Do you have a dumb question that you're kind of embarrassed to ask in the main thread? Is there something you're just not sure about?
This is your opportunity to ask questions. No question too simple or too silly.
Culture war topics are accepted, and proposals for a better intro post are appreciated.

Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Notes -
Anyone have the stones to cover Scott Aarsonson's Mathpocalypse in the main thread? Or this guest post on Terence Tao's blog that reeks of denial?
I don't know anything about academia or math but the feathers certainly do look ruffled.
More options
Context Copy link
Inspired by last month’s guest post and my own trip to Fort Worth this weekend: what does a land value tax do to parking?
In the long run, of course, it’s going to push for more productive developments than a flat slab of asphalt. I’m interested in the short run. Whoever owns the lot loses their subsidy, raises parking prices accordingly, and/or sells to someone with the capital for an improvement. A business which currently relies on the cheap lot down the street is not likely to enjoy that process. I suspect a lot of small American operations rely on such setups. Does this give them a reason to oppose LVT?
Isn't it perverse, to begin with, if businesses that rely on cheap (or any) parking cluster where the land is valuable? If their customers drive to them, why can't you have them in whatever location in the customer's driving radius has the cheapest land instead? Most European cities, and many American ones, already work like that, with shops that cater to driving customers setting up on marginal land on the city's periphery (e.g. nestled between industrial parks) instead of downtown.
That's the problem that the Georgists don't consider. This was the entire basis of the downtown retail collapse that began in the 1950s and still hasn't really reversed itself, and was the impetus for many of the detrimental urban renewal projects that those same Georgists like to bemoan. If you're interested, check out my essay on East Liberty, particular Section 13B, where I expound on the topic you brought up in greater detail, in the context of an actual city neighborhood.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
A "more productive" version of parking is multi-tiered parking garages. We would likely see prices for parking increase, and therefore the profitability of parking garages increase while the profitability of businesses relying on cheap parking decrease, on the margins. Which will annoy customers somewhat as parking will cost more, but the benefits of LVT will outweigh this. Oh no, you had to pay $500/yr more on parking garages but your income tax went down by $5000/yr. It's worth it if you're actually doing the math, even if it's psychologically unpleasant.
In addition to multi-tier parking garages- more rideshares or robotaxis, possibly more private busses, possibly increased demand for quality/consistency/enforced policing of antisocial behavior on public transport.
While it would not scale for every urban parking lot, some could be bought out by a group of nearby businesses for validated customer/employee parking. If the businesses only operate from 9-5, then from 7-midnight they could attempt to turn the lot into a drive-in theater, concert venue, food truck pavilion, or frankly a valet lot for a neighborhood 5-15 minutes walk away.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Where are you going in Ft Worth?
It was a family visit this previous weekend.
When we went to lunch, the restaurant had a sign warning not to use the neighboring lot, which apparently belonged to a couple other businesses. There was a garage under apartments across the street, but the entrance controls made me think it was only for the apartments. We ended up parking in a random free spot on the far side of that building. Easy enough, though I'd have been annoyed if the rain had picked up.
What made me curious was the juxtaposition of completely free and completely restricted parking options.
This sounds more like Fort Worth than any number of important landmarks.
Do go to the Kimbell though. They do provide free parking in the obvious spot(and a phenomenal collection of the Dutch masters).
Oh, I’ve been! First time was back when they had the Pavia tapestries exhibit. Great museum all around.
And it’s small enough that you can just… go through it, and not need a guide to make sure you don’t miss anything.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Raising parking prices is not an option, you can't get as much from surface parking as the owner of the skyscraper next door gets from its tenants.
In the short term, these small operations will have to dedicate some parking spaces to its customers or rebuild the buildings into something that has parking downstairs and commercial space upstairs.
If the environment is dense enough for skyscrapers, you'll need a lot less parking. After all, there's a skyscraper full of people right there who can just walk across the street and sustain the businesses. If the area isn't dense enough to have a decent-sized population within walking distance of the businesses, probably the land value won't be that high either.
More options
Context Copy link
Even in smaller towns? There should be a marginal plot where the land is currently undervalued, but not by enough to justify a rebuild. Maybe those situations are rare?
I think there’s a coordination problem here where some businesses really benefit from subsidized parking. It’s still a distortion, but that’s the kind of distortion which breeds opposition to a reform.
I was thinking about downtown parking. If you have a parking lot right across the street from a building, their LVT should be practically identical.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Is anyone monitoring the biological attack in Russia?
The first reporting I saw on this was from Moscow Times, which, to put it mildly, is far from being a reliable source when it comes to Russia. I deliberately stopped following the story after that. Where is the information coming from? How is Western media getting enough details to report it being a lab leak? A biological weapon? As far as I know, exactly one person died in the middle of literal Siberia. Seems monkeypox-ish to me.
Unless it’s a false flag to justify using nuclear weapons, the FSB angle is going to be minimizing the extent and threat of the outbreak. I don’t necessarily believe the lab leak story but I think it probably is something weaponized or at least serious, because that’s that the confirmed pattern of hospital quarantines (not lockdowns, quarantines) seems to match.
More options
Context Copy link
I wouldn't use The Moscow Times for anything. It's not a real Russian news source, it's some slop publisher LARPing as Russian.
If you want the official Russian perspective on things, I recommend TASS.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I learned from my early earning on Covid and ordered some n95 masks won't hurt to have them when sanding if this blows over in 3 months.
During Covid I semi-accidentally discovered ("well, we've got a box full of N95s anyway, couldn't hurt to try") that masks are great for yard work too. I can now pour mower bags into compost bags and bins without worrying that any shredded dry grass inside will get blown up into my face and trigger my allergies.
But as long as we're at it, what other weird supplies are good to have on hand for emergencies? The standard list does include "dust mask (to filter contaminated air)", but given the subsequent "plastic sheeting" entry and instructions on sealing your home with that, they were clearly thinking about airborne radioactives rather than about airborne germs. I've also got some potassium iodide pills (picked up after demand died down post-Fukushima) with similar "I'm probably not within the blast radius of any nuke targets but I may be smack in the middle of a downwind fallout plume" thoughts in mind. Not sure if they'll do any good or if they'll just keep my family's thyroids free of radioactive iodine while our bones accumulate radioactive strontium, but they were cheap to buy and tiny to store.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Nope. I have Indian wholesale antibiotics and recently got a second cat, I think the plague is irrelevant to me.
It’s a gain-of-function enhanced bioweapon version of pneumatic plague. The stock version naturally has a 90% fatality rate. 77% if you can get them on antibiotics less than a day after infection. This one has probably been bred or engineered to be resistant to most major antibiotics. There’s also some indications it’s been modified to have a longer-non-symptomatic carrying period to compensate for the high fatality rate.
Pneumatic plague? I hope my car doesn't catch it.
Ah, this is why your refrigerator is running.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Supposedly the function they were working on was making the bacteria produce a euphoric feeling to get infected people to go out and spread it rather than lay in bed.
More options
Context Copy link
What's your source for this information? Don't know anything about it and curious to read more where you're getting this from.
Same user posted a conspiracy theory that the Iranians hit the USS Lincoln with multiple ballistic missiles. Was proven wrong almost instantly.
Also claimed Lindsay Clancy was a MKUltra victim.
So... if I had to guess... ZeroHedge comments section.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Is it a lab leak or a bioweapon attack from Ukraine? What's your best guess about this whole thing?
The best guess is a common, regular, run of the mill Russian fuckup. A low-paid under-trained lab worker, in a lab neglecting basic safety protocols because nobody's got time for that elaborate shit, breaks a vial with live pathogen. Not wanting to get chewed up by the superiors, cause trouble, and maybe get docked some pay for causing trouble, she never reports it. When she feels bad, she goes to the regular local hospital. In the hospital, nobody has any idea about who she is and why she's there, so she is treated as anybody who'd show up with respiratory symptoms in the beginning of the flu season. Except it doesn't go like flu at all, instead she dies quickly and horribly. People start checking and find out where she'd been working. Major "oh fuck oh fuck oh fuck" flags start going up, and people start bouncing it up the chain of command, which automatically engages "lie, deny and hide" strategy, but it's obviously too big to be handled like that now. So the real containment protocols - which existed in Russia since the Tsar's times, it's not their first rodeo by far - start activating, and that's where everybody learns about it.
The plague control labs have existed in Russia since forever, and not only for plague, for other diseases too. Those labs deal with monitoring, defending against, etc. various pathogens occurring naturally, including the plague. There were also weaponization efforts, including in Russia, but as far as it is known, Irkutsk lab hasn't been any part of that system. Of course, there's always possibility of something that we don't know coming up, but so far the best guess is the lab fuckup, followed by multiple chained safety protocol fuckups.
More options
Context Copy link
Multiple sources are saying that the index case was a worker at a lab known to have stocks of plague bacteria. So as close to smoking gun evidence of a lab leak as you are going to get in an authoritarian country.
Pneumonic plague is a rare natural variant of bubonic plague caused by the same Y pestis bacterium - I see no evidence that the variant we are seeing has been the subject of gain of function research (or that it wasn't, but a leak of unmodified plague is more likely even if some of the work being done at the Irkutsk lab was GoF). Weaponisation research on plague could include aerosolising (non-GoFed) plague bacteria in a way which would consistently generate the (more deadly and more transmissible) pneumonic form - a lab leak outbreak where the index case was pneumonic would be strong circumstantial evidence that this was happening.
To do weaponisation research on GoFed Y pestis (as opposed to doing the GoF work and the weaponisation work separately) would be an act of such monumental stupidity that I don't expect even the Russians to do it.
As I understand, if you get it from inhaling vapors from a broken vial, it'd be 100% pneumonic. One gets the bubonic one via an infected insect bite, and the way of ingress defines how it goes - if it's the bite, it goes to the closest lymph node, settles there and you have a bubo. If it's inhaled, it settles in the lungs, thus pneumonic. You don't need to modify anything between one and the other, it's just how it got in that matters.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I'm generally dismissive of unconventional weapon scares, whether we're talking about Iraq, Iran, or in this case Ukraine. What would be the point? It would have zero impact on the war, and provide justification for an unconventional retaliation.
More options
Context Copy link
Irkutsk is in East Siberia. Why would Ukraine bother sneaking the bioweapon all the way there, instead of, say, Moscow? It would be either sabotaging an existing biolab or the biolab having an oopsie.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Was thinking of doing the same -- antibiotics, not cat. But not sure what or where to buy.
All day chemist has antibiotics if you're willing to wait.
The cat was my wife's friend not spaying and....
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Attack or lab leak?
Lab leak supposedly but the FSB is heavily covering it up.
They reflexively cover up everything.
It's not only them.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
So, what are you reading?
I'm still on al-Katibi's The Rules of Logic. Also picking up Addas' House of the Prophet.
The Control of Nature, John McPhee. I was expecting an essay about the New Orleans levees, but it actually covers the Old River Control System upstream. This is designed to keep the Mississippi from changing course, which is way cooler than just mitigating floods.
I’ve written before about McPhee’s talent for English and I have not yet been disappointed. Still, there haven’t been any lines as quotable as Levels of the Game or Rising From the Plains…yet.
Have you read Cadillac Desert? Sounds like it might be up your alley.
No, I'll have to check it out!
Oh it's pretty great.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
The Gospel According to Isaiah 53. Always trying to faithfully be a good Catholic. It’s an argument that’ll never be decisively settled between Jews and Christians. Though it is odd and funny that prior to Rashi’s commentaries in the 1100’s, the Rabbi’s interpreted it referring to a personal Messiah, just as the Christians do. After Rashi, the argument flipped the other way and Jews began viewing it referring to the “collective Israel.” It’s one of the reasons why looking back to the Second Temple’s destruction and the necessity for Jews to “reimagine” the religion in the Council of Jamnia/Yavneh, one of the chief apologetic’s of the Christians against the Jews was that they don’t follow the Torah, but the misguided traditions of the Rabbi’s, because for a thousand years beforehand, both Jews and Christians interpreted scriptures the same way in this respect.
More options
Context Copy link
Twelve Caesars by Mary Bird. Contrary to my initial expectations, this is not the book about Roman History per se (though it features as a background) and not about the famous work by Suetonius (though it is present on the background too) but about the "Twelve Caesars" as a cultural meme and in general, about how Romans (mainly prominent, high-born Romans, of course, nobody cared about others) have been depicted in European art and culture over the centuries, and which part of this is supported by actual verifiable historical facts (spoiler: less than we'd like to). It turned out more interesting than I would expect from this description, I do not regret spending time with it.
More options
Context Copy link
Finished LoTR and read Anguish Languish as a quick palate cleanser. It's an amusing brain tickler to try and read the sentences in the plain text, decode their semantic meaning, and maintain the awkward accent that sits between the two at the same time. Some are almost too easy, a lot of them take two or three passes, but even after getting my "ear" in there's a couple in there that I gave up on figuring out.
It's fun to try and imagine what tenor to hit when reading it out loud for a listener and whether to add the semantic pacing and rhythm or try to recite it as plainly as possible and resist slipping into normal language. Would recommend it to anyone who has young kids that they read out loud to, you could try it both ways.
Funny, from the examples given on Wikipedia, it sounds like a mash-up of regional British accents, almost half Scots half West Country.
And different classes too. It's all over the place. That's what makes it fun, you're pushed and pulled between multiple competing accents while trying to read and not-read it in your own voice.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I'm not and that's a crime in itself.
More options
Context Copy link
About one-third of the way through The Story of the Lost Child.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Who is your favorite Roman Emperor and why?
I'm personally a fan of Lucius Verus. I think by indulging in vices and taking pretty egregious credit for the accomplishments of his subordinates, he is a far better role model than the long suffering Marcus Aurelius. He's an entertaining/funny emperor without being super malicious like Caligula or Commodus.
Antoninus Pius, the last emperor that knew his shit.
Or Diocletian, the emperor that brought the empire back together, if only to prolong its suffering.
More options
Context Copy link
Marcus Aurelius followed by Constatine XI Palagiaos.
More options
Context Copy link
Julian
More options
Context Copy link
Gallienus; the guy who essentially setup Aurelian for success and who unjustly usurped most of the glory that should’ve been accorded to the former for keeping it alive for as long as he did. Aurelian thrived in the house Gallienus built.
Also love Nerva, but his reign was too short.
More options
Context Copy link
Pupienus, solely for the name.
More options
Context Copy link
What’s your beef with Marcus Aurelius? He’s a great leader and a great human!
I’d say he was a pretty good emperor and Meditations is a historic treasure. He is just less entertaining than his failson and failbrother.
More options
Context Copy link
Am I the only one who thinks it's no accident that Marcus Aurelius was literally the last of both the five good emperors AND the Pax Romana? He was the Merkel of Rome, a compelling and competent but fundamentally short-termist manager. He completely failed at imparting his ideology on his own son, who became an indisputably bad emperor. His reforms were largely centered around welfare and disadvantaged groups, a laudable goal, but not conducive to the long-term functioning of the state.
Commodus was the first of the Nerva-Antonine emperors to succeed his biological father. Up to that point the emperors managed succession by adopting known-suitable heirs. I don't think "raise any son to be a potential Good Emperor" was possible, or widely believed to be possible at the time.
There were a few familial heirs groomed from childhood for the throne who either were good emperors (Marcus Aurelius himself was one of Hadrian's closest male relatives and hand picked as his eventual successor while still a child) or probably would have been (Germanicus and Augustus's grandsons seemed to be decent emperors in the making before their untimely deaths). Pretty much everyone assumed you could raise an heir to be a good emperor, and several such cases actually turned out pretty well. The only reason Nerva through Antoninus Pius adopted successors instead of naming their sons was because they were old men in a low fertility society who didn't have any. I'm not aware of a single Roman emperor who ever chose someone from outside their bloodline to succeed them if they had a choice. Trajan or Hadrian passing over their own son in favor of some competent general or administrator would have been utterly unthinkable.
We had 1500 years of diving right monarchies in Europe, and longer elsewhere. To bolster your point: if there was a consistent way to get good heirs, we would’ve found it by now. You always have a high risk of reversion to the mean.
I think the theory that Marcus’ wife cheated on him and sired Commodus from the affair is possible, but unadjucatable at this point. Either way, you still have other good emperors with awful sons like Septimius Severus and Caracalla/Geta and arguably Vespasian/Dominitian. I don’t blame Marcus too much for Commodus.
Cthulu always swims left, monarchies dive right to avoid him.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I also wanted to add to ad that the greatest Roman is Cincinnatus, the original George Washington. If we’re going emperors then Augustus has to be at the top of the list.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Maximus Thrax, but only because the whole story is hilarious.
Was he the one reported to be 8 feet tall?
That's the one.
More options
Context Copy link
And supposedly his wife’s bracelet barely fit around his finger.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Julian the Apostate, because he's the most human (or, rather, he's the one whose humanity is most accessible to us, due to how much of his writing survives). I feel like he would have fit in here pretty well.
Did God Stop Me From Rebuilding The Jerusalem Temple?: Much More Than You Wanted To Know
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Do Byzantines count? Justinian I a restless soul who married an actress in a huge scandal, and was almost brought down by sports fans.
I’m one of those guys who’ll eternally die on the hill that the Roman Empire was not the Byzantine Empire. The argument was never predicated on the naive lay expression of the observation that goes, “If it were Rome… why is it called Byzantine then?…” Yes, we all know it was a made up term and how it came about. If someone wants to come along and say that the Byzantine Empire was a “continuation,” or an “offshoot,” or a “descendant” of the Roman Empire, that’s fine. But it was absolutely not the Roman Empire in the classical understanding of things.
Years ago, I remember getting into a debate with some idiot who argued with me over this exact question. His arguments themselves were remarkably thin, to non-existent, with him mostly [and quite literally] doing the herp derp, and trying to throw a bit of personality after his bad arguments to fortify his case, in the same way a bowler tries guiding the ball along the lane after he’s released his throw. He said “… just because the Eastern Empire no longer wore togas, doesn’t mean they weren’t Roman!… They even referred to themselves as Roman!…,” which was not my argument. And the people who say shit like this never come to terms with the recognition that “empire,” is the key word in that sentence.
Rome was the cultural and ideological capital and epicenter of the Roman Empire. Once the capital moved to Ravenna and subsequently Constantinople, and other evolutionary trends were taking root, there came a point where it would’ve been unheard of for a Byzantine Emperor to do something like dismiss a Visigothic King in the west, without the material boots on the ground to do so…
I fully accept (as anyone should) that Roman emperors had other seats of power such as Milan, and Constantinople and Antioch, and became important seats of power in the east. But all that time, Rome was still the cultural heart of the empire, Rome belonged to the empire or the empire belonged to Rome. The people of say, Constantinople weren't "Roman", by any stretch of imagination, even though they considered themselves to be because they were territorially, part of the Roman Empire (but not culturally).
Once the Western Empire declines and Rome passes beyond the power of the emperors in the east, then the empire is no longer truly "Roman,” in the same way state of Virginia is no longer English. The people in the east remember that their empire was originally Roman, but they are not Romans, and Rome is no longer a part of the Empire. Understanding this is simply basic, and somehow it goes over the heads of so many people.
The argument isn’t that the roots of Byzantium weren’t originally Roman, only that at some point it became something it historically wasn’t. This is exactly why we have divisions between the Roman Republic and the Roman Empire in the first place. People don’t seem to recognize that by saying “just because their language was different, just because their religion was different, just because their military was different, that doesn’t mean they weren’t Roman!,” completely misses point. In fact this makes my case for me. At what point when you begin tallying up the differences and separate out the nuances do you have to reach, before you start calling it a different thing?
No. The Byzantine Empire was not the Roman Empire, and Constantinople was never its capital. It was a descendant of the Roman Empire. The Roman Empire ended when either Romulus Augustulus or Julius Nepos were deposed. Take your pick.
If you're going to hold the position that Byzantium wasn't Rome, and that Rome ended with Romulus Augustulus, then when did Byzantium start? Would you put it at the partition, at Rome's fall, or somewhere in between?
You could argue the visible trends were taking shape with the partitioning by Diocletian in 285. You could put the start date at either 330 with the founding of Constantinople, when Constantine declared it “Nova Roma,” (literally, “New Rome”) as the successor to historical Rome (“successor,” which incidentally makes the case I make, not the case of those who detract); which is a complete misnomer if you’re someone who thinks the Roman Empire never ended until 1453. Or you could place it in 395 when the division between the eastern and western halves became permanent after the death of Theodosius I.
“State” and “Empire” are two different things. Those two are not identical. And when you distinguish the two notions, you fully understand why “Byzantium” still carries historical weight in academia but somehow not in the public eye. Because by separating those notions, you fully understand the geopolitical reality of the early Middle Ages. An “empire” is a geographic and cultural hegemony. Certainly even historians argue and disagree with each other on the early dating of when the empire’s dissolution happened; but precisely zero of them that I’ve ever read dispute that by the end of the 7th century after losing the west to Germanic tribes and the rest to Arab invasions, the Mediterranean hegemony was gone forever, and hence the Roman “Empire” ceased to exist. What remained as far as an intact but damaged bureaucracy, you had in Constantinople, which was the same in 500 AD as it was in 600 AD. That was what was “left” in some sense that splintered off into it’s own center of power as a distinct, homogenous, highly militarized, Greek speaking kingdom that could hardly be called “Roman” in the original sense of the term. This is why historians continue to defend the use of the term “Byzantine.” Because calling a medium sized, Greek speaking, Hellenic kingdom “the Roman Empire,” feels geopolitically and historically inaccurate, because it is.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
But they called themselves the Roman Empire and were considered to be Romans by their historical contemporaries. Byzantium is historical revisionism.
And Rome WAS part of the Roman Empire during the reign of Justinian. He initiated a very costly war to retake Italy, which succeeded.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I would strongly suggest you read The Sarantine Mosaic. Thank me later.
Thanks in advance!
More options
Context Copy link
Seconded.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Constantine, obviously. Perhaps Alexios I Komnenos if you're allowing eastern ones.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
(This post starts off talking about trans issues, but that's really just a jumping-off point for a question about language. I'm not soliciting people's opinions about trans issues in this thread.)
I've made a lot of posts about transgenderism this year, in the course of which I've had numerous opportunities to debate with our assorted trans-affirming posters. One of my most recent top-level posts was largely concerned with the ease with which one can embarrass progressive politicians simply by asking them to define the word "woman".
In attempting to define this word, several of our resident progressives have independently converged on something like the definition below:
I will concede that, unlike many definitions proposed by trans activists, the one above has the virtue of not being circular. My main objection to the definition, however, is that no other word in the English language is defined this way. We are using the same word for "a person who is X" and "a person who isn't X, but wants to be". The word "billionaire" means "someone with a net worth of $1 billion or more"; it does not carry the secondary meaning of "someone who wishes they had a net worth of $1 billion or more". Likewise "lawyer", "doctor", "soldier" and so on (some of these are even protected terms, and you can land yourself in legal hot water for describing yourself as such without good cause). It strikes me as profoundly odd to use the exact same word for people who are X, and for people who aren't X but who wish they were X.
Yesterday, a second example popped into my head: "entitled". Wiktionary defines it as "having a legal or moral right or claim to something" (e.g. "If you or a loved one has been diagnosed with Mesothelioma, you may be entitled to financial compensation."); in other words, a person who is entitled to X is a person who deserves X. However, in common parlance, the word is often used to mean almost the converse: holding the erroneous belief that you have a legal or moral right or claim to something. Wiktionary again: "(figuratively) Convinced of one's own righteousness (self-righteousness) or the justifiability of one's actions or status, especially wrongly so [emphasis mine]; demanding and pretentious."
So we have a curious situation where a single word means both "having a legal or moral right or claim to something" and "believing that one has a legal or moral right or claim to something, but erroneously so". In other words, when we criticise someone for being "entitled", what we really mean is that they have a false sense of entitlement. I presume what happened was that someone criticised someone else by saying "he thinks he's entitled to sth" or "he's acting like he's entitled to sth", then over time this got compressed further and further until you can say "I can't stand entitled people" and everyone understands that you mean "I can't stand people who erroneously think they deserve things they don't" as opposed to "I can't stand people who deserve things".
In effect, the word "entitled" is almost a contronym: a word with two meanings which are directly opposed, a word which is its own antonym. (Examples: "dust" which can both mean "to remove dust" [cleaning a house] or "to add dust" [adding icing sugar to a cake]; "sanction" which can mean both "to give approval" or "to impose a penalty upon".) Some of these are only examples because the same word can mean different things in British English and
English (Simplified)American English, but not always. The other obvious example is "literally" which, in common parlance, can mean both "in a non-figurative sense" and "figuratively". A possibly related example is "guilty" which refers to both "responsibility for wrongdoing" and "a feeling of regret for wrongdoing". Notably, one doesn't imply the other: plenty of people who are responsible for wrongdoing don't regret their actions, and plenty of people who haven't done anything wrong nonetheless subjectively feel guilty (so much so that there are at least two different kinds of guilt specifically associated with people who are or may be innocent of wrongdoing).The two definitions of "entitled" aren't quite the same as the two definitions of "woman" offered by our trans-inclusive posters. The two definitions of "entitled" boil down to "he is X" and "he isn't X, but he erroneously thinks he is". For this reason, no one would ever describe themselves as "entitled" under the second meaning of the term. But the secondary meaning of "woman" proposed by trans activists concerns itself not with belief but with desire or aspiration: "woman" either means "she is X" or "he isn't X, but he wishes he was". While there are some rather batty trans-identified males who claim to be literally female (up to and including claiming to be capable of menstruating and similar), the impression I get is that the majority of trans-identified males understand that they are not female. As such, the word "woman" either means "a female person" or "a non-female person who aspires to be female".
Can you think of any other examples of words like this, where a single word in isolation can either mean "X" or "wishes to be X" or "erroneously thinks he is X"?
As an aside, I was curious if the ideological capture of Wikipedia I and others have been complaining about for years extends to Wiktionary. The website offers the following definitions of the word "woman":
None of which seem trans-inclusive on their face: there's no mention of "a person who identifies as X" or "a person with a female gender identity". The "usage notes" section likewise makes no reference to gender ideology. However, the image used to illustrate the page is a 5x4 grid of thumbnails of various people, including Mother Teresa, Marilyn Monroe, Aung Sun Suu Kyi, Oprah Winfrey... and Laverne Cox, a trans-identified male, who is not a woman according to any of the six definitions above. (Not even #4: Cox isn't married.) In effect, this means that the Wiktionary page for "woman" is not internally consistent: the image it uses to illustrate the concept of a "woman" uses a photo of someone who is not a woman according to the very definitions it espouses! Imagine if you searched "horse" and the definition was accurate, but one of the images used was a photo of a donkey.
The page for "man" is illustrated with a similar 5x4 grid. Unsurprisingly, none of the people included are trans-identified females.
Someone once posted here that a woman is the only type of human who can never become a transwoman. This has the virtue that, in our troubled age, everyone knows what a transwoman is, but no one knows what a woman is, so we define the unknown in terms of the known and thus avoid circularity.
Hold on...maybe a woman can become a transwoman in some circumstances. If a woman became a transman first and then reverted back to being a woman later on, wouldn't she be a transwoman?
Circularity, unavoided.
That would be a transtransmanwoman. Totally different thing.
More options
Context Copy link
No, that would be a detransitioner.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I think I can take the credit for that one. Only a man can be a transwoman, therefore transwomen are not women. QED.
Of course there are potentially imaginable counterarguments but they require such a degree of semantic deconstruction that there's nothing left for reassembling afterwards, rendering them moot.
More options
Context Copy link
There was a rather talented Warhammer 40k fan artist who had a thing for femboy characters, and who claimed to be a femboy themselves.
Then it turned out they were a woman. A woman who fantasized about being a man who tried to look like a woman.
Humans are strange.
Based and femboy pilled. This is not the first time women have been caught flat footed trying to get into social circles that are ostensibly built upon the glorification of boys/men performing femininity. There was that one onlyfans woman who stuffed silicone packers to pretend being an extremely successful youthful MTF. (Obviously because her face is literally that of a woman).
More options
Context Copy link
There is a reason why Slaanesh is called she who thirsts. She definitely fits the lore.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Right off the top of my head, literally certainly qualifies. Rewind about a century or so, and it was much more common to see the word literally used as a more emphatic version of the word figuratively, which actually makes a sort of sense, given that a common use of the word literature is to refer to creative writing, be it fiction, poetry, or whatever. Example: by voting for x, we are literally eating our own seed corn.
More options
Context Copy link
How about: gentleman. Originally referring to one's rightful birth into a gentry family, then broadly meaning "someone who acts like a gentleman should".
Specifically, Confucius went to great lengths to redefine junzi from its meaning of "nobleman" to the desired Confucian meaning "a man who acts in accordance with Confucian virtues", that is: "someone who acts like a nobleman should".
The term "gentleman", then, is completely analogous to trans-inclusionary meaning of "woman" as "someone who acts like a woman should", by some notion of "should". The last part hides all of the contradictions that trans-exclusionary feminists point to. Who is to say how a woman should act? And can anyone say how a woman should act without either devolving to stereotypes, or broadening to such generalities of virtues to describe people in general?
Confucius, on the other hand, would be very happy if everyone acted like a Confucian gentleman.
Or even simpler, man.
The word man has, since time immemorial, had three meanings, with "adult human male" the least salient. And now it technically has a fourth trans-inclusive meaning.
2 seems dodgy to me. It's metaphorically true but not definitionally or literally true. Somebody talking about your brass testes is not going to suggest selling them to a metallurgist.
I was joking a bit about Thatcher - I think that counts as a non-literal usage. But I think expressions like "be a man", "man up", "turning boys into men" etc. and compounds including "manly" and "manliness" are using sense 2 literally.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
The definition of gentleman has actually changed though. Using it for the weird Norwegian royals(there are multiple) who don't meet the behavioral definition would be deeply nonstandard, while all of the wiki examples except Laverne Cox are central examples of the category 'woman' even if some of them have unusual lifestyle decisions.
More options
Context Copy link
So "gentleman" either means
More or less?
There was also the alternative definition of a gentleman, namely a man with sufficient wealth from acceptable sources (primarily land and government bonds) that he could enjoy an upper-middle-class standard of living without working or being actively involved in the management of a nonfarm business. In Tudor through to early Victorian England, demonstrating that you possessed this level of wealth would (eventually) lead to you being recognised as a gentleman and your children as being born into a gentry family. The old gentry families never really succeeded in pushing back on this (did they even try? - I'm not sure) and "gentry are armigerous" didn't help because the heralds needed money and would happily sell a coat of arms to anyone vaguely suitable who could afford one. Burke's landed gentry used land and office holding as inclusion criteria, not antiquity.
A key difference between the British class system and the pre-French Revolution continental European class system, was that the British considered the gentry to be a non-noble class, so we tended to adopt the wealth-based definition. Whereas the analogous class in continental Europe was the untitled nobility, and was supposed to be a closed-blood class, or at least one where entry required spectacular battlefield achievement recognised by the Crown and could not be bought. A gentilhomme had to be a legal noble, although not necessarily rich (younger sons inherited noble status and privileges, but not the family estates).
More options
Context Copy link
'Gentleman' and 'well bred' indicate a well mannered and well behaved male, with no implication of upper class background. A gentleman from the trailer park or the project wouldn't be the expected outcome, but it wouldn't shock anyone either. Conversely the badly behaved children of celebrities/european nobles are not gentlemen.
They do now. Traditionally it meant you were a member of the gentry i.e. upper class. I believe it meant specifically that you were armigerous (but less sure on that).
The word was a description of rank first and became expanded to behaviour only later.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Yes. I suspect that's a common strategy for virtue ethicists: start with a term that means "high-born", and redefine it to mean "one who lives virtuously". The term "chivalry" underwent this, with Eleanor of Aquitaine's court. "Noble" carries a virtuous connotation.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link