site banner

Culture War Roundup for the week of November 16, 2026

This weekly roundup thread is intended for all culture war posts. 'Culture war' is vaguely defined, but it basically means controversial issues that fall along set tribal lines. Arguments over culture war issues generate a lot of heat and little light, and few deeply entrenched people ever change their minds. This thread is for voicing opinions and analyzing the state of the discussion while trying to optimize for light over heat.

Optimistically, we think that engaging with people you disagree with is worth your time, and so is being nice! Pessimistically, there are many dynamics that can lead discussions on Culture War topics to become unproductive. There's a human tendency to divide along tribal lines, praising your ingroup and vilifying your outgroup - and if you think you find it easy to criticize your ingroup, then it may be that your outgroup is not who you think it is. Extremists with opposing positions can feed off each other, highlighting each other's worst points to justify their own angry rhetoric, which becomes in turn a new example of bad behavior for the other side to highlight.

We would like to avoid these negative dynamics. Accordingly, we ask that you do not use this thread for waging the Culture War. Examples of waging the Culture War:

  • Shaming.

  • Attempting to 'build consensus' or enforce ideological conformity.

  • Making sweeping generalizations to vilify a group you dislike.

  • Recruiting for a cause.

  • Posting links that could be summarized as 'Boo outgroup!' Basically, if your content is 'Can you believe what Those People did this week?' then you should either refrain from posting, or do some very patient work to contextualize and/or steel-man the relevant viewpoint.

In general, you should argue to understand, not to win. This thread is not territory to be claimed by one group or another; indeed, the aim is to have many different viewpoints represented here. Thus, we also ask that you follow some guidelines:

  • Speak plainly. Avoid sarcasm and mockery. When disagreeing with someone, state your objections explicitly.

  • Be as precise and charitable as you can. Don't paraphrase unflatteringly.

  • Don't imply that someone said something they did not say, even if you think it follows from what they said.

  • Write like everyone is reading and you want them to be included in the discussion.

On an ad hoc basis, the mods will try to compile a list of the best posts/comments from the previous week, posted in Quality Contribution threads and archived at /r/TheThread. You may nominate a comment for this list by clicking on 'report' at the bottom of the post and typing 'Actually a quality contribution' as the report reason.

2
Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

I've never been a prepper, and I think the most likely explanation for the recent stream of disruptions is defensive updates to vulnerable systems. Still, I've stockpiled food and water and other things, why not? If there is a big cyberattack or event that severely disrupts supply chains and infrastructure I don't want to be kicking myself thinking I should have known better. And now I can read the headlines every day without that in the back of my mind. Is anyone else doing the same? Surely the Twitter algo plays a big part in propagating the "bad feeling", but on this question I've updated to "better safe than sorry."

My big thing is to prepare for the things you’d need no matter what actually happens. 95% the preps are actually the same. Nonpershible food, water, warmth and security without access to the grid. That’s the same whether it’s hurricanes or dirty bombs or war or famine. After you have that and enough to hold out for however long it takes, you can add on from their to protect against more specific threats.

The question is what we should be prepping for. It was always a good idea to have a week of food and water stocked up against natural disasters, but unnatural disasters may get much weirder. If the disaster is "human-directed AI creating massive cyber attacks" then the phrase "money in the bank" may become greatly ironic soon; you may want a week or a month of cash in the home safe too. If the disaster is (seemingly impossible now, but ask me again next spring) "human-directed AI creating massive bio attacks", then "a week or a month" of everything may be too much of an underestimate, despite the extra hassle and extra opportunity cost of anything longer. If the disaster is (seemingly impossible now, but ask me again in 2028) "self-directed ASI creating massive bio attacks" ... I'm not a Christian anymore, but I can't think of any better advice than "Be kind and compassionate to one another, forgiving each other" whether or not you buy the rationale for that in Ephesians.

Surely the Twitter algo plays a big part in propagating the "bad feeling"

It does amplify the conspiratorial. I agree that this wave of outages (my own bank was having major problems for an afternoon...) seems to be solely or at least primarily due to screwed-up updates from sysadmins trying to brace for AI-enhanced attacks, there's going to be a wave at some point of the actual attacks, hitting more hardened targets than Binance. We handled Y2K bugs extremely smoothly because we could look for and fix problems years before there was any risk (I first heard about it from a 1990 Arthur C. Clarke novel, and ), but modern security bugs come in all sorts of varieties and most instances are invisible until analysis of them is halfway to an exploit.

I could handle a week with no travel, internet, or power if needed, and kind of deal with a week with no travel, internet, power, or water if absolutely necessary. I'm not sure where that puts me on the prepper-spectrum, or even if it's the right aspect to be considering.

Having stuff on hand is handy outside of big emergencies: We've had water main breaks every few years that cause loss of pressure and boil-water advisories, but I had jugs of water stored. A couple power outages have gone through suppertime, but I have a camp stove and flashlights. A credible pandemic scare happened (for the first bit, at least...) and I had a pantry full of food.

Pushing for just three days of self-sufficiency (like the UK downthread) is just alien to me.

I already have a lot of this (due to the nuclear prep that I started in 2022 and got serious about in 2024), including a fair amount of bottled water, but eh, I suppose I could increase the amount of non-perishables I keep on hand somewhat.

(Does help that I'm anorexic and well-fed, the latter partially as more doom prep. To put it another way, by the time I actually start getting upset with the lack of food, cannibal looter mobs will be rampant and I'll likely have had to shoot some.)

cannibal looter mobs will be rampant and I'll likely have had to shoot some

Your cannibal looter mob, my opportunistic acquisition of nutrients following self-defense.

I am not a prepper because I have no interest in surviving apocalyptic scenarios. I like modern conveniences and benefits of civilization way too much for that. If I somehow happen to survive something like a nuclear strike despite my complete lack of intention to do so, I’d probably off myself in the aftermath. The prepper worldview is deeply alien to me, and I imagine that goes both ways.

No children, then.

You can still take the easy way out with kids, you just Lindsay Clancy them first before doing yourself.

Guilt-free suicide is a benefit of going childless. You gotta let the losers have that one.

Our primary source of heat is a wood stove and we get our water from a well. The well depends on electricity, though we do have a hand pump that hasn't been installed yet and a small generator to provide temporary power. I cut and split all our firewood, and we also keep free range chickens that produce a steady flow of eggs. We have tried some gardening, but haven't been too successful. I guess we could really lean into that if necessary. I have been managing the surrounding woods to promote edible plants and mushrooms. We have guns. We also keep decent stores of food. We could survive fine for a while, but in a real collapse none of that would last or be safe for long. I guess my main concern would be to join or form a collective of able-bodied and trustworthy friends and family who could come together for mutual trade and safety, i.e. a tribe. Depending on how things shake out, that could mean moving somewhere else or inviting more people here. Hopefully, the tribe would coordinate around some wacky post-apocalyptic religion based on the worship of a mythological St. Trump.

I'm not actually a prepper though. We're just poor and live in the country. Well, my wife has somewhat prepper tendancies.

I've been a wannabe prepper for almost as long as I can remember. I've kind of started to sour on the idea the last couple of years as I've realized the financial tradeoffs of going full rural prepper are large. It's a huge black swan play with much higher odds of ending up substantially less wealthy than you could be versus reaping massive rewards. There's a reason why people move to cities, and there's a reason why "nice" rural areas are relatively expensive. Starlink makes this more doable, but if you're really going hard, you're going to end up doing two full-time jobs, with the second being a really inefficient farm/ranch. The guy I know who kind of pulls it off does so because his wife doesn't seem to mind managing the child labor and butchering livestock while he drives an hour into town to work his computer job.

For urban prepping, my biggest issue is waste from a lack of maintenance. I don't like eating from cans day-to-day, so my canned food gets ancient just taking up space. You can do it well, but it requires dedicated meal planning to appropriately work your way through staples, which has benefits in and of itself. Again, a significant other dedicated to this is great. I deep-fry turkeys during the holidays. This is a great excuse to have a few propane tanks laying around at all times which can be very useful. Also excuse to hang out with people.

An idea I don't hate - I've done it - just straight-up buying a year or two of freeze-dried food and putting it in a cool, dark closet.

I'm now kicking myself because while I am close to a river, I should have a shallow well - which you can legally do in my state without telling anyone about, and other wells hit water before the limit in my area.

Vehicle recovery is also underrated. I don't have the best vehicle for recovery, but I try to travel with the equipment so that I could either recover my own vehicle or pull someone else out. Being able to work with snatch blocks can be handy in general.

Doing your own maintenance and mechanical work pays dividends. You build a skill set and use the money saved on labor to acquire better tools. It snowballs until you become pretty efficient at it. Often, the biggest savings come simply because you aren't having to cover someone else's taxes, and benefits. A professional will still be faster and more efficient than you, but the long-term compounding of tooling and competence is a could way to prepare.

All of this explains why people focus on guns, even though a large collection is probably not the most efficient use of money. They are fun and cool in and of themselves, and while ammunition life isn't indefinite, it's a lot easier to store than food. So, I guess, here is some advice on guns. Long guns are way easier to be effective with than pistols, but of course much harder to conceal. My suggested purchase order:

  1. AR-15

  2. Mid- to full-size pistol

After that, it really depends on what you plan on doing and how many more guns you want to buy:

a. 12-gauge shotgun: Good for bird hunting, and they do an excelent job of converting live things to dead things at close range.

b. Ruger 10/22: Small, cheap ammo. You can carry 1,000 rounds without breaking a sweat. Can kill things - probably better than you think.

c. Hunting rifle: Can hunt with it; long-range shots.

d. Another AR-15: One is none, two is one, bring a friend.

e. Deep-conceal pistol: I just struggle to bring myself to carry a mid- or full-size pistol around everywhere.

All that said, the one gun I've actually used productively was a .357 to dispatch a deer wounded by a vehicle.

AR-15

For what it may be worth, I disagree with this suggestion. If you feel that you need a semi-automatic rifle, I would avoid anything that's black and scary looking and go with something with wooden stocks, for example the Ruger Mini-14.

If for any reason you have to shoot someone (or shoot at someone, or even just brandish), you don't want to project the image that you are a psycho survivalist type who is looking for trouble. You want to look like a bona fide sportsman who just happened to be in a situation where he needed to defend himself (or his family) and he grabbed the nearest thing available.

There are very few situations where I think there is materially enough of a visual difference between long guns to change the outcome. You either live in an area (like an open-carry red state) where the AR-15 is already the most common rifle around, or you live in a jurisdiction where brandishing or firing any long gun is going to draw massive scrutiny regardless of whether it has a wood stock. I feel like the wood furniture lore ceased to matter over 10 years ago. The price, the ubiquity, and the modularity make an AR a far superior choice over a Mini-14 for the vast majority of people, in my opinion.

I 100% support having a collection to fit any scenario. High on my list of acquisitions are a Winchester 1897, a Marlin Model 1895 SBL, and a coach side-by-side.

Since I live in a ban state, I've thought a lot about this. It is true that the Mini-14 looks a lot friendlier, however, ARs are a lot better in almost every way such that it barely makes any sense to choose the Mini-14 if you have the choice. AR magazines are super cheap, parts are everywhere, manual of arms is super easy, the design of it reduces muzzle flip, it's more reliable, it's more accurate, it's way cheaper in general, and the magazine reloads are a lot quicker, too. Also ARs are easier to take apart and clean. It's really a fantastic gun. At least the upper is legal where I am, so I bought a BCM upper, and I bought an HM3X magnifier for it, going to rob my 10/22 of the Sig Romeo 5 to pair with the HM3X. Just have to wait for Viramontes to be decided before buying the PSA lower.

Whenever you buy a Mini-14 instead of Eugene Stoner's finest creation, the ATF generals convene and begin to tell the head honcho:

Mein Fuhrer... Stoner...

Since I live in a ban state, I've thought a lot about this. It is true that the Mini-14 looks a lot friendlier, however, ARs are a lot better in almost every way such that it barely makes any sense to choose the Mini-14 if you have the choice. AR magazines are super cheap, parts are everywhere, manual of arms is super easy, the design of it reduces muzzle flip, it's more reliable, it's more accurate, it's way cheaper in general, and the magazine reloads are a lot quicker, too. Also ARs are easier to take apart and clean.

I don't know enough about guns to respond to this in detail, but I am pretty confident that there are guns out there which are reasonably reliable and accurate but which don't look black and scary. And are worth the extra money (although obviously this is a personal decision). For what it may be worth, I had such a gun for a while (a semi-auto rifle with wood stocks) and I was completely satisfied with its reliability and accuracy.

The Mini-14 is reasonably reliable and accurate, at least the newer models are. Worth the extra money, certainly not. If there are other such (new production) guns, I don't know about many of them, but there are always tradeoffs in moving away from the AR ecosystem.

I have a mother who is a wannabe prepper, and I have the problem of figuring out what to do with very old and expiring cans of food. The solution is simple. Soup. All of those beans go in the instapot and turn into soup. With a little sourdough starter and flour (which can also keep) you can make meals, although they're not the best. Once you satisfy your macros, your main concern is flavor, so remember to stock up on salt and spices, and your can opener.

Yeah the key to maintaining a pantry is to cycle the food. It doesn't just go in a closet for someday. Ideally you've got about a year's worth of nonperishables on hand. Stuff you eat anyway. You use the oldest first, and when you buy new stuff it goes to the end of the queue. FIFO.

My advice is get a twelve gauge with a variety of ammunition, a quality set of game butchering knifes(including lopping shears, hatchet, and hacksaw or sawzall if you have a generator or solar panels to charge batteries), freezer, then a .22 lr, then self-defense handgun, then a grandpa-style deer rifle good for white-tails/mulies, feral hogs, exotics if they're a thing in your neighborhood, etc, then a meat grinder and sausage stuffer, then a smoker, then an AR-15. You can use a 12 gauge to shoot big game if you buy slugs or buckshot, although you'll have to cut out more meat ruined by the shot. But the most abundant game is likely to be rabbits or squirrels anyways, and a large garden+ seasonal foraging knowledge+ rice stockpile will take you a lot further than deer poaching.

I would never talk someone out of a shotgun as their first firearm, and your priorities fall well within the bounds of what I would consider great (then again, who am I). I think shotguns are arguably the best close-quarters home defense weapon, and they are great for shorter-range hunting. If you live in an area suited for that type of hunting - and mentioning feral hogs is a strong indicator - a 12-gauge is a strong contender. I still give the edge to the AR because even if it's less devastating at across-the-room home defense distances than what a shotgun can throw, it is far superior at greater ranges. ARs are modular, have higher capacity, lower recoil, and are one of the most proven fighting platforms ever built.

I will say yes to a good knife, though for someone who has never butchered an animal before, it's hard to know what you actually need until you do it. Really, one just needs the experience of actually butchering an animal. I butchered some sheep and goats at the aforementioned friend's place and was able to adequately field dress and butcher my first deer solo. I've done most of the field dressing on a deer before with a Leatherman—optimal no, but completely serviceable. I would put having the materials (love this thing as a simple, beginner all-in-one) and knowing how to sharpen and hone a blade well above the specific knife itself. Honestly, I'd take a box cutter and a basic chef's knife over a lot of specialized setups.

The only things I'd actually push back on in your priority list are the meat grinder, sausage stuffer, and smoker (before and AR). I'm certainly not against processing equipment; it massively elevates the eating experience. My brother-in-law just took his first deer, and when I asked him how many pounds he was going to grind (since I had some ribeye trimmings to cut it with), someone told him grinding was silly and he should turn all of it into jerky - which I thought was equally silly. But in an actual emergency, you can still get the protein in you without a sausage stuffer. If the goal is "I'm going to start hunting for meat," I'd put the dedicated hunting rifle over a shotgun.

I agree on gardening and foraging. If you're really committed, it should be a priority. I really wish I didn't hate gardening - it is sneaky difficult and one really should practice - but I just detest inefficient farming to the depths of my soul for some reason.

I'll use this opportunity to ask you this: I have a Mossberg 500 12 gauge pump shotgun. It has a 28 inch barrel. I want a shotgun with an 18 inch barrel, though I still want the 28 inch barrel. Would you buy another barrel, or a whole other shotgun? 18.5 inch barrels are unreasonably expensive... Something that I also think about is that training regimes for handguns are very plentiful and you can easily find out what you need to work on by recording a quick video of you shooting your handgun. I have done this, and I'm doing a ton of things wrong that I still need to work on. But for shotguns, I am struggling to think of how you'd actually work on getting better with a shotgun, other than practicing reloads with dummy rounds and also dry firing with those same dummy rounds and focus on making sure you never short shuck the pump during your sessions.

I find it interesting that you productively used a .357. I am pretty sure that that caliber really does meet minimum energy and diameter requirements for hunting. I guess the modern choice would be 10mm?

I will push back against your pushback against the smoker. A Weber Smokey Mountain can be used as a regular charcoal grill, too, and it's a lot more efficient at smoking than a Weber kettle grill is. Though I suppose it's less good at regular grilling, so it is a bit of a tradeoff.

I'd get another shotgun because it looks like a barrel gets you a big chunk of the way to another shotgun.

The deer's front legs were shattered so I was able to get close to it. I got the .357 because at he time I thought revolvers would be more robust than a semi-auto; I'm less sure of that now. Lot's of hype behind 10 mm, seems really good to me and hard to beat the capacity and reload speed.

Absolutely if you can integrate anything into you're general life it moves it way up on the list, and could alter the makeup of the list.

There’s a Maverick 88 SKU that includes both barrel lengths.

https://www.mossberg.com/maverick-88-security-field-combo-31014.html

The Maverick 88 is a great deal, but this isn't what I asked. I already have a shotgun with a longer barrel. Buying another shotgun with both barrels would be a waste. A two-shotgun setup makes sense, but for that, you don't need three barrels.

It’s what I’d personally go with, it addresses the flexibility with a cheap workhorse but doesn’t force you to mess with your Mossberg. If you have two folks out hunting, you both have the necessary barrels, and you get your shorter home defense as well. But yes, it might feel like a waste.

You could just buy the barrel, but two is one and one is none. However if you do get a shorter barreled shotgun, it’s not true redundancy if you actually use the longer barrel primarily.

What do you think of the Mossberg Shockwave?

The Mossberg Shockwave is funny to me. I'd like to shoot one someday just to see what it's like. Now that the NFA is down temporarily, it might be a little outdated. I don't think I'd seriously consider buying one. The lack of a stock is quite a detriment, though I guess you could just put on a real stock.

On the order of months, my wife and I are going to buy 40 or so acres an hour outside the city. It'll let me LARP (best case) my farmer fantasy and also (worst case) my prepper fantasy. It's fun.

Aside from that, we already have a couple weeks worth of food and water, along with a go bag and various emergency supplies. That's more for natural disaster purposes than permanent social breakdown, though. In a case of complete breakdown, probably the best thing to have a supply of is enough fentanyl to OD on (or whatever the most pleasant way to go is).

All the recent disruptions have entirely reasonable explanations, but it's odd that they're happening all around the same time. I'd be curious to see an analysis if it's a real escalation or just recency bias. Could also be AI-related but in more comforting ways (vibe coding shitty code, or rushing to deploy patches to vulns).

In my experience, people are trying to release all their updates now because once Black Friday hits there is a code freeze until Christmas is over.

This is a very real factor that interacts complicatedly that, as a big bank application owner, I can say we've been 80% devoted to 'modernization'(migrating to harder infra, patching everything and building up automated patching pipelines ect) since project glasswing first started and in the past month or two 100% devoted. We do know that we'll be able to get exemptions through the code freezes though so it's more the limited staffing due to the vacation time always taken this time of year than freezes motivating pushing stuff as soon as possible. We have firm wide drop dead dates for modernization updates regularly through the new year which is unheard of, usually this is the time period we devote to knocking out tech debt and individual projects because it was hard to guarantee you'd have all the stakeholders for some project present.

Every part of the internal tech org is heavily stressed. DBAs and infra support staff are having their own rights and access levels tightened at the same time the volume of applications doing migrations and demanding org mandated audits is spiking. All the while teams are trying to grapple with what is best use of AI is both in how to improve our own productivity but also how to build tools for the business. suddenly you have people spending $3k+ tokens a month that are producing as much code as whole teams did a couple years ago and there's this virgin pasture of AI tooling presented for captivated users that like their shiny new toys. That could be exciting if those were our captive pastures but they're not quite. While we have our hands tied trying to finally finish migrating off end of life architecture that was built by engineers a generation ago, there are dedicated teams wandering around trying to eat our lunch, showing off new tooling to the business that they can build totally outside the controls we have to abide by.

TL;DR things are moving fast and semi-chaotically while everyone is stressed, but things really are getting patched and security is improving at a rapid clip. It's not surprising to me that some roll out was botched.

I think the biggest concern right now is the explosion in AI-assisted vulnerability discoveries. Large critical infrastructure takes security seriously but is not the best equipped to deal with this. My contact in power plant controls complains that the security engineer (controls, not IT) knows nothing about security and has no real interest in it, spending most of their time installing firmware and Norton updates. My main concern is a cyberattack on critical infra that takes down sections of the grid, gas distribution, datacenters, or Internet trunks. Any of these could cause outages lasting a week or longer if equipment or data is damaged.

I have some level of confidence that datacenters and Internet trunks themselves are safe. At least, they're much harder targets than the others, and the hyperscalers are absolutely putting massive resources into securing them.

Of course, all the supporting infrastructure is vulnerable as heck, and a datacenter with no power doesn't do much.

Something it seems some "preppers" often seem to neglect is that you should be collecting skills as well as materiel. Do you know First Aid? How good are you at setting traps or snares? When's the last time you tied a knot? How fit are you? Could you walk, say, 100 km in a day if required?

I think besides the practicality of these things (which can vary: I think for a lot of the short-term disruptions one could anticipate a lot of these skills would not be necessary, or even all that helpful) it is the mark of a well-rounded person that can live well without all the conveniences of modernity, even for a short time.

Could you walk, say, 100 km in a day if required?

Average human walking speed is quoted as 5km/h, so you are asking for someone to walk 20 hours straight. 100km in a day is longer than the longest recorded military forced marches according to Gemini (though maybe you were thinking of someone carrying less gear).

I'm not saying it would be easy. Nor would I necessarily set the bar of acceptable fitness at being able to do it and feel fine afterwards. But I think it's a decent metric for something you are able to do if you have to.

(Hopefully you never have to)

4 miles per hour is pretty sustainable if you are fit and on smooth terrain -- see, uh, Jack London IIRC? 15 hours of constant fast-walk would be tiring, but I guess if there's a horde of urban zombies at your back it would be good to pick up the pace to... somewhat above average!?

Ultramarathoners run without sleep for days, although the average person shouldn't be expected to do such things. It's genuinely impressive and something that only humans can really do.

historically, the most important thing to prep for has been your Government going crazy (whether far right or far left, with far left more common in the 20th century), and the most important prep has been a passport to get you to somewhere the Government has not been going crazy. The second most important prep is probably to be able to handle whatever likely severe weather event could happen by you.

I think a more extreme version of what happened in Spain (?) last year, where either mobile payments and cell networks or the whole grid goes down for a few days, seems very possible. I think this is a big reason why governments are encouraging people to stockpile a week’s food and water.

Beyond this, I think that ‘full prepping’ [for the collapse / apocalypse] is more of a hobby than a reasonable precaution. Maybe if you’re a decabillionaire a hundred million for a survival compound in New Zealand is a small price for peace of mind in a very unusual tail scenario, but for everyone else I think it relies on a specific kind of ‘The Road’ style apocalypse fantasy where the world is destroyed enough to descend into lawlessness and anarchy, but enough humans survive that those who stockpiled enough guns, ammo and MREs on their Idaho ranches can live live petty lords.

I don’t think this is likely. Either civilization survives or it doesn’t, but I think in the event of a total collapse (most plausibly AI assisted or led extinction scenario or maybe nuclear MAD) either you’re not surviving or you’ll wish you didn’t.

Prepping is a form of playing with dolls for grown men. This includes your decabillionaire, he just plays with big enough dolls that it seems like he's really doing something. Preppers are enjoying playing fantasy with questions about what caliber of guns to stock, how many round of ammo, are crossbows a good idea, what kind of solar panels and how many, etc. It's fun.

This has nothing to do with whether it's a good idea or not, just that we as men should recognize that we are playing with dolls.

but for everyone else I think it relies on a specific kind of ‘The Road’ style apocalypse fantasy where the world is destroyed enough to descend into lawlessness and anarchy, but enough humans survive that those who stockpiled enough guns, ammo and MREs on their Idaho ranches can live live petty lords.

Yeah, this is something I have thought about a lot. Based on the Biblical story of Noah, it seems like it's been a compelling fantasy for a long time to be part of an elite few with the foresight (or Divine inspiration) to prepare for and survive some cataclysm.

I suspect another issue that plays into it is so-called "Main Character Syndrome." The one prepper I know seems disappointed to be leading a mediocre life, as opposed to being some bigshot tech CEO or prominent politician or whatever. I think being a prepper lets him pretend to himself that he's more important, that he will be some kind of warlord after the SHTF.

Obviously everyone has the right to do their own cost/benefit analysis, but I agree that this sort of thinking probably causes people to spend signifcantly more time and energy prepping than they otherwise would.

I suspect another issue that plays into it is so-called "Main Character Syndrome." The one prepper I know seems disappointed to be leading a mediocre life, as opposed to being some bigshot tech CEO or prominent politician or whatever. I think being a prepper lets him pretend to himself that he's more important, that he will be some kind of warlord after the SHTF.

"Main Character Syndrome" isn't a bad description, but I wonder if the problem is even more general than that. We grew up in small tribal units where we were basically guaranteed to have a Role. Maybe not the best hunter or the wisest elder, but some sort of niche where we could see that our existence made a difference to the tribe. That's something that almost everyone is lacking nowadays. We live comfortable lives free of striving, but also free of mattering.

Yes, this is a great and often underappreciated point. The smaller the unit (the business, the family, the community) the more likely genuine and viable specialization actually is.

"Main Character Syndrome" isn't a bad description, but I wonder if the problem is even more general than that. We grew up in small tribal units where we were basically guaranteed to have a Role. Maybe not the best hunter or the wisest elder, but some sort of niche where we could see that our existence made a difference to the tribe. That's something that almost everyone is lacking nowadays. We live comfortable lives free of striving, but also free of mattering.

Yeah, I think that's a very reasonable hypothesis. It's common to meet someone with wacky beliefs, and if those beliefs were correct, it would mean that the person matters. So it does seem like something people are universally attracted to thinking, which suggests that it's the result of our evolutionary past.

On the other hand, it could just be that we're all exposed to so many movies, books, and other stories where the main character (the one we are supposed to identify with) matters, it's just hammered into us from an early age.

Or here is another possibility: We're all descended from men who really did matter. Guys who actually did become warlords after the cataclysm, war, or plague, or some other event, or just put together a band of plucky rebels, or whatever. And here I'm not using the word "men" in the general sense, I mean human males. I'm pretty confident that preppers are overwhelmingly male. Why is that?

I'm not sure the decabillionaire bunker is even the best option for them. It needs staff and automation to work, and both of those are unreliable (and with what money will you pay the staff or technicians?) You'd be better off filling a bag with millions of dollars to throw cash at the mob (I know someone who literally did this while fleeing Indonesia in the 60s) as you run to your flight off to Buenos Aires.

I think the core of the ‘New Zealand Plan’ beloved of Thiel, Newell and co (which I don’t necessarily endorse; I’ve written about it derisively here before) relies on the prediction that the world enters a period of profound instability, conflict and violence, maybe a ‘The Road’ style scenario in the US, or a ‘Bronze Age Collapse’. The remote reaches of the South Island of New Zealand are far from major population centers, fertile, scarcely populated, temperate and the native population that is there is almost exclusively homogenous Anglo New Zealanders (the Maori and most recent immigrants are largely concentrated on the North Island around Auckland). In this scenario they probably have weeks, months, or even years to flee and so can fly by jet or commercially. Their staff and small families live with them and are happy to come with them to escape the same problems, and they all live happily around Lake Wanaka for a few years until the problems blow over.

https://www.theguardian.com/news/2022/sep/04/super-rich-prepper-bunkers-apocalypse-survival-richest-rushkoff

The billionaires considered using special combination locks on the food supply that only they knew. Or making guards wear disciplinary collars of some kind in return for their survival.

special combination locks

Proof that all those tech billionaires are still just nerds.

Yes, aside from regional disasters shutting things down, the most likely long-term collapse scenario, besides AI, is that society's function crumbles such that the monopoly on violence is broken and there are multiple groups violently vying for control, but you still have to go to work and make money and feed your family and pay for stuff except the economy sucks so it gets harder and harder to do that. Think, like, Mexico. Civilization is definitely going to keep existing, but it can exist in many unpleasant forms. It could exist like India does now. It could always be worse.

So much of it is where you are as well. In rural Michoacán you live in a war zone. In better parts of Mexico City your only interaction with cartels are invisible taxes on things like construction.

It's worth noting that despite being controlled by hyperviolent gangs in a perpetual state of warfare Mexico is getting a nicer place to live with time, not worse.

Much of Mexico isn’t really cartel territory (it’s not important to drug or people trafficking) and so is just a generic developing country whose low salaries and close proximity to the richest nation on earth makes for plenty of economically viable industry. But yeah, life in a lot of Mexico is pretty good, at least by global standards.

I'm not a fan of prepping. In any long shutdown or social collapse, your most important resource is your relationships with other people. Your charisma and ability to follow, or lead. Your good sense and charm. The material stuff doesn't really matter. You can stockpile rice and water and have no way of cooking it if your apartment electricity goes out. You can build a complex in the woods and only make yourself a target if your neighbors hate you or are less-prepared.

In the event of any real disruption (defined as: nobody is going to work), this is my plan:

  • Walk five minutes over to my neighbor's apartment and get our things in order.
  • Drive eight minutes over to another friend's apartment. Without ever having discussed this matter with anyone, I am confident this is the Schelling Point where our friends will naturally meet up.

It's possible at this stage that we will have to gather up more of our friends. Sans Google or even any telecommunications networks, I could probably find and acquire ~6 of them without putting myself in danger of losing the group. (Although, come to think of it, I think the existence of Starlink makes a total telecommunications outage extremely unlikely.)

Once my friends and I are gathered, I am confident we would already form one of the largest organized groups in the city, and have enough charisma and intelligence to credibly negotiate all problems in front of us. Thirty to fifty healthy young men is enough to, e.g., acquire supplies and groceries, cook, resist looters and gangs, organize transportation, protect women and children, coordinate with other groups, etc. etc.

I don't think there is any amount of prep I could do that would really prepare me to survive on my own for more than a few days, maybe a few weeks at best. I live in an apartment in the city. My family lives quite far away. I do not have access to a vast palatial estate or a nuclear bunker. I do not have a garden or farm or greenhouse. I could acquire a backup electrical generator or solar panel, but they wouldn't power very much that would allow me to survive for much longer than what I could do without them.

Besides that this is what I would acquire to prepare for any serious emergency:

  • A few gallons of clean water
  • Some liquor
  • A few pounds of rice
  • Some canned food
  • A can opener
  • A burner or grill that does not require electricity to operate
  • A starlink terminal
  • A gun
  • A first-aid kit
  • Some books to pass the time

Most of this is stuff I already have on hand anyways.

(Although, come to think of it, I think the existence of Starlink makes a total telecommunications outage extremely unlikely.)

There are quite a few scenarios in which Starlink is toast.

  • ASAT use or other Kessler Syndrome trigger
  • High-altitude nuke creates a temporary third radiation belt (as Starfish Prime did)
  • Carrington Event II: Electric Boogaloo

They're in space, but they're not invulnerable; they're just vulnerable to different things - and you may be noticing that all three of these cases look like they're likely associated with shit hitting the fan (although not all SHTF scenarios include one of these).

More importantly I'm pretty sure Starlink relies on ground stations for actual connectivity for the time being -- I've no doubt that Elon's goal might be to phase those out with sat-sat connectivity and maybe some of these space servers, but if there's no internet to connect to I think the subnet goes down as well in this case?

Well we can make up whatever scenario we want I guess. But when the average person posting on Twitter or in my groupchats says I need to prepare, I don’t think they’re envisioning Kessler Syndrome. These scenarios would probably fit a World War III style conflict if it degenerated into the fulfillment of MAD. But unless that happens the day the war pops off I think we’d have plenty of prior notice.

IIRC the Chinese WWIII plans are basically a repeat of Pearl Harbour (possibly excluding the "no declaring war" part), with massive missile attacks on all US bases in the West Pacific (and Free Asian bases) and, yes, massive ASAT use to destroy all US military satellites. So yeah, Kessler syndrome begins on day one.

Kessler syndrome would take some time to fully destroy Starlink, as it's more a case of "satellites have a half-life measured in weeks" than "all the satellites explode instantly". But I'd expect it to probably be useless by the time the nukes flew, let alone afterward (where scenario #2 kicks in).

SpaceX has dramatically changed the math. It’s cheaper now to put satellites in space than it is to launch the ASAT to blow them up. SpaceX already has some 10,000 satellites in Space, China is not blowing them all up and the US could put replacements up faster than China if they tried. So you escalate to a Kessler scenario, but it’s thought that that would only impact satellites in LEO. Satellites in geo-synchronous and MEO orbits would probably be fine. That leaves a lot of military assets on the table. GPS / GNSS would keep running.

Plus, any Kessler Syndrome scenario impacts Chinese and Russian satellites as well. Maybe that’s a price worth paying if space is an American advantage, but it isn’t free for the Chinese to blow it up. Think about it, destroy a multi-trillion dollar piece of world infrastructure on which civilian communications networks and financial markets depend, and then the military satellites that image your bases are still up. Military planning is moving toward non-kinetic space warfare for all these reasons.

Now, we can make up whatever scenario we want, I’m not saying no fun allowed. But to meaningfully disable the internet in a SHTF situation, we need to imagine a lot of unrelated crises all at once. Power would have to shut down at hundreds of Starlink gateways across the world, your neighborhood would have to experience a blackout, the telecom backup power grid would have to fail. The ability to do maintenance would have to be blocked. Datacenters would have to shut off. It will be patchy and touch-and-go but to really imagine everything going down we have to imagine backup systems failing, solar panels breaking down, physical wires being ripped out. You are probably still going to have GPS, although maybe your phone will require data you can’t get to use it.

It’s reasonable to imagine this impacting local areas for some period of time. (I heard that Hurricane Milton back in 2024 left some people without service for a week.) But the prepper fantasy requires a lot of things to happen all at once that probably won’t.

Your phone will probably not have data in a crisis. But a Starlink router or a normal GPS receiver will probably still work and provide great value. Internet will probably still work somewhere and continue to pass information, even if not at all times at all places. Any scenarios where this is not true are going to be so catastrophic that most preppers are probably not capable of preparing for them. You’ll need a nuclear bunker and 500 pounds of rice.

Starlink has a pretty clever way of avoiding Kessler: keeping all the orbits low enough that they require constant ion-engine maintenance to fight upper atmosphere drag even for large satellites. From those, any debris with a radial or retrograde velocity component is likely to burn up immediately, and any other debris is (due to it's much higher surface area to mass ratio) still likely to come down (at least low enough that it's no longer a hazard to the other satellites, even if it then takes weeks to reenter) quickly.

AFAIK they're still screwed in the nuke and uber-Carrington cases, though.

Starlink will not cause Kessler, and that was legit clever.

It will be destroyed by Kessler, should it occur. There are other satellites above them whose debris can go through the Starlink volume without burning up, and elliptical orbits with drag at perigee lose apogee first until they circularise (i.e. they would continue going through the Starlink orbital volume for years).

Also, no, I didn't say "uber-Carrington". I just said Carrington II. The reason the historical Carrington Event didn't destroy satellites is just that we didn't have any yet.

I hadn't considered debris with perigee in the Starlink volume and apogee much higher. Very good point.

What fraction of debris would we expect to look like that? With any perigee much lower, that apogee drops rapidly. With perigee any higher the debris circularizes before passing through the volume, which back-of-the-napkin math is telling me would happen fast (for their 480km shell; 550km might be screwed) for anything that wasn't compact and dense.

I don't know the fraction of debris that'd go into the Starlink volume. You do raise a decent point, though - after all, Starlink is a substantial chunk of all satellites in existence, so if Starlink itself can't chain-react then you could plausibly run out of debris before you ran out of Starlink satellites to hit.

If this is too too personal, please ignore, but you mentioned in another comment that you are gay. Is your friend group also gay men? I feel like, in a disaster, a tight knit group of adult men with presumably no children would be ideally positioned.

I've often thought that being gay would be incredibly convenient in certain ways and that the influence of gay communities is probably a lot more impactful than it generally given credit for. As in, I wonder how many business deals and even treaties have sprung from underground connections between gay men on either side, sort of like trees are connected by the mycelium networks between them. Although I wonder if the rise of hookup apps has devolved this community somewhat.

Not being gay, this is more of just a theory on my part from talking to gay guys. None of this is really a part of the mainstream discourse.

I've often thought that being gay would be incredibly convenient in certain ways and that the influence of gay communities is probably a lot more impactful than it generally given credit for. As in, I wonder how many business deals and even treaties have sprung from underground connections between gay men on either side, sort of like trees are connected by the mycelium networks between them.

Linked without comment. I don't trust Wired magazine further than I could throw it, so I have no idea how accurate the allegations are.

Older boys (think 11-16) often thrive in true collapse situations (think Gaza) compared to anyone else. They are physically very healthy and capable, clannish, brave, cruel and unconscionable etc. Older and more socialised males often find it hard to adapt to let go of their past social roles.

If you're trying to survive through a long term collapse there's actually a lot of bulk grunt labour that adult men tend to resent and find beneath them that needs to be done but which women and children don't usually mind. Whether modern women are any good at it is another manner but modern men definitely aren't going to be.

Aren’t there premodern tribes where the men just loaf around most of the day while women do all the work?

There's historical records of that, but IIRC most of the actually-investigated examples show the men working in seasonal high-pulse labor(annual big game hunts or fisheries) and construction while the women did most of the foraging/gardening that happened year round. Supposedly the tasmanians worked that way- the women did the big game hunting and fishing and all other heavy labour and the men loafed around and beat them. But the clearest examples are dead primitives, so I suspect the pattern is exaggerated.

My friend group is something like 60% straight men, 25% straight women, 15% gay men. I could access gay world if I needed to but I'm not particularly indexed into it. I don't have to be, I know some gay men who are. If you know ~5 gay men 2 of them probably are.

I think "the gay community" is mostly exaggerated or misunderstood. Imagine if you and your friends had a dinner party circuit that also coordinate going to the bars. A good portion of them are having sex with each other. And, in fact, everyone else in your life who isn't in your dinner party circuit has their own dinner party circuit, or has chosen not to belong to one.

There are lots of underground connections made in this way but from what I can tell they're much less salacious than most people would suppose. Imagine the opportunities you would forgo if you never went to dinner parties. I have heard other much more scandalous rumors, mostly concentrated around Silicon Valley. But taking what I know for a fact about e.g. Peter Thiel compared to the rumors I have heard, I personally don't take much stock in them.

In a crisis I would not turn to gay world for help.

I could access gay world if I needed to

This line is really funny to me. As if you were a fantasy protagonist with the secret ability to call on the spirits for aid in times of great duress, or something.

In a crisis I would not turn to gay world for help.

I'm a fan of Brandon Sanderson's Stormlight series, and it struck me you just need to say the proper words to unlock the powerups. Don't deny it! I will unite instead of divide. I will bring men together.

That’s basically how it works actually

I feel like, in a disaster, a tight knit group of adult men with presumably no children would be ideally positioned.

Getting sexual/romantic satisfaction without having to deal with women and having fewer defensive liabilities in a post-apocalyptic scenario? Gay guys just can’t stop winning.

Bands of unmarried young men used to have a lot of influence on society, and they kind of just don't now, except for (if my theory is correct) gay guys.

Rome was supposedly founded by a band of unmarried young men, although probably not mostly gays ones if the Sabine women are any indication.

Apartment prep is rough, but I'm told that it's easier than you think.

One commenter says:

What is overlooked here is making sure your preps don't prevent you from getting laid in the mean time

In the event of any real disruption (defined as: nobody is going to work), this is my plan:

Walk five minutes over to my neighbor's apartment and get our things in order. Drive eight minutes over to another friend's apartment. Without ever having discussed this matter with anyone, I am confident this is the Schelling Point where our friends will naturally meet up.

What if the crisis is that there is a new covid-like virus going around, except that it has a real chance of killing the average person?

Once my friends and I are gathered, I am confident we would already form one of the largest organized groups in the city, and have enough charisma and intelligence to credibly negotiate all problems in front of us. Thirty to fifty healthy young men is enough to, e.g., acquire supplies and groceries

Sorry if I am jumping to conclusions, but does this mean you are prepared to form a gang and rob/steal whatever you need?

His gang robs and steals; your posse scavenges and appropriates resources; my group credibly negotiates all problems in front of us with charisma and intelligence.

His gang robs and steals; your posse scavenges and appropriates resources; my group credibly negotiates all problems in front of us with charisma and intelligence.

Bravo

What if the crisis is that there is a new covid-like virus going around, except that it has a real chance of killing the average person?

Well, I guess I can't design a simple plan that works in every contingency. If there were a real, sustained, severe pandemic going around, I would probably die. I don't have the resources to maintain myself in isolation for potentially years and I am not going to organize my life now around the very small chance that this becomes necessary.

Sorry if I am jumping to conclusions, but does this mean you are prepared to form a gang and rob/steal whatever you need?

"All options are on the table," right? But this probably isn't necessary. A group of thirty to fifty guys is capable of many problems, including the vastly more likely problems that would come up with any sustained disruption. Look at the aftermath of Katrina for a plausible range of activities.

Well, I guess I can't design a simple plan that works in every contingency. If there were a real, sustained, severe pandemic going around, I would probably die.

FWIW I think that a bona fide pandemic is much more likely than the sort of Mad Max scenario where it would be helpful to be in a gang of 30-50 guys. That being said, it's difficult to estimate and compare the probabilities of these sorts of black swan events.

Anyway, probably one of your immediate friends has family with a country house within driving distance of the city. So your point about relationships would seem to be meritorious.

Pandemics are scary. With 8.3 billion of people on the planet, and growing, there is a lot of opportunity for novel viruses to spawn, even when you aren't purposely engineering them with Claude. Last time, I had the thought that it might be good to get infected early, roll the dice and either die or develop natural immunity. As a young man, it was easy to suggest that with covid. It might be a bit more unwise with a deadlier virus, or one with more lasting effects.

The government has officially recommended ten days worth of food and water, medicines, etc and a bug out bag for a while.

FWIW I think the recent outages are just enshittification and that we're unlikely to see society collapse, but we will see recurring maintenance issues.

It's not what you have. It's who you know. Definitely if you live in the dramatic climates of the US you should have a week's worth of food and water and a plan for if your heater breaks. But that's just for the small situations.

For the large situations, you need to be friends with your neighbors. Your kids need to play with your neighbor's kids. You need to be surrounded by smart, conscientious people who can work together and solve problems, like turning the water retention pond into potable water through stills and boiling. That neighbor who grills every day in summer? I don't need a large grill myself, I just need to be able to bring some charcoal over to him.

I listen politely to my police officer neighbor at his son's birthday party and invite his son over to play in our backyard whenever there's a nice day. I compliment the neighbor who is teaching his son to fire a gun in his backyard, even though his fireworks keep my kids awake all summer long.

Outside your immediate neighbors, you need to know people. Know who is the power in your county and your nearest city. Identify the local business everyone patronizes and spend time there. Volunteer in your community, give and receive favors.

Then you have something that you can always trade for, which doesn't require a ton of storage space. The people who do best in crisis are fixers. If you can connect someone with a problem to someone with a solution, then that's best.

The people who do worse in a crisis are those who are tied to a specific place, like farmers. If you turn your house into a bunker with food and ammo, you are stuck there and are a large target for desperate people.

The people who do worse in a crisis are those who are tied to a specific place, like farmers.

I think farmers would do well given the fact that they usually know lots of other farmers. If everyone you know owns an isolated complex of buildings, spare vehicles and guns, has reasonable experience in security (against animals and thieves), and a ton of food lying around, you seem pretty well set up. The major problem would be that a lot of them are old.

an isolated complex of buildings

And that's the problem. Look at how medieval farmers lived: in compact villages with the fields radiating from them. The village usually had a manor where the local crime lord knight lived and which kept the bulk of their supplies secure.

A single farmstead can be raided with relative ease. You fell a tree across the access road, the farmer gets out of his pickup, you shoot him.

Modern farmers do not produce their own food any more than normal homesteading larpers do, usually less. They produce highly specialized cash crops which they sell to a processing facility. They produce these crops at the end of a long industrial supply chain which they repay with bulk raw commodities, some of which you could technically eat or make edible* with primitive technology but nobody in the first world is going to.

*technically rice threshing is simple enough that lots of people would figure out how to eat stolen brown rice in the apocalypse. But rice farming goes on in very selected locations and with unreliable diesel it's Not Happening.

That's a fair point, I was thinking of livestock farmers where (according to Claude) 28% of US farmers specialise in cattle, and on the high end something like 40-45% of farmers are in livestock if you count other livestock and non-specialised cattle farming.

One fairly primitive technology for turning inedible crops into food is a cow, pig or chicken stomach. In the Irish famine of the 1840s there were cash crops, livestock, and a rotting staple crop, and apart from pigs (which were slaughtered to replace the staple crop) livestock numbers grew in those years.

Certain ranchers are probably an exception to the rule- if you work cattle from horseback you almost certainly already have everything you need to make it through a crash back to 19th century production.

The output of a wheat farm is... pretty much wheat berries? ("Combine" is short for "Combine harvester", so called because the threshing is combined with the harvesting)

You could make it into porridge in extremis, but making flour is not real hard either -- a grain farmer ain't gonna starve, and if you happened to put in canola the year the balloon went up you could probably trade veggie-diesel for anything you can find until the cows come home.

Yeah, but combines rely on spare parts and diesel and in a true collapse things stop getting into the countryside very fast. Farmers aren't making their own of either.

Nobody's going to be eating a thousand acres of mustard seed, but IMO farmers would deal with the breakdown of logistics better than city people will because they are always dealing with poor logistics. Power outages are more common, town is half an hour away, and there's no pipeline feeding them water. They have stuff on hand as a basic measure to get through a normal month, even without explicit prepping.

It's more that there's the sunk cost fallacy, it's hard to leave behind your cows and john deere you invested so much time and money into even well after the point you should have gotten out of Dodge.

The other day when I was out enjoying nature, an anthropomorphized bird of relatively small stature suddenly swooped down and opened its beak and told me it was a good idea to have 15 days worth of items. He appeared to be a somewhat dignified member of that Avian race. It could be nothingburger or it could everythingbagel, I don’t know.

Good thinking.

I kind of want to be a prepper, too. It seems fun and appeals to my masculine fantasies. I know there's whole sections of YouTube for this, but let's put together a Motte list of good prep ideas:

  • Month's supply of food and water is a pretty easy one.
  • Lots of charcoal for your grill seems like a good idea if the power goes out
  • Getting a good value Honda generator will help your heating, cooking, and food storage a lot. However, keep in mind generators need regular checking even when not in use, which doesn't appeal to my masculine fantasies
  • Kerosene for oil lamps and heating
  • Radio will generally keep working longer and in worse conditions than almost every other communications infrastructure
  • Chickens eat bugs and convert them into protein with their bug gut infrastructure for you without too much space or water requirements and you can keep them alive for maybe longer than your freezer will last
  • Good idea to have a trauma kit (tourniquet, quik clot, sterile medical gauze, maybe a splint)
  • Good idea to have other medicines (antibiotics? pain meds? ibuprofen?)

Longer term...

  • Good physical fitness and general health is going to be even more important in case of a disaster
  • A basic bitch pump shotgun is good for all kinds of game depending on your loading, and it's also arguably the best self-defense you're going to get if Claude sends drones after you
  • Make good friends with your neighbors because forming a community is the most important thing

Bad ideas:

  • You and approximately 10,000 other people in your city already developed a plan to eat the ducks in the park and any other wildlife within a 50 mile radius
  • Scavenging for resources probably isn't a good plan, because approximately 10,000 other people want those resources too and it's better to already have it if you foresee a need for it

Probably just LARPing:

  • It might be a good idea to have a plan and resources to escape the city on foot in case the military blocks the exits or traffic jams cause permanent blockages

Feel free to add to my LARP list!

For the LARP list:

  • Martial arts training so you can defend yourself without using ammunition
  • A sword for similar self defense purposes (or at least a good stick)
  • Bullet proof vest
  • Compass and map for navigation
  • Handheld tools for repairs and emergency construction purposes (the bridge is broken! Let's chop down a tree and build our own!)

sword martial arts training

No, no, no! You're LARPing all wrong!!! At least in this particular context of LARPing!

The real reason to do martial arts training is for fun and fitness. Maybe there are hot blondes at the jiu-jitsu place? But you've got to have the sword either be a practical item, like a machete, or a decorative item on your wall that you secretly hope to use someday as a bushidō warrior.

I like the idea of a bulletproof vest, but it's hard for me to justify that purchase. You'd use soft armor in case society just kind of quietly starts breaking down even more, but you still have to go to work and don't want any trouble, and hard armor in case you need to Kyle Rittenhouse defend some local spot from the angry mob.

Yes honey, I need this 8th looks-like-an-AR-but-is-new-and-uses-proprietary-mags-and-parts rifle for the apocalypse. It's going to happen ANY DAY NOW.

Realistically, you pretty much just need an AR and a Glock and a Mossberg pump shotgun. Maybe a thousand rounds for each? Maybe a Ruger 10/22 with 10k rounds? Sorry hell-state-residents, it's going to be difficult to get that AR.

Realistically, you pretty much just need an AR and a Glock and a Mossberg pump shotgun. Maybe a thousand rounds for each?

I wouldn't even go that far. Depending on where you live, of course.

Oh and booze. Inexpensive high-proof spirits in large quantities last indefinitely, can be consumed for analgesic or stress relief purposes, can be used for antiseptic purposes, and are likely to have high trade value.

And you can cut a beer can in half, pour in some alcohol, and presto: instant camp stove.

me alcohol, and presto: instant camp stove.

Oh yeah! I remember making the ones where you cut the bottom of one off, flip it upside down, poke some holes to make it a burner, and then put it inside the bottom of another one. It worked amazingly well! Kind of a waste of drinkable Everclear though. Good use for denatured ethanol.

Kerosene lamps are very inexpensive and surprisingly reliable, continuing to operate even in severe wind and rain. I use them for camping and keep one in my emergency supplies bin.

Solar panels are also not very expensive, without installation. Getting a few and storing them could provide a way to harvest electricity during an extended outage. In such a case, jerry-rigging a contingency installation could be as simple as propping them at an angle on the ground. Kits that include a battery substantial enough to run tools and electronics can be had for under $1000.

Gasoline as a liquid fuel doesn't store well and gasoline supplies will be depleted within days, so propane, kerosene, or diesel are better liquid fuels for long-term contingencies.

However, keep in mind generators need regular checking even when not in use

From folks that use them professionally, the recommendation seems to be for propane or dual-fuel models using propane. They are, I hear, less prone to trouble when used infrequently because of the closed fuel storage. On the other hand, liquid fuels are probably a bit easier to find and move.

It's a good suggestion. For me, though, there is only so much space I want to sacrifice, and stockpiling propane is going to be expensive in that regard, as well as monetarily. Probably I should figure out something, since California and Texas surely have no problems using their generators once in a while...

Having enough food and water for 3 days to a week is just good practice. Fairly low effort and will get you through the worst part of a crisis until the government can get through to you. It is also nice if you are sick or incapacitated for some other reason.

Beyond that, consider a camping kit with a portable gas stove in case electricity cuts out, and warm clothes so you can manage without heating in the winter. And maybe some extra gas for the car so you can move around freely.

Being in good physical shape is usually not considered prepping, but it will probably help a lot if you have to live without modern comforts for a while.

Being in good physical shape is usually not considered prepping, but it will probably help a lot if you have to live without modern comforts for a while.

Counterpoint: the most effective way for vertebrates to carry energy reserves is as body fat rather than cans of food.

Claude claims that mammals can get 4-5MJ/kg from metabolizing skeletal muscle but 32-34 MJ/kg. That is a factor of seven or eight. A kilogram of body fat will sustain you for four or five days energy-wise, a kilogram of muscle mass will last half a day.

Obviously it depends on what kind of apocalypse you anticipate. If you need to outrun a pack of Utahraptors, being overweight will likely not work out for you.

Power fatties stay winning

Best shape of my life I was 235lbs / 105kg and probably like 20% body fat but I could lift and run and fight all day and looked like a chubby samurai with legs like tree trunks and shoulders like rocks and a little pot belly

You may have to fix damage to your home, or want to help out your less fortunate and well-prepared neighbors.

If you are just sitting at home with locked doors waiting for government assistance though, then you are right that you are better off being fat and conserving your energy.

Assume that you are Ukrainian in 2022 February. How will you prep?

One of the problems with prepping is that people often underestimate how much of everything is intertwined.

You will run out of electricity before you run out of food. And as long as there is electricity the rest of the supply chain will chug along in a modern state. I mean - have a couple of buckets of clean water and a lot of heinz baked beans (also as a bonus you will have steady supply of natural gas for cooking and cleaning), but storing more is impractical and if disruptions are more than a couple of weeks you are fucked anyway.

But if you have to stock on something - i would say Everclear 95%, complete protein powder and drinking water. Everclear is disinfectant, potent calorie source and cooking fuel. And will make waiting for your certain death more bearable.

Assume that you are Ukrainian in 2022 February. How will you prep?

Passport, a fast car, and plane tickets off-continent.

but storing more is impractical and if disruptions are more than a couple of weeks you are fucked anyway.

True, not prepping for a doomsday scenario (impossible), but "let's stay inside until this all blows over". Like imagine there's a full grounding of all flights that lasts 3 days instead of 1. That will lead to a panic and run on the grocery stores. I don't want to be a desperate chump fighting with everyone for the last pickings of groceries. During the beginning of COVID I had the experience of walking in to the frozen food section being 100% empty except for a single box of frozen vegan mac and cheese. That went away immediately but it's easier to imagine a 2x-4x worse event than COVID that causes a worse panic and shortage.

Assume that you are Ukrainian in 2022 February. How will you prep?

With the benefit of hindsight, I would say that the most important prep would be an EU passport. It's less of a concern in the US, of course, but there are a number of places in the world where being able to flee to another jurisdiction in case of foreign invasion (or domestic turmoil) ranks high on the list of useful preparations.

For disinfecting you don't want above 70% alcohol because higher than that it evaporates too quickly.

It is easy to make 70% from 95%, but not the other way around.

There are only 2 countries that are running large scale cyber-disruption efforts : Russia and North Korea.

Both nations know that they must be conservative in how far they go, or the US will be forced into action. NK is fairly easy to isolate, and Russia has a big Ukraine shaped wound that the US can stamp over whenever it wants.

Also, given that the US is self-sufficient when it comes to farming and energy, disruption to international supply chains is unlikely to cause serious risk to people's lives. Discomfort sure, but nothing worth prepping for.

I think a similar argument can be made against buying iodide during the Cuba crisis: "There is only one country in the world which has ever used nuclear weapons in anger: the US. They will have no possible incentive to repeat that because we are not living in Imperial Japan. Hence we are safe."

Anyone paranoid enough to care about prepping would start from a capabilities analysis, not from established behavior. The list of threat actors which might plausibly have the capabilities to cause havoc by attacking IT systems certainly has more than two items. Start with the obvious ones: the USG, other western governments, China, Russia, NK. The big three LLM firms. Musk, plausibly. Possibly anyone with enough GPUs to run the latest Chinese models.

If you did not anticipate OpenAI on your list of threat actors a year ago, you would also hedge for unknown unknowns.

Russia has a big Ukraine shaped wound that the US can stamp over whenever it wants.

Any direct kinetic conflict between the US and Russia would carry a substantial chance of turning into an ICBM exchange. A rational US president (ha!) would be reluctant to escalate to such a level, perhaps over cyber attacks which starve a few million Americans, but likely not over Russia defrosting the freezers in all US supermarkets.

And "we will give more aid to Ukraine" is might be of limited deterrence value. "We will give Ukraine what they need to take Moscow" would do the trick if it was easily done. It is not easily done.

There are only 2 countries that are running large scale cyber-disruption efforts : Russia and North Korea.

Both nations know that they must be conservative in how far they go, or the US will be forced into action. NK is fairly easy to isolate, and Russia has a big Ukraine shaped wound that the US can stamp over whenever it wants.

Also, given that the US is self-sufficient when it comes to farming and energy, disruption to international supply chains is unlikely to cause serious risk to people's lives. Discomfort sure, but nothing worth prepping for.

FWIW, my concern is that there will be another epidemic, but this time with a virus that poses a serious danger to the average person. If that happens, it seems like it would be nice to have the option of skipping trips to the grocery store for a month or two and hiding out at home as much as possible.

Another issue is that if there is a disruption, I'd rather not have to go to a FEMA camp to pick up food and water. The idea of having government bureaucrats having that much power over me, combined with the thought of dealing with other citizens in a similar situation? Very unappealing. It's arguably like going to the DMV to get a driver license except the stakes are higher, the amount of disorganization and chaos is a lot higher, and the level of anger and hostility is higher.

What if a Democratic president is in office and something like that happens? Based on what happened during Covid, I think it's pretty likely that certain favored groups would be prioritized when it comes to food and water distribution.

Having a couple months' food and water in my basement doesn't cost much money in the scheme of things and may end up saving a lot of aggravation and humiliation.

What if a Democratic president is in office and something like that happens? Based on what happened during Covid, I think it's pretty likely that certain favored groups would be prioritized when it comes to food and water distribution.

While I found that horrifying and I have an endless pit of hatred for everyone responsible, I retain a faint scrap of optimism that even Democrats and (God forgive me saying this) bioethicists would be capable of seeing that doing so in a "real" crisis would be a massive step towards race war.

Functionally "food to the cities" gets you 90% of the way there without being explicit. They might still try via zip codes and someone planning it would be stupid enough to say the quiet part out loud though.

'Food to the cities' is what we should expect in the event of rationing. Most regimes just starve the rural poor to keep food riots quelled, and expect them to forage or subsistence farm to make up the difference(sometimes this even works; in WWII rural areas tended to have higher caloric intakes despite lower allotments in axis powers late in the war).

'Food to the cities' is what we should expect in the event of rationing.

I don't disagree! Phrased it poorly, perhaps, sorry.

In that case, you're looking at food that stores well while being nutritionally complete, plus probably also a garden/greenhouse(you will not meet your bulk caloric needs out of a suburban backyard, but it can make your food a lot less boring and more nutritious). So- rice, pasta, and ramen, legumes, and canned vegetables with a long shelf life, stored inside plastic tubs to keep pests away. A freezer full of meat(chest freezers won't defrost quickly, so this should be ok for minor outages/rolling blackouts). A garden, more for variety than for a major calorie contribution. And supplements- it's probably much easier to have multivitamins, vitamin c pills, etc on hand than to get your nutritional needs perfect with entirely shelf stable food.

What I do find perplexing is why many states recommended people do this right before this started happening.

Did they have early warnings? Of what? From whom? Are we just selectively reading into recommendations that have been issued since the beginning of the Ukraine war?

Many of my ultra-normie friends are asking me about prepping out of the blue lately. As if there's a latent feeling that something is about to go down.

What is going on?

Perhaps I am misremembering, but my impression is that scares like this take place every few years. i.e. the government makes some kind of preparedness announcement and people start to think it means something's imminent.

The FORTRESS initiative has blown up on social media, and apparently some blogs, as some sort of warning that the end is nigh.

Why the UK started pushing the 3 days of readiness now when the US has been doing that for 20+ years is more interesting imo.

As if there's a latent feeling that something is about to go down.

Iran, AI anxiety, economic anxiety, a sprinkling of TDS goosing those.

sprinkling of TDS

"Trump violates norms in a way which makes him high-variance, including by increasing tail risks" seems to me to be one of the most obviously correct statements you can make about him, regardless of partisanship.

I don't disagree and maybe I'm overindexing on 2016 still, I think there's something particular to the way Trump drives certain people insane regardless of what he's actually done or might do.

a sprinkling of TDS

Is it TDS or just believing in linear extrapolations? The past year has been the most unhinged in six years of his administrations so far, with 2025 achieving the second place.

I am not psychologist, but from my perspective it does not seem that the blue wave has lead Trump down a path of reconciliation. And his cult of personality makes it unlikely that JD Vance would invoke the 25th.

Sure, he is not the only demented person who has recently sat in the oval office, but Biden had two redeeming factors: one, he had a lifetime of sticking to the mos maiorum, he was very much DC establishment. Announcing an intent to genocide a people on twitter would have been so out of line with the established US diplomatic strategy that it would have been completely left field coming from Biden. Two, Biden was likely not calling the shots.

My expectation is not that he will start WW3, but my error bars on that are a bit higher than usual. More likely his badness will be on the level of "cutting a deal with China where the US allows them to take Taiwan".

Is it TDS or just believing in linear extrapolations?

I said a sprinkling for a reason; it's an intensifier, not a sole cause. I could have just said "partisan bias" but Trump generates more than average. It's like the inverse of FEMA camps which was (imo) strongly right-aligned as a paranoia. The current wave of prepper panic isn't purely left-aligned but much more so than past ones I've observed.

If Lloyd Austin had made a statement about Army bases having 90 days of supply etc, I suspect that less than 5% of the people currently concerned would have even noticed, and certainly wouldn't be discussing prepping about it.

The past year has been the most unhinged in six years of his administrations so far

not even close to 2020 but maybe I'm defining it a bit differently.

Huh? The US government has recommended storing a minimum of 3 days of water and food since 2003 at least.

Is this new? Maybe it's just the places I've lived, but my state and local authorities have always suggested a modest degree of "prepping" in my lifetime, whether for winter storms, hurricanes, earthquakes, or wildfires.

I stock a bunch of bottled water after some boil water notices, and a small camping stove and a few days worth of shelf-stable food seems a small investment after some power outages (I have only electric appliances). After the pandemic I've added some other stuff too.

Don't forget to restock the medicine cabinet. I remember basics like antiseptic, paracetamol and ibuprofen disappeared so fast during the start of Covid. I still pause when walking past and look at how cheap some of those things are while remembering the empty shelves.

This reminds me that I need to set up the hand pump on the well.

It never hurts to have some additional food and water and possibly a backup source of power. Even a small natural disaster can leave you with it both for a few weeks.