assed "God's going to come down hard on you!" and they all immediately undergo a ridiculous level of fasting and repentance.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Another layer is that Jonah himself is not destroyed. Even after doing as God commanded, he still wishes to see Nineveh destroyed, and is angry when it is not. The story ends with God attempting to reason with him, rather than simply smiting him for his rebellious attitude.
I think this is the part that trips up a lot of secular readers, they see God as "chickening out" because, like Jonah, they aren't really worried about fighting sin as much as the are hating the outgroup.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Jonah is a wonderful piece of satire, and it's a shame it will just be used as "kids, look at this time a whale vored a dude". Basically every other prophet suffers rejection, humiliation, and violence from their own people. Meanwhile, Jonah is sent to Israel's mortal enemies, tries to get out of doing his job, walks through the city giving the most half assed proclamation ("Forty days more, and Nineveh shall be overthrown!")... and it works perfectly. Even the cows cover themselves in sackclothes and sit in ashes. Absolutely brilliant.
That said, it's unclear if teachers will present the narrative excerpts as clearly work of fiction, like Aesop's fables. Is that too close to establishment of religion? Schools are obviously allowed to teach evolution even though it offends young earth creationists.
The beautiful part of Jonah is the prayer, which is unfortunately not part of the reading. It acts as a sort of maximum externalization of salvation from a rock bottom psychological state, with Jonah poetically describing himself as being barred into the bedrock of the ocean (literal rock bottom). Many of the metaphors we use today to describe being in psychological disaster — can’t get above water; trying to stay afloat; drowning; out of our depths; swallowed whole; confined; in hell; fainting / dying; flooded with work; suffocating — these are all found or implied in the small little poem-prayer. In my view this is the real utility of the work, with the tale of empathy placed around it for added tropology. When the ancient Israelite found himself in disaster, he would remember Jonah, and in remembering Jonah he would remember what Jonah did. Jonah’s salvation comes from three behaviors:
His cessation of avoidance (no more fleeing from the Great Ought)
His expressing out of his troubles in words, imagery, and emotion (extremely useful psychologically, functioning as catharsis and rubber duck debugging in one)
His orientation toward hope and eventual deliverance from his troubles (“(though) I have been banished from Your sight, yet once more I will look toward Your holy temple”)
These are great behaviors. If you were to teach these behaviors in a class, it would be an advantage to those students who would otherwise avoid, ignore, and despair over their troubles.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
What even is the moral of Goldilocks, other than that burglary is bad?
Bears can and should eat bratty little girls, and if the little girls get away that's a disappointing ending.
Seems there were three versions, the first with a nasty old woman instead of a cute little girl:
Digging into it is fascinating, the history seems to be that it was originally an oral folk tale and when it was first written down seems to be difficult to pin down; this one attributes it to Eleanor Mure in 1831 written down as a version of a story told inside the family but not published, and the bears are more violent to the intruder. First published version seems to be Robert Southey published in 1837 and that kicked off mass-market popularity and new versions.
Over time, the story got tidied up (the dirty old woman becomes a beautiful young woman and then a little girl, the three bears change from three bachelor bears to three friends sharing a home and then become a family of father, mother and baby) and softened (the bears don't do anything to the intruder, she jumps out an open window and gets away scot-free so far as the ending goes) so that it became suitable for children.
More options
Context Copy link
Moderation is best. Be neither too hot nor lukewarm; walk the middle path.
More options
Context Copy link
I actually have a book that's the sequel where the bear family shows up at Goldilocks' suburban house while the parents are out. They trash the whole place while she's frantically running around trying to fix all the messes. Then the parents come home from grocery shopping and there's her long explanation of what happened, starting with 'I know I'm not supposed to let strangers in but technically I knew them I've been to their house...'
Fun variation, maybe something to do with [large, furry] brown home invaders. They're not like us, tell you what.
More options
Context Copy link
I actually have it in a collection of preschool books. Small kids love hearing the three voices ("Papa Bear said in his great BIG voice...") It teaches concepts of hot, cold, lukewarm. Big, small, medium. If there is a moral it might just be: looks can be deceiving. A nice cottage may look inviting, but maybe a family of bears lives there! Remember kids, don't take candy from strangers.
More options
Context Copy link
"Don't wander around in the forest" and "don't take other people's shit" seem sufficiently didactic for a old children's story. (The first in particular is a very popular theme)
Yeah. Goldilocks is a brat, the bears leave their house open because they don't expect any intruders and she doesn't seem to have even the plea of necessity about needing shelter and food, she tries all the porridge and sleeps in all the beds and doesn't explain herself when discovered, she just runs away without making good for the damage she did.
"Don't take stuff just because it's lying there" is a very good lesson for small kids. They need to learn about "this belongs to someone else, ask first" at that age.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Sometimes things aren't the right fit for everyone?
More pointedly, I think the image of "trying Papa's things and Mama's things and then realizing that the Little One's things are just right" is supposed to lead children away from messing around with their parents' things when they're home alone. Which is less of a moral lesson and more of a practical, avoiding-accidents-in-the-home sort of lesson. The story doesn't actually illustrate that lesson, so much as wrap the image in a fun little story that'll stick in kids' minds.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
One would think it should be the Christians who would be disappointed that parts of God's Word have been omitted.
Basic Biblical literacy is good, and I suspect any attempts to teach as if the stories are actually God's Word will not exactly convert nonbelievers.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link