This weekly roundup thread is intended for all culture war posts. 'Culture war' is vaguely defined, but it basically means controversial issues that fall along set tribal lines. Arguments over culture war issues generate a lot of heat and little light, and few deeply entrenched people ever change their minds. This thread is for voicing opinions and analyzing the state of the discussion while trying to optimize for light over heat.
Optimistically, we think that engaging with people you disagree with is worth your time, and so is being nice! Pessimistically, there are many dynamics that can lead discussions on Culture War topics to become unproductive. There's a human tendency to divide along tribal lines, praising your ingroup and vilifying your outgroup - and if you think you find it easy to criticize your ingroup, then it may be that your outgroup is not who you think it is. Extremists with opposing positions can feed off each other, highlighting each other's worst points to justify their own angry rhetoric, which becomes in turn a new example of bad behavior for the other side to highlight.
We would like to avoid these negative dynamics. Accordingly, we ask that you do not use this thread for waging the Culture War. Examples of waging the Culture War:
-
Shaming.
-
Attempting to 'build consensus' or enforce ideological conformity.
-
Making sweeping generalizations to vilify a group you dislike.
-
Recruiting for a cause.
-
Posting links that could be summarized as 'Boo outgroup!' Basically, if your content is 'Can you believe what Those People did this week?' then you should either refrain from posting, or do some very patient work to contextualize and/or steel-man the relevant viewpoint.
In general, you should argue to understand, not to win. This thread is not territory to be claimed by one group or another; indeed, the aim is to have many different viewpoints represented here. Thus, we also ask that you follow some guidelines:
-
Speak plainly. Avoid sarcasm and mockery. When disagreeing with someone, state your objections explicitly.
-
Be as precise and charitable as you can. Don't paraphrase unflatteringly.
-
Don't imply that someone said something they did not say, even if you think it follows from what they said.
-
Write like everyone is reading and you want them to be included in the discussion.
On an ad hoc basis, the mods will try to compile a list of the best posts/comments from the previous week, posted in Quality Contribution threads and archived at /r/TheThread. You may nominate a comment for this list by clicking on 'report' at the bottom of the post and typing 'Actually a quality contribution' as the report reason.

Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Notes -
Back in 2025, DOGE axed USAID and, according to partisans on the left and right, the results have been monumental.
To the left, USAID was somehow singlehandedly keeping millions of Africans alive. The loss of USAID resulted in their deaths. Wikipedia, the fallen one, reports this:
Obviously this is farcical on its face. And nearly 18 months later, there is no evidence of the massive death wave that was predicted.
Not to be outdone, the right has its own version of a USAID conspiracy theory: that closing USAID somehow killed leftism in South America.
Since USAID was shut down, seven countries in Latin America have held Presidential elections (Bolivia, Ecuador, Honduras, Chile, Costa Rica, Peru, and Colombia). All seven have elected a President who is right of center. Brazil now remains as the strongest center of leftism in Latin America. But it looks like they might flip as well. In the first round of voting, Flávio Bolsonaro beat Lula by nearly 2 points. They now advance to the runoff.
Conservatives on X are crowing about how this shows that USAID was propping up leftist governments in Latin America. But... I just don't see the mechanism. The money spent was too small. The programs too ineffectual.
The likelier truth about USAID is, like most government programs, it was essentially useless. The biggest political effect is that it allowed leftists a sinecure with good pay and benefits. And cutting it was worth it for that reason alone. But did cutting USAID kill people in Africa or bring down communists in Latin America? Press D to doubt.
The PEPFAR numbers get complicated, even under their own assumptions, if you look at them remotely critically. USAID as a whole have numbers some more plausible backing, but that's damning with faint praise, and they're still not that plausible.
Part of this is the difficulty of getting any serious numbers at scale: you can't get a good measure of how many people are dying of what cause in Somalia for the same reasons people are (presumably) dying in Somalia.
More of it's because they had easy metrics that showed they were Doing Something, and a lot of reasons to conflate Doing Something with actual productive impact, and very few people with the ability to investigate those numbers had or have the ability to promote their findings. So you get a lot of statistics where the underlying measure is partly or mostly money spent, sometimes added through many other statistics that are partly money spent.
The political impact is messy, and virtually unprovable and undisprovable. The steelman arguments are less a clear fund labeled 'make sure Lula gets reelected', and pretty much any spending could also have a side effect of an army dedicated to promoting a specific political viewpoint or blamming the political opposition, but it's not clear what proof would look like, and even less clear what would be needed to show it didn't happen.
More options
Context Copy link
I don’t think it’s as simple as either side says. I don’t think USA was specifically trying to prop of Leftist governments in Latin America. But having said that, avoiding the problems that come from leftist policies does prop up leftist governments. It’s like anything else, removing the consequences of bad ideas simply enables people to continue making those bad decisions. So in that sense, because those leftist governments could rely on Americans and (American tax dollars) to bail them out, they suddenly face the political consequences of the results of leftist policies. They can’t hide from it, because if the government owned power plants can’t keep the lights on, they can’t hide that, and the public will demand better. This is why homeschooling and private schools are popular in the USA, the failures of public schools are too obvious to hide and changes are demanded.
More options
Context Copy link
I AM bought in on the idea that the crushing of funding for various NGOs and similar government agencies that controlled the flow of 100's of millions of dollars with minimal accountability has resulted in the collapse of the overall lefty network of professional activists and organizers, and thus reduced their capability of shifting outcomes in various countries.
The amounts of rampant fraud that has come out in the last couple years is convincing me that there are well-oiled grift machines out there that convert tax dollars into either Mansions, Range Rovers, and Crab legs for some particular class of people, OR converts them into protests, election influence, and propaganda for particular candidates or causes. And STILL DOES, but has to be more judicious with its spending. Nudging a lefty candidate over the line in Bolivia, thus, would be less of a priority than, say, making one of your guys the Mayor of New York or Los Angeles.
And these flows were HIGHLY dependent on the U.S. government acting as a rich but absent-minded benefactor who hears a nice sounding cause or title and keeps writing checks because nobody told them what the money actually went to. Then you've got your George Soros' and Meckenzie Bezos supplementing these efforts, and funds being directed towards keeping those funds flowing, and it becomes a perfect parasitic organism.
So it is completely believable to me that organizations doing the work on the ground and sloshing money around to various causes in-country got dismantled due to lack of funding and these close elections are now slipping back towards the less-well-funded side.
I would want to see the actual money flows traced, however.
I just want to note how nonsensical this sentence is on its own. It is incredible how the very acronym for non-governmental organization is now tied to government funding and nobody bats an eye. And it is not just USA, it is the same in EU and everywhere, NGOs are now openly used as vehicle to support government policies at best and vehicles for corruption and nepotism at worst.
The word NGO itself is used for deliberate equivocation and propaganda, as if government is crushing private charities - by not giving funds. By the way, the same language was used by Harvard president Randall Kennedy in his latest debate against Crowder, where good professor likened Trumps funding cuts to "extortion". It is like the classic beggar vs rich man joke:
RIGHT?
I feel like when I was younger, if you were part of an "NGO" the implication was that you were privately funded but also worked in tandem with governments to achieve generally important goals. Like the Red Cross, or Amnesty International, the Government recognizes they provide important services that supplement the government's own capabilities and thus endorses but does not fund their operatons. Red Cross, at least still claims to meet this definition closely. This was helpful to make sure there is always excess capacity for emergencies, and possibly to avoid international disputes if 'official' government actors were to get involved in a space.
NOW, its basically tacitly accepted that a private organization can become an arm of the state but because of the label we don't expect it to be held to account by the voters, and also if the owners/operators become fabulously wealthy it doesn't quite register as "abuse of taxpayer funds" because in theory these NGOs can also take private money too.
And because the Constitution doesn't really create any strict rules on how such orgs can interface with the state the rules are made up and the funding can be tucked away in various large omnibus bills where nobody technically has to answer for or justify the spending.
On the flip side, as we've seen, that makes it fairly trivial to de fund them if the current President (with a friendly congress) turns a serious eye on them.
And yeah, I agree its a deliberate equivocation that lets them straddle the "private vs. public" divide without anybody thinking too much about how much that distinction matters.
There's plenty of other examples of grinding down the private/public distinction to a sheer fiction (revolving doors between large corpos and regulatory agencies, defense contracting, whatever Hunter Biden was doing) but the term "NGO" is the one that makes it a blatant mockery on its face.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
The US elections coming up will be instructive. So far the absentee ballots requested are way down, which might speak to the disruption of some, um, how shall we say, "get out the vote" efforts.
If Democrats don't win bigly, as predicted by polls and prediction markets, then perhaps there was a lot of electoral fraud after all.
I am genuinely surprised that the polls insist on a Democrat sweep at this stage.
Aside from Gas prices (which are trending down?) and a few bad candidates in races, the GOP is pretty well situated and the base seems motivated!
So I actually have some bets on some Prediction markets that there's a likely stronger Republican showing than expected, especially in Texas. Regardless of how 'bad' Paxton is, its just truly hard to imagine a Dem waltzing to victory there.
Which... we've already seen that the polls can have such a bias. As you're suggesting, if the polls have a bias AND any theoretical electoral fraud machine is crippled, we should honestly expect a narrow Republican victory rather than the certain blowout they allege is brewing.
Trump and Co. sure seem to be acting like they expect a good outcome.
So yeah. I will slightly update my priors on 'electoral fraud is a systemic problem and it impacts national elections' in favor of "true" if the Dems have an underwhelming night.
Democratic control of the press means whatever is worst for the Republicans will be front and center of the voter's minds. And the fifth column among the base supposedly mad that Trump didn't deport 100 million people (that is, Fuentes) doesn't help.
I expect a blowout in favor of the Democrats.
See I sort of believe the opposite, insofar as there's been a 'silent conservative' faction that doesn't get registered since the media is so outright biased, EVERY election is made to seem like an easy win for the Dems, and this particular rake keeps slapping them in the face.
There's a lot of conditions that I think WOULD trigger a Dem blowout, among them an actual recession, an actual infantry-based shooting war, or another plague or other disaster to hang on his neck (guess there's still time). I don't think we have that.
The main factor in the Dems' favor is simply the trend that the party in power usually 'loses' the midterms. But they haven't done a single thing to sell themselves that I can see. Likewise, its not clear what animus will get Dem voters to the polls other than a seething hatred for Trump.
The last time I saw a seemingly motivated Dem base was after Roe was overturned and even that didn't produce a pronounced blue wave, although it might have thwarted a red wave.
It would also be risky to assume that Trump and Co. don't have an actual, effective plan in mind given how efficiently they've dispatched so many other geopolitical foes (Iran being the stubborn holdout).
When mainstream faith in the press is this low, its hard to believe that the driving factor at work will be media coverage.
Although yes, the median voter might be sour on the GOP by now.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Wanna bet?
YES! As stated, I've placed bets, although zeroed on more specific races/outcomes.
What are your odds on the midterms swapping control of both House and Senate?
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
The Trump administration has been extraordinarily chaotic. And dysfunctional. Also war.
Chaotic, maybe. Dysfunctional, hardly. You couldn't have asked for better performance on the core goal of the administration. They have completely closed the border and have deported 1 million people, accelerating over time. No one could have predicted that level of success. IMO, they earn an A+ on that issue, and it's the most important issue.
Deporting 1 million people in 1-2 years sounds like a success until you consider that somewhere between 5 and 20 million people entered under Biden. So at best he's falling short of reversing the change wrought by the previous admin and at worst he's bailing water from the lifeboat with a spoon. That's assuming you only care about illegal migration specifically; if you have a problem with H1Bs then it's even worse than that.
What are you even talking about? He has cracked down on H1Bs as well. You just want the impossible.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Second most important. The most important always will be cost of living. And the only way I could characterize the Trump foreign policy signature issue - tariffs is difunctional.
Immigration is by far the most important for Trump (and also for me and the health of the country).
Though people might say affordability is the most important, it was always a fake crisis that the party out of power uses as a cudgel against the party in power. Except for a couple years during the Biden admin, real wages have gone up consistently. But people's expectations go up faster thanks to Instagram and other comparison tools.
And of course the usual solution to "affordability" is to subsidize demand or to rob Peter to pay Paul, which just makes the problem worse.
I know that it's still important for Trump to acknowledge the retarded demands of the people. It's just that, in 5 years, no one will remember that gas was $1 higher than normal for a sixth month period. But immigration, if left to continue unabated, will permanently ruin the country.
I’m going to somewhat disagree. There are a lot of affordability issues, especially for young adults. That’s a bit harder to pick up on because when you aggregate everyone in the workforce, you capture the big raises that go to some sectors of the economy and not the stagnation in others. You also capture a COL that can miss that some things have gone up massively while others have not.
If you’re in your twenties, the things that have gone up in cost (for example homes) are things that matter a lot to you, and that take up a bigger chunk of your potential budget. In the case of homes, you also don’t have a home to sell to raise money for that home. If im trading a house for a bigger house, I only need to come up with the money to afford the increase, I already have a house to sell. If you move on to groceries, an increase of ten percent is going to be huge if groceries are 15% of the budget.
More options
Context Copy link
I agree with you. Doesn't change the fact that USA is unfortunately functioning democracy and people are swayed by the strain on their wallets. If Trump manages to hold to some legislative power he may as well be celebrated as visionary 20 years down the line - especially when we see what joy and benefits diversity brings on France's streets now. But doesn't change that winning elections in democracy is not optional.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Compared to Trump 1 this has been a positively stoic 2 years, with plenty of policy wins racked up.
I simply disagree.
The War is baked in, but as stated, gas prices have actually been on the downward trend, which is the main day-to-day reminder of the war.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Is that why he promised $5000 to everyone if they won the midterms?
Yes.
Very literally yes.
If he didn't think they were within distance, why even bother? At this point, I suspect they view it as a simple matter of goosing turnout.
Trump said as much recently.
https://polymarket.us/event/usgub-oh-2026-11-03
We'll see if that's an effective strategy considering his approval ratings.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
The Senate in particular seems like it will be hard for Democrats to capture. They need to flip 4 seats.
The easiest to flip are North Carolina, Maine, Texas and Ohio. After that, Iowa, Alaska, Kansas. With the exception of Maine these are all red states! Trump won Texas by 14, Iowa by 13, Ohio by 11!
They also need to avoid being flipped in Michigan, Minnesota, New Hampshire, and Georgia.
Michigan in particular is a tough race for them with a DSA Muslim vs a turbo normie. Wouldn't be surprised to see Rogers win that one by 8 points.
That's a gimme. Pretty much no one would have a chance at beating Cooper.
I have been amused by the "Criminals for Coop" signs. Interesting that both sides have run almost entirely negative campaigns afaict.
More options
Context Copy link
I never bet against Susan Collins or John Sununu. It's a personal rule of mine. I do believe Talarico probably has a slight edge in Texas, and if the race isn't called before midnight local time he almost certainly won(the worst administered elections in the state are in a blue county, albeit not the bluest- and Harris county is just generally dysfunctional, this is not ipso facto evidence of fraud). Willing to believe Alaska and Ohio are well within reach for democrats as well.
More options
Context Copy link
How much you wanna bet? I'll take even odds that Rogers loses.
Why would I ever bet you with those odds when I can get much better odds on Kalshi? What a strange offer. Counterparty risk means I wouldn't bet you at any odds, no offense.
Kalshi is only offering those odds because nobody will bet at even odds; the purpose of the site is for bettors to make money, not to prove their points. It's like insisting that your team is going to win a football game and then insisting the other party give you points; it doesn't exactly demonstrate confidence in your position. If anything, you should be giving him odds.
Yeah but it's also kinda bad faith to walk into a conversation where a guy is saying 'I think X should happen more than 10% of the time' and say 'OH. YOU THINK X HAPPENS. GIVE ME A 50% BET' which is what happens in a lot of these public peer-to-peer bet situations where somebody/both party tries to tip the scales to be ludicrously favorable and then meanders around saying 'He didn't want to bet with me he must not have true conviction'
More options
Context Copy link
This is just not how anything works. I might think my air fryer is worth $300 in terms of the value it provides to me, but it doesn’t mean I’d buy it for $300 from some guy off the street when Amazon is selling it for $100.
We’re also allowed to think prediction markets are wrong without betting on them. They are bad for all sorts of reasons. They are going to have to clear a large hurdle for me to even consider it.
Finally I am not predicting a Rogers 8 point victory. I only said I wouldn’t be surprised. Gun to my head he wins by 2.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Talk is cheap. I don't believe you.
Here you go.
You can get much better odds on Kalshi. All you're "offering" is an opportunity for you to dutch-book and make free money (ignoring counterparty risks and work, of course).
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Basically what I'm saying. If the big national races are close, semi-coinflip outcomes should ultimately come down for the GOP in the end. You have to believe in a serious blue wave to expect a flip of the Senate, especially a flip that actually gives them 'control' vs. just a nominal majority.
Polymarket believes blue wave, Nate silver believes blue wave, polls predict blue wave, RCP believes blue wave, rumors are that GOP insiders believe blue wave, I am pro Trump also - but I think that his absolute remarkable dumb political luck has finally ran out. A nominal majority is control when it comes to appointments and passing laws.
Based on September polling. Which, last cycle in some of those important states, undershot Republican performance by 6-12%.
But who knows. Maybe this will finally be the election where the polling was accurate and not
a targeted psyop to demoralize GOP votersunderstandably and accidentally mistaken all the time in the exact same direction.More options
Context Copy link
I’m not sure how seriously I take polymarket, polls and Nate Silver. Not that they’re certainly wrong, but there’s always the issue of motivated reasoning. Elections are something that almost everyone cares about the outcome of, and this is going to come out in what people predict. A lot of people really really want a blue wave, just like a lot of people wanted Trump to lose. This shows up in polling data and predictions because they’re all made by humans.
I believe that Nate Silver wants to be right and does his best.
Now the question is not whether you take said sources seriously, but whether you do it consistently or not. Empirical evidence is that people that are under the impression they are winning are not busy unskewing the polls. When the Iowa gold standard poll came out two years ago, republicans didn't try to prove that it is wrong, they just laughed at it. With good reasons.
I have taken Nate seriously for more than a decade so far (and he has always given Trump higher chances than the rest of his cohort, so there is that), so if I have to make exception now - there has to be good reasons for it. This year may be different - but the only different thing so far is that I really dislike his prognosis.
Now if your gut tells you that Republicans are in better shape than presented, and said gut was also mostly right about the 2016-2024 elections - I will say - great - a track record is a track record.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I have not heard the 'GOP insiders' rumor, personally.
I also don't see Dems acting like they expect such a win.
The problem with citing PolyMarket, Nate Silver, RCP, and polls is they're all functionally drawing from the exact same data, nobody has 'insider' info here.
IF that dataset it tainted, biased, or otherwise missing something, which has happened before then they can't give you a more accurate picture just by aggregating them together.
And we already have some pretty sizeable polling misses in the primaries!
I think its fair to say the error bars are probably larger than you think. Like, after the Ur-example of a polling miss in Trump's 2016 original win, you should keep your salt grains on hand for reading political polls.
More options
Context Copy link
And importantly, Trump needs 50 non-cucked Republicans to make any appointments. Judges can rule like kings in many cases. We need Trump to be able to appoint them which he can't do without those 50 votes.
I am hopeful for a blue fizzle based on demonstrated poll bias. But maybe I have my head in the sand.
Do you have links towards serious analysis why polls are terribly wrong that is not fueled by binge on copium and hopium?
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
North Carolina is a Purple state, It has a democrat governor and a republican state legislature. It doesn't help that the Republican senate candidate is fairly odious, and the democratic senate candidate is a fairly popular former governor. I think it is likely Roy Cooper takes the senate seat.
I agree that North Carolina is a likely flip, made less painful by the fact that Thom Tillis was a closet Democrat.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Very few bad things show up in the aggregate death statistics. In Israel, 2023 had less deaths than 2021, 2022, 2024, or 2025. Are we to conclude that October 7th was fake, or that it was no big deal?
We would conclude that anyone claiming October 7th killed millions of people is an idiot.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I don't think it's tenable to deny that the US intervenes in other democracies. A lot of money is spent on facially-neutral "Initiatives" that are staffed by the 95% Democratic Washington DC one-party state. They will define democracy, a priori, as left-wing culture war victories, and spend money. A lot of this stuff was operant in Hungary, where NGOs lead out of Washington defined Orban's government as anti-democratic and spent money on his opposition. It's the same kind of thing that hobbled the American occupation in Afghanistan. It happens everywhere, it's the American government on autopilot.
It's even public knowledge in Brazil in one respect: In the run-up to the 2022 election, there was a lot of speculation that Bolsonaro could seize on irregularities and declare the election invalid. The CIA and the Biden White House told the Brazilian government that if this happened they would cut all diplomatic ties and consider sanctions.
At the same time, I don't believe that everything in the world was a giant USAID-organized US government plot. For one thing, USAID is basically what every department of the American government looks like when it interacts with foreign countries. For another, USAID would have been the most successful program in the American government, ever, if true. I find it much more likely that the modal failure for USAID was elites in foreign countries skimming vast quantities of money off the top.
Yes, I think this is the correct take.
USAID was just a small part of a whole government pressure program in support of Leftism. Cutting USAID didn't have much of an effect since the amount of money spent was small and most was simply wasted. But turning off or even reversing the whole government pressure is quite impactful.
For example, this time it is Lula who must beware of U.S. intervention. And Trump actually did tariff Brazil for their politically motivated prosecution of Bolsonaro. (It's currently at 25%). Brazilians can look forward to the prospect of being much richer if Flavio Bolsonaro is elected and the tariffs are ended. My $PAGS stock which I recommended on the finance thread two weeks ago is up 21% today on election news.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I think this one is more fun: Joe Rogan Claims Rap Has ‘Fallen Off the Charts’ Because the ‘USAID Got Defunded’
This one is not true- african american culture is getting less 'in' due to differential fertility rates, red tribe culture is taking its place very slowly. Look at what the youths are doing. They want to wear red wing and drive trucks and do greek life etc.
Another win for the barber-pole model?
No, no- it’s not some sort of reaction to the dominance of hip hop. It’s simply that an increasing percentage of teenagers and early young adults are red tribe due to fertility rates.
The African American population was likewise young relative to the population as a whole when black culture became cool. But that’s increasingly not the case; the youth bulge is with the SEC Americans- who have several advantages, because they’re already elites and already know how to have fun. You may not like Greek life and two stepping and Aggie football, but these things are equivalencies of cultural universals that young people want in every society.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Somebody needs to figure out how Jazz is doing, though that might be more dependent on the CIA
More options
Context Copy link
Also allegedly why Nike (and hoodwear generally) is in decline
NKE has been in free fall since 2021.
Why? They're still pretty good shoes, I have some. Market downturn? Sentiment shift?
Everything that isn't MAG 7 (and Nvidia in particular) has done poorly recently, let alone consumer discretionary, primarily due to high inflation.
More options
Context Copy link
COVID relief was basically helicopter money for the lower class who knew how to work the benefits system. From a zoomed out view it looks a lot like their stock tracking their target demographic's disposable income.
More options
Context Copy link
Short answer.
They stopped celebrating greatness and started celebrating ugly black women. Iron law of fashion: never put a fat person in your advertising.
They cut off outlets like Foot Locker in favor of direct to consumer. This was a huge mistake.
They leaned into sneakerhead culture which peaked during Covid and is now considered cringe. Ain't no one waiting in line for limited releases when they've got a closet full of old stuff they tried to flip and are stuck with.
I vaguely remember an article from a year or two ago ( maybe this one? )that made a pretty strong case for point 2 being by far the biggest aspect of the decline. Shoes (particularly athletic shoes where fit is extremely important) are like the one item of clothing you really want to be able to try on before buying, and nuking their brick and mortar retail presence just completely kneecapped the brand.
More options
Context Copy link
Also, didn't the old stuff end up rotting after a few years? You don't need to build athletic shoes to last forever when they're going to be worn out in 6 months or a year. But you can't keep the interest of a collector community when the collections literally falls to pieces in half a decade.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Oh I know, it's just another funny USAID conspiracy theory
Shh.. nobody tell him.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Lol. That's a good one.
My personal favorite is when the New York Times implies causation by using weasly language construction.
"He criticized the President. Now he's being deported." (serial rapist)
"He donated money to Trump. Then he lost his house."
"Man dies after police incident"
My cousin got the vax. Two weeks later? BAM. Falling space junk.
Classic case of jiving with cosmic debris
More options
Context Copy link
That's because the vaccine has the 5G beacons that are used to target the space junk correctly.
Happened afterward. ✅
Plausible method of action. ✅
Epistemological hygiene check passed. Very good chance it was causative.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
USAID was spending most of its money in Africa, so I'd expect that to be where things change.
There is maybe a story to be told that USAID was a method for coordination among the left. They go out and verify that a charitable cause in another country or region will advance the goals they care about, and private money simply follows their recommendation. This is somewhat explicitly what they were doing. Its just that they didn't say something like "advancing leftist ideology is our goal". Usually the goal of USAID was stated to be a kind of soft power projection by the US. Show the world we are the good guys by giving money to good causes.
I do think USAID was doing something. Simply because throwing billions of dollars around in poor nations is bound to have some effect. From some numbers I looked up on wikipedia we were giving about 1 billion to ethiopia, ethiopia's government expenditure is about 25 billion. Therefore we were contributing about 4% of ethiopias government budget. Its play money for the US, but that is a big amount for other countries. Certainly enough to sway elections.
The parsimonious explanation is that an extra 1 billion dollars given to Ethiopians is immediately spent on consumption, mostly on imported goods.
Definitely nice for the Ethiopians who benefited, but I doubt they made any progress on fixing entrenched problems.
We simply must get past the idea that government/NGO spending does anything useful unless we can closely track it and see the progress. Allocating funds != accomplishing goals. Look at California High Speed Rail. This applies doubly in corrupt countries.
Yes, to be clear when I said USAID money was definitely doing something I don't mean to imply that "something" is good. My default assumption with untracked aid money is the "something" is being used by the government in charge to hand out bribes to their friends.
I'd expect that removing the spigot of money results in more political upheaval since the group in charge has less of an ability to bribe people into being allies. And they either have to make that up through increased extraction from their enemies, or reduce their bribing amount. Both of which make their position weaker.
I just ultimately don't think it should be the responsibility of the US taxpayer to worry about these things. So I'm happy to see the program ended.
More options
Context Copy link
Education would be another one. I'm generally not prone to trying to correct the misconceptions of normies in the course of my daily life, but one thing I do bring up from time to time is that additional funding for education generally has little to no effect on outcomes. I encourage them to google that. Because it's something they can immediately grasp (and be shocked by), some even do so!
Doesn't precipitate any major political changes but once I was lucky enough to observe, afterward, that when the subject ("We just need more money for schools!") came up again in a group setting the freshly-pilled normie sat quietly with a distressed look on his face.
From such beginnings, perhaps...
This has me thinking about taxonomy. In this context, let me suggest:
Normie: One who derives political/policy opinions from ambient social consensus
Midwit: One who does the above, but is smart enough to search for supporting (never conflicting) data
Contrarian: One who, driven by reflexive disgust at normie consensus-assumption, searches for conflicting data
There's no tension between being a midwit and being a contrarian. Indeed, a tremendous amount of contrarianism is simply reversing popular or intuitive assumptions, seeking data that supports the beliefs they arrived at for fundamentally emotional/ideological reasons, and scoffing at the naivete of people who accept the convention claims.
More options
Context Copy link
I almost want to say real education spending has never been tried. Literally though a big issue is the cities with lot of money have powerful teacher unions that just find ways to gobble up the money to their members.
The data is really bad on more money and schools. The one thing that has me seeing a little daylight is it appears Mississippi has actually succeeded at fixing the schools.
This turn-around became so famous it they actually coined a term for it.
More options
Context Copy link
They fixed it via ending social promotion and by mandating phonics, right? Did they do anything else? Without looking it up, I would assume their spending is very low by US standards.
They imposed strict discipline and consistent standards. Mississippi is one of the few places where corporal punishment is still normal in schools.
More options
Context Copy link
I mostly agree spending hasn’t been important in US education. Learning is mostly having a floor of resources and then independently grinding thru a textbook.
But I would still say spending more hasn’t been tried. Because the blue cities turned their schools into job programs.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
This is how it usually goes down for me.
NPC: We need more tax money for our underfunded public schools
Me: How much do you think insert local ghetto spends per student?
NPC: I don't know, $3000?
Me: They spend $34,000 per student per year. There's 20 kids to a class, so that's $680,000 per teacher.
NPC: Nevertheless
I've encountered similar (but in reverse) with people arguing the US needs to reduce military spending (especially among people who are otherwise supportive of NATO).
The USA is definitely getting little bang for its buck procurement wise.
More options
Context Copy link
Yeah, people are shocked when they learn that defense is only like 15% of federal spending and most of that is just social programs and salaries as well.
We spend almost as much on veterans disability (much of which is fraud) as we do on weapons procurement.
And a lot of the weapons procurement budget is being spent inside the US so it's less evaporative than foreign aid
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Why is South Africa the appropriate reference country? If you look at the impactcounter dashboard (the Brooke Nichols project) they break down their death estimates by cause and provide a methodology for them. To take one example: Malaria. Approximately 71k of their death estimates are from additional Malaria cases due to canceling the President's Malaria Initiative. As best I can tell from Wikipedia the initiative never extended to South Africa.
It's the only data we have.
The streetlight effect is still the streetlight effect even if it's dark in the park.
I guess an iron law of writing is that one should never use weak evidence in your argument, even if it's all that is available.
I'm just going to take it out, since it seems like a lightning rod for people who, lacking evidence of their own, latch onto the weakest part of the argument like a terrier onto a bull's penis.
Latching onto the weakest part of an argument is a necessary defense against Gish gallops.
Sufficient, but not necessary ... and superior as deterrence vs future gallops, but not as dismissal of a current gallop. Dismantling just the strongest argument instead (or the first, if the galloper hasn't signified what they think is strongest) is a great way to claim the rest are beneath you.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Yet the logic isn’t applied by your critics to the initial claim that there will be hundreds of thousands of deaths. Curious how you need evidence to support your claim but they don’t.
The dashboard I linked to does give the source of its data though.
The methodology page for malaria generally is here and it relies on this medrxiv paper for the estimation of the impact of the PMI. The paper provides specific estimates for impacts by country and over the course of the year based on what countries were receiving PMI, how much of their national anti-malarial program it constituted, and what kind of stockpiles were already available.
More options
Context Copy link
Yeah, every online debate is just a meta argument about who the burden of proof falls on.
I think the lesson for me is not to proactively provide evidence but rather to make claims and then address with evidence if there are non-lazy counterclaims. Otherwise people will just do their lazy drivebys while sitting on the toilet.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Yes, actually. If your argument is purely speculative, you should be up front about that. "Here are my assumptions and logical arguments as why I think X even though I don't have hard evidence" isn't the most convincing, but it is at least honest. Incorporating bad evidence or evidence that doesn't actually support the central claim makes you look like a bullshitter.
I did state it was the only evidence we have. But yeah. It's removed now.
Better to state the universal negative, let people come up with counterexamples, and then attack those. Prevents lazy drive-bys.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Was that meant to be South America?
Fixed
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Forgive the self-reply, but I feel like it's too juicy not to point out the amazing parallels between Brazilian politics and US poltics.
Obviously Bolsonaro is the Brazilian Trump.
Trump: almost assassinated. Bolsonaro: almost assassinated and seriously wounded.
Trump: defeated by a geriatric man from a previous regime. Bolsonaro: same.
Trump: defeated by a "corrupt socialist". Bolsonaro: Defeated by a corrupt socialist.
Trump: Janaury 6th. Bolsonaro: January 8th
Trump: target of judicial warfare. Bolsonaro: same, but actually sent to prison
Trump: stymied by kinglike judges. Bolsonaro: stymied by Godlike judges.
Trump: children proposed as political heirs. Bolsonaro: children elected to Senate and maybe Presidency
Trump: ballot harvesting in black areas might have lost him election. Brazil: Ballot harvesting in black areas but no electoral college.
Brazil is just like the U.S. except like 50% more retarded. Lusotropicalism enjoyers are on Cloud 9.
More options
Context Copy link
At least for the "killed people in Africa" claim, the numbers most cited about how many people cutting it would kill were beyond bogus to the point of what I would consider blatant academic malpractice: https://youtube.com/watch?v=-4eQZdxlPCU
I cannot believe how facile the basis for this claim is.
It's embarrassing that so many progressive journalists uncritically reported such an obviously spurious finding. But what really alarms me is that it wouldn't surprise me if the level of numerical or statistical aptitude among the journos at the NYT, the BBC etc. was so remedial that they literally wouldn't understand why this finding was spurious.
No one who is unable to define the differences between "mean", "median" and "mode" should be working as a journalist. (Okay, fine, you can be a film or literary critic. If you're reporting on the news, you need to understand stats. Your opinions should not be taken seriously if you don't.)
I largely agree here, but the ability or gumption to wrap your head around median, mean, and mode is only barely entry level if "understanding stats" is the goal. I have probably a fair understanding of statistics--if by that we mean different methods (or methodologies), the relevance of statistical significance (and/or irrelevance), and the development of statistics over time. But I take a great deal on faith, unable to personally recite formulas or really understand how Cronbach's alpha is calculated, etc. I do think anyone writing, making, or citing conclusions based on statistical data has the responsibility to mention the limitations and assumptions made in gathering and computing that data. I'm personally very wary of using quantitative methods to measure anything affective (attitudes, for example), but abuse, or at least uninformed use, of statistics is rampant, and not just by left-leaning journalists.
Agreed, I was using "explain the difference between mean, median and mode" as a metonym for "have a basic understanding of fundamental statistical concepts".
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Yes, and if true, it would be trivially easy for people to raise money and save those lives. The fact that no one really made an effort shows a lack of belief. If relatively small amounts of money is all it takes to save African lives, they all would have been saved long ago.
I would argue that EA has been trying to pick up some of the slack. Likely they favored the most effective measures, but it seems to me that they stopped because they ran out of funds rather than because they thought that most of the things USAID funded were net negative
The truth is that before Trump, USAID was spending 12-15G$/a on global healthcare and EA (with a total budget of 1.5-2G$/a over all cause areas) is simply not in the position to simply replace the gap with some spare change.
Was there some USAID funded NGO delivering books with inspiring stories about racial justice to some structurally disadvantaged girls? Probably. Was this where the median dollar was spent? Unlikely, it seems more likely that it got into vaccination campaigns and the like.
In the past, USAID was part of a broader strategy of the US painting itself as the good guy. Sure, sometimes they would bomb the shit out of you and steal your oil, but overall they were not a terrible hegemon as these things go. Trump does not care about USAID as a tool of soft power because he does not understand soft power. His levers of foreign policy are tariffs and the US military.
I read an article describing aid recipients being asked where they think the aid comes from. They had no idea. I'm growing increasingly skeptical of of our precious soft power and the ruinous consequences for losing it.
Was the influence campaign really aimed at the end recipients though? Presumably the local governing class knew where the money was coming from.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
USAID has been, since its early days, a tool for the CIA to do all of the things they are not legally allowed to do since the Church Comittee kneecapped their dirty tricks department.
If you wanted to overthrow a nominally democratic government, you called USAID.
This was a well-known talking point among the 70s and 80s hippies, but they seem to have conveniently forgotten about it recently.
The problem with USAID, is just like the Roman legions, it began to turn its attention inward and become a player in domestic politics.
Yeah but it seems like in a bunch of places that what originally started as a local CIA office with clearish aims 50-60 years ago then eventually got swallowed into this huge NGO complex and run by people with do-gooderism aims but insufficient understanding of what the projects they're suddenly taking over are actually supposed to be doing
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
The US never gets any credit for any of the great things we do (Covid vaccines being a recent example) but gets maximum blame for bad things. No one ever said how great the US was because of USAID, but when we took it away, there were howls of protest.
So I would say that, it's not just Trump. The U.S. hasn't understood soft power in a long time. Everyone hates us. So, if hated, better at least to be respected than to continue to beg for scraps of affection.
I do hope that EA's will fully fund the most effective measures with a small share of the bonanza of money coming their way post Anthropic and Open AI IPO's. Personally, I predict little progress on Africa's core problems but much higher SF real estate prices and political donations to politicians who promise to regulate AI. Perhaps I'm overly cynical. I do think that EA's in general believe what they say. It's just that they are also lazy and bullshit and status seeking, just like everyone else.
Oderint, dum metuant.
More options
Context Copy link
“But you fuck just one goat…”
Exactly what I’m talking about.
Every country except America is basically so full of goat fuckers they sing about it in the national anthem. They’re proud of fucking goats. And the sins of the US are like “You didn’t save the world hard enough this time. Why aren't you perfect.”
We've been a doormat for ingrates.
Ingratitude isn't just an international problem. Look at what is happening in France? An entire population supported cradle to grave and they are ungrateful, resentful, and destructive of the people and institutions that entirely support their lives.
Yes. We're still learning and relearning things that have been known for ages. As Tacitus said in 117 AD:
Imagine being a Muslim in France. Of course you hate the French who are at once obviously superior, yet also weak and self-loathing.
A weak ruler subverts the natural order of things and is naturally hatred. The Muslim population would like the French a lot more if the French kicked them around once in a while and crucified people for burning churches.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
There were lots of Covid vaccines available. The counterfactual where the US didn't develop a covid vaccine looks like one where Sputnik and Astrazeneca take most of the three US vaccine's early market share.
Sputnik? No, I seriously doubt that.
In the end, vaccines didn't end the pandemic. Omicron did that.
So the question was how many effective doses can be delivered in the shortest amount of time to save the most lives before the arrival of Omicron. A vaccine that arrived in 2022 was mostly useless. The US vaccines which arrived in early 2021 saved millions.
Sputnik predated the US vaccines.
Yes, I remember. It doesn't mean it was going to replace the US vaccines which were superior in quality and had better data to support them. As I'm sure you remember, scaling is also an issue. I didn't get my shot until June 2021. Imagine how long it would have taken if only Sputnik was available.
US vaccines saved millions of lives.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link